If you stop and think about it, alcohol is just the worst. Almost every one who drinks has experienced the pain of a mean morning hangover (at least once). Also, the experience of being drunk… why is that enjoyable? When drunk you slur your words, it’s hard to think straight, you’re liable to say or do something that will offend the people around you, and you can’t legally drive a car. Why does any of that sound like a good way to spend a Friday night?
To a sociologist, the reason people drink alcohol is that they have been socially taught to. That is, we like alcohol because we’ve been taught to overlook the negative side effects or we have redefined them as positive. If that’s confusing, don’t worry. Let’s talk about another drug people abuse (marijuana) and how the sociologist Howard Becker argues we socially construct getting high and being a stoner.
Becoming a Marijuana User
In 1953 Becker set out to answer what appears to be a simple question: how does a person become a marijuana user. After interviewing fifty marijuana users Becker (1953: 235) concluded that:
An individual will be able to use marihuana for pleasure only when he (1) learns to smoke it in a way that will produce real effects; (2) learns to recognize the effects and connect them with drug use; and (3) learns to enjoy the sensations he perceives. This proposition based on an analysis of fifty interviews with marihuana users, calls into question theories which ascribe behavior to antecedent predispositions and suggests the utility of explaining behavior in terms of the emergence of motives and dispositions in the course of experience.
The first point should be pretty obvious. You can’t get high if you don’t inhale when you smoke marijuana (like President Bill Clinton). So the first step to becoming a pot smoker is learning to properly smoke pot. Most often this takes place when an experienced smoker socializes (i.e. trains) a novice smoker in the mechanics of the task.
Becker’s second point might be harder to understand. Drugs inherently alter your physiology… that’s what makes them drugs. Being in a chemcially alterted state can be disorienting. But don’t believe me, watch this:
David, the little boy in the movie, had not been socialized to how anesthesia works. Similarly, when you ingest any drug you have to be taught to recognize the effects. So for marijuana maybe that would include heightened senses, food cravings, and possibly a sense of anxiety or paranoia. When you haven’t been socialized it’s easy to go into a panic or ignore the effects altogether.
For instance, around 2007 a police officer in Dearborn Heights Michigan stole marijuana from a drug arrest, baked it into brownies, and then consumed the brownies to get high for what he said was his very first time. He then called 911 because he thought he was dying. Becker would likely say that if he had been socialized and knew what effects he should expect, the police officer wouldn’t have likely freaked out and incriminated himself.
After you’ve learned to inhale properly, learned to recognize how the substance will alter you, then the last step to becoming a marijuana user is to redefine potentially negative experiences as positive. As we talked about above, smoking marijuana can lead to anxiety, paranoia, insatiable food cravings, hyper sensitivity, confusion, etc.
To see an example of this, we need look no further than the comment section under the video I just showed you. What WeBeChillin420’s comment does is reframe a panic attack into a desirable thing. S/he seems to be nostalgic for his or her first time consuming freak out quantities of marijuana.
Becker and the scholars he inspired to research marijuana communities further point out that it’s common among smokers to say that “coughing gets you higher.” Actually, coughing after smoking is your body’s way of telling you that you inhaled something it didn’t like. It’s your body literally gasping for air. It seems just as likely that marijuana users could think of coughing as a bad thing or as a sign they inhaled too much. Instead smokers socially construct coughing as a positive and desirable thing.
All Drugs Are Socially Constructed
While Becker focused on marijuana, we can extend his ideas to every type of drug. For instance let’s look at caffeine. Coffee and Red Bull are said to be “acquired tastes.” Doesn’t this mean that you have to learn to like them? You have to learn to like to feel a slight jitteriness? What you can take from Becker’s research is that how we think about drugs, how we react to any drug or medicine we ingest, and how we feel about others who’ve used drugs are all social constructs.
Nathan Palmer, MA is a visiting lecturer at Georgia Southern University. He is a passionate educator, the founder of Sociology Source, and the editor of Sociology in Focus, where this post originally appeared.
Comments 21
Bill R — July 15, 2014
That I've been taught to do almost everything I do is obvious, self-evident. Most of what we ingest is based on learned behaviors. Certainly many things we do are not beneficial to our well-being or "happiness".
Short story: When I was about 10 years old my uncle forced me to eat 10 raw clams at the beach, stating that I couldn't tell if I really liked clams unless I ate at least 10. Later, although the wrath of god was rained down upon him by my mother, I realized I actually liked clams and have relished them since.
Nature and nurture are each powerful forces that interact.
cd — July 15, 2014
It depends on what particular effects you're considering. It didn't take practice for me to appreciate the way moderate amounts of alcohol turn off my social anxiety. It does take practice to enjoy the way larger amounts of alcohol affect balance, or the relaxing effect of knowing that there's definitely no way you're getting any more work done today so why worry about it, or the way marijuana affects the perception of time.
As for caffeine, I love the taste of tea and drink it every day and I *still* hate the effects if they go beyond staving off withdrawal. But I don't think this is what people mean by coffee being an acquired taste. I think it's more like the way olives are an acquired taste, in that it's bitter and strongly flavored and has to be approached with the right expectations if you're going to enjoy it.
Gwendolyn Snyder — July 15, 2014
I'm so sad this post didn't at least touch on Maureen Dowd's epic freak out last month.
What a gift from the gods.
arintno — July 15, 2014
Sociology Source link should be sociologysource.org
DeColonise — July 16, 2014
Interesting piece. We humans have most likely used drugs, mostly psychadelics , for probably as long a we walked on this planet--we, among most other mammals, like to alter our state of being from time to time--how society teaches about drugs is key to healthy drug use on the other hand.
The drug culture in industrial society (and in particular western society) is very very backwards and destructive.
For example cannabis, that is taken as an example here, can be used in very good ways and many other cultures have a whole other relation to it than to "just get stoned a friday night". It has spiritual meaning for many landbased human cultures throughout history for example.
Regarding alcohol, why its even legal I think has a lot to do with the fact that its a drug that tends to make sure that people can continue the boring industrial wageslavery without loosing their minds before weekend comes and people, again, can drink to forget. Its a drug that do not alter the wheel of capitalism or industry, same goes for both tobacco and caffeine as well.
Psychedelics which I wrote about first, who most likely are drugs that have been used most by humans throughout our species planetary history, tend to be negative on the wheel of capitalism and industry. Often one hear that people get lazy and unsocial. While that is no doubt true in some cases, I don't think that it is the most honest answer to give. Fact of the matter is that many who uses psychedelics, such as cannabis, are very creative. It's just that they are not creative in the way that supports industrialism and/or capitalism very well. They tend to get interested in more healthy and sane things.
But most users of drugs in our western society, in which has such a terrible drug culture, use drugs only to flee something or to "Party". It has no bigger significant in their lives and I don't think any drug use should be about partying or fleeing your life.
Larry Charles Wilson — July 16, 2014
By watching babies learn to eat solid foods you will soon notice that most everything we ingest (other than mother's milk) is an "acquired taste."
Danelle Coleman — July 16, 2014
I wouldn't say you have to "learn" to like a drug, I would instead say you have to learn to see past the negative effects in order to experience the positives. Marijuana relaxes you, so does alcohol. That is the primary reason people use it. To relax. Not because we think we should like feeling disoriented and have hangovers. Those are just the pros and cons. Everyone determines if the positive effects of the drug are worth the negative. And everything new can be scary the first time.
This would apply to a drug. Your friend tells you that you may feel a little paranoid or anxious at first. When you first start feeling these things they don't panic you, because you know that is normal and its just part of the overall experience.
I do agree that the act of drinking on the weekends is a social regimen, I also believe it is based on the effects of alcohol being a relaxing drug vs purely on doing it for the sake of doing it.
Damien Quinn — July 17, 2014
I don't think your line of reasoning is totally off but I think the mechanisim that creates the socialization of the intoxicated experience is a little different than is suggested here.
Without a doubt, there are some intoxicants that do benefit form being socialized. These are the intoxicants that tend to enhance whatever mood you're already in. Psychedelics, cannabis and alcohol would all be in this loose category, they all make you feel better if you're feeling good and terrible if you're feeling bad.
Expectations do have an impact on the individuals experience but only in the sense that, if you are worried that the drug might kill you sober, you'll reach levels of terror (in proportion to your level of intoxication) once you're stoned. Socialization helps with this, for example, experienced stoners don't worry about dying of a brownie OD (for long) because they are sure it won't happen.
On the other hand, there are plenty of intoxicants that make you euphoric regardless of set or setting and your level of socialization in relation to these substances is almost irrelevant once the user has decided to take them. Opiates or amphetamines would fall into this category, again, very loosely.
Biggus Disqus — July 21, 2014
Becker and the scholars he inspired to research marijuana communities
further point out that it’s common among smokers to say that “coughing
gets you higher.” Actually, coughing after smoking is your body’s way of
telling you that you inhaled something it didn’t like. It’s your body
literally gasping for air. It seems just as likely that marijuana users
could think of coughing as a bad thing or as a sign they inhaled too
much. Instead smokers socially construct coughing as a positive and
desirable thing.
Well, in the case of cannabis it actually is a good thing because some of the compounds present in the smoke make it act as an expectorant( as opposed to making the smoker "gasp for air").
So the coughing from smoking cannabis is generally different than the coughing from inhaling smoke from a campfire or a cigarette and has been speculated to be a factor in why people who smoke both cannabis and tobacco have lower instances of lung cancer than those who smoke tobacco by itself (thanks to coughing up more tar and other crud that would otherwise remain in the lungs). Of course, there are many confounding variables such as smoking cannabis with too-hot a flame or smoking concentrated extracts, etc. that can induce coughing fits for the conventional reasons so it's a more nuanced issue than it seems.
One thing that vividly illustrates the stark differences between cigarette smoke and cannabis smoke is the state of the interior walls of the residence of a heavy cannabis smoker vs. a heavy cigarette smoker (assuming both are smoked indoors).
The once-white walls of a cigarette smokers' house (among other things) will be yellowed and may have built up enough residue to feel oily to the touch. Thanks to this residue the room tends to stink even if no cigarettes have been smoked in it for a long time. The yellowing is from the same stuff that darkens a cigarette's filter (tars and related compounds) and coats lung tissue, darkening the lungs.
The walls of a cannabis smokers' house will still be the original shade of white even after many years of heavy smoking and the room will have no detectable odor of anything having been smoked in it once the smoke has settled out of the air. There will be a lot more dust present in the rooms cannabis is smoked in vs. rooms it's not smoked in because the residue from cannabis smoke falls out of the air as particulates vs. the vaporized tars from tobacco that condense onto surfaces and stick.
Also, the part about making a negative seem like a positive (in the context of a panic attack) seems like a stretch. If someone tries to put a positive spin on a cannabis-induced panic attack then I'd wonder more about their mental health and would not assume it was a means of redefining a negative as a positive in order to socialize oneself into being a "marijuana smoker."
It's a potential issue that would best be avoided but is not so severe as to inhibit most consumers from continuing to consume it, so in that respect it's like going to the beach and getting a sunburn; we didn't want a sunburn and they are annoying and sometimes serious but the chance of getting one won't stop most of us from going to the beach, especially as we learn how to prevent them. It seems to me more like a simple matter of perceived rewards outweighing perceived risks.
Panic attacks are not uncommon after smoking strains very high in THC but low in CBD, especially among those with a low tolerance. So one way of minimizing them is getting more balanced strains or complementing a high-THC strain with a high-CBD extract or edible. I've had such a panic attack more than once, and they seemed to stem from the combo of a high-THC/low-CBD strain, consuming a high dose quickly, and having low blood sugar at the time. They were also unpleasant enough for me to figure out how to prevent them, and after putting in some effort toward that end they are no longer an issue. It never occurred to me to try to spin a panic attack as part of the fun, which it most definitely is not.
Biggus Disqus — July 21, 2014
What you can take from Becker’s research is that how we think about
drugs, how we react to any drug or medicine we ingest, and how we feel
about others who’ve used drugs are all social constructs.
I think that many psychedelics defy the assertion that how we react to them is a social construct due to the nature of their effect on cognitive processes. How such experiences are interpreted after the fact will certainly be culturally-defined but things like DMT or ibogaine work at a fundamental level of cognition that allow the re-writing of what used to be considered "fixed" social imprinting (the personality stuff that once we're adults used to be generally considered very hard or impossible to change).
The effects that these types of drugs induce are happening at the neurotransmitter level which means they are altering our actual physiology (temporarily). So for example consuming psilocybin-containing mushrooms means we're perceiving the world through a "psilocin lens" instead of the usual "serotonin lens" we're used to.
On the other hand consuming alcohol, or cocaine, or even cannabis does not work like that. With those, we're still seeing the world through our conventional serotonin lens but other, mostly-peripheral effects on our perception and nervous system functioning are felt (e.g. stimulated vs. depressed).
So most mind-altering drugs (especially those used recreationally) are merely altering our post-perception interpretation of stimuli or altering our metabolism whereas many drugs classified as "psychedelic" are altering the neurochemical foundations of perception itself and so need no external stimuli at all to induce powerful experiences; people who are drunk or geeked out on cocaine do not like to sit quietly in total darkness and silence for a few hours but such a setting acts like a blank canvas for a psychedelic and boredom is never an issue.
This is why psychedelics such as LSD or ibogaine have shown such spectacular results in experiments studying their ability to "cure" alcoholism or opiate addiction (and sometimes addictive tendencies in general). By allowing the re-writing of what we might consider pathological imprinting it eliminates the root of the problem and so if it takes, the cure tends to be permanent.
The irony is that used properly, psychedelics (aka "hallucinogens") can help one learn to better handle the real world and thereby not feel so compelled to escape it with a conventional type of recreational drug. That's one of the ways that ibogaine cures opiate addiction. It breaks our social constructs, and sometimes shatters them to pieces which can be scary as hell, but that is also what their therapeutic benefits largely stem from.
It's a nuanced point that's hard to parse (not unlike trying to describe a psychedelic experience with words or talk about ego loss without using the world "I") but I suppose what I'm getting at is that while the ways that we consume and interpret most -but not all- mind-altering substances are social constructs, so are the ways that we arbitrarily categorize drugs as well as the way that we talk about them. And that can result in preconceptions about what's going on in someone's head when they're "high" that may not jibe with what's been observed in medical/scientific studies of how some types of drugs work at the physiological level (as opposed to the psychological).
So while the statement "All drugs are socially constructed" might be true in some sense, it's also true that some drugs corrode or demolish social constructs (sometimes permanently) and I would argue that the deconstruction (or demolition) of social constructs is not a form of social construct.
Kate Johnson — July 22, 2014
I remember as a teenager (in a country where teenagers drinking is both legal and generally considered appropriate) learning to drink. It takes learning to like the taste of alcohol - that was a big thing, learning to like the bitter flavours was odd. But I also remember learning how to be drunk - particularly in a group. How you behave after one drink - feeling just a little distant from worries and a little slow didn't take me any time to like but learning how to be pissed in a group takes practice. That giggly silliness and daft often hyper behaviour is such a learned response to a depressant. I remember it taking a few years before as a group we knew how to do it.
elizabeth31 — July 23, 2014
While I will heartily agree with some of your thoughts here (especially: "we can extend his ideas to every type of drug. For instance let’s look at caffeine"), some of this almost lends to suggest that you don't actually smoke marijuana. Let me 'splain.
When you say, "Actually, coughing after smoking is your body’s way of telling you that
you inhaled something it didn’t like. It’s your body literally gasping
for air" you sound a little bit confused as to the consumption of marijuana.
Firstly, coughing happens from loads of things when smoking, and MOST often from what we call "user error" (refer to step 1: LEARN HOW TO CONSUME THE DRUG!) There are TONS of ways to consume marijuana that range from harshest to the lightest of light. If one was concerned about "coughing" (which btw, isn't like a tobacco smokers cough--you will cough for a minute if that and be on your way never to cough again), there are a plethora of options that produce little to no smoke (a layered bong with ice catcher, a vaporizer, edibles, etc). Coughing isn't indicative of your body expelling anything--if you inhale that THC is going nowhere except to your fat cells fast.
Second, we know that your body isn't actually desperate to get rid of the effects, because THC stays in your body for months and sometimes years, whereas everything else (caffeine, alcohol, heroine, meth, coke, etc, etc) is expelled in the short span of DAYS. Your body is not threatened at all by THC, but if take a few shots and see how your body feels about tequila!
Third, as Biggus Disqus down there mentioned, you can see the effect of what level of "coughing" a chronic marijuana user has vs a cigeratte smoker, by just visiting their house! Tobacco users tend to have everything "in its place", but still can't hide the lingering smell and ashy walls, bad breath, yellow fingers, as well as thin film on everything. This is because Tobacco smoke IS something your body wants to expel--it sticks to everything! A weed smoker may have a messier house, but only needs to open a window and there is zero evidence they ever partook. The smoke is not coating their walls and sofas, or leaving an impossible to take out smell (ever bought a car from a smoker? The smell never leaves...)
I could go on the subject of coughing for days, literally, but I don't want to bore you as you are probably NOT a smoker and have no interest in becoming one. I will wrap this up, therefore.
At the end of the day, I DO agree with your basic premise. I have a HUGE problem with how it is an "ok addiction" to be addicted to Caffeine and Nicotine in our society, and how people tend to not care. There is another one I can't recall right now, but the point is we say some "addictions" are ok, and some are not, and that IS bothersome, because it is all cultural perception. Then again, we are all living in a Eurocentric society, and Europeans have been known to enjoy alcohol and tobacco for many centuries now. Other cultures liked weed, but they are not in control. Such is the Capitalist mindset. Cheers!
XVIII | maxweylandt — August 10, 2014
[…] Do You Have to Learn How to Get High? […]
Leee95 — August 25, 2014
I actually find this article very interesting, especially the beginning section about alcohol. After reading this article I thought to myself "why do people drink?" When you really think about it they're no good side effects to drinking. You throw up, promiscuity is increased, and your rational is completely thrown out the window, but just like the article said we as a society have been socially conditioned to think that those horrible side effects are good. I personally think that's crazy, and somewhat amazing how society can turn something pretty negative into a weekend activity for many.
artie fufkin — November 19, 2014
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IRBAZJ4lF0U#t=96
Sandra Edwards — April 25, 2020
I just really thought about this as it is mention here in the article. We grew up and have seen our parents or other relatives drinking alcohol.So, we learn from there to drink even during special occasions, but never thought or even was told some of us,that it has a negative side to drinking, where, if we drink excess alcohol, it could cause much danger physically and mentally. Even marijuana has much negative side effects, but in this modern socierty, many see them both with much more positive than negative benefits solving their problems. Unfortunately, they don't help us too much dancing in the clouds of happiness. Instead, they can easily send us into a place where there are more sadness. These are not alternatives solutions to life's problems.
Zaza K Green — September 8, 2021
A few weeks ago, a friend strongly recommended Vibes CBD oil, told me to go to the site https://vibescbd.co.uk and try to buy one for a start. After a couple of weeks, I did it. After I tried it, I immediately sat down and ordered a few more, it's very cool! I advise each of you.
Scott Piligrimm — May 18, 2022
I am against alcohol. It's very unhealthy, and besides, I can't stand a hangover in the morning. Weed is a completely different thing, I like the effect of cannabis. I decided to grow cannabis as a houseplant, so I found a trusted blog with information on where to buy cannabis seeds and how to grow them so check it out. I think I will give up alcohol altogether.