The uproar in the blogosphere pales only in comparison to the uproar in our email inbox about My New Pink Button.
Penny R., Eden H., Alicia T., Shannon H., Nils G., Shiquanda S., Mickey C., and Bob C. have all sent in links to a new product designed to bring back the “fresh” to your lady parts. For 30 bucks you can get 3 days of pretty-in-pink. That’s right, genital dye to pinkify your private parts. In case you weren’t worried about this particular repulsivity, now you know. (It apparently works on men as well as women, and nipples too).
As they say at Jezebel: “Anti-aging mania and marketing: Not just for your face anymore!”
Shiquanda and Mickey brought our attention to this particular Q&A in the FAQ section:
Q. “Help! I’ve noticed I am turning a more brown color down there on my inside lips, is this normal”?
A. Yes, it’s perfectly normal and there are many factors that can contribute to this. Ethnicity is a big factor, also age, hormone change, surgeries, childbirth, sickness, health, diet and medications can all contribute to a change from “Pink” to “Brown” in a woman’s genital area.
So this is kind of fascinating: browner coloring is “normal,” but you should change it anyway. The message is that normal is not ideal. We are normal (or at least white people are), and we still need fixing.
The FAQ makes plain the two ways in which marketing tries to convince us to change our bodies: both by telling us that our bodies are abnormal and by telling us that they are normal. Normal bodies are icky, we’re told, your body should appear, as much as possible, as if it is not a body at all. I mean, isn’t that part of what shaving our legs, chests, and genitals (both male and female) are about?
I think the ubiquitousness of breast implants in the media also sends the message that beautiful breasts have the look of breast implants (in terms of shape, size, and the position of the nipple). I recently saw mannequins in a store window who were built to look as if they had breast implants. Do you get how crazy that is? If a mannequin is supposed to represent the ideal body, then the ideal body isn’t one with naturally large breasts, it’s one with fake breasts! Nuts. This world is nuts. (Kristi reminds me that this is insensitive to those with mental illness… and she’s right.) Weird! This world is weird!
(I looked this up on Snopes, but no word yet as to whether it’s a hoax. I have no idea whether this product is for real or whether it’s a big-enough-seller to get my panties in a bunch over. Though it appears that you can order it, but it is of questionable efficacy. Scam-status and efficacy aside, I think it still reveals something interesting about how we are told that our bodies aren’t good enough.)
Lisa Wade, PhD is an Associate Professor at Tulane University. She is the author of American Hookup, a book about college sexual culture; a textbook about gender; and a forthcoming introductory text: Terrible Magnificent Sociology. You can follow her on Twitter and Instagram.
Comments 49
d. — January 17, 2010
a blogger at "I, asshole" ordered the product and wrote about it : http://iasshole.org/?p=1771
it appears to be a scam.
thoughtcounts Z — January 17, 2010
I appreciate the listing of "...sickness, health..." in the FAQ you quoted. That's pretty much all-encompassing, isn't it?
AR — January 17, 2010
So it’s “normal,” but you should change it anyway. The message is that normal is not ideal.
Well, mass infant mortality was also a pretty normal part of the human experience for most of the time humans have existed, but that didn't make it ideal.
naomi — January 17, 2010
It reminds me of teeth-whitening: it's normal for teeth to be, well, ivory-colored, but marking insists to us that we make them bright white. Of course, the "yet another product women are supposed to buy to look beautiful" aspect, not to mention that it's for genitals, is annoying in yet another way.
I do hope it's a hoax, but the vagina mints were only a hoax in the sense that they were just regular breath mints repackaged as vagina mints and then sold with fine print specifying it as a "novelty item," but they really were being sold as mints for vaginas.
fntm — January 17, 2010
There's a video: http://thedoctorstv.com/main/procedure_list/630
Kristi — January 17, 2010
I'm a frequent lurker and a big fan of this blog. Using the words crazy and nuts as general slurs, as you did in this post, is ableist. When people say crazy or nuts when they mean bad, confusing, or dangerous (to name a few), it reinforces stereotypes of the mentally ill as bad, confusing, and dangerous. This contributes to a social climate that discourages people with mental illnesses from seeking help (lest they be labeled crazy or nuts) and tacitly approves the marginalization and mistreatment of those who are labeled such.
Ableist language is pervasive, even among social progressives, so I understand that you probably didn't realize that such language is harmful. The Ableist Word Profile at FWD/Forward is an excellent resource on the topic.
Wehaf — January 17, 2010
Also interesting (and sad) is that there are two colors for white women, and one designated for "women of color".
An "Other" Mother — January 17, 2010
This was actually on the Doctors talk show! How crazy!
The Amazing Kim — January 17, 2010
I recently saw mannequins in a store window who were built to look as if they had breast implants
I've seen mannequins with prominent ribs and hip bones. I mean, they're plastic shells, they don't have skeletons.
Sivko — January 17, 2010
This reminds me of reading about anal bleaching, which uses the same stuff: http://www.villagevoice.com/2005-07-05/columns/britesmile-for-bungholes/
Modern Girl — January 17, 2010
I'm hung up on why the girl is only wearing ONE stocking. Why? Why? Someone explain.
Marsha — January 17, 2010
The folks at Consumerist just posted a review of this product: http://consumerist.com/2010/01/new-genital-dye-doesnt-really-work-but-is-quite-tasty.html
Linkurile săptămânii « Down the Rabbit Hole — January 17, 2010
[...] Moment WTF: Nu eşti sigură pe tine? Vrei să fii de neuitat? Simplu. Vopseşte-ţi vulva în roz! [...]
make teeth whiter — January 18, 2010
I visited this site. Good and stylish. I am really impressed with the FAQ section.
Tadjio — January 18, 2010
The mannequins with "implants" are just bizarre. Makes me think of the mannequins at the local Forever 21 clothing outlet -- these mannequins, we noticed, have breasts in 3 sizes: about B-cup, small A-cup, and completely flat. They tend to group the mannequins in threes so it's usually fairly obvious that 1 out of every 3 has a completely flat chest. (The store doesn't carry juniors sizes and the models are all wearing women's clothing.)
Also, there seems to be less neuroticism about it in America, but I have seen products marketed in Asia for for bleaching one's nipples -- specifically intended to turn darker-pigmented nipples "pink". I'm sure something like this product already exists for your girl parts as well, but the whole idea of bleaching your most sensitive regions is wince-inducing.
Защо продължаваме да говорим за феминизма? « It Looks Like A Feminist Blog — January 19, 2010
[...] Играчки, интереси, символи на любов, роли, представи за красиво, (достигащо до абсурд, както Ралф Лоран ни даде [...]
MC — January 20, 2010
whether or not it's a scam, there are still plenty of plastic surgeons capitalizing on and encouraging women's insecurities about the shapes of their nether regions.... seriously not cool. also seriously not cool that i read these things and dismiss them as ridiculous and STILL CAN'T DEFEAT THAT CREEPING SENSE OF PARANOIA THAT MY HOO-HA MIGHT BE FUNNY LOOKING AND MAYBE I REALLY SHOULD BE CONCERNED! goddamnit.
Chris — January 21, 2010
Can't remember if you've covered this product before, but for a product aimed at men to address a similarly "created" problem: http://freshballs.com/
"Fresh Balls: Fnally, the solution to a problem men have suffered with for generations."
(Potentially slightly NSFW dialogue in the auto-play video, if you work in a place where you don't want the phrase "sweaty balls" repeated ad nauseum in your work cubicle.)
My New Pink BUTTon « accidental altruist — April 23, 2010
[...] seen on Sociological Images. Inspired by comments in Jezebel. Product website fails to provide warnings that the product may [...]
My New Pink Button. | Sexually Oriented — August 14, 2011
[...] are we trying to impress here? What standard are we even trying to live up to? Much appreciation to this blog on normalness and this [...]