Race’s role in higher education gets a lot of press. Recent challenges to admissions procedures and classes on race highlight problems with whiteness, raising questions about the state of college diversity. But what often gets left out of these conversations is the impact of diversity on learning itself and the nuances of how these impacts differ between students.
A diverse student environment can have a positive effect on learning, especially since students from other backgrounds can help each other think about topics differently. In addition, students can learn from the lived experiences of their out-group peers.
- Patricia Gurin, Biren (Ratnesh) A. Nagda, and Gretchen E. Lopez. 2004. “The Benefits of Diversity in Education for Democratic Citizenship.” Journal of Social Issues 60(1): 17-34
- Sylvia Hurtado. 2006. ” Linking Diversity with the Educational and Civic Missions of Higher Education.” The Review of Higher Education 30(2): 185-196
While diversity has overall beneficial impacts for the educational process, these outcomes are not created equal. White students are more likely to connect class concepts to abstract theory or class contexts rather than personal experiences, and they are more likely to join in class discussions than are black students.
- Josh Packard. 2011. “Activating Diversity: The Impact of Student Race of Contributions to Course Discussions.” Teaching Sociology 41(2): 144–158.
- Lisa M. Nunn. 2011. “Classrooms as Racialized Spaces: Dynamics of Collaboration, Tension, and Student Attitudes in Urban and Suburban High Schools.” Urban Education,46(6): 1226-1255
Students from different backgrounds connect to professors, faculty, and educational spaces differently, affecting their scores and educational success. Notably, this affects the way educators teach and grade. Nonwhite students, particularly under a white teacher, are more likely to feel alienated in the classroom, participate less, and receive lower scores.
- Yoshimitsu Takei & Roger Shouse. 2008. “Ratings in Black and White: Does racial symmetry or asymmetry influence teacher assessment of a pupil’s work habits?” Social Psychology of Education 11:367–387
Comments 2
Rachel Kinnunen — March 10, 2015
Good article Neeraj - very relevant and in line with the article Hunter Gehlbach wrote recently in regards to how "Learning about Commonalities Can Improve Student-Teacher Relationships and Boost Achievement" in situations such as the ones you described here
Rachel Kinnunen — March 10, 2015
Learning about Commonalities Can Improve Student-Teacher Relationships and Boost Achievement