
We seem to have been struggling with science for the past few…well…decades. The CDC just updated what we know about COVID-19 in the air, misinformation about trendy “wellness products” abounds, and then there’s the whole climate crisis.
This is an interesting pattern because many public science advocates put a lot of work into convincing us that knowing more science is the route to a more fulfilling life. Icons like Carl Sagan and Neil deGrasse Tyson, as well as modern secular movements, talk about the sense of profound wonder that comes along with learning about the world. Even GI Joe PSAs told us that knowing was half the battle.
The problem is that we can be too quick to think that knowing more will automatically make us better at addressing social problems. That claim is based on two assumptions: one, that learning things feels good and motivates us to action, and two, that knowing more about a topic makes people more likely to appreciate and respect that topic. Both can be true, but they are not always true.
The first is a little hasty. Sure, learning can feel good, but research on teaching and learning shows that it doesn’t always feel good, and I think we often risk losing students’ interest because they assume that if a topic is a struggle, they are not meant to be studying it.
The second is often wrong, because having more information does not always empower us to make better choices. Research shows us that knowing more about a topic can fuel all kinds of other biases, and partisan identification is increasingly linked with with attitudes toward science.
To see this in action, I took a look at some survey data collected by the Pew Research Center in 2014. The survey had seven questions checking attitudes about science – like whether people kept up with science or felt positively about it – and six questions checking basic knowledge about things like lasers and red blood cells. I totaled up these items into separate scales so that each person has a score for how much they knew and how positively or negatively they thought about science in general. These scales are standardized, so people with average scores are closer to zero. Plotting out these scores shows us a really interesting null finding documented by other research – there isn’t a strong relationship between knowing more and feeling better about science.

Here, both people who are a full standard deviation above the mean and multiple standard deviations below the mean on their knowledge score still hold pretty average attitudes about science. We might expect an upward sloping line, where more knowledge associates with more positive attitudes, but we don’t see that. Instead, attitudes about science, whether positive or negative, get more diffuse among people who get fewer answers correct. The higher the knowledge, the more tightly attitudes cluster around average.
This is an important point that bears repeating for people who want to change public policy or national debate on any science-based issue. It is helpful to inform people about these serious issues, but shifting their attitudes is not simply a matter of adding more information. To really change minds, we have to do the work to put that information into conversation with other meaning systems, emotions, and moral assumptions.
Evan Stewart is an assistant professor of sociology at University of Massachusetts Boston. You can follow him on Twitter.
Comments 29
B2B Inspection — September 24, 2020
Very useful blog thanks for sharing.
Gabriel Ibarra — September 24, 2020
How can you translate these findings to undergraduate students? I see them less and less engaged as time passes. Does it have to do also with the way they are learning? (e.g. online vs. face-to-face)
Jared Mai — October 3, 2020
The website additionally gives a great and active assistance solution that is ready to respond to swiftly and swiftly to any one of your questions as well as aid with solving any trouble. The assistance solution on the site, working in Live Chat, is ready to help in the hours showed on the site, as well as you can always speak to the e-mail address. Additionally, you have the opportunity to review info on frequently asked questions. This is a different section that supplies information on the numerous sections gathered on the website. The website additionally has a hotline telephone, which you can additionally get in touch with. And the casino site has its very own web pages on social media networks, which will certainly not leave indifferent young users of the website. Gambling enterprises can just be made use of by persons over 18 years of age who are in charge of themselves. In case of a betting dependency, the site provides 3 web links, on which there is a site where you prepare to assist with your issues. In general, https://www.spinsbest.com still has space to expand as well as exactly how to establish, yet already for that short time of its presence, great development and development shows up. So keep it up!
shell shockers — October 4, 2020
How can you translate these findings to undergraduate students? I see them less and less engaged as time passes. Does it have to do also with the way they are learning? (e.g. online vs. shell shockers)
hannah berry — October 15, 2020
In a rapidly changing world, the only route you take to fail is to take no risks. geometry dash
Anita — October 22, 2020
Very interesting.... Are you looking for Rotary Joint Manufacturer? Click to there to read more.
Josh Normandi — October 28, 2020
Well, That sounds great. but the things change rapidly. the search gets outdate. and the new theories evolve.
The Covid-19 era is not over yet and the world is again on the brink of another crisis because of the 2nd wave about to start.
In KSA the restriction are normal and a large number of expats have returned back to their jobs in Saudi Arabia.
they are also facing an issue about the iqama expiry and is yet to be solved. However they work and live there to bring ease to their families.
Hares Werev — October 28, 2020
Uncommon day to all. Every individual is before long stressed over his own and his own security. Nevertheless, to get supreme success of your home and security for your life, you have to utilize stunning frameworks https://top10pack.com/best-elderly-alarm-systems/ to ensure your home. Your home must be guaranteed. Additionally, you could all things considered watch what's going on in the house on cameras
Horea — October 30, 2020
I do believe it is. Knowledge about everything is power.
https://online-application.org
Leigh — October 30, 2020
Awesome! I think it is always needed.
https://www.application-filing-service.com/
shawn jasper — November 10, 2020
For better performance of Emotional Lobotomy you will definitely need the best services. https://www.academicforum.co.uk/2020/11/five-changes-in-educational-technology.html
papernow.org — November 10, 2020
Content*
Introduction (1 paragraph);
Answer to the question, description of the first point (2 paragraphs);
Description of the second point, solution of the problem (2 paragraphs);
Conclusion, contacts, terms of service / delivery (1 paragraph).
papernow.org — November 10, 2020
https://papernow.org/
Structure and design
- Headings h1, h2:
main key request in the h1 header;
if possible, an additional request in h2.
papernow.org — November 10, 2020
https://papernow.org/ Expectations from the form and content of the text are described. Let's see how this works with SEO copy for an online store. We will not discuss the style and presentation of information, now we are only interested in the technical side of the issue.
Anna Davis — November 25, 2020
I know its not an easy task to do, all details are different and I feel that this world have a tough days ahead and we need to adapt these challenges and get it working, we are getting some details from Pipeline Construction Inspector certification, we are getting daily reported cases.
directions — December 4, 2020
Thanks for sharing. I find a lot of interesting information here. A really good post, very thankful and hopefully you will write more articles like this one.
bubble shooter
James H. — December 4, 2020
Interesting. Thanks this was an interesting topic. Companies like Masonry Calgary Pros at https://www.masonrycalgary.com/ are doing what they can to help.
chrisgail — December 5, 2020
I am very against for war because it is not suitable for peace and it destroys the economy of any country that is why you have to settle their all disputes with discussion. cheap dissertation writing service
emily goutagny — December 11, 2020
there are many more where it is not. Recent work in cognitive science has demonstrated that knowing is a shockingly tiny portion of the battle for most real world decisions. http://casitabuilderlasvegas.com/
Steve — December 16, 2020
I feel that this is responsibly the best course of information which I received it long time I would urge people to see more of these types of data which very important for medication management services, I hope this is being looked after.
Guillermo Guzzetta — December 21, 2020
Jual Beton Instan dari bermacam-macam merek terbaik harga murah dari distributor sah di indonesia. Tersedia Ready mix concrete kemasan ataupun kendaraan beroda empat truck beton ... segera kunjungi https://tiangpancangmegacon.kedungsepur.my.id/2020/08/harga-tiang-pancang-megacon-geyer.html
Mariana Gregori — December 21, 2020
Toilet cubicles range is made and manufactured with every washroom use and environment in your mind; and for sale in a complete variety of colours ... tap https://medium.com/@toiletcubiclephenolic/cubicle-toilet-phenolic-tangerang-ukuran-per-m2-custom-murah-f64fbd0aba39 for detail information.
Salvatore Dominski — December 21, 2020
Kamar toilet toilet salah satu adalah penting yang elemen ada pada semestinya fasilitas publik seperti mall, gedung olahraga, gedung pertemuan, dan lain-lain ... tap https://showerbox.jabodetabek.my.id/2020/10/jual-shower-box-pondok-melati-bekasi-1.html to go further.
Harrison Crotts — December 29, 2020
Ahli kontraktor pembuatan, renovasi dan perawatan kolam renang di Indonesia. Pelayanan kencang dan ... klik https://mozaik.jabodetabek.my.id/2020/09/jual-mozaik-kolam-renang-cimanggis.html untuk lebih detail
Emelia Traunfeld — January 4, 2021
Phenolic board ialah Panel Partisi kamar kecil yang kamar kecil dari merupakan lapis Kraft paper dan resin yang dilaminasi beberapa dengan decorative paper pada ... tap https://medium.com/@toiletcubiclephenolic/cubicle-toilet-phenolic-tangerang-ukuran-per-m2-custom-murah-f64fbd0aba39 to go further.
vasilisa — January 4, 2021
The problem is that we can be too quick to think that knowing more will automatically make us better at addressing social problems. That claim is based on two assumptions: one, that learning things feels good and motivates us to action, and two https://vlastidengi.com/ reading news.
Mary Clabo — January 6, 2021
Are you looking for car towing service in Indonesia? You're in luck because alat.berat.id provides all types of towing in Indonesia. tap https://carcarrier.netlify.app/car-carrier-surabaya-bitung.html for more offers
Elyse Mcghehey — January 7, 2021
Kaca tempered yakni kaca yang dikeraskan dengan memanaskan kaca umum hingga menempuh suhu sekitar 700 * C, info lebih detail https://kontraktorpartisikaca.blogspot.com/2019/11/jasa-pembuatan-partisi-kaca-1-di-0812.html
cookie clicker — January 12, 2021
I really appreciate this wonderful post that you have provided for us. I feel strongly that love and read more on this topic. I have spent a lot of my spare time reading your content. Thank you a lot.
cookie clicker