“Health care is a right!” It’s a familiar refrain on the left. Progressives argue universal human dignity requires that access to care not be restricted to those who can pay. It is a central tenet of what it means to live in a democratic society. British theorist E.G. Marshall noted that health care was one of many “social rights” necessary for humans to flourish and hence be part of a well functioning democracy. As a reaction, many on the left ask government to step in and provide this necessary good.
Is it time for us to think of access to responsible journalism in the same way? The first amendment pays special attention to the freedom of the press because of its central position in challenging those in power. In the era of “over the air” television, the three major networks took seriously the responsibility owed to the public. Watch a broadcast of Face the Nation or the evening news and compare it to today’s news fare.
The advent of cable television, however, eviscerated the quaint notion of the public airwaves (and a corresponding public trust). The result has been a slow descent into covering the spectacle of politics over actual politics itself. To accommodate this new reality, politics has become more spectacular. In particular, this 2016 presidential race is unprecedented for the lack of public policy coverage. It has been almost entirely replaced by low cost “pundits” that analyze easily digestible “optics” or “tactics.” Substantive discussion about critical questions facing the nation have taken a backseat to weeks of argument over whether a major party candidate calling a judge a “Mexican” means the candidate is a racist.
I don’t mean to romanticize the politics of yesteryear. Penny presses were plenty salacious. But in a time and age where issues are increasingly complex, our system requires a sober, thoughtful citizenry capable of making thoughtful decisions (at least thoughtful enough to “do no harm” and not elect demagogues). We need news sources that are not driven by profit motive to cover important affairs of state in a banal way.
Given this, is it time for us to think about demanding the creation of impartial “public news” in the fashion of the BBC. We have something on radio in the US that isn’t directly driven by profit and strives to provide public policy coverage. Would an NPT (National Public Television) akin to our National Public Radio (NPR) give citizens the tools necessary to make informed decisions?
I don’t mean a replacement for PBS. I mean a 24 hour public television news station that was “listener sponsored” and sought to present pressing policy issues and world events in an interesting and compelling way. It would not be bound by ratings in the same way that CNN, Fox or MSNBC are bound. Could you have a television version of “All Things Considered” or “Planet Money” that would take an honest stab at objectivity and would provide those who listened with a better understanding of public challenges?
The parallels with health care are important, if imperfect. Not everyone has the time or inclination to read longform journalism. But most Americans do have a few moments to watch the news. How many people would switch from Fox or CNN if they had an “NPR TV station” as an alternative? Would they be better informed citizens if they did?
Comments 9
Emma Watson — May 22, 2024
Very well written article thanks for the information try Mb Whatsapp
Clark Kent — May 28, 2024
All the information in this article seem legit, try to edit pictures with picsart mod.
Frank — August 7, 2024
Discover seamless efficiency in real estate management with Crecentech Systems Private Limited's expert podio crm services. Optimize your operations and elevate client satisfaction today. Explore our tailored solutions and transform your real estate business with cutting-edge CRM technology. Ready to enhance productivity? Contact us now!
Poem Generator — August 8, 2024
Our Poem Generator tool enables you to create poems like haiku, free verse, and sonnets with length variations.
Sudadera — August 8, 2024
Explora nuestra moderna colección de Sudadera perfectas para uso casual. Alta calidad, cómodo y a la moda. ¡Compra ahora!
redheadhome — August 13, 2024
Thought-provoking piece! Just as healthcare is essential for a thriving democracy, so is access to responsible journalism. It's vital that we uphold these pillars for an informed society. Speaking of essentials, understanding costs like Septic Tank Inspection Cost can also contribute to making informed decisions about our homes and communities.
jonsmith — September 30, 2024
Honista Instagram latest version
enables Instagram users to download media directly from Instagram
Linda — October 10, 2024
Thanks for sharing your valuable thoughts on responsible journalism and the idea of National Public Television—it’s a crucial topic! Try GB WhatsApp for enhanced messaging Get it here.
gb whatsapp download — October 23, 2024
Share large images without compression, please use GB WhatsApp.
Safe Download