The New York Times has been catching a lot of criticism this week for publishing a profile on the co-founder of the Traditionalist Worker Party. Critics argue that stories taking a human interest angle on how alt-right activists live, and how they dress, are not just puff pieces that aren’t doing due diligence in reporting—they also risk “normalizing” neo-nazi and white supremacist views in American society.
It is tempting to scoff at the buzzword “normalization,” but there is good reason for the clunky term. For sociologists, what is normal changes across time and social context, and normalization means more than whether people choose to accept deviant beliefs or behaviors. Normalization means that the everyday structure of organizations can encourage and reward deviance, even unintentionally.
Media organizations play a key role here. Research on the spread of anti-Muslim attitudes by Chris Bail shows how a small number of fringe groups with extremist views were able to craft emotionally jarring messages that caught media attention, giving them disproportionate influence in policy circles and popular culture.
Organizations are also quite good at making mistakes, and even committing atrocities, through “normal” behavior. Research on what happened at NASA leading up to the Challenger disaster by Diane Vaughan describes normalization using a theory of crime from Edwin H. Sutherland where people learn that deviant behavior can earn them benefits, rather than sanctions. When bending the rules becomes routine in organizations, we get everything from corporate corruption up to mass atrocities. According to Vaughan:
When discovered, a horrified world defined these actions deviant, yet they were normative within the culture of the work and occupations of the participants who acted in conformity with organizational mandates
The key point is that normalization doesn’t just stop by punishing or shaming individuals for bad behavior. Businesses can be fined, scapegoats can be fired, and readers can cancel subscriptions, but if normalization is happening the culture of an institution will continue to shape how individual people make decisions.This raises big questions about the decisions made by journalists and editors in pursuit of readership.
Research on normalization also begs us to remember that some of the most horrifying crimes and accidents in human history are linked by a common process: the way organizations can reward deviant work. Just look at the “happy young folks” photographed by Karl Höcker in 1944…while they worked at Auschwitz.
Evan Stewart is an assistant professor of sociology at University of Massachusetts Boston. You can follow his work at his website, on Twitter, or on BlueSky.
Comments 1
Elijah A Alexander Jr — November 29, 2017
During my 57 years of observing visual media I've noticed that everything the "unconstitutional" government desire it uses the media to either normalize or squash. Since the nation has never followed it's constitution in a very subconscious way they have normalized government's Trustee control over the people rather than how the Preamble and Article 6 reads which require "We The People" to control the governors.
White Nationalism has always been "Normalized" subliminally. The "Dukes of Hazard" sitcom's use of "good old boys" theme song was subliminally normalizing it. What that did was to suggest the people called "white" are the "good old boys" in control of the laws and are not going to prohibit "the good old boy's" actions by the laws. Subliminally it suggest all other people has to be subjected to those laws "the good old boys" are no to be subjected to unless they cross a certain line.
In that light I say we should stop "worrying" about White Nationalism and get into the constitution and prohibit it. The six conditions the Preamble say the Constitution is supposed to accomplish, perfected Union, establish Justice, insure domestic Tranquility, provide for the common defence, promote the general Welfare, and secure the Blessings of Liberty to ourselves and our Posterity, disallows any separatism within this nation's people nor the independent nations of the people found on this land prior to the Europeans' arrival they supplanted it form. Therefore, we should require the implementation of the constitution studying it's spirit as found https://hubpages.com/politics/The-U-S-Constitutions-Spirit .