
Picture a small office with three employees: Jake, a white man; Anita, a Latina woman whose husband lost his job a year ago; and Crystal, a Black single mother. Even though all three have similar duties, Jake takes home $1000 per paycheck, while Crystal gets $700 and Anita earns $600. The office also used to employ Anne, another Black woman, but she was laid off in 2009. Crystal and Anita are fortunate to still have their jobs, but their wages put their yearly earnings below the federal poverty line. Unable to get by on their wages alone, their families also depend on public benefits.
This specific scenario is imaginary, but it reflects on-going trends. The Great Recession brought hard times to most Americans, but it was especially devastating for women of color. Today, Black women and Latinas face worse job and wage prospects, and experience higher poverty rates and greater difficulties in gaining access to health care. Many female-headed households have depleted their “rainy day” savings and depend on a patchwork of low wages and bare-bones supplements like food stamps and unemployment insurance to make ends meet. The 2009 recession and slow economic growth since then have derailed many women’s previously modest economic progress. Seven years later, America’s women of color are still worse off than they were before the economic crisis hit.
Eroding Financial Security
Black and Hispanic women suffered big income losses during and after the Great Recession. In 2009 alone, Black females holding jobs dropped from 58.8 to 54.6 percent, while Latinas holding employment fell from 51.9 to 50.1 percent. Today, 8.9 percent of Black women and 7.4 percent of Latinas are looking for jobs they cannot find (and their rates of unemployment exceed the national average by 3.8 and 2.3 percentage points respectively).
Already struggling households headed by Black women and Latinas plunged into poverty. From 2007 to 2011, the percentage of Black female-headed households in poverty jumped from 43.9 to 47.3 percent. The numbers are worse for Latina-headed households, for whom the percentage in poverty grew from 46.6 to 49.1 percent. Today’s poverty rate for Black female-headed households is still above pre-Recession levels at 45.6 percent, while the Latina rate has fallen to 46.3 percent.
Limited Access to Health Insurance
Thanks in large part to the Affordable Care Act, health care access is one of the few areas where Black and Latina women have returned to pre-Recession levels. Between 2007 and 2011, private health insurance dropped from 54.1 percent to 50 percent for Black women and 45.2 to 41.6 percent for Latinas. The bulk of that loss came from employment-based health insurance, and reflects the employment losses women of color suffered.
Some emergency provisions of the Affordable Care Act went into effect in early 2010, offering health coverage to some Americans who lost jobs. Government-provided health insurance increased coverage in 2010 from 36.7 to 45.5 percent for Black women and from 31.1 to 42.1 percent for Latinas. Today the share of women of color who still lack health insurance has fallen significantly. However, women of color remain vulnerable in the many states that do not offer Medicaid to those close to the poverty line. Research shows that people without insurance often put off needed health checkups and may delay life-saving care until too late.
A Hostile Political Landscape
Despite Barack Obama’s historic presidency, America’s women of color are also losing political leverage. Since 2009, 10 states have adopted photo ID laws that disproportionately burden otherwise eligible low-income, Black, and Latino voters. Many of them cannot afford cars and do not have drivers’ licenses, and states make it difficult to obtain alternative forms of photo identification. Twenty-five percent of Blacks eligible to vote and 16 percent of Latinos eligible to vote lack a valid photo ID, compared with only 8 percent of whites.
In addition to facing barriers to voting, Black and Latina women rarely appear on the ballot for public offices whose incumbents make crucial decisions about the economy and social benefits. Black and Latina women only fill 27 of the 535 seats in the U.S. Congress, and they fill only 340 of the 7,382 state legislative seats. Until more women of color vote and serve in office, policymakers will likely remain uninterested in addressing their extraordinary economic difficulties. Latinas and Black women and the families that depend upon them will continue to fall behind, even as the rest of America recovers from the Great Recession.
Comments 1
Simple martini recipes — December 4, 2015
Advocates for transgender people have long decried the mainstream media’s lack of attention to the continued violence against transgender women of color in particular. And there is hope that the population’s increased public profile can shine attention on the discrimination transgender people still face in employment, health care, and the criminal justice system.