Dr. Bethany Pope sent in a segment from a National Geographic show about animals’ sexual behavior. The clip is an amazingly gendered discussion, describing animals’ motivations and behaviors through the lens of what is considered normative masculine and feminine sexual behavior, the correct place of males and females in the social hierarchy, and the assumption that males and females are locked in a zero-sum game. The anthropomorphizing of other species begins at the outset, when we learn female hyenas want “more than equal rights, they want to beat males at their own game.” In fact, “Africa’s plains are among the most macho places on earth…they’re testosterone-fueled battlefields,” filled with “swaggering” males. Bethany sums up the tone regarding hyenas, saying, “The documentary presents them as an abomination, usurping male gender roles.” Indeed, at about a minute in we learn that hyenas “seem mixed up.” A hyena “swaggers,” “confident” and “cocksure,” its penis swinging “low and proud.” But what’s this? The swaggering, cocksure hunter “has a secret”! That’s not a penis, it’s an enlarged clitoris; our hero is a she! Not only that, there’s not a penis anywhere to be found, as this is an all-female pack; “these female are some of the most masculine in the world — and they like to sniff each other an awful lot, too. Compounding the “confusion,” they have a “bulging” sac, like a scrotum. And not only are female hyenas masculinized, but the poor males are emasculated, reduced to being “subservient, servile, and scared.” It is rather stunning example of anthropomorphizing the natural world and applying gendered norms of sexuality to other species, and worth sitting through the full six minutes to get the full effect (the video might not be safe for some workplaces; there are a lot of lingering shots of penises and clitorises. A lot.):
Gwen Sharp is an associate professor of sociology at Nevada State College. You can follow her on Twitter at @gwensharpnv.
Comments 164
pduggie — January 26, 2012
I dunno, seems somewhat subversive. First you have the male dominated world of African animals, and then...surprise! the he is actually a she. And male domination is called into question
(but male HORMONE domination is not)
Anthony Tantillo — January 26, 2012
Also the way hyenas have sex is by inserting the penis into the clitoris.
Now if you thought that might be painful, they also deliver their pups through the clitoris.
Most hyena mothers die during labor.
Nature is pretty crazy sometimes.
Erika Harada — January 26, 2012
Some like to "blame" it on higher levels of androgens among female hyenas, but...research has shown that that is not true. For hyenas, this is what has worked for them evolutionarily; to call it a difference from the "norm" is really kind of close-minded. There is a massive variety in how animals reproduce, and how they behave wrt gender, and contrary to popular belief, those ways are not set in stone either; they can change substantially based on the environment. People sure like to anthropomorphize, though.
Anonymous — January 26, 2012
Countdown to MRA panic over our horrible hyena-lady future....
(As an aside, what the heck kind of phrase is "with no external vagina"? The vagina is not usually an external organ, folks. Perhaps he meant "vulva.")
ctl — January 26, 2012
Hyenas also fellate one another to show submission, like a pup would lick one's face.
Plus, if you want to be grossed out, look up "hyena butter."
I love hyenas, they are my favourite damn animal.
Anonymous — January 26, 2012
I got a chance to visit the hyena sanctuary in No. Cal and see some of the footage they have of hyenas interacting with enrichment features (non-regular items the keepers bring into the environment to provide change, good stress, interest, etc.) The video showed two different groups of hyenas (first the females, then the males) coming into an enclosure filled with hay bales. The female hyenas tore through the place, quickly destroying the hay bales and looking like they were having a grand time (i.e. they didn't look stressed, angry, nervous about territory, but relaxed and secure.) The room was reset and the males given the same chance. They moved more slowly, didn't seem scared or nervous particular, but were cautious. They played with the hay bales, and did some damage, but there was not the wholesale gleeful destruction evident in the females' play.
The difference was quite striking and it would be all too easy to create really gendered descriptions. I probably have above, although I've tried not to.
Gilbert Pinfold — January 26, 2012
I expected more enthusiasm for the ambivalent, trans-normative world of hyena sexuality.
LarryW — January 26, 2012
I'm reminded of Disney's Nature Series back in the 1950s. Even spiders were anthromorphized.
Anonymous — January 26, 2012
National Geographic presented the world from a androcentric perspective? NO WAY! They do that all the time in their magazine. I expect better of them and their pretty pictures.
Boner Killer — January 26, 2012
reminds me of that book "sexual politics of meat" comparing animals to humans while forgetting the unique component of humanity: culture.
Steph — January 26, 2012
I'm reminded a little of March of the Penguins - in which a very anthropocentric narrative of romantic love is applied to wildlife footage that could have supported any number of alternative interpretations. I recall Morgan Freeman's smooth tones explaining how, at the end of the arduous process of journeying to and from the ocean and hatching a chick in the midst of Antarctic storms, the mating pair "...finally get to spend some time together", as if this was their abiding purpose all along. They could have, for instance, claimed the pair were saluting each other and acknowledging their perseverance at the conclusion of a difficult business venture (assuming they really wanted to have a human-esque narrative). Why must it be romance? I think it's a lovely movie, but it's interesting to look at the stories we are trying to tell about ourselves when we're trying to tell stories about other species.
Naomic3 — January 26, 2012
However, in biology, "male" and "female" are actually defined by behavior, not by XX versus XY. We tend to think that we are anthropomorphizing animals by gender roles, instead of the other way around--our perception of sex is shaped by how we categorize behaviors to begin with.
Eric Gonzalez — January 26, 2012
I don't think that the claim that it's a clitoris is right. For one the birth canal goes through as does the urethra which as far as know isn't the case when we do choose to call it a clitoris. 2: the clitoris and the penis are homologous (science speak for "the same thing") anyway. The penis and clitoris are the same, derive from the same tissues, and so on.
Also the idea that the males are servile is dramatized obviously, even so far as not to be accurate. But you know what? Servile males are more common in nature anyway. In other primates its a mixed bag, gorillas are a matriarchy, and chimps and bonobos have a social structure so differen't I don't think it can even be compared.
Jacque — January 27, 2012
And then they turn around and use this anthropomorphic idea of animal gender to support an argument for the natural-ness of human gender order
Anonymous — January 27, 2012
I don't know what's more depressing: that National Geographic thinks that powerful females are "messed up," or that debunking the former causes another sociology-is-not-a-science troll-fest in the comments.
LarryW — January 27, 2012
Perhaps this conversation should wait until we are able to communicate with our animal brothers and sisters.
ctl — January 27, 2012
I remember reading of a study that concluded hyenas were better at team problem-solving than dogs (or wolves? I don't quite recall) or chimps, despite their apparently-lower individual intelligence.
Captain Pasty — January 31, 2012
I had a couple of lectures about hyenas in my undergrad degree. It's basically just an enlarged clit, which is bigger than the penis. Hyenas also have no external vagina, so they invert the clit to have sex. They also give birth through it, where it can sometimes tear. It's usually twins, and they will fight to the death when they are born.
This video though is awful, the commentary is awful. I'd recommend to stick to David Attenborough documentaries.
ff — March 25, 2013
umm this so fuckin nasty
Environmental Sociology and Sociological Images | John Girdwood — January 9, 2015
[…] NATIONAL GEOGRAPHIC GENDERS ANIMAL SEXUALITY […]
lisa — December 18, 2020
Quality content is the main driver for users to go see a site and that’s what this website is providing. Thank you!savannah cat for sale
zack smith — December 20, 2020
I have three kids and I learnt a lot from having a dog around my children. Since we got our dog we have seen an improvement in terms of their behaviour towards animals and also humans and they are definitely growing to be animal loving. Great article on dog.Cats
poul — February 28, 2021
She is so gifted to have that kind of talent. I also studied fashion designing before, but I have failed to finish it. I did not pursue it because I lack of interest, I wanted to have a title as a designer, but it is so hard to finish a piece.Travel
john — May 23, 2021
The information that you mention in the article is very informative for me.cosmetic beauty facial mask raw material
lisa — July 23, 2021
I know this web site presents quality depending articles and additional material, is there any other site which offers such things in quality?pet food supplier singapore
lisa — July 24, 2021
I have three kids and I learnt a lot from having a dog around my children. Since we got our dog we have seen an improvement in terms of their behaviour towards animals and also humans and they are definitely growing to be animal loving. Great article on dog.cute cat
lisa — September 11, 2021
Pet health care is really good. Great blog… A frightened dog prefers to run away from the owner. Lack of training is solely responsible for the exhibition of such behavior. So, training is really essential which helps a pet to understand certain signs and sounds developed by the owner.Pet CBD
lisa — September 20, 2021
hank you for being so positive about the way pregnancy makes you feel in yoga. I was fully prepared for a self deprecating comparison to these animals, but you made it meaningful. My husband and I are trying to get pregnant, and I have worried about my practice being limited and feeling lost as to what I can do. This was a really helpful insight.how much does it cost to buy a maltipoo
lisa — October 16, 2021
There are a lot of health benefits with this vapors, the more informaiton you can find here,thanks for sharing with us. Mostly sharing us about electronic cigerettes and liquids always.Dogs
emma — October 24, 2021
They played with the hay bales, and did some damage, but there was not the wholesale gleeful destruction evident in the females' play. Doggy Daycare
john — October 30, 2021
The female hyenas tore through the place, quickly destroying the hay bales and looking like they were having a grand time (i.e. they didn't look stressed, angry, nervous about territory, but relaxed and secure.) The room was reset and the males given the same chance.Yorkies
lisa — November 23, 2021
Dogs can get excited and jump up. Unfortunately, this is enough to knock toddlers off their feet. Some behaviourists suggest sending them for a time out on their doggy bed if they misbehave like that. Don’t let any of your pets climb into the baby’s crib. Pets need a bedtime routine as much as we do, so make sure they know where their own bed is.dogs for sale
lisa — November 29, 2021
There is a massive variety in how animals reproduce, and how they behave wrt gender, and contrary to popular belief, those ways are not set in stone either; they can change substantially based on the environment. dog bed wholesale
LISA — November 30, 2021
There is a massive variety in how animals reproduce, and how they behave wrt gender, and contrary to popular belief, those ways are not set in stone either; they can change substantially based on the environment. Cheap Dog Dresses
lisa — December 8, 2021
The female hyenas tore through the place, quickly destroying the hay bales and looking like they were having a grand time (i.e. they didn't look stressed, angry, nervous about territory, but relaxed and secure.) The room was reset and the males given the same chance.Bengal cats & kittens
zack smith — December 11, 2021
You also using the robot floor cleaner to pick up the pet hair, that also fine. Could yo please advise about the capability of picking up the hair on and in the carpet. Lost pets
emma — December 14, 2021
For one the birth canal goes through as does the urethra which as far as know isn't the case when we do choose to call it a clitoris. 2: the clitoris and the penis are homologous anyway.pet medication
emma — January 5, 2022
The room was reset and the males given the same chance. They moved more slowly, didn't seem scared or nervous particular, but were cautious. They played with the hay bales, and did some damage, but there was not the wholesale gleeful destruction evident in the females' play. Snuffle Mat
Maria — January 12, 2022
They always try their best to guide dog owners so they know what to do and what not to do. I follow to keep dog healthy site that help me a lot.
lisa — January 20, 2022
It made sense when you said that kittens need to be vaccinated for feline herpesvirus since there's no cure for it. My husband and I want to find a good local vet before adopting a kitten from a shelter next week. Thanks for teaching me what vaccines we'll need to get from the vet to ensure our kitten stays healthy and is protected from common issues.Paws Bistro
maxwell — February 25, 2022
The video showed two different groups of hyenas (first the females, then the males) coming into an enclosure filled with hay bales.collare per animali domestici
lisa — March 4, 2022
For hyenas, this is what has worked for them evolutionarily; to call it a difference from the "norm" is really kind of close-minded. rottweiler
lisa — March 8, 2022
There is a massive variety in how animals reproduce, and how they behave wrt gender, and contrary to popular belief, those ways are not set in stone either; they can change substantially based on the environment.AuthorityAquarium
lisa — March 26, 2022
They moved more slowly, didn't seem scared or nervous particular, but were cautious. They played with the hay bales, and did some damage, but there was not the wholesale gleeful destruction evident in the females' play. Yorkie Dog Food
emma — April 6, 2022
Since we got our dog we have seen an improvement in terms of their behaviour towards animals and also humans and they are definitely growing to be animal loving.Katze
lisa — April 14, 2022
The video showed two different groups of hyenas (first the females, then the males) coming into an enclosure filled with hay bales.Savannah Cat
lisa — April 21, 2022
They moved more slowly, didn't seem scared or nervous particular, but were cautious.best cat toys
lisa — April 23, 2022
They also give birth through it, where it can sometimes tear. It's usually twins, and they will fight to the death when they are born. maine coon for sale
lisa — May 18, 2022
How they behave wrt gender, and contrary to popular belief, those ways are not set in stone either; they can change substantially based on the environment.Pied Champion for sale in australia
lisa — June 8, 2022
Great article! It can be a massive responsibility for a kid to have a pet, especially getting a dog. Great life lesson for kids to learn.outdoor dog kennel
Emma — June 14, 2022
But do you think it is effective for every student? I agree with your words that it can enhance their skills but the understanding matter. Thanks for sharing!
Emma — June 14, 2022
love everything that you do! I mean you’ve done it again because these are so freaking adorable! Silly question here – what type of paper did you use to print these? I’m so excited to make them!click here
lisa — June 20, 2022
Children who don’t have a ton of interaction with real animals as pets or during other activities are still taught to connect to them through different forms of entertainment. For this reason, children are naturally interested in animal companionship in one way or another.cool dog facts
lisa — August 2, 2022
A frightened dog prefers to run away from the owner. Lack of training is solely responsible for the exhibition of such behavior. So, training is really essential which helps a pet to understand certain signs and sounds developed by the owner.travel with dog
lisa — August 29, 2022
Pets category in your sidebar, so I had to check it out. Are the images that you used for the dog and cat a silhouette of your dog and cat, or are they from somewhere else? something similar for our dog food containers….yes, two because they eat same brand but Lucy eats senior food and Abby eats Adult.loss of cat gift
lisa — September 6, 2022
Basically this blog has been sharing us about pets and in the environment and more entered the great process as well. Keep follow about transition and vibrations for great sources always, health treatment provide for cats and dogs. Excellent to be visiting your blog again, it has been months for me. Rightly, this article that I’ve been served for therefore long. Nice Poeci
lisa — September 8, 2022
This is so magnificent listing of effective herbs for puppies. We all recognize benefits of turmeric and few different herbs for curing irritation and different issues in human but it's far useful for pets, am gaining knowledge of this first time. I like the manner you have got acquire all these vital herbs for common fitness of dogs.chinese shar pei mini
lisa — September 15, 2022
A cat does not need as much attention as a dog does. Also, cats are far more intelligent that dogs, that is a known fact. I am not saying that cats are inherently better, but that is where the facts point to, that is what I am saying.fancy guppie
Aice — September 28, 2022
They moved more slowly, didn't seem scared or nervous in particular, but were cautious. They played with the hay bales and did some damage, but there was not the wholesale gleeful destruction evident in the females' play. Luxury pet beds
Wilson — October 18, 2022
I was fully prepared for a self-deprecating comparison to these animals, but you made it meaningful.pet care
Wilson — October 26, 2022
I also studied fashion design before, but I failed to finish it. I did not pursue it because I lack interest, I wanted to have a title as a designer, but it is so hard to finish a piece.Gifts For Pet Owners
Wilson — October 27, 2022
Some behaviorists suggest sending them for a time out on their doggy bed if they misbehave like that. Don’t let any of your pets climb into the baby’s crib. Preferable Pups
Loura — November 14, 2022
Since we got our dog we have seen an improvement in terms of their behaviour towards animals and also humans and they are definitely growing to be animal loving.fresh dog food
emma — December 11, 2022
We tend to think that we are anthropomorphizing animals by gender roles, instead of the other way around--our perception of sex is shaped by how we categorize behaviors to begin with.Veterinarians
emma — December 14, 2022
Unfortunately, this is enough to knock toddlers off their feet. Some behaviourists suggest sending them for a time out on their doggy bed if they misbehave like that.dog ownership guide
yousuf — January 14, 2023
I believe you have mentioned some very interesting points , regards for the post. generalwebsurfer
yousuf — January 14, 2023
That’s a excellent perspective, nonetheless isn’t make every sence whatsoever dealing with which mather. Just about any method with thanks in addition to pondered try and promote your own article straight into delicius nevertheless it is very much a problem in your information sites is it possible i highly recommend you recheck it. gives thanks again. generalabout
yousuf khan — January 14, 2023
I think this web site has got very fantastic indited written content articles . boyntech
yousuf — January 14, 2023
I think this web site has got very fantastic indited written content articles . healthinessy
yousuf — January 14, 2023
An attention-grabbing dialogue is value comment. I believe that you need to write more on this matter, it won’t be a taboo subject however usually individuals are not sufficient to speak on such topics. To the next. Cheers touristlogic
Smith — February 8, 2023
We understand the importance of your family's pet. That's why we offer transport services that ensure their safety and security along with great prices. Pet transport service
Adam — February 21, 2023
They moved more slowly, didn't seem scared or nervous particular, but were cautious. They played with the hay bales, and did some damage, but there was not the wholesale gleeful destruction evident in the females' play. smart travel pet insurance
Adam — March 5, 2023
Keep follow about transition and vibrations for great sources always, health treatment provide for cats and dogs. Excellent to be visiting your blog again, it has been months for me.Pet care products
Adam — March 5, 2023
I recall Morgan Freeman's smooth tones explaining how, at the end of the arduous process of journeying to and from the ocean and hatching a chick in the midst of Antarctic storms, the mating pair "...finally get to spend some time together", as if this was their abiding purpose all along.Pet care products
jazz — March 23, 2023
I have recently started a website,muttertag gif 2023 the information you offer on this web site has helped me greatly. Thank you for all of your time & work. “Everyone is responsible and no one is to blame.” by Will Schutz.
jazz — March 23, 2023
Wow, excellent post. I'd like to draft like this too - Math Tutor Delta BCtaking time and real hard work to make a great article. This post has encouraged me to write some posts that I am going to write soon.https://www.mathnasium.ca/langford
jazz — March 23, 2023
We offer not only top quality dumpsters, but we also go above and beyond with our customer service. bottle recycling We believe our customers deserve the best of the best, so we work hard to provide that! petting zoos We offer dumpster rentals for any project you are working on, or will be working on, big or small!
jazz — March 23, 2023
After study a couple of of the weblog posts in your web site now, hydrafacial near me and I actually like your way of blogging. I bookmarked it to my bookmark website listing and will probably be checking back soon. fresh prep calgary Pls take a look at my website as nicely and let me know what you think
Adam — April 5, 2023
They also give birth through it, where it can sometimes tear. It's usually twins, and they will fight to the death when they are born.Pet groomers Townsville
Zampa — April 28, 2023
Keep follow about transition and vibrations for great sources always, health treatment provide for cats and dogs.mini french bulldog
Wilson — April 30, 2023
Lack of training is solely responsible for the exhibition of such behavior. So, training is really essential which helps a pet to understand certain signs and sounds developed by the owner.Dog Breeds
lisa — July 11, 2023
Pets category to your sidebar, so I had to check it out. Are the photos that you used for the dog and cat a silhouette of your canine and cat, or are they from some other place? Something similar for our canine meals packing containers…Pet Bandanas
Daniel — November 15, 2023
Looking for Abyssinian kittens for sale? Visit Tour website and find your perfect pedigree kitten. This breed is affectionate, active and fun.
Click here: https://abyssiniankitten.com/ for more available Abyssinian kittens
Alia Parker — February 11, 2024
The Houndsy Kibble Dispenser is an innovative solution for pet owners, offering automated and precise portion control for feeding your furry friend. With user-friendly features and reliability, it ensures convenient and efficient mealtime management for your hound.
Daniel — February 22, 2024
We are a professional corgi breeder which means we have dedicated our lives in breeding quality Pembroke Welsh Corgis and your next special stubby legged family member. We have available males and female corgi puppies ready for their new home. Visit our here at : https://littlecorgipuppies.com/
For more available puppies
Sarah — April 12, 2024
Since we got our dog we have seen an improvement in terms of their behaviour towards animals and also humans and they are definitely growing to be animal loving.Catio
Anderson — April 27, 2024
I was fully prepared for a self deprecating comparison to these animals, but you made it meaningful. My husband and I are trying to get pregnant, and I have worried about my practice being limited and feeling lost as to what I can do. Bengal cat
EB — July 20, 2024
Greetings from Poland!
(Find a dog breeders…)
maine coon — August 23, 2024
Are you considering adding a furry friend to your family? Look no further than Furkittens.com for the most delightful Maine Coon kittens!
Here's why adopting a Maine Coon kitten from us will be the best decision you'll ever make.
maine coon breeders near me