Comic-Con ended yesterday, so I’m afraid you’ve already missed out on a wonderful opportunity. I don’t mean attending Comic-Con itself. I’m referring to a contest that S. and Mordicai K. told us about, the Sin to Win contest from video game company EA (image from Kotaku; also see the discussion at ars technica):
The text about the “steps” of the contest:
1. Commit acts of lust. Take photos with us or any booth babe. 2. Prove it. [Gives Twitter and email address]. 3. Repeat. Find more babes for more chances to win.
Brian Crecente at Kotaku says,
Despite the tone of the contest, the rules state that judge’s reserve the right to disqualify any submission that are “inappropriate for any reason, including without limitation, for depicting or mentioning sex, violence, drugs, alcohol and/or inappropriate language.”
Um…ok…Mixed messages, anyone?
As S. pointed out in the email to us, the “You” figure in the instruction is almost certainly meant to be male (though it theoretically could be a short-hair female), and the prize is specifically a woman–not a date with an attractive person. So we see the reinforcement of the presumption that “gamer = heterosexual male.” S. also says,
You can take photos of “us” (presumably EA employees or possibly developers) instead of or in addition to “booth babes”, but you cannot apparently win dinner with one of “us” — only with “two hot girls.”
So the possible prize isn’t to maybe hang out with some of the people who maybe create or market games, because apparently, who’d want to do that? Or, perhaps, what developer/EA employee wants to spend an evening being forced to hang out with some random contest winner?
For other examples of women being offered as (less explicit) rewards to men, see this post about Tag, a Dell Computer ad, and an Air Conditioning Technical Institute van. I was going to post links to posts about the presumption that gamers are male, but there were so many, it’s easier just to tell you just to go to the “More” tag and then search for “video games” or “video games gender.”
Comments 8
misti — July 28, 2009
I'm curious to know if any women entered this contest. There doesn't seem to be any specifics about how they choose a winner (whether it's best photo or a random drawing), so I'm wondering if a woman won the grand prize (if it was even possible) if they would change the prizes at all. I'd gladly take a dinner with Nathan Fillion and Neil Patrick Harris, but frankly, I'd probably be just as keen to discuss video games with two female "hotties" over a free dinner. Free is free, after all.
abby — July 28, 2009
Something cool happened:
http://videogames.yahoo.com/events/plugged-in/ea-blasted-over-questionable-marketing-stunt/1338121
(It actually got a negative response!)
Quib9 — July 28, 2009
More than a little similar to a contest run for the District 9 movie, which initially only allowed males 18-24 to enter. http://hour42.blogspot.com/2009/06/sexism-used-to-create-buzz-for-sd-comic.html They later added a second contest for female applicants after some negative feed back.
It's more than a little disappointing to see nerd culture conflated with blatant sexism.
mordicai — July 28, 2009
Yeah-- because comic book geeks need more of a misogynist reputation...
pffft — July 28, 2009
My money is on another attractive female winning the contest, as if to flip the bad press and simultaneously please their precious male fanbase.
Rosemary — July 28, 2009
Ugh. I saw this story last night and shook my head, though at least the people it was supposed to appeal to called BS as well. They are not endearing themselves to half of the population with stuff like this. And yes, women are half the population, I wish they'd realize that.
mordicai — July 28, 2009
Apparently ALSO at ComicCon, a jerk asked Megan Fox if he'd make a sex tape with him-- & was roundly boo'd down for it. So at least things are changing for the better.
Fernando — July 28, 2009
http://kotaku.com/5325071/gaygamers-pic-with-booth-bear-cops-2nd-in-lust-promo
For the same-sex picture, taken at PAX last year, he won a prize package that included a limited-edition T-shirt and a voucher good for $240 at the Electronic Arts Store. In an email back to EA, he declined the cash chit with a few suggestions of better uses to which they could put the dough:
"1) A new sexual-harassment training video/seminar
2) Another PR team to try to spin this whole debacle of a contest into a positive light
3) A direct phone line to EA's legal depart to use before you try anymore PR stunts
4) Six copies of your game when it releases, since I know you've lost at least that many fans with this stunt
5) Or the next time you go to Hooters (for the wings, of course), leave a $240 tip for your waitress in a karmic way of balancing out what has been done to the booth babes of SDCC due to this contest"