
A prison watchtower silhouetted against the sky, with barbed wire fencing in the foreground.“prison guard tower” by Rennett Stowe is licensed under CC BY 2.0.
Extensive research has examined how prison affects the lives of adults once they leave the system. However, scholars have been limited in their ability to investigate how prison affects the lives of people who are incarcerated consistently or intermittently during their “coming-of-age” period. These long-term prison sentences (10 years or more, although not always continuous) are difficult to study because scholars are often unable to enter prisons to conduct research, leaving a gap in our understanding of a particularly vulnerable population of young people.
David Knight addressed this issue by conducting research with consistently and intermittently incarcerated African American and Afro-Latino men, as Black men make up roughly half of adult male sentences which last for 5 years or longer.
The interviewees were with 18 to 34 years olds and were either incarcerated at the time of the interview or had been incarcerated during their teenage and adult years. Knight concluded that young men who were incarcerated early in their lives in both groups understood their identities as deeply connected to prisons. Rather than just thinking about prisons as places, many interviewees understood their experiences even outside of the physical space as defined by their incarceration. They described their lives, from childhood to adulthood, and even after being released, as restricted and deprived in comparison to their peers.
- “In prison, you still [get] older year after year. You still turn eighteen…still turn thirty…but it’s the setting that makes you act a different way…Instead of getting your own apartment…a single cell…The first time you may fill out a job application is for a prison job.”
Knight also found that some who were continuously incarcerated described being detained during their youth as a means of ‘protecting’ them from dangers from the ‘outside’, such as violence and addiction.
- “When I look back at my teenage self…it’s a good thing I came to prison, if only for the fact that I can really stop and listen…it would have been bad for me, way worse than it is now.”
Although mortality rates are often lower inside prisons than outside of prisons, Knight’s interviewees describe their experiences as dehumanizing, degrading, and debasing. In other words, we can understand these sentiments as a commentary on the lack of support for marginalized communities, rather than support for what is happening in prisons themselves.
This research highlights that prisons are not just physical spaces, but institutions that profoundly shape identity and future life opportunities. Incarcerated youth, during critical developmental years, are further marginalized from peers who experience key educational, social, and personal milestones. As prisons increasingly become environments where young men and women grow up, it is crucial to continue studying how they shape the transition to adulthood.