Edward Bernays (1891-1995) is largely considered the founder of public relations (or “engineering consent,” as he called it) but is not known very well outside of the marketing and advertising fields. A nephew of Sigmund Freud, Bernays was the first to theorize that people could be made to want things they don’t need by appealing to unconscious desires (to be free, to be successful etc.). Bernays, and propaganda theorist Walter Lippman, were members of the U.S. Government’s Committee on Public Information (CPI), which successfully convinced formally isolationist Americans to support entrance into World War I. While propaganda was commonly thought of as a negative way of manipulating the masses that should be avoided, Bernays believed that it was necessary for the functioning of a society, as otherwise people would be overwhelmed with too many choices. In his words:
Modern propaganda is a consistent, enduring effort to create or shape events to influence the relations of the public to an enterprise, idea or group.
[Source: Bernays, Propaganda, 1928, p. 52; available here.]
After WWI, Bernays was hired by the American Tobacco Company to encourage women to start smoking. While men smoked cigarettes, it was not publicly acceptable for women to smoke. Bernays staged a dramatic public display of women smoking during the Easter Day Parade in New York City. He then told the press to expect that women suffragists would light up “torches of freedom” during the parade to show they were equal to men. Like the “You’ve come a long way, baby” ads, this campaign commodified women’s progress and desire to be considered equal to men (relevant clip starts at 3:00):
“Cigarettes were a symbol of the penis and of male sexual power…Women would smoke because it was then that they’d have their own penises.”
Here are some of the news photographs of women smoking publicly during the Easter Parade:

[Photos via.]
The campaign was considered successful as sales to women increased afterward. Cigarette companies followed Bernays’s lead and created ad campaigns that targeted women. Lucky Brand Cigarettes capitalized on recent fashions for skinny women by telling women to “Reach for a Lucky instead of a sweet”:


Marlboro, in stark contrast to the Marlboro Man ads we’re familiar with today, started the “Mild as May” campaign to encourage women to take up smoking cigarettes that were appropriately mild and easier to smoke:


Chesterfield, in a 1930s ad, argued that “women started to smoke…just about the time they began to vote”:

A later ad for Phillip Morris tells women to “Believe in yourself!”

Cigarette makers also worked to teach women how to smoke properly. Ads often depicted women in the act of smoking. Some companies, like Philip Morris, even held smoking demonstrations for women:
[Via.]
The article describes how a “pretty registered nurse” is touring the country to teach women proper smoking etiquette. The article also lists “men’s pet peeves” and “women’s pet peeves” for men and women smokers. (Full text after the jump below.)
Together, these efforts to conflate smoking with freedom and make smoking acceptable for women created a new set of consumers and reinforced Bernays’s argument that demand could be created.
Article Text:
To a small group of members of the Society of New York State Women, Florence E. Linden, pretty registered nurse and ex-actress, recently lectured on the etiquette of cigaret smoking. The women were mostly over 49. The lecture was mostly about habits and manners which make smoking objectionable. The anomaly in these statements derives from the fact that 99% of women over 45 do not smoke and that the lecture was sponsored by Philip Morris & Co. During the past year, Miss Linden ahs toured the country lecturing to clubs, department store employees, nurses, charm school students on smoking manners. Women are the greatest potential market for future increases in cigaret sales. But women’s bad smoking habits have furnished the anti-women-smoking campaigners with their best ammunition. Therefore, in her lectures, Miss Linden smartly stresses all the things not to do with a cigaret. Men’s pet peeves against women smokers are 1) messy ways of opening packages; 2) affected mannerisms; 3) puffing like a steam engine; 4) lipstick smears. Women growl at men smokers for 1) using dishes; 2) dousing butts under faucet and then dropping in sink. To smokers of either sex Miss Linden advises: when smoking in bed use closed type of ash tray (smoking in bed caused hundreds of deaths last year); in the woods grind butt out against tree; on lawn let butt burn to ashes; for additional hints on smoking posed by Miss Linden.
Comments 106
Matthew Coulter — February 27, 2012
If you like this article, check out BBC's Century of the Self to get a more detailed history of this event and other things Edward Bernays was involved in.
Karissa — February 27, 2012
Thank you for writing about this! A few years ago I was watching a tv show (I think it may have been Torchwood) and one of the female characters lit up a cigarette after sleeping with another woman. I was startled to notice that my immediate reaction to her smoking was to take it as evidence that she was a strong and independent woman. I don't smoke and I don't really like smoking in generally (although I don't try to stop people from doing it), yet I was experiencing feelings of approval at her perceived powerful womanhood.
Since then I have tried to pay attention to the portrayals of "strong women" (and also sometimes lesbian women, which is another interesting dynamic if you think of the cigarette as a phallic symbol) as "smoking women" in tv and movies. It seems like a fairly common occurrence to me, although I do not have any data on it to help me rule out the possibility of confirmation bias.
But anyway, I really appreciate the opportunity to place my idle observations in a historical context. And if any commenters post links to academic research on the subject of strong-women-smokers in popular culture, I will be very grateful!
christianrclarkson — February 27, 2012
Interesting that the men's 'pet peeves' were all about women failing to smoke properly while apparently women just hated men making a mess. Because obviously they'd be those ones cleaning up those dishes later!
LNel — February 29, 2012
I know I'm late on this post, but Bernays did not fabricate this idea out of thin air. In the 1900s, in particular pre-war Greenwich Village, rebellious women, many of whom called themselves feminists, consciously smoked in public as a protest of male dominated culture. "Proper" society from mid-town would travel to Greenwich Village to see these "emancipated women" smoking, and it was often written about in papers describing Village activity (often with shock and horror, and accompanied by descriptions of women's short hair and sandals, more concrete symbols of women's new freedom).
Prior to the 1920s smoking was quite literally a display of freedom for women, no conflation there. Cigarettes were a physical symbol of men's social power; women didn't smoke because they wanted a penis, they smoked to demonstrate that they could be, and were, socially equal to men. Bernays may have helped publicize this idea, but he certainly did not come up with it himself. The effect would not have been nearly as wide-spread had feminists and suffragists not already been using and popularizing cigarettes as a symbol of the new emancipated woman.
Women's desires to be equal to men was already, and necessarily, commodified. This is an example of companies co-opting what women were already doing.
Aa — March 2, 2012
The "Believe in Yourself" text looks so much like the text used on LOL Cats pictures that at first I thought it was a manipulated image.
john brown — March 4, 2012
Lippmann was not a member of the Committee on Public Information.
Kryptonitezirconium7 — August 4, 2012
Everything liberal and leftist is just seduction that appeals to the pride of the minorities to corrupt and destroy them, and to destroy the majority groups though the minorities. This includes lesbianism, feminism, etc. It's time to lock and load, and form a millitia to execute governmental change. Together we can nail these sons of bitches who fucked both you and me, I'm counting on you buddy, don't let me down. We have the power! We can do it! Unimaginable wealth and social wellness is within reach, let us behave ourselves valiantly for our people and for our GOD.
Cito Kurrukan — February 3, 2015
I watched about this topic in Century of the Self on Youtube. Very interesting. And it reminds me of these cigarette ads.
altes-gasthaus-hempelmann.de — April 26, 2019
Um mittels GPS die Katze zu orten, ist ein Sender und ein Empfänger nötig. Als GPS-Sender gilt ein Peilsender für Katzen. Der Empfänger ist ein Handy oder https://altes-gasthaus-hempelmann.de/
Gamblo — June 25, 2019
Bernays developed the theory of "market research" in 1896. His theory was developed using an experimental study of the marketing activities of newspapers to the community of New York City. The paper was edited with particular regard to the activities of the United States Army's General Newspaper, and in particular the Army magazine. As Bernays noted, some newspapers in the community had been published for the first time on the front in the United States Army. This newspaper was the "second best selling one in the country." https://gamblingtribe.com/ The two best-selling ones were, "The New York Herald Tribune" and "The City Herald." The latter one sold for "four times (the) average in New York City."
Linda lange — March 29, 2020
My grandmother was the Lucky Strike woman pictured " An ancient prejudice has been removed. I have a photo of her in the original oil painting that the ad came from.
Dave Rubin — August 17, 2020
A DOPED UP CRIMINAL, WHO RESISTED ARREST AND DIED FROM A HEART ATTACK, BROUGHT ON BY DRUGS, BRINGS THE COUNTRY TO CHAOS!
A 5-YEAR-OLD CHILD IS EXECUTED, BY A SHOT TO THE HEAD, WHILE RIDING HIS BIKE, BRINGS OUT THE 3 MONKEY SYNDROME:
SEE NOTHING!
HEAR NOTHING!
SAY NOTHING!
What about CHILD LIVES MATTER?
Wrong Color!
DON'T LOOK FOR JUSTICE IN THIS BANANA REPUBLIC!
WHISTLE-BLOWER WILLIAM BINEY:
"My government that used to be a Constitutional Republic, we're not anymore"!
Your Sister — July 9, 2021
Cigarette as a phallic symbol? According to who exactly? "Penis envt" is a fabrication, and the only penis envy or worship comes from homosexuals (males).
Lesbian women generally have such all-consuming sexual episodes, they fall asleep, not reach for cigarettes. Lesbianism is not liberal or leftist, exactly the opposite. Actual lesbians are usually intellectuals who recognize the freedom afforded them by western civilization. You won't see genuine lesbians, for example, welcoming or even tolerating islam, with it's monstrous honor killings and female genital mutilation. This is all the fantasy of a degenerate jew like Freud, and the mindless throngs who swallow toxic prescriptions administered by his pseudoscientists.
Lesbians smoked because their experience bloomed within a bar culture, and anyone who's had more than enough to drink knows a cigarette can keep you from vomiting. Pair that with the fact young people always embrace what is fresh to their world. The last thing a programmed populace needs is to vilify those who are invisible allies.
Nick — February 14, 2024
Ladies, elevate your vaping experience with Shop Top Vape Brands. Discover a world where elegance meets functionality, offering a curated selection of high-quality, stylish vape devices tailored for the modern woman. From sleek, discreet pens to flavorful e-liquids, find everything you need at competitive prices. Embrace a lifestyle of sophistication and satisfaction with our premium vaping solutions. Your perfect vape awaits – explore our collection today and find your match.
Scott — September 15, 2025
Historical campaigns like the “Torches of Freedom” reveal how cultural forces, gender norms, and marketing influence public behavior and perceptions of smoking. Today, vaping represents a modern evolution of that narrative, offering a safer, controlled alternative that appeals to people who want autonomy over their consumption. Unlike traditional cigarettes, vaping allows users to choose flavors, nicotine levels, and devices suited to their lifestyle. Trusted platforms like Vape Vice provide a secure and diverse selection, helping users explore this modern habit responsibly. By combining cultural awareness with reliable products, vaping has become both a personal and social experience, offering variety, convenience, and enjoyment.