In a link sent in by Anjan G., Victoria’s Secret model Adriana Lima explains what she does in the months prior to walking the catwalk (source). Here’s a summary:
- For months before the show, she works out every day with a personal trainer; for the three weeks before, she works out twice a day.
- A nutritionist gives her protein shakes, vitamins and supplements to help her body cope with the work out schedule.
- She drinks a gallon of water a day.
- For the final nine days before the show, she consumes only protein shakes.
- Two days before the show, she begins drinking water at a normal rate; for the final 12 hours, she drinks no water at all. She loses up to eight pounds during this time.
The result.
Lima’s training and nutrition regimen reveal that the look that is believed by some to be the epitome of feminine accomplishment — the look required to be a Victoria’s Secret Angel — is accompanied by significant physical strain. Lima looks as she is supposed to on the runway, but she is also dehydrated and hungry.
The story reminded me of this photograph, taken by Zed Nelson. It shows Ronnie Coleman, immediately after walking off the stage at the Mr. Olympia competition, breathing through an oxygen mask. He would take first place. Explaining the photograph, Nelson writes:
Oxygen administered to exhausted contestants during final round of judging. The strain of intense dieting, dehydration and muscle-flexing, places high levels of strain on the heart and lungs, rendering many contestants dizzy, light-headed and weak.
Bodybuilders often have extreme and rigid exercise and diet plans in the months preceding a contest. In those months, a male bodybuilder’s goal is to make himself appear as strong as possible. He must balance his body’s functional needs with his aesthetic goals, and sometimes the latter wins over the former.
Male bodybuilders and female models, then, represent aesthetic extremes of masculinity and femininity, but their bodies aren’t the natural extension of male and female physicalities. Instead, achieving the look require significant sacrifice of one’s body. In other words, they look fit and strong, but looks can be deceiving.
See also: criticism of female body builders and the right to consume women’s beauty.
Lisa Wade, PhD is an Associate Professor at Tulane University. She is the author of American Hookup, a book about college sexual culture; a textbook about gender; and a forthcoming introductory text: Terrible Magnificent Sociology. You can follow her on Twitter and Instagram.
Comments 72
QX — December 4, 2011
" In other words, they look fit and strong, but looks can be deceiving."
Not really. They ARE fit and/or strong, then they do show/contest prep to take their appearance up a notch, temporarily. No amount of workouts, protein shakes, supplements, diuretics, whatever, can take someone from Jane or Joe Average to VS model or pro bodybuilder in a few months. The base has to be there, and the base will still be there when the show is over.
Seth Eag — December 4, 2011
I think these critiques would be much more successful and better understood if we referred to these things as what they are: self-mutilation.
Guest — December 4, 2011
"Bodybuilders and models, then, represent aesthetic extremes of masculinity and femininity, but their bodies aren’t the natural extension of male and female physicalities."
Just because it is possible to fake your way into looking "good" by starving yourself, using drugs or whatnot, does not mean that everyone who looks like that is unhealthy.
Quiet Riot Girl — December 4, 2011
I guess you haven't read Male Impersonators by Mark Simpson (1994, Cassel)
In that book he explains that actually bodybuilding is a very feminine activity, as it is based on narcissism, masochism and 'passive' display of the body. Like modelling.
Christopher Hutton — December 4, 2011
This is too scary for me to believe. I could not support such an event.
pduggie — December 4, 2011
So a peacock puts on a brilliant display of plumage to attract a mate. One could say that his display isn't a 'natural extension' of what a bird's physicality is. It, in fact, interferes with his ability to fly. But on the other hand, it is entirely nature that has led the peacock, through sexual selection, to have such a display, so that is, in fact a natural extension of the birds 'masculine" (for a peacock) qualities.
If a peacock could reason about how it might be more successful attracting a mate, perhaps it would invest in a chemical regimen which would weaken its heart and muscles and shorten its life expectancy, but increase the aesthetic attraction of its plumage. There is a 'natural attractiveness' of peacock plumage and there are better and lesser examples of it.
We shouldn't privilege the use of only 'natural' (whatever that means, in a world where all is nature) methods to extend aesthetic beauty toward a cultural ideal. Peacocks do it "naturally" through selection.
pduggie — December 4, 2011
the whole thing reminds me of the This American Life show recently about love for cars. One segment was on car stereo competition. One of the contestants got into the hobby to impress girls with his cool stereo.
But the competitors have 'degenerated' to the extent that the cars can barely be driven, you can't hear music on it, and you dont' sit in the car during the test.
But they are objectively loud.
Ashley — December 4, 2011
How can she be dehydrated with a gallon of water a day? I've drank a gallon in one day, and I was sitting on the toilet for most of the day.
Tanya — December 4, 2011
This sort of thing has always puzzled me.
I am fat, and throughout my life I have been forced to listen to/accept people's judgement that I am not and cannot be 'healthy' - no matter what my diet and exercise habits are - because I am fat. And at the same time society holds up 'healthy' role models such as these who are not only not practising healthy habits (they are, in fact, practicing very unhealthy ones) but who's very 'job' depends upon the practice of unhealthy habits (yes, I know, some models are naturally slim, etc... but many do what Lima does, or something similar).
Noelle — December 4, 2011
" In those months, a bodybuilder’s goal is to make himself appear as
strong as possible. He must balance his body’s functional needs with
his aesthetic goals, and sometimes the latter wins over the former."
so...what exactly do female bodybuilders do? or am i to believe they don't exist?
Larrycharleswilson — December 5, 2011
My problem seems to be that I don't worry about my weight (even though my wife says I'm fat and both my oncologist and cardiologist want me to lose some) and that I'm "turned off" both by skinny people whose bones stick out and by bodybuilders who look to me like a parody of homo sapiens.
Andrew — December 5, 2011
Intense daily physical training regimes. Extreme diets. Long work days with high risk of dehydration. Sacrificing one's health and well-being in pursuit of a physical ideal that is unattainable to most.
This sounds exactly like the life of most professional athletes, who vastly outnumber supermodels. And not just pros, for that matter; Lima's description of her physical regimen sounds a lot like what kids in certain sports are pressured to put themselves through in high school or even earlier. I've heard plenty of similar stories from dancers as well - really, any job that requires rigid maintenance of a certain body type is going to have a lot of people going to extremes like this.
With that in mind, why on earth do we celebrate the accomplishments of athletes while denigrating the profession of modelling? Would Lima's "sacrifice" be any nobler if it were in the service of tennis or gymastics rather than bras and panties?
Links 12/14/11 | Mike the Mad Biologist — December 14, 2011
[...] North Dakota Cops Do Not Need Drones, Damnit There Will Be Teblood – The Unbearable-ing (updated) Behind the “Perfect” Body: Models and BodyBuilders Confessions of a Retail Worker: My friend went two days without food. How Goldman Sachs and Other [...]
Zelfvertrouwen legt meer gewicht in de schaal dan gender « De Zesde Clan — January 9, 2012
[...] De boodschap is duidelijk… Gender is hard werken! [...]
Progress Henderson — June 25, 2012
While it is true that in order to give the most definition, male bodybuilders must dehydrate and deplete, if you were flexing that much muscle while fed for competition poses, you would need oxygen. It is a simple matter of lung volume compared to oxygen demands of skeletal muscle. Also, to say that Ronnie Coleman looks strong, but appearances can be deceiving is ludicrous. Watch any youtube video of him working out. He is one of the most functionally strong bodybuilders ever. He is stronger than many strength competitors. It is easy to sit on the sidelines and criticize the achievements that people make through years of hard work, dedication, and sacrifice. Just because you aren't in a place where you can see yourself transforming your body to an ideal that you would like to see, does not mean it cannot be done. There is a reason there is so much sex appeal to genetic maximums, it is by far more desireable than the soft excuses that society wants to let people with bad diet, exercise, and sleep habits use to feel "good" about themselves. Grow up, wake up, and take accountability for the gift you have been given of a body.
Dog Pile 2 | Fierce, Freethinking Fatties — August 8, 2013
[...] Beauty standards of all genders are almost impossible to attain, and those who are considered the “prime examples” are actually devastating themselves: [...]
Teigou — October 24, 2016
I bet bodybuilders may suffer ffrom some degree or type of obsessive compulsive disorder accompanied by the need for some kind of validation. The validation is somehow achieved through the newly acquired physique it becomes pleasurable and addictive.
They may look strong physically, but mentally things can be the opposite.
Oscar82 — December 21, 2023
Thank you for sharing this insightful perspective on the sacrifices and challenges that both models and bodybuilders undergo to achieve what is considered the epitome of aesthetic beauty. It's a reminder that the pursuit of the "perfect" body often involves significant physical strain and sacrifices. If you're interested in exploring supplements that align with a fitness journey, particularly those focused on fat loss, you might find valuable information at https://dinespower.com/en/fat. They offer high-quality fat burners that could provide a balanced approach to achieving fitness goals. Feel free to check it out for additional insights!
Oscar82 — December 21, 2023
Thank you for sharing this insightful perspective on the sacrifices and challenges that both models and bodybuilders undergo to achieve what is considered the epitome of aesthetic beauty. It's a reminder that the pursuit of the "perfect" body often involves significant physical strain and sacrifices. If you're interested in exploring supplements that align with a fitness journey, particularly those focused on fat loss, you might find valuable information at https://dinespower.com/en/fat. They offer high-quality fat burners that could provide a balanced approach to achieving fitness goals. Feel free to check it out for additional insights!