In doing research for a book I may write about voluntary childnessness, I came across a telling graphic from the Pew Research Center. First, note that the percent of women age 40-44 without a biological child has almost doubled since the late ’70s. Today about one-in-five such women (18%) have never given birth:
The percent of women is even higher among women with professional degrees (a master’s or equivalent and higher). One-in-four women with a master’s degree, and nearly that many women with PhDs, have no biological children by ages 40-44.
Here’s where the really telling graph comes in. Though women with higher levels of education are less likely to have biological children than other types of women, the trend of increasing childlessness shown above doesn’t apply to them. In fact, women with master’s and PhDs in the most recent data are more likely to have children than their counterparts 14 years ago. In the first half of the 1990s, nearly one-in-three women with professional degrees did not have biological children; today it’s one-in-four. Childbearing among the most educated women, then, bucks the trend. It has gone up.
The data probably reflect greater endorsement of the idea that a woman can, or should be able to, balance both a career and a family, as well as the rise of policies that make that possible. University of Florida sociologist Tanya Koropeckyj-Cox, who’s studied this stuff, says as much. It may be hard to imagine now, but there was a time when having children would destroy a woman’s always-already fragile career; as much as we may love or hate the “mommy track,” at least today there is one. Koropeckyj-Cox also suggests that women with higher incomes may have greater access to infertility treatments, making overcoming health problems or delayed childbearing more possible for them than it is among women with less education.
In any case, the data suggests an interesting story about gender, childbearing, educational achievement, and historical change. I’d be happy to hear more interpretation in the comments.
Lisa Wade, PhD is an Associate Professor at Tulane University. She is the author of American Hookup, a book about college sexual culture; a textbook about gender; and a forthcoming introductory text: Terrible Magnificent Sociology. You can follow her on Twitter and Instagram.
Comments 76
Leslee Bottomley Beldotti — September 24, 2012
I'm 45 years old, childless, and my highest level of education is a B.A. I chose not to have any children, in part, because throughout my 20's and 30's I couldn't afford one. Often I could barely afford to feed myself, so having a child seemed incredibly selfish to me.
I doubt that attaining more education would have changed my choice, because my amount of student loan debt would have been even greater.
Renee — September 24, 2012
I'm not going to go back to the original data source to check, but before you spend a lot of time interpreting this in the context of the mommy track and all that, you should confirm that the women without biological children (or who have never given birth) are actually childless. Many women wait until their 40s and end up adopting, or having children via surrogacy, or have stepchildren.
That said, I think it probably is true that women with more social and economic capital are more able to make the work-life thing work, but that applies at all ages.
Kit M. — September 24, 2012
I'd be interested in seeing marriage rates considered alongside these data.
Yrro Simyarin — September 24, 2012
I wonder if this might be explained by the increase in the number of women with this level of academic attainment. It no longer requires as much (I said as much, I didn't say it doesn't take any) conviction/sacrifice for a woman to earn a PHD, therefore more women who seek to have children as well will have attained one... you are getting closer to a more general sampling of women rather than a very selected group.
WOMEN, EDUCATION, AND TRENDS IN CHILDLESSNESS « Welcome to the Doctor's Office — September 24, 2012
[...] from SocImages [...]
Ivan — September 24, 2012
Great interpretation. On the other end of the income/education spectrum, there is an increase of childless, or child-free :), women without atleast some college education. Any thoughts on that?
Michaelangelo Anastasiou — September 24, 2012
This graph does not tell us much in and of itself. We can only try to analyze by theoretical speculation. I would assume that this trend is more likely to be an outcome of increased social inequality between higher and lower levels of education, as opposed to the fact that the idea that women can balance work and family is being more and more endorse by society. According to this reasoning, we would have seen increases in all education categories, assuming respondents were employed (which bring up another point, that in order to make that argument we have to control for employment status). So I'm gonna go with a structural/conflict paradigm explanation on this one. Women with masters/phds degrees are having more children simply because they are in a better financial situation than they were in the past. The opposite holds true for people with lower levels of education.
I also reject the following statement: "It may be hard to imagine now, but there was a time when having children would destroy a woman’s always-already fragile career;", simply because this is still the case today, especially among people of lower income/education.
Sarah — September 24, 2012
I am interested in what the says about how abortion and other issues that influence one's desire to have children relate to this research. For example what percentage of women have had one or more abortions? What proportion have been a victim of a sex crime? Gender discrimination? Income across their life span? And so on. It is certainly worth me pulling up the initial article to find out. Thanks.
oliviacw — September 24, 2012
Being in that age group myself (40-44), I'd suggest that demographic issues have a lot to do with it. I have observed that women my age overall (but especially those with college degrees and with professional careers) appear much less likely to have children than those either 10 years older or younger than us. I think "children of the baby bust", born during the time of zero population growth, increased entrance of women into the professional workforce, etc, have been a group with a particularly low reproduction rates. I suspect the line in that first Pew chart will start to trend down again in a few years.
Julie — September 24, 2012
You might also observe a growing childfree population as more and more people, including women, are:
1. With the power of the internet, able to see through all the hype society places around children and parenthood and see the real picture, which, honestly, isn't always nice.
2. Have better access to and education on birth control.
3. Are realizing that parenthood is NOT mandatory.
4. Are with the power of the internet, able to hear from and connect with other like-minded people, drawing strength and resolve from their support.
I count myself among such women, and consider myself very lucky for it.
Julie — September 24, 2012
Oh, one thing I'm wondering. Have the rates of women with PHDs changed from 92-94 to 06-08? The shift in the data might have something to do with the change in overall population size in that group.
[research] Women, Education, and Trends in Childlessness « slendermeans — November 16, 2012
[...] [Read more: sociologicalImages] [...]
quick hit: Women, Education, and Trends in Childlessness | feimineach — December 30, 2013
[…] [Read more: sociologicalImages] […]
Women, Education, and Trends in Childlessness — March 28, 2014
[…] [Read more: sociologicalImages] […]
Women, Education, and Trends in Childlessness (feimineach) — February 14, 2015
[…] [Read more: sociologicalImages] […]
Exams vce — December 15, 2021
VCE files for all popular IT exams shared by community. Pass Cisco, Microsoft, VMware, CompTIA exams, and vce exams download. Share your braindumps and upload VCE
Tif — January 7, 2022
I recall how difficult it was for me to best dissertation help , and I am confident that I could delegate it to professionals with ease. That is why, for instance, I strongly advise that I seek assistance from a company like this. I already know where to seek for them; all I have to do now is consider the company’s competence, which can be put together swiftly and efficiently here. I also want to be of support to you. This is something I sincerely hope is the case. I’m crossing my fingers for a good outcome.
elizabethcaroll — February 8, 2022
The study has highlighted that the number of women in childlessness is increasing, and there is an association between age and education. In 2008, the share of white women with a bachelor's degree or advanced degree was 27%, while the rate among Hispanic women was 14%. According to the report, the increase in the share of educated women has been associated with a lower childless rate. Yet, the decrease in childless rates is even more striking among younger women. If you want to become an educated woman, contact write my paper agency for help!
There is a large difference in childlessness rates between white and non-white women. Unmarried women with only a high school diploma are more likely to be childless, while those with some college education have a lower rate. The rate of childlessness has also risen for Asian and black women, although these figures are similar. Marital status is the most common cause of childlessness, with never-married women experiencing the lowest rate.
Anonymous — March 10, 2022
Our mission is to create millions of new ukulele players, which in turn helps millions experience the joy of music
.
hipo — March 29, 2022
Awesome, exactly what I was looking for, it's very easy to understand! paper minecraft
prepaid meter — June 16, 2022
Very informative. keep it up
red ball 4 — July 14, 2022
Ready to do my part of the job guys, just let me know where we stopped and I will continue from there.
Courtney — July 14, 2022
Once you carry your own water, you learn the value of every drop. red ball 4
alchemy game — July 28, 2022
Is it hard to write a mobile application? I’m interested in writing a tourism application.
Fiona Cross — July 28, 2022
I’m pretty sure that robots will take a lot of our current jobs, but I am sure that they will create new jobs, easier ones for us. Just like it happened before.
alchemy game
Rose Kane — September 17, 2022
Anyone knows where I can find cheap computer parts? I’m trying to build low budget PC for me. Scribbleio
Eve Host — September 19, 2022
Not like this, I’m not afraid to lose game, but not like this… Cupcake 2048 game
Tomas Hanna — September 24, 2022
My neighborhood looks so different from above, just finished recording my local area with drone, footage is awesome, wanna see it?
Rivka Eggleston — September 24, 2022
Keep your focus and pay attention, is it too much to ask?
Emmalyn Billingsley — October 17, 2022
I want to go to university which teaches how to become pro YouTuber or pro Blogger.
Louie Kinder — October 17, 2022
New gadgets are so cool, the problem with them is that they cost too much, price is their only issue.
Enjoy tunnelrushunblocked
Israel Mahan — October 17, 2022
Anyone thinks that this post is brilliant? No one? Well I do...
Have fun - earntodie
Victoria Long — October 25, 2022
Why dark humor is both funny and painful at the same time?
drift hunters unblocked
Eve Frost — October 26, 2022
I’m looking forward to Google VR technology? When is release data by the way?
Fireboy and Watergirl unblocked
Rachel Woods — November 2, 2022
One more stupid suggestion in this comments section and I will lose my mind for good. Fly or Die io
Victoria — November 3, 2022
I really want to trust someone fully, I really want to open up but consequences can be really painful, for example, betrayal... play getaway shootout
Running game — November 25, 2022
I love to teach people, I love to share my experience and knowledge with them.
Game of running — November 25, 2022
Guys, quickly Pewdiepie shared a new video, it is so funny that you will laugh hard, it is about Happy Wheels Game of running
Paperio game — November 25, 2022
Winter is better than summer, change my mind :D Paperio game
scarlett smith — December 2, 2022
Any gamers around? I just installed Dota and wanted to know if this game is hard, or how should I play it. idlebreakout
Harry Davis — December 3, 2022
Which one is better after all? Xbox or PS??? Eternal conflict between two companies. play doge miner 2
Mikaela Bedard Snakeio — December 14, 2022
Guys no matter what HODL, market will grow again and bull run will start, just have some patience.
Flor Knight — December 14, 2022
How about we wait for him first, listen to his advice and make decision afterwards? Sounds good? www.snakeio.info
Blaire Fulton — December 14, 2022
Triggered Dota players are pure gold mines if enjoy trolling people. www.pixelgun3d.org
Among us — February 20, 2023
Book your ticket, we will make sure that you get a comfortable and safe ride.
Temple run — February 20, 2023
Most of the people lack creative ideas, they can’t think outside the box and follow boring patterns in their projects.
outspellaarp — March 30, 2023
Keep trying, you will fail anyway, this is how life works
unblocked fireboyandwatergirl — March 30, 2023
Fighting games are my thing, I hate puzzle or strategies, I more enjoy fast-paced games.
Mark David — July 6, 2023
Keeping the interior of your car clean is essential not only for aesthetics but also for your overall driving experience [Watch Video Guide]. Regularly cleaning the inner dirt of your car can make a significant difference in maintaining its appearance and preserving its value. Start by removing any trash, such as food wrappers or empty bottles, and use a vacuum cleaner to eliminate dust, dirt, and debris from the seats, floor mats, and crevices. Wipe down surfaces with a microfiber cloth and a mild cleaning solution to remove smudges, fingerprints, and stains from the dashboard, steering wheel, and door panels. Don't forget to clean the windows and mirrors for a clear view. By investing a little time and effort in keeping the interior of your car clean, you can enjoy a fresh and pleasant environment every time you hit the road.
Mark David — July 7, 2023
The winning noise of a car can evoke a range of emotions and perceptions. It is the distinct sound produced by the engine and various mechanical components as the vehicle accelerates or maintains its speed. The tone, pitch, and volume of the winning noise can vary depending on the make, model, and condition of the car. For some car enthusiasts, a deep and powerful winning noise can be exhilarating, evoking a sense of power and performance. On the other hand, a smooth and refined winning noise can be associated with luxury and elegance. However, excessive or unusual winning noises can indicate mechanical issues that require attention and maintenance. Overall, the winning noise of a car contributes to the overall driving experience, adding an auditory dimension that can enhance or diminish the pleasure of being behind the wheel.
Mark David — July 8, 2023
Dental care in Scarborough offers a comprehensive range of services to promote oral health and enhance smiles. With a focus on patient comfort and satisfaction, dental practices in Scarborough are equipped with state-of-the-art technology and staffed by highly skilled professionals. Whether it's routine check-ups and cleanings, cosmetic dentistry, orthodontics, or restorative procedures, patients can expect personalized care tailored to their unique needs. From preventive measures like dental exams and x-rays to advanced treatments like dental implants and teeth whitening, Scarborough's dental clinics strive to deliver exceptional care in a welcoming and friendly environment. By prioritizing patient education and utilizing the latest techniques, dental providers in Scarborough are dedicated to helping individuals achieve optimal oral health and maintain beautiful smiles for years to come.
Fight in snow — July 26, 2023
Jokes aside, it is time for hard work and productivity, need just little bit of motivation and we are good to go.
Robert Gonzalez — August 16, 2023
What kind of magic is it? I’m impressed, no actually I’m shocked by this. Alchemy game
Erin Frost — August 17, 2023
Hey, sorry, scrub here, how do you find faulty device? play snail bob
Lucila Colwell — August 22, 2023
Fun fact, it is okay to have different opinion and it is okay to talk about it.
Emily Evis — August 22, 2023
You make mistakes very often, but no worries, we will work on this issue and we will keep you informed. mahjongg solitaire aarp
Cool game — October 9, 2023
It took me a while to realize what I was looking at, awesome puzzle indeed, looks so confusing at first glance.
Top game — October 9, 2023
Before you will answer, note this: I can tell exactly when you are lying...
unblocked cat — November 8, 2023
Tired, same people, same scenarios, same food, same view, etc. It is all the same, as if I live in some kind of cage.
shooter aarp — November 8, 2023
Where is the fun? My friend told me that this place is entertaining and interesting, I guess he lied to me.
lol 1v1 — November 8, 2023
When did you last have a deep conversation with someone? I believe it was a long time ago.
io tetris — November 8, 2023
Now this is what I call quality blog with no BS and only facts, my respect m8.
io bloxd — January 8, 2024
Is there any way to run troubleshoot on my phone and find out what is slowing it down?
lol 1v1 — January 8, 2024
There are a lot of different economic blueprints, some of them are successful some of them not that much.
play basket random online — April 4, 2024
We are expanding our business, we are hiring more people and we are working on our new big projects.