Cross-posted at Caroline Heldman’s Blog.
Essence Music Festival, the “party with a purpose,” is a three-day event in New Orleans, featuring speakers during the day and musical performances at night. It also caters to an almost exclusively black audience, bringing 400,000 people to the Crescent City each year. Their sheer presence challenges informal systems of segregation in New Orleans.
After the show, I walked through the French Quarter with a few friends and noted how unusual it is to see so many black people in this part of town. Despite losing 118,000 black residents after Katrina, New Orleans is still a majority-black city, but highly segregated and even more so after Katrina. Formal and informal “policing” generally keeps black locals out of the touristy French Quarter, with the exception of Black residents who work/entertain there.
You can see just how segregated in this map by Eric Fischer (each dot is 25 people; red = White residents, blue = Black residents, and Green = Asian residents):
I first learned about this informal segregation a few years ago when I convinced my reluctant friend, Earl, to go to the Cat’s Meow on Bourbon Street for karaoke. A few blocks from our destination, Earl lagged behind for a moment, distracted by a cat painting, and a group of white locals “warned” me that I was about to “get jumped” by the black guy behind me. Once on Bourbon, we were there for less than a minute before a police officer approached us, questioned Earl’s reason for being there, and told us both to leave.
Policing also occurs in “black neighborhoods” in New Orleans. Working and living in the Seventh, Eighth, and Ninth Wards, my white students and I have been stopped more times than I can count by NOPD, other law enforcement, and “friendly” white people who question why we are in these neighborhoods (or as one member of the National Guard called the Seventh Ward, “Ghettoville USA”).
With the Essence Festival in town, it was refreshing to see many black faces around the French Quarter over the weekend, enjoying the most enriching nightlife in the country. But not everyone saw it this way.
An acquaintance told me her white roommate stayed in all weekend because the Essence Festival was in town and she didn’t want to “get shot.” A white friend who works as a server in the French Quarter told me she was happy when the Essence Festival was over because she wouldn’t have to hear all the racist comments from her fellow servers and her boss. While these white residents live in a majority-black city, they feel threatened when black people come from out of town and don’t follow the rules that keep local blacks in “black neighborhoods.”
Then came the news that a New Orleans Police Department Commander was reassigned pending an investigation of instructions he gave to officers on Friday night when deploying them into areas catering to Essence Festival visitors. He allegedly instructed them to single out young, black men, although the exact language he used has not been released. It’s worth mentioning that Essence has never had an incident of violent crime during its seventeen years, and (now former) Mayor Ray Nagin reported that there is less crime in the city during the festival.
The presence of hundreds of thousands of black people from other parts of the county who don’t know the unspoken rules of racial segregation in New Orleans exposes both these rules and the pernicious racism that undergirds them.
————————
More maps from Eric Fischer.
Also on residential segregation, see our posts on how it leads to uneven rates of asthma, lead poisoning, and exposure to toxic release facilities. But we blame poor people anyway.

Comments 80
lola — July 6, 2011
this is identical to the kind of informal code that is discussed in Washington DC. it's a majority-black city (although those demographics are changing) and i've had so many conversations with people who didn't feel "safe" in certain neighborhoods that had more people of color. there are folks who honestly don't venture outside of a small affluent corner of the city because they fear for their own safety!
i'm curious about the Bourbon street incident, though. you were "asked to leave"? on what grounds? did the police officer state something specific? as someone who has witnessed and been the subject of racial profiling, i admit, i was a bit confused by the vagueness of the story. was it really as simple as, "your friend is black and you both need to leave"?!?
Cocojams Jambalayah — July 6, 2011
Here's a link to a 2010 online discussion about racism in New Orleans:
http://www.city-data.com/forum/new-orleans/1128401-racism-holding-new-orleans-northshore-back.html
Here's a comment from that discussion:
11-29-2010, 01:33 PM
Redlionjr
Originally Posted by WestbankNOLA
while Houston still has pockets of segregation. No New Orleans segregation is obvious and plain and sight. It's awholeeeeee different scale when you compare the two. Matter fact, I can say the only time I saw any real integration in New Orleans was in the French Quarter and that's because people are sight seeing,eating,shopping, etc. And more then half of the people in FQ are tourist anyway. I have family in the N.O. so when I do happen to go into real neigborhoods in the city I don't see any real sense of integration. In Houston yes you will have your older sections of towns be pred. Black or Hispanic. And some of your high income areas. pred. White. But to see segregation on the level of New Orleans you have to go out to the outerskirts past the burbs and sub-divisions to catch a true glimpse of segregation. It's pretty common to see White,Black,Indian,Korean,Viet,Nigerian,Ethopian,M exican, on one street, block in Houston. And i'm not bragging because I love New Orleans. I feel as though it is honest about it's segregation. While Houston can be heavy integregated(which probably is more so do to no zoning then a utopia)Houston tends to put up this facade is if it is some kind of race mixing utopia when that's far from the truth. Pepople of different backgrounds just live by each other because they can afford the housing
Anonymous — July 6, 2011
I'm sure someone will come in and rationalize how there is no racial (if not racist) element to it...
rg — July 6, 2011
Am I the only person who sees the irony in a "nearly exclusive " black event that bemoans segregation? LOL!!!
Anonymous — July 6, 2011
It's kind of disheartening that this article only seems to consider the feelings of white residents of New Orleans. You get the opinions of many racist whites, and a white person who is made uncomfortable by racism (though her reaction is "I wish black people would go away" as opposed to "I wish my boss was less disgusting"), and yourself and how refreshing it was to "see black people." But, there was a black person in this story; what is his opinion on being painted as a thug or a rapist for simply being a few feet behind you? How does he feel about the blatant segregation, and being profiled? In a crowd of black people, you couldn't find one black person to speak to?
It's definitely an interesting topic, and one I have a lot to say about (because this certainly is not a New Orleans-specific trait), but when I read articles like this, on a blog that does not have a good track record with acknowledging the opinions of nonwhite people as equally as valid (if not more so) than the white bloggers, I have to wonder, does Caroline even care about my opinion? Or is this just about how some whites are racist, some whites are made uncomfortable by racism but are still a bit racist themselves, and some whites think racism is just terrible and prefer to see black people around?
Eugene — July 6, 2011
This lady is so wrong, so out of touch. She s not from here...
C. D. Leavitt — July 6, 2011
The reason there aren't many blacks from NOLA in the French Quarter except those who are working shops or entertaining is because the majority of people there who aren't working shops or entertaining are tourists. Locals aren't as likely to flock to the tourist stuff, regardless of color. There's some commentary that can be made on the racial dynamics of the city, but that one really isn't a valid criticism and I wonder if Dr. Heldman is not native to NOLA because she doesn't grasp how a tourist spot like that works.
As an example, here's the map for Las Vegas, NV, which is relatively well-integrated except for the suburbs and one region which has remained primarily black: http://www.flickr.com/photos/walkingsf/5559885507/
Yet if you visit the Strip, the people who are not working will primarily be white or Asian, as they make up the majority of the tourist traffic. The Hispanics who are spread throughout the city aren't walking the Strip in large numbers because that's something tourists do. It's similar in NOLA. It's unusual to see that many black people in the French Quarter because of tourist demographics, an entirely separate issue from segregation.
LadyAnthros — July 6, 2011
I'm not as critical of this blog as some of my fellow readers, but I have to agree that this post seemed mainly about how nice it is for a white lady to "see black faces."
I realize the author had other, more sophisticated intentions, but they didn't quite pan out (at least for me).
Rodrigue — July 6, 2011
Oy vey. This is a classic example of an outsider conceptualization of a city.
She is not from here, nor does she really "get" living here. She is not now, and will not until later understand being a "local," Or have any real sense of race relations in the city.
I think what mostly tips it off is that she went on bourbon street
for any fucking reason. And that she assumes that anyone on bourbon
street is a "local" and not a tourist. and that Earl would be reluctant
because of racism and not just because it's fucking bourbon
street.
It's hilarious and probably offensive on some level that she's living in the seventh anyway.
Gilbert Pinfold — July 7, 2011
" Mayor Ray Nagin reported that there is less crime in the city during the festival."
Heh.
Gilbert Pinfold — July 7, 2011
... And then business as usual after the festivities.
Kelly Seiler — July 7, 2011
Thank you for this. As a white person this kind of overt racism is so often invisible.
As many people in the comments have alluded to white people who are concerned about racism do like seeing black faces. Out of touch white people have very few other ways to judge how non-whites are treated and that is one sign at least that we are in an atmosphere that is open to all.
K00kyKelly — July 7, 2011
Thank you for this. As a white person this kind of overt racism is so often invisible.
As many people in the comments have alluded to white people who are concerned about racism do like seeing black faces. Out of touch white people have very few other ways to judge how non-whites are treated and that is one sign at least that we are in an atmosphere that is open to all.
K00kyKelly — July 7, 2011
Thank you for this. As a white person this kind of overt racism is so often invisible.
As many people in the comments have alluded to white people who are concerned about racism do like seeing black faces. Out of touch white people have very few other ways to judge how non-whites are treated and that is one sign at least that we are in an atmosphere that is open to all.
boy517 — July 7, 2011
ya know I LOVE New Orleans ! Yes people I am a Yankee , a real New York/New Jersey Progressive. When my family (on my mother's side) first immigrated to American from Panama, my Cousin came to New Orleans, illegally in the late 1940's. Needless to say , his son became a U.S Marine Colonel during the Vietnam War.
I go to Mardi Gras every year, and and have been there for the Frecnh Quater Fest, July 4th, even Southern Decadence ...GOD I love that city !!!!! I have made some good friends from NOLA, Slidell, Homa, maybe its because we are Catholic but I have never had any issues once I am there.
My birth cert says NEW YORK CITY and I am VERY Proud of that however my soul says New Orleans, LA !! " Let the Good Times Roll " Baby!!!!!!!
Dianne Jarreau — July 7, 2011
Yes, I have often wondered about the comments of my black friends and relatives that seem not to encounter any racial animosity in NOLA as long as they are dropping the going rates for tourist accommodations and service in the renowned restaurants.
Frankly, I heard the same excuses( back in 1952 )out of the white employees, to wit, the racist comments you continually overhear in the tonier spots are being made by white visitors from other Southern states.
Also, quite frankly, I doubt if anyone of any race has the faintest idea where the communities leave off and which residential areas are white or not white, UNLESS they happen to be looking for an apartment to rent or a house to buy, as I was in 1952; whereupon you discover the true immensity and variety of New Orleans non-white population. Yesterday, I finally read an admission, that this being the very reason that the former Federal Administration in Washington,D.C. had for letting slip their make-over plans for NOLA which would better facilitate the Oil Industry as it had when the Tsunami disaster occurred along the Oil-Shelf from Sri Lanka to Timor L'este(both events occurring between Xmas 2004 and Autumn 2005) It was hinted to me that this was already in the works as far back as when former Sen.Daniel Patrick Moynihan of New York was ambassador to India, and that he had written about it somewhere in his papers; as had a Major in the British military, also, who seemed to know all about the technology of it. More than once, I experienced posters showing up at the nytimes.com who were either Indonesian or crazy attempting to communicate the technical points of how a disaster on that scale can be made to occur. Of course, we know about the back-wash that took place from the gulf hurricane at NOLA;but is there any connection to the "unknown as impending" earthquake which occurred in Haiti within the next several years? Natural? or Technologically induced?
Things have not much changed at the ordinary human level, the sociological level of administration, since I was there; and despite, Treme, on HBO.
Case in point:"In 1951 he was arrested at a bar in Louisiana for violating segregation laws. He was in a black establishment drinking alcohol with African-Americans. he protested in court that he was invited to the bar by black men in uniform and that he was proud to drink with US soldiers."
That would be Zachary Scott of Austin,Texas(and "Hollywood" where he had a sound career as a screen-villain who had appeared opposite Joan Crawford in Mildred Pierce). Scott paid the fines in court of everyone involved. My husband was one of the men in uniform who "invited" Scott and they had a lot to talk about as Zachary Scott's father was a well known surgeon in his community and my future husband was back in his family's home-town for surgical training at the former Medical College of Louisiana (1834-1847), University of Louisiana (1847-1884); because although he had been originally posted to Fort Benning,Georgia, he went to Korea to serve in a M.A.S.H. unit.
Eskimopie2012 — July 7, 2011
Race relations, in new orleans, as any other American city, are extremely subtle and complex. Your little trip to the French Quarter i'm afraid, didn't provide you with enough hands on experience to make such sweeping generalizations about a city with such a rich racial and cultural history. What you are observing is Classism, and in New Orleans that majority of the poor are black. But, there are also old, wealthy black families, black lawyers, politicians and most importantly, black cops. So your theory is way off. Stay a little longer next time, and maybe leave the french quarter.
Eskimopie2012 — July 7, 2011
And its not racist to fear being shot in the french quarter, there is at least one murder every Essence Fest. There was a stabbing on Bourbon Street this year. Safety is a major and valid issue for people who work in the quarter.
NIK — July 7, 2011
I don't think it has anything to do with racism... It has everything to do with class. I've been to NO several times and never felt ostracized by the white community. I wear a clean shirt and carry myself in a respectful and polite manner, like anyone should. However, I CAN understand why there would be trepidation towards the LOCAL BLACK community... I've personally witnessed two robberies, a stabbing, and a woman dropping her pants and peeing in the middle of the sidewalk on Canal St. Yep, broad daylight. ALL were members of the local black community. I just paid some quick visits, yet witnessed such disgusting behavior from locals... Imagine actually living near that.
Hattie Watts — July 7, 2011
I for one find this to be very old news,all you really need is one black cousin or close friend that lives in that city to hear the true story of New Orleans,very much prejudice,always have been, always will be,hey you are still down south,with all the adds to (come party with us!) you see posted every where,you would hope that you could pack your bags and have a real good time,But you are still down south,and nothing really changes down south.
guest — July 8, 2011
Or, quite possibly, the white people don't go to the black music festival because *gasp* they don't like what the music. Gee......
I dislike rap, and jazz--most of it---and the majority of black music that I've run in to (which may certainly be less than representative) seems to be loud, misogynistic and profane. Why ever would I go?
I
Anonymous — July 9, 2011
Wow.
Two points, first for the commenters, second for the blog owners:
1. When you say it's about class, not race, the assumption behind that statement is that class and race have no relation to each other. Which isn't true at all.
2. This blog needs robust moderation. I've mentioned it before, as have several others. With the current comments that are allowed here, this blog is not a safe space for MANY, MANY people. It's disheartening to me that Lisa and Gwen are not concerned about the racism, sexism, fat-shaming, transphobia, homophobia, etcetera that constantly show up here. I understand that you're both busy, but put out a call for some volunteer moderators and make this blog a better space for respectful discourse.