In 2009, 470,000 15-year-olds in 65 developed nations took a science test. Boys in the U.S. outperformed girls by 14 points: 509 to 495. How does the U.S. compare to other countries?
The figure below — from the New York Times — features Western and Northern Europe and the Americas (in turquoise), Asia and the Pacific Islands (in pink), and the Middle East and Eastern and Southern Europe (in yellow). The line down the middle separates societies in which boys scored higher than girls (left) and vice versa (right).
Notice that the countries in which boys outscore girls are overwhelmingly Western and Northern Europe and the Americas.
This data tells a similar story to the data on gender and math aptitude. Boys used to outperform girls in math in the U.S., but no longer. And if you look transnationally, cultural variation swamps gender differences. Analyses have shown that boys outperforming girls in math is strongly correlated with the degree of inequality in any given society.
One lesson to take is this: any given society is just one data point and can’t be counted on to tell the whole story.
Via The Global Sociology Blog.
Lisa Wade, PhD is an Associate Professor at Tulane University. She is the author of American Hookup, a book about college sexual culture; a textbook about gender; and a forthcoming introductory text: Terrible Magnificent Sociology. You can follow her on Twitter and Instagram.
Comments 43
Guest — February 17, 2013
gender and math aptitude link goes to:
Oops!
This page doesn't exist.
Alison — February 17, 2013
Nice post!
GraduallyGreener — February 17, 2013
I really like seeing this kind of data, but it's pretty weird data viz to put northern Europe, North America, AND South America together into one color category, and then East/South Europe and Middle East into another color category.
"Analyses have shown that boys outperforming girls in math is strongly correlated with the degree of inequality in any given society." Do you have links to these analyses?
Ellie — February 17, 2013
Indeed weird groupping of countries. On the one hand, countries like Russia, Hungary or the Baltics (where the Soviet attitude towards mathematics and women in MINT might still have an influence); on the other, countries like Yemen, where many girls don't even go to school.
Is Australia/NZ, two countries much similar in policies, gender attitudes, etc. to US/UK, part of the statistical "Asia/Pacific" region?
Lisa — February 17, 2013
Re education in New Zealand, girls have been consistently out-performing boys at school for a number of years. A good analysis of this can be found at: http://www.otago.ac.nz/christchurch/otago014782.pdf
This comes from data collected from a longitudinal study that has followed 1000 children from their entry into school until age 18. There is ongoing discussion in education circles about the disadvantaging of boys in the current education system.
Lala — February 17, 2013
Why the heck would you put the americas and northern europe together, and east/south europe with the middle east? It seems very manipulative, there are many better divisions (americas vs europe, western europe vs eastern europe vs americas, latin america vs north america/western europe vs eastern europe etc...).
TRANSNATIONAL DATA ON GENDER AND SCIENCE APTITUDE | Welcome to the Doctor's Office — February 18, 2013
[...] from SocImages [...]
Channing Walton — February 18, 2013
There is an interesting book on this subject http://www.amazon.com/Trouble-Boys-Surprising-Problems-Educators/dp/0307381293
Tusconian — February 18, 2013
Very weird groupings of countries. I agree with other commenters, that seems manipulative. There are a dozen ways to group countries that make sense, and this isn't one of them. To me, it honestly seems like the countries are lumped together based on whoever's making the graph's personal opinions on culture, in addition to economic and geographical means. The same point could be made if North America, South America, the Middle East, and Europe each had their own categories (whether or not Europe is divided). Does Poland really have that much in common with Tunisia, but nothing in common with Germany? And Germany has more in common with Brazil than it does with Poland? And they don't even seem to stick many countries in the categories they're typically placed in; some of the Asian countries, I typically see referred to as the Middle East, and some countries I've mainly seen referred to as Eastern Europe are placed into the Western Europe category. I think this skews the data to make an extreme point, where more accurate categories would make the same point to a less extreme level, and seems to erase certain, *ahem* not-quite-so-"Western" countries. For example, combining South and Central America with Western Europe is used to make a point....specifically about Western Europe. Both regions have similar trends, and of course, the US is left out of that slide, despite following the exact same trends as both Western Europe and South and Central America. This could be a lead in to questions about how colonialism or Western European attitudes towards schooling affect gender equality towards test scores, but it just kind of compares Western Europe to Asia, and "tsk tsk"s at the United States, as if they US's score is particularly unique. Why even include South America and the Middle East if the point of the study barely acknowledges them?
And of course, Africa is completely left out, and so is apparently Australia. Because Australia may as well be England/Arkansas with a beach (depending on who you ask), and Africa doesn't even have any schools south or west of the parts that get hurriedly lumped into the "Middle East" category as if the lower population of black Africans has severed them from the landmass. And there certainly aren't African countries with rising middle classes and levels of education, or gender equality issues that might be relevant to examine on a global scale....
Sebastian E. Wenz — February 19, 2013
These results are from OECD's Program for International Student Assessment (PISA), aren't they? If so, why don't you tell your readers?
I agree with your lesson. Here it would also be interesting to know more about the contents assessed? Science is very broad and I believe that there are sub topics where the gender differences might look different. However: pretty impressive and informative graphs!
Miguel Lozano — December 8, 2015
It is false, in all the world men outperform women in science, the simpler proof of this is to look at the results of any Knowledge Olympiad.
Unfortunately only the International Mathematical Olympiad have the information about the sex of the participants. But not in the others, where it could be really very hard identify the sex of the contestant only by the name, not only because we are not familiar with these names, but because specially in Asia Pacific some names are used for the both sexes.
Jack William — September 21, 2021
Women are more likely to live in poverty than men across all countries. The best cv websites are also less educated and have less access to health care. Representation for women varies widely from country to country, with countries.
Neha Hayat — November 8, 2021
This is so amazing and adorable post for all the new generation but there are web also very beneficial Competitive intelligence consultants available for giving you their best advice for starting your prospective businesses.
dima cia — November 12, 2021
Drift Hunters is an drift racing video game. It's a realistic browser-based 3D car drifting simulator.
can natural CBD — January 20, 2022
One thing missing in your blog is that you did not show about poverty, as this is one of the important topics and must be considered in your blog.
sara laurence — March 11, 2022
Gender discrimination has become a major problem but royal book writers have always speak in support of gender equality and always want a peaceful society without any gender discrimination.
neha hayat — March 17, 2022
unfortunately, we are living in a society where gender discrimination has become a major problem and as an active member of sanitiz 19 I am totally against this gender discrimination.
Web Design Company — March 31, 2022
Orientation segregation has turned into a significant issue however web design company have generally spoken on the side of orientation fairness and consistently need a quiet society with next to no orientation separation.
Logo Design Services — May 12, 2022
Orientation segregation has become a big concern, but Logo Design Services have continually advocated for orientation equality and peaceful society with little orientation separation.
letsplayindoor — July 4, 2022
Such a wonderful article I must say that you have an exceptional writing skills but one thing I would like to recommend and that is our childminding services from lets play indoor which is considered to be one of the best services.
sara — July 5, 2022
Your article is just amazing but one amazing thing I would also like to recommend you and that is our child minding services from letsplayindoor as we are offering the best services.
Liam Olivia — August 12, 2022
According to me women are likely to be more talented than man as if you see your surrounding you will find many women from online exams help who are doing fantastic things in their life.
smith — August 24, 2022
This article is very amazing and its is most wonderful writing skill about gender and science aptitude and where the gender discrimination is main issue.
Pay Someone To Do Your Courseits a very useful platform for any level of students they offering the best services
sana — September 21, 2022
I just understand one thing from your article that indeed you have amazing writing skills but just like to tell you that Dubai mobile app development is offering the best app development services.
Do My Classes Now — October 20, 2022
I like the article you provide all the details i like your writing skills keep it up im also a writer and also a online class taker In US .I doonline class help to students in their studies.
kiara — December 19, 2022
The content written in this article is exceptional and explains well about the transnational data. But if in the future you want a mobile app development Dubai solution, then get in touch.
Jasper Miller — February 15, 2023
The content is very useful and informational. We are a Blockchain Development Services provider, if interested kindly contact us.
warren — February 28, 2023
Such a wonderful article but just like to suggest you that Tekrevol is offering the best and most professional mobile app development Dubai services.
Aliena Jose — March 29, 2023
Worthy read. Meanwhile, if you have an idea of developing hybrid apps, contact Techmango, a hybrid app development company
Noelletessaa — April 10, 2023
Great article so far!
Really enjoyed to read the content.
As a tech enthusiast, I always enjoy inspiring about the latest advancements in the industry.
Speaking of useful fintech business tools and app development service, have you checked out opris
binance clone script. It's a powerful solution that can help businesses launch their own crypto exchange platform quickly and easily.
Keep your good work.
Cheers!
Michael White — June 2, 2023
Request to Take My Courses For me to Pay Someone To Take My Course and reach the peak of academic accomplishment. We have an outstanding track record of A+ grades and a 99% success rate. When you entrust us with your course, you are selecting a team of specialists with a track record of producing great outcomes. We leave no stone untouched, from rigorous course completion to flawless assignments and great exam achievement. Our dedication to quality guarantees that you get the grades you want. Choose us and see how your academic experience will be altered with A+ marks and an exceptional track record.
Bharat Logic — July 4, 2023
This thought-provoking article highlights the importance of addressing gender disparities in science aptitude. It's crucial to encourage and empower girls in pursuing STEM fields to ensure equal opportunities for all.
BharatLogic specializes in healthcare app development, providing innovative solutions for businesses in the healthcare industry.
Becky — August 18, 2023
This article offers outstanding insights into transnational data. Should you ever need mobile app development Miami expertise in the future, don't hesitate to reach out.
Mathew — August 18, 2023
Fantastic article! If you're ever looking for top-tier app development in Miami, consider checking out Jafton's offerings. They're among the best in the business.
Ben White — August 28, 2023
Orientation segregation has become a pressing concern. However, app developers in New York
and web design companies have consistently advocated for orientation equality. They always strive for a harmonious society with minimal orientation discrimination.
Ben White — August 28, 2023
Orientation segregation has become a pressing concern. However, app developers in new york and web design companies have consistently advocated for orientation equality. They always strive for a harmonious society with minimal orientation discrimination.
Muntaha Haider — June 25, 2024
Nice Post! Thanks for sharing this valuable insight custom mobile app development
Helen D Lingrosso — June 26, 2024
Thanks for sharing this! buy fish online in pakistan
Paul Magnussen — August 7, 2024
That's a fair number I'm glad that i found something i wasn't expecting for my case study......My suggestion is bring these things in a book or a from of app quick question? do these information easily found in any app? kindly please name it. If not i would say hire a app developer or a company from offshore to work with because its affordable cost one of the i know best in app development work is in oman i guess if you search mobile app development oman may help you find the best one.
Michelle — December 17, 2024
The examination of gender and scientific ability across nations and regions is indeed interesting. It highlights important factors regarding the interplay between various cultures, educational systems, and students’ performance in science. Such results may assist in the development of more effective and inclusive educational policies. For those interested in developing an application which draws on such data for educational purposes, O16 labs app development company would be an ideal fit. They have the required knowledge and skills to build such innovations that would effect positive changes.