Botox has forever transformed the primordial battleground against aging. Since the FDA approved it for cosmetic use in 2002, eleven million Americans have used it. Over 90 percent of them are women.
In my forthcoming book, Botox Nation, I argue that one of the reasons Botox is so appealing to women is because the wrinkles that Botox is designed to “fix,” those disconcerting creases between our brows, are precisely those lines that we use to express negative emotions: angry, bitchy, irritated. Botox is injected into the corrugator supercilii muscles, the facial muscles that allow us to pull our eyebrows together and push them down. By paralyzing these muscles, Botox prevents this brow-lowering action, and in so doing, inhibits our ability to scowl, an expression we use to project to the world that we are aggravated or pissed off.
Sociologists have long speculated about the meaning of human faces for social interaction. In the 1950s, Erving Goffman developed the concept of facework to refer to the ways that human faces act as a template to invoke, process, and manage emotions. A core feature of our physical identity, our faces provide expressive information about our selves and how we want our identities to be perceived by others.
Given that our faces are mediums for processing and negotiating social interaction, it makes sense that Botox’s effect on facial expression would be particularly enticing to women, who from early childhood are taught to project cheerfulness and to disguise unhappiness. Male politicians and CEOs, for example, are expected to look pissed off, stern, and annoyed. However, when Hillary Clinton displays these same expressions, she is chastised for being unladylike, as undeserving of the male gaze, and criticized for disrupting the normative gender order. Women more so than men are penalized for looking speculative, judgmental, angry, or cross.
Nothing demonstrates this more than the recent viral pop-cultural idioms “resting bitch face.” For those unfamiliar with the not so subtly sexist phrase, “resting bitch face,” according to the popular site Urban Dictionary, is “a person, usually a girl, who naturally looks mean when her face is expressionless, without meaning to.” This same site defines its etymological predecessor, “bitchy resting face,” as “a bitchy alternative to the usual blank look most people have. This is a condition affecting the facial muscles, suffered by millions of women worldwide. People suffering from bitchy resting face (BRF) have the tendency look hostile and/or judgmental at rest.”
Resting bitch face and its linguistic cousin is nowhere near gender neutral. There is no name for men’s serious, pensive, and reserved expressions because we allow men these feelings. When a man looks severe, serious, or grumpy, we assume it is for good reason. But women are always expected to be smiling, aesthetically pleasing, and compliant. To do otherwise would be to fail to subordinate our own emotions to those of others, and this would upset the gendered status quo.
This is what the sociologist Arlie Russell Hochschild calls “emotion labor,” a type of impression management, which involves manipulating one’s feelings to transmit a certain impression. In her now-classic study on flight attendants, Hochschild documented how part of the occupational script was for flight attendants to create and maintain the façade of positive appearance, revealing the highly gendered ways we police social performance. The facework involved in projecting cheerfulness and always smiling requires energy and, as any woman is well aware, can become exhausting. Hochschild recognized this and saw emotion work as a form of exploitation that could lead to psychological distress. She also predicted that showing dissimilar emotions from those genuinely felt would lead to the alienation from one’s feelings.
Enter Botox—a product that can seemingly liberate the face from its resting bitch state, producing a flattening of affect where the act of appearing introspective, inquisitive, perplexed, contemplative, or pissed off can be effaced and prevented from leaving a lasting impression. One reason Botox may be especially appealing to women is that it can potentially relieve them from having to work so hard to police their expressions.
Even more insidiously, Botox may actually change how women feel. Scientists have long suggested that facial expressions, like frowning or smiling, can influence emotion by contributing to a range of bodily changes that in turn produce subjective feelings. This theory, known in psychology as the “facial feedback hypothesis,” proposes that expression intensifies emotion, whereas suppression softens it. It follows that blocking negative expressions with Botox injections should offer some protection against negative feelings. A study confirmed the hypothesis.
Taken together, this works point to some of the principal attractions of Botox for women. Functioning as an emotional lobotomy of sorts, Botox can emancipate women from having to vigilantly police their facial expressions and actually reduce the negative feelings that produce them, all while simultaneously offsetting the psychological distress of alienation.
Dana Berkowitz is a professor of sociology at Louisiana State University in Baton Rogue where she teaches about gender, sexuality, families, and qualitative methods. Her book, Botox Nation: Changing the Face of America, will be out in January and can be pre-ordered now.
Comments 54
E — September 18, 2016
Resting Bitch Face is certainly a gendered term, and one borne of different expectations for what men and women should look like. But how could Botox be popular with women for its ability to erase a frowning expression? For that to work, women would need to choose to undergo Botox with the knowledge that it makes them frown less––and I, as a typical Jane Doe, had no idea Botox did that until I read this article. I also doubt it's a subconscious draw towards "non-frowniness" that women are responding to. The main criticism I hear about Botox is that it makes women look frozen and expressionless. Far from being a positive draw, losing the ability to appear "introspective, inquisitive, perplexed, contemplative, or [yes, even] pissed off" seems to be judged by all (both men and women) to be a definite negative of Botox.
Botox is very popular, but so are lip fillers and face lifts and any number of other cosmetic alterations. I don't see a reason to believe that Botox is different in kind from these, or any more insidious than them either. It's just the same old cultural obsession with youth and wrinkle-free beauty. Isn't that scandalous enough?
Meli Pennington — September 28, 2016
Thanks for this! I experienced unexpected depression after a surgery that left part of my face immobile for several weeks - the research that facial expressions affect mood is out there, but not really talked about. Many women use Botox to smooth away expressions without considering potential emotional effects.
Also Botox has been used to affect emotion in depressed patients by neutralizing sad and worried expressions - maybe an "emotional lobotomy" of sorts, or maybe an interruption of a feedback loop that's dysfunctional. But since the effect wears off, patient and doctor can decide if they want to proceed with treatments over time.
I've written about this at my site:
http://wildbeautyworld.com/2013/09/24/do-facial-expressions-rule-emotions-my-one-woman-experiment-in-the-field-plus-how-botox-could-help-depression/
I look forward to your book!
Lovely Links: 9/30/16 - Already Pretty | Where style meets body image — September 30, 2016
[…] “I argue that one of the reasons Botox is so appealing to women is because the wrinkles that Botox is designed to ‘fix,’ those disconcerting creases between our brows, are precisely….” […]
Assignment 2 research – smiles in images – Kate Aston — October 25, 2016
[…] A couple of months ago the phrase “resting bitch face” came up on my Facebook feed. This article by Dana Berkowitz, came to me via Catherine Banks’ comment on Holly’s blog post above, […]
Kris Santa Cruz — April 8, 2019
See nothing wrong with botox
Amie Cole — April 8, 2019
I am a student at a medical university and studying for a cosmetologist, I want to write a couple of interesting facts. The myth about the dangers of injecting BTA (Botox) is unfounded. A dangerous dose of more than three thousand units at a time, and only in case of intravenous. In cosmetology, a single dose is ten times less and depends on the purpose of the procedure and the area on the body. In addition, botulinum toxin type A is a medical product that has passed a lot of research and is approved for use in America and in the world.
Another common misconception is that after applying BTA, the face turns into a frozen mask. This is not exactly the case and one popular service write an essay for me on "How Botox effect on the muscles", contact me and I'll share it with you.
Mandy Angelica — July 6, 2019
I first started my career as a freelance content writer and some part time assignment writer for my university students. Gradually, this work shifted to my interest in research writing. This change bought me to a career in research department of the dissertation help. Academic writing was always my dream job. Writing made me what I am right now. As days passes my work got a lot better and I gained expertise in business related dissertation writing such as human resource, and management. I gain lots of spot awards as my word count speed got improved and then my work got quite expanded. Working with other writers, proof reading and edited skills improved time to time which made me a research department head. The Dissertation help Online UK was our top priority as our most number of customers was form UK.
Harley Jade — December 19, 2019
Agencies and organizations look to sociologists for their unique ability to define the difficult dimensions of a problem, separate the most critical variables that affect it. cheap assignment writing help sociologist to perform research.
kelly dimarco — March 24, 2020
It is not that beneficial for long term . We at Essay Help are here to provide you all solutions for your Academics Research Writings, Reports, Assignment,Article, Thesis and Dissertation in a professional manner to mark yourself on the top in your career as you deserve the best. Our expert writers will deliver you the best according to your needs and budget.
kelly dimarco — March 24, 2020
It is not that beneficial for long term . We at Essay Help are here to provide you all solutions for your Academics Research Writings, Reports, Assignment,Article, Thesis and Dissertation in a professional manner to mark yourself on the top in your career as you deserve the best. Our expert writers will deliver you the best according to your needs and budget.
Maria Lena — April 10, 2020
Given that our faces are mediums for processing and negotiating social association, it bodes well that Botox's impact on outward appearance would be particularly enticing to custom assignment help UK women, who from early childhood are taught to project cheerfulness and to disguise unhappiness.
Hassan Ali — April 22, 2020
Hello Sir
what is sponsor post of price of this site?https://thesocietypages.org/
waiting for your reply wiht positive response.
Thanks.
Johan Rock — May 30, 2020
Nice blog It is the best blog about Sociology also I found a narrative website That provides Cheap Assignment Writing Service.
ExclusivePapers — June 13, 2020
If you happen to seek writing help from some other custom writing services, then you might easily notice that our service greatly differs from others.
Anna Humphries — June 25, 2020
The amount of knowledge that this blog conveys so clearly and coherently to their readers is better than some college lectures that I have had! cheap assignment writing service uk
Ana Smith — July 24, 2020
Assignment Writing Ace offers you to avail the online assignment writing services to the students to achieve their academic goals in good grades. We have the best team of expert assignment writers who are extensively experienced to provide you with the best quality of assignment writing. Their capabilities and knowledge about the subject enable them to provide services regardless of any topic.
DCOBA — July 30, 2020
Dubai College of Business Administration places special emphasis on arranging research programs, seminars, workshops, and symposium. A number of vibrant societies are formed and run by the students under the following names: Outdoor Sports Society Events Society Debates Society Media & Publications Society Indoor Sports Society Guest Speaker Society Alumni Society IU Society for Corporate.
Alice Martin — August 8, 2020
A lot of people want to participate in college activities but their schedule forbids them to do so because of the endless assignments. However, these are the last years for you to experiment freely with yourself and this is why we advise you to take all the chances you can. As for assignments, leave the work to reliable help with assignments online of Apex Essays Writing and we promise that you would not regret it. We will make sure you do not lag in class while you can fulfill your dreams of participating in events.
Amal Khaled — August 12, 2020
RightSource gives you quality services of premium marketing solutions for your brand. The in-store display solution allows you to provide the right place and recognition to your brand. We have been serving our customers since 1993 with a professional group of more than 50 people. We use various significant ways to display your brand for the best possible results.
Botoxul, identitatea sexuala si lobotomia emotionala - Cafe Gradiva — September 7, 2020
[…] Sursa: thesocietypages.org/ […]
Karl Rebi — October 9, 2020
Everyone can use Paperwall101 to find some inspiration to write academic papers. They have a rich database of assignments on different topics.
hughes — October 30, 2020
custom assignment help UK
shawn jasper — November 10, 2020
Thanks for this.
shawnjasper — November 10, 2020
For better performance of Emotional Lobotomy you will definitely need the best services of https://www.artipot.co.uk/2020/11/how-to-prepare-presentation-for.html
Sam — December 10, 2020
I like posts that fill in your knowledge gaps. This one is of the sort.
navonwolf — December 21, 2020
Everyone will find their own creative inspiration. For me, skribbl io and io games are games of inspiration and high spiritual value.
Arno Savard — January 25, 2021
If you want a map for the online gambling world to win your treasures, check out detailed Casinority’s guidelines about gambling laws in different countries, and other specific rules connected to different jurisdictions. Casinority https://casinority.com/casino-games/ makes gambling informed and more secure.
thomas — February 3, 2021
Everyone writers can use Paperwall101 to find some inspiration to write academic papers. They have a rich database of assignments on different topics.
Sonia Devil — February 22, 2021
Thanks for sharing this. Affordable Dissertation UK
Monika Jacob — February 22, 2021
this was great, botulinum toxin is the greatest weapon against aging that will become very important in medicine in the future. And if we talk about present then Affordable Dissertation UK has become very important for students.
Emma Joe — February 25, 2021
Thanks for sharing. word to pdf
Anonymous — March 18, 2021
Botox is very popular, but so are lip fillers and face lifts and any number of other https://gramvio.com/mixcloud-downloader/ cosmetic alterations. I don't see a reason to believe that Botox is different in kind from these, or any more insidious than them either
https://gramvio.com/mixcloud-downloader/ — March 18, 2021
I am a student at a medical university and studying for a cosmetologist, I want to write a couple of interesting facts.
leather jacket — April 13, 2021
Indulge in the quality and style you have never experienced before! leather jacket brings you the most trendy and stylish product line this season. Visit leather jacket and grab your favorite superstar attires! leather jacket
Michael Fields — June 1, 2021
Nothing can be more exciting than slaying the same look as your favorite fashionista in your favorite show! We manufacture high quality jackets and coats from all the famous movies and shows throughout the world. Grab your top picks now at
Jackets For Men
Black Orchid Events MD — June 1, 2021
Botox has done a marvelous job against aging. Thank you for an informative post. Black Orchid Events MD
Liem Mayer — June 5, 2021
Choose phrases can be any, all depends on the intimacy of relations in the company, and the number of statements is regulated by the number of time allocated to the game website here.
Alexandra Daddario Apparels — August 10, 2021
Do you want to boost up your style game this season? Buy most stylish and classic masterpieces for your wardrobe at Alexandra Daddario Apparels.
Best savings coupon — August 31, 2021
Are you looking for the Smart Furniture Coupon ? Don't Worry Here The Best Savings Coupon Bring the Amazing Sale discounts On branded stores.
anand s — September 14, 2021
Very nice blog and articles. I am very happy to visit your blog. Now I am found what I want. I check your blog every day and try to learn something from your blog. Thank you and waiting for your new post. Also, Visit my website. https://www.oddylabs.com/</a
Davies Thompson — September 22, 2021
English words are a few words for students in their country. I write my essays and write cheap college coursework writing service compete with local students. Professional writers are familiar with the requirements of the university.
Benedict Nelson — September 23, 2021
Is there a better way to kill the clothes your loved ones have? Bow your heads this season and become an expert in your clan! Get a good collection of coats and cruella merchandise and keep up the good work filmstarjacket.com
many essays — September 23, 2021
Hi, I want to tell you about a page where there are many essays that you can read, choose and order online. This is every student's dream.
It makes their lives easier.
Most students cannot do their homework on their own, so such services are just right.
They employ good writers who have good writing experience. They learn a lot to have good reviews
many essays — September 23, 2021
Hi, I want to tell you about a page where there are many essays that you can read, choose and order online. This is every student's dream.
It makes their lives easier.
Most students cannot do their homework on their own, so such services are just right.
They employ good writers who have good writing experience. They learn a lot to have good reviews
Misha John — November 2, 2021
Wow this is so good content i like it so much keep sharing more content and blog like this i really like your effort. city beach discount code
Malcolm Alden — November 6, 2021
It was so great to see you perceiving this point, it genuinely feels inconceivable the weeknd costume. Thankful for sharing such critical information which is incredibly hard to get routinely. I have favored your site and will hoist it to my friends and others.
Megan Wallace — November 6, 2021
It was so incredible to see you see this point, it really feels incomprehensible leather celebrities. Grateful for sharing such basic data which is staggeringly difficult to get regularly. I have leaned toward your site and will lift it to my companions and others.
Pheta — November 30, 2021
Computer technology for people with disabilities is a website that has unanswered messages that contain important updates. You can also get help writing essays to easily manage proofread my essay
https://studyfy.com/proofreading. It has a community forum that has updates so it no longer has administrator awards. You can join them for daily updates.
Dean — December 4, 2021
I love your work here, honestly, you are the best. Your words can simplify the confusions
Brown north face puffer jacket
Dennymorisson — December 7, 2021
Very Informative & watchful content, You guys also try it
Door and window services Palm Beach Gardens
for best services of Advance Windows & doors.
NYC Manhattan Towing — January 10, 2022
Excellent information you have shared, thanks for taking the time to share with us such a great article. I really appreciate your work.
Jennifer Scarlet — January 25, 2022
Very well. Keep sharing more. Please also read mine at Fun Livin' and let me know where I can improve.
Dean — February 16, 2022
It's encouraging to see that some individuals are still making an effort to manage their websites. I'll make sure to check back in shortly
John Wick Black Suit