The #MeToo movement that began in 2017 has reignited a long debate about how to name people who have had traumatic experiences. Do we call individuals who have experienced war, cancer, crime, or sexual violence “victims”? Or should we call them “survivor,” as recent activists like #MeToo founder Tarana Burke have advocated?
Strong arguments can be raised for both sides. In the sexual violence debate, advocates of “survivor” argue the term places women at the center of their own narrative of recovery and growth. Defenders of victim language, meanwhile, argue that victim better describes the harm and seriousness of violence against women and identifies the source of violence in systemic misogyny and cultures of patriarchy.
Unfortunately, while there has been much debate about the use of these terms, there has been little documentation of how service and advocacy organizations that work with individuals who have experienced trauma actually use these terms. Understanding the use of survivor and victim is important because it tells us what these terms to mean in practice and where barriers to change are.
We sought to remedy this problem in a recent paper published in Social Currents. We used data from nonprofit mission statements to track language change among 3,756 nonprofits that once talked about victims in the 1990s. We found, in general, that relatively few organizations adopted survivor as a way to talk about trauma even as some organizations have moved away from talking about victims. However, we also found that, increasingly, organizations that focus on issues related to women tend to use victim and survivor interchangeably. In contrast, organizations that do not work with women appear be moving away from both terms.

These findings contradict the way we usually think about “survivor” and “victim” as opposing terms. Does this mean that survivor and victim are becoming the “extremely reduced form” through which women are able to enter the public sphere? Or does it mean that feminist service providers are avoiding binary thinking? These questions, as well as questions about the strategic, linguistic, and contextual reasons that organizations choose victim- or survivor-based language give advocates and scholars of language plenty to re-examine.
Andrew Messamore is a PhD student in the Department of Sociology at the University of Texas at Austin. Andrew studies changing modes of local organizing at work and in neighborhoods and how the ways people associate shapes community, public discourse, and economic inequality in the United States.
Pamela Paxton is the Linda K. George and John Wilson Professor of Sociology at The University of Texas at Austin. With Melanie Hughes and Tiffany Barnes, she is the co-author of the 2020 book, Women, Politics, and Power: A Global Perspective.
Comments 26
madalin stunt cars 2 — October 4, 2020
Strong arguments can be raised for both sides. In the sexual violence debate, advocates of “madalin stunt cars 2” argue the term places women at the center of their own narrative of recovery and growth. Defenders of victim language, meanwhile, argue that victim better describes the harm and seriousness of violence against women and identifies the source of violence in systemic misogyny and cultures of patriarchy.
Janey Campbell — October 8, 2020
This discussion was going on in the 70s and 80s.
Christine Brooks — October 11, 2020
The Omegle webcam is one of the most secure ways for online dating which accepted by widely international users. This live webcam video chat foundation was rollout in the year 2009 with the concept of a 1Vs1 random video chat facility. And now this platform becomes the first largest place where the daily uncountable number of strangers visit for random video chat
unicorn_s — October 11, 2020
nice article!
Annie — October 30, 2020
The ratio are really impressive!
clean windows now
Lee — October 30, 2020
I think I read here about this. I am glad I found this here.
grill recipes — November 4, 2020
Be proud of the fact that you have the ability to rise above any situation and deliver the best no matter what the circumstances could be. Excellent article! Thank you for your tremendous efforts in this wonderful piece of work.
Dingi — November 4, 2020
Thanks for this! This was very helpful! grill recipes This can't be more accurate.
James Brown — November 7, 2020
Great post! By the way, guy if you want to see what real writing is you can visit this website https://jetwriting.com/essay-help and buy any type of paper you need.
marry — November 23, 2020
If we have health problems then we have solutions also. According to best laptop for listening to music medicines are available which are best for our health. We can consult with doctors and can use medicines to get rid from health problems and can be fit.
Meredije — December 2, 2020
This is one of the most interesting points to see building service contractors near me have been working this pretty well.
Boyhot — December 4, 2020
Have a good time!
directions — December 4, 2020
Your article gives me another approach to the subject. I hope to read more articles from you.
fireboy and watergirl
Joya Edsall — December 21, 2020
Beli Beton Precast Online bermutu dengan harga murah terkini 2020 di MegaconBeton.com! Pembayaran gampang, pengiriman pesat se Indonesia. segera kunjungi https://tiangpancangmegacon.jabodetabek.my.id/2020/10/jual-pondasi-tiang-pancang-di-cilodong.html
Danial Tei — December 21, 2020
Phenolic Board kamar mandi high pressure laminate. Ada adalah bahan yang sebagian tak jarang sebagai bahan partisi ... klik https://showerbox.jabodetabek.my.id/2020/10/jual-shower-box-batuceper-tangerang-1.html for detail information.
vasil — December 22, 2020
Я люблю казино и гемблинг . Также принимаю участие в разных турнирах. Одними из них являются турниры по покеру . Это очень здорово, как раз ищу себе команду:)
Art Ambroz — December 29, 2020
Pakar kontraktor pembuatan, renovasi dan perawatan kolam renang di Indonesia. Pelayanan kencang dan ... lihat https://perawatan-kolamrenang.netlify.app/perawatan-kolam-renang-cilacap.html untuk info paling update
les chrapid — January 4, 2021
Thank you very much for sharing this useful information. I was doing a project and for that, I was looking for related information. Some of the points are very useful. Do share some more material if you have. slope unblocked
Osvaldo Shalash — January 4, 2021
Toilet cubicle sizes are essential and can vary from kind of person using the washroom. Our guide sets out the dimensions used as standards ... tap https://partisi-kamar-mandi.blogspot.com/2019/03/cubicle-toilet-phenolic-yogyakarta-murah.html for detail.
Emanuel Rabena — January 6, 2021
If the automobile is damaged, roadside assistance must certanly be called. An excellent towing company will get the car from the road and to a secure location. Crashed vehicles ... visit https://carcarrier.netlify.app/car-carrier-surabaya-solo.html for detail
Harland Wloch — January 7, 2021
Kaca tempered yaitu kaca yang dikeraskan dengan memanaskan kaca lazim sampai menempuh temperatur sekitar 700 * C, info lebih detail https://railing-kaca-murah.blogspot.com/
Kyle — January 8, 2021
Great stuff thanks! https://www.treeremovalbrampton.com/
Kyle — January 8, 2021
Great stuff thanks! tree services
play solitaire — January 12, 2021
Thanks for sharing this information. I really like your blog post very much. You have really shared an informative and interesting blog post with people.
play solitaire
vasilisa — January 15, 2021
Если не знаете, хороший сайт о казино и гемблинге , то здесь написано подробно https://omg.md/posts/kazino-frank-otzyvy где искать отзывы о казино, репутация казино, обзоры казино с хорошими отзывами )
Ambrose Dalluge — January 18, 2021
Epoxy is a mass and heat painful and sensitive material. The solution time (time it takes the combined epoxy resin and hardener to originally harden up) can differ dramatically depending on... click https://jasawaterproofingcoating.blogspot.com/2019/11/jasa-waterproofing-coating-parepare.html for detail.