A recent New York Times article highlighted the phenomenon of African Americans downplaying racial markers in their resumes in order to compete in the job market:
Tahani Tompkins was struggling to get callbacks for job interviews in the Chicago area this year when a friend made a suggestion: Change your name. Instead of Tahani, a distinctively African-American-sounding name, she began going by T. S. Tompkins in applications.
Yvonne Orr, also searching for work in Chicago, removed her bachelor’s degree from Hampton University, a historically black college, leaving just her master’s degree from Spertus Institute, a Jewish school. She also deleted a position she once held at an African-American nonprofit organization and rearranged her references so the first people listed were not black.
Black job seekers said the purpose of hiding racial markers extended beyond simply getting in the door for an interview. It was also part of making sure they appeared palatable to hiring managers once race was seen. Activism in black organizations, even majoring in African-American studies can be signals to employers. Removing such details is all part of what Ms. Orr described as “calming down on the blackness.”
The article provides some sociological data on how African Americans are faring in the labor market:
[The] Popular perception that affirmative action still confers significant advantages to black job candidates…is not borne out in studies. Moreover, statistics show even college-educated blacks suffering disproportionately in this jobless environment compared with whites.
“The average organization either doesn’t have diversity programs, or has the type that is not effective and can even lead to backlash,” said Alexandra Kalev, a University of Arizona sociologist who has studied such efforts. “So in the average organization, being black doesn’t help.”
Playing down one’s black identity may carry a psychic toll for those who do so:
In “Covering: the Hidden Assault on Our Civil Rights,” Kenji Yoshino, a law professor at New York University, wrote about this phenomenon not just among blacks but also other minority groups. “My notion of covering is really about the idea that people can have stigmatized identities that either they can’t or won’t hide but nevertheless experience a huge amount of pressure to downplay those identities,” he said. Mr. Yoshino says that progress in hiring has meant that “the line originally was between whites and nonwhites, favoring whites; now it’s whites and nonwhites who are willing to act white.”
John L. Jackson Jr., a professor of anthropology and communications at the University of Pennsylvania and author of “Racial Paranoia,” said he wondered about the “existential cost” of this kind of behavior, even if the adjustments were temporary and seem harmless.
“In some ways, they are denying who and what they are,” he said. “They almost have to pretend themselves away.”
Comments 4
Cathy Toll — December 11, 2009
On a related matter, I am told by leaders of the online university Capella that graduate students of color experience a totally different atmosphere in online courses where their "race" is not evident. Research at Capella indicates that these students feel listened to more and find their ideas considered with more seriousness, and they attribute it to the unintentional "covering" provided by virtual classrooms.
Tweets that mention “calming down one’s blackness” » Contexts Crawler -- Topsy.com — December 11, 2009
[...] This post was mentioned on Twitter by pam, Contexts Magazine. Contexts Magazine said: Crawler: “calming down one’s blackness” - http://bit.ly/6MAQGk [...]
mc — December 11, 2009
Women do this too, I'd say -- it's a very conscious decision for me to use my initials in all official things (including my work email, every resume i've ever done, my website, etc) rather than my distinctly female name -- and I've definitely had comments made before. You know, "Oh! I'm sorry, I was looking for a man! Didn't realise you were a girl!" (Girl. Not woman. Right. Well, fooled you on paper.) Being black, being female, being of any ethnicity -- these things are all 'marked', and we all want to be 'blank' so that our 'accomplishments' stand out over our names, genders, or races.
But this here I think is part of a wider phenomenon -- just wanted to point out that adjusting things on text in ways to hide or disguise certain 'unfavorable' or 'inherent' characteristics isn't only limited to this situation, and is a long-standing tradition. I have friends of Jewish descent whose families changed their names or name spelling upon moving here to sound 'less Jewish'. I'm sure there must have been some Irish in 19th century NYC dropping the O' from their names to get a job, or a general trend of people making their names WASPier so as to seem 'better' on paper. I think it's interesting how we can tie this into wider trends from this specific article.
bad credit loans — December 29, 2009
Hello!!! thesocietypages.org is one of the most excellent informational websites of its kind. I enjoy reading it every day. thesocietypages.org rocks!