Cross-posted at Scientopia.
fds sent us a link to a set of “extreme” ads. One of them was an Italian ad designed to draw attention to the seriousness of child sexual abuse. I’ve placed it after the jump because it is VERY disconcerting. My comments may be quite provocative as well.
Text: “CERTAIN THINGS HANG ON FOREVER: Set the kids free from abuse and violence.”
With the comments below, I do not mean to trivialize the trauma that many people suffer from child sexual abuse. That said, I want to problematize the message of this ad. The message, I believe, is two-pronged.
On the one hand, it says “Don’t sexually abuse children/protect children from sexual abuse… because it is very serious and can affect a child for his or her whole life.” This seems like a reasonable message.
On the other hand, it says “If you have been sexually abused, you will be broken for the rest of your life.” This is the message that I find problematic. I know sexual abuse survivors who resent this message. I have students who, when I question this claim in class, thank me. Sometimes they tell me that I am the first person who ever gave them permission to fully recover from their experience. Or, they say, they’ve never felt particularly traumatized and, so, always felt like there was something terribly wrong with them… because there wasn’t something terribly wrong with them.
Of course reactions to sexual abuse are going to vary along many different dimensions and, in many cases, it causes quite severe trauma. But I don’t like how these ads disallow the possibility that one can be sexually abused as a child and grow up to be an emotionally healthy adult.
Lisa Wade, PhD is an Associate Professor at Tulane University. She is the author of American Hookup, a book about college sexual culture; a textbook about gender; and a forthcoming introductory text: Terrible Magnificent Sociology. You can follow her on Twitter and Instagram.

Comments 95
Patrick — March 15, 2010
Well, I am not sure I agree with you here, but it's a difficult question.
First off, my disagreement comes from the fact that it is an ad similar to those billboards against drunk driving (for example). And whilst you can drive drunkenly and not have an accident, these ads always point out accidents. It's just the nature of the message to focus on the worst consequences.
Now, it gets problematic for me because I'm not sure what this ad is supposed to do. I can't think of many people who think child abuse is okay. In fact, I think it is universally regarded as one of the worst crimes, maybe even the worst crime of all. So do you really need an ad campaign to drive the point home? Probably not. And, given that you rightfully say reactions to abuse are different, and not one reaction is wrong, this ad might even do more harm than good.
So I don't think you need this billboard, but if you do it, you'd probably have to reference long-term trauma. I don't know if there's a statistic, so maybe "59% of child abuse victims are likely to be traumatized for life"? On the other hand, there's always the danger of being called out on for "not taking it seriously enough". Hm.
Andrew Ferguson — March 15, 2010
That image appears to be directly lifted from photographer Phillip Toledano's work. It's almost identical to something from his 'Hope & Fear' series back in 2004, seen here:
http://www.mrtoledano.com/Hope-Fear/10
Dawn — March 15, 2010
This reminds me of an ad from the 70s about how child abuse is passed down generation to generation or would be unless the reader would send money to whatever organization it was. My mother is a survivor of child abuse (domestic violence, sexual abuse) and the ad made her angry because she WASN'T abusing us and she was tired of being pegged as a potential child abuser because she was once an abused child. So she sat down and wrote that agency a letter. I remember this clearly -- it was probably 1978 or 79 and the ad was in Time Magazine -- because it stuck with me, my mom's anger and her activism.
anonymoussociologist — March 15, 2010
First I have to say that the image in the ad itself really disturbs me. I think that if input from actual sexual abuse survivors was taken into consideration, the ad designers would realize this image is quite upsetting. One does not need to see a young child with multiple hands on them to understand sexual abuse. My stomach turns looking at the image.
This ad does little to reach an abuser/ those aware of abuse. I agree with the comment above that it is such a taboo subject many don't report it. There is a lot of denial that goes on when a child confides in an adult about sexual abuse. Some adults are strong enough to seek help for that child, but many others are not. And many times the child is dismissed, called a liar, or even blamed. I have seen this especially in cases of incest. Entire families are aware of the pedophile family member(s), but do not stop them or even confront them. This leads to some survivors feeling they are making too big of a deal about the abuse, since no one else reacts. And of course this creates great confusion within the survivor. Some may not ever deal with the abuse because it has been normalized by those around them.
I also agree with the message portraying survivors as individuals who are permanently destroyed. I have seen time and time again the power of therapy to help one work through abuse. Many times it will lead to a full recovery and the ability for the survivor to move past the abuse they suffered. I wish instead of such ads there were discussion panels about sexual abuse so that survivors can share their experiences, instead of being defined by some advertising company trying to use shock factor methods to raise supposed "awareness."
Kat — March 15, 2010
Sorry, can't agree at all here. Not one iota. But I'll tell you whether I got over it when I'm 70.
Bri — March 15, 2010
I'm rather confused as to the point of this ad. What's the target audience? As previously stated, those who are former victims are going to be offended/disgusted/triggered/etc... and the vast majority of "normal" (read: non-abuser) population will probably have some similar reaction. Am I really more likely to stop or report abuse than I was before? (Not really, since, as previously stated, this is one situation where the public majority are greatly offended/upset and are likely to report IF they are aware of the abuse.)
Is it directed at the potential/current abuser? I.e. don't touch her, you'll do harm? Again, what percentage of non-sociopathic abusers are unaware they are doing wrong?
I'd also agree that, as a former victim of childhood sexual abuse, the predominant tenet in our society is that one is "broken" forever after experiencing such abuse. I always struggle with this, as trying to explain that "no, I'm not permanently damaged" is taken as implied attack on those who DO suffer permanent, lasting trauma. And often met with resistance that I must, somehow, really be traumatized SO deeply that I'm in total denial, rather than capable of having a normal, healthy adult life (well, let's not get into who gets to define "normal".) I'm not trying to belittle the life experience of an incest survivor who will always struggle with hir past. I just wish I weren't belittled for my own experiences.
Ketchup — March 15, 2010
It's a McCann Erikson ad for Spain.
I thought the message they are trying to get across is: abuse is very destructive, so just don't ignore it, deny it, nor its life-long destructive consequences. It's not trivial. Take action. Thus the "Set the kids free from abuse and violence" second sentence.
I hate the hands over the child's body. Although they are physically "dead," and there is an artsy feeling to the whole setting of the photo, the hands are groping the child. It violates the child and it's making us watch it.
In general, what kind of people work in the big multinational advertising agencies? It's the same people who make the ads sexualizing children, sexually objectifying women, who normalize homosexuality, pornography, etc. It's surprising when they ever do anything ethical related to these issues. And then it's usually because of the client's demands.
Obviously in this case, the ad was approved by the organization who requested it.
Ketchup — March 15, 2010
Re the target audience, when I wrote, " Take action. Thus the “Set the kids free from abuse and violence”
I forgot to write that I think the ad is addressing people who may know someone is being abused or who suspects it. I don't think the ad was primarily directed at abusers or victims.
Ketchup — March 15, 2010
I also take issue with this idea that most people know sexual abuse is wrong and a horrible crime. What? Everything in this phrase "most people" and "know sexual abuse is wrong" is ignorant and naive. A person who tortures a child for years has a completely deformed psychological structure where there are a multitude of dynamics going on, telling the person all kinds of things about what they are doing. And even if, on some level, there may be one current of thought where the person tells themselves they are doing something wrong, there are multiple others which deny it or dismiss it, twist it around, distort it, etc.
This is not too different than people close to the abuser who may know or suspect that they are abusing or have abused someone. Any "knowledge" of that being wrong can and often gets washed out of their conscience quite easily when discomfort and anxiety levels start to rise.
And as for the majority of the rest of people, who is neither a direct perpetrator or aide to an abuser, I find society quite hypocritical. Sure, everybody loves to blabber how much they are against child abuse, but when you start examining either on an individual level, or on a political level what people do with their babbling, it's atrocious. Mostly nothing at best. As far as I know, the statistics of abuse victims has not changed, it's astronomical ( like one in three women, and one eight men). Even if this includes the entire range of types and degrees, it shows that prevention is a joke. Reparation as well.
Aion — March 16, 2010
“I can’t think of many people who think child abuse is okay. In fact, I think it is universally regarded as one of the worst crimes, maybe even the worst crime of all."
Yeah, and in the REAL WORLD there are many "wrongs", that society turns into justifiable and valid excuses based on socialization and power.
"Rape is wrong", but "can we say XYZ was really rape if she wanted it before she passed out"?
"Racism is wrong", if it can be proven, but usually it's not "really" racism, we must consider the "objective" party's opinion (the person with the power), as they have no motive to be biased. (Like, whaaaat?).
"Child abuse is wrong", but a good spanking is necessary if the child is "bad" and must be kept in line.
Child sexual abuse is wrong, but, what if the child has a "body?" What if it were an 8yr old black girl who "developed early"? what about if she was 12-17? What about if she was "easy", didn't have a father around and needed a father figure?
The list goes on and on. Even MURDER which is certainly universally declared evil has many many exceptions to the rule...What if they're terrorists? What if they threatened your family? What if it was a woman who got out of line?
Let's not get into the idea that "morality" and "wrong" don't have a lot to do with issues of power being played out and the value of the lives in question.
JoyfulAnn — March 16, 2010
"On the other hand, it says “If you have been sexually abused, you will be broken for the rest of your life.” This is the message that I find problematic. I know sexual abuse survivors who resent this message."
This resonates with me, as I know someone close to me who when he was a child, was sexually abused and raped on multiple occasions by an adult male neighbor. When he first told me this, I was shocked and appalled, and felt that surely my friend must be traumatized and have needed counseling. But my friend assured me that the incident didn't bother him anymore, that he held no lingering ill will towards the man, had never sought counseling, and hadn't come forward when the man was prosecuted for sexually assaulting other children.
I just couldn't believe it. How could he be ok after suffering such a traumatic event? Surely there was deviant behavior bound to surface from his repression and refusal to seek counseling! And yet, in all the time I've met my friend, he's given me no reason to think that he's not completely fine. He leads a completely normal life, is married and has a healthy relationship.
While I personally can't imagine how terrible it would be to go through the situation my friend (or any other sexual assault child victim) has gone through, it's not fair of me or anyone else to not let him have his right to move on. I'm not trying to belittle anyone else who has lingering problems after a sexual assault experience, but for the society at large to insist that what you experienced as a child will leave you irrevocably damaged and deviant, that's just unfair. If society at large presses the issue that sexual assault against a child is a terrible, awful, heinous, and reprehensible crime, somehow wouldn't that make the victims feel even worse, especially if they have to see ads like this reminding them how TERRIBLE the experience was and that they shouldn't be over it.
What I'm getting at is, does society's perception of the crime make the victim feel worse?
Leah — March 18, 2010
Though I agree and commend you for pointing out that abuse does not inherently mean a person is irreparably damaged, for the purposes of the ad it works and is, I think, reasonably appropriate.
I'm not sure who the exact target audience is, but I'm moved to agree with the poster above who said it is probably aimed at people who suspect or are aware of abuse but hesitant to report it, or something very similar (as opposed to being aimed at abusers). But your typical PSA strives to send a message to people that slaps them in the face, rather than going into great sociological detail about the wide range of possible psychological results and great chances for limited, if any, lasting effects. For all intensive purposes of this particular ad, I doubt it would be very efficient to write a message that states something along the lines of, 'many, many people will fully recover and will be able to live a very full, happy life, but sexual abuse is still bad, so... report it.'
If the ad were targeted toward victims, it would be more appropriate to say that full recovery is, yes, very possible and don't worry about being branded by others or yourself, because you don't need to be. But because the ad is saying a big, generic "NO" it makes more sense to send a dramatic message, especially if its intended audience suspects or knows about it but isn't reporting it, or whathaveyou.
Ducky — March 23, 2010
I'm new to this website so forgive me if I come off badly.
I really liked your message with this article. I was sexually abused as a child but my incidents really weren't that bad. I grew up feeling shame until I admitted to myself what had happened. That was all I needed. I'm okay now. I know I'm very lucky to have only been abused in a minor way and that it doesn't follow me around.
However, I don't want to tell anyone what happened because children who are sexually abused are automatically looked at as permanent victims by mainstream. Or maybe that's just my fear? I'm not a victim, I don't feel like a victim, I don't want to be looked at like a victim.
ckilgore — March 31, 2010
I don't assume the phrase "hang on forever" is the same as saying victims of abuse are permanently "damaged", but that the effects of child abuse are lifelong. While it is true that some victims of sexual abuse turn out to be happy, emotionally healthy adults, there is no doubt that the experience would have a lifelong effect. If you feel bad about not being traumatized enough, that is "hanging on forever", if someone is giving you "permission to fully recover from their experience", that is "hanging on forever".
Celena — April 15, 2010
Another thing to remember is that the damage done doesn't always manifest itself in extremes... sometimes we don't realize the effect it has on us... either because it doesn't interfere with our lives, or because we choose not to let it... but it doesn't mean harm wasn't done... and it doesn't mean we are not a little different than we may have otherwise been... for better or worse.
Felicia — May 4, 2010
My mother was sexually abused by her older brother, who tried to molest me and my 4 sisters too. Could her trauma from her own abuse subliminally cause me to marry a gay man? I was a virgin when I met him and he didn't want sex except orally on him. I thought he was just "waiting for our wedding night".
Let Go...Let Peace Come In — July 8, 2010
The Let Go...Let Peace Come In Foundation is a newly formed nonprofit with a mission to help heal and support adult survivors of childhood sexual abuse worldwide. We are actively seeking adult survivors who would be willing to post a childhood photo and caption, their story, or their creative expressions to our website www.letgoletpeacecomein.org. We need to "show" the world that we will no longer be silenced and that there are enough of us to make a difference. By uniting survivors from across the globe we can help provide a stronger and more powerful voice to those survivors who have not yet found the courage to speak out. Together we can; together we should; together we NEED to stand up and be counted. Please visit our site for more details on how you can send us your submissions.
Thank you for everything you do!
Gretchen Paules
Administrative Director
Let Go...Let Peace Come In Foundation
630 W. Germantown Pike, Suite 180
Plymouth Meeting, PA 19462
Nikki — January 8, 2011
Don’t sexually abuse children, because it is very serious and can affect a child for his or her whole life. Some says “If you have been sexually abused, you will be broken for the rest of your life”. And I disagree with it. If you have been sexually abused don’t feel that you’re unworthy to interact with peers, be strong because of what happened. Because of what happened you learn many things in life like, being brave and independent. If you were abused and it traumatized you and you need help, don’t be embarrassed, there are plenty of people behind you know will support you in that.
Jessica — July 10, 2011
I
co-facilitate a support group for Adult Survivors of Childhood abuse and
although there are lifelong effects, childhood abuse is not a life sentence. As
adults who were abused as children we are all survivors. Our group focuses on
going from survivor to striving to thrive.
In reading some of the other responses to this blog I am more certain
than ever that the culture of abuse needs to change, starting with every
survivor coming forward and taking back what was stolen so long ago. If we all stepped up and took responsibility
for stopping the cycle by sharing our experiences and our strengths maybe the
next generation will have a chance to heal faster, and the next to come forward
sooner, and the next to say enough! What
worries me most about this ad is not its message but the possible arousal of predators
who view it. We cannot stop childhood sexual abuse if we keep putting images of
children being victimized out in media. This message could have been conveyed
without victimizing another child even if it were a false, digitally created
image.
Cellardoormail — August 8, 2011
there are so many things wrong with this ad, i dont' even know where to begin. it's totally disgusting. Sensationalizing and marketing a survivor's trauma - re-writing someone else's story into one's own self-interested narrative. as you have already pointed out in some ways, such intense voyeurism about the sexual nature of child abuse is not helpful for anyone, least of all survivors. Saying this ad is child abuse preventative is sort of like claiming that the Saw series of movies have an anti-violence message.
MelissaJane — August 8, 2011
>Isn't this obsessive censoring a result of collective actions of people with a "normalize homosexuality" mentality?
Yes.
Moudou — August 8, 2011
I agree with your point, they could have solved it by saying "some things CAN hang on forever".
I do though have to wonder whether those who have gotten over it couldn't just be thankful for that and let it go rather than turning that into an issue.
It seems either they elect to feel bad or those despite much effort cannot, have to feel like they're failing.
Samrogo79 — August 8, 2011
EEven though I don't think the ad meant permanent brokeness, I'm glad to hear this point of view: that people can recover.
Will — August 8, 2011
Regardless of whether the survivor fully recovers or not (I consider myself fully recovered), it does "hang on." It is a salient part of the person's identity and something the survivor must be conscientious of their history in order to avoid repeating the cycle. The status as "survivor" is always there; it's the pain, guilt, and shame that diminish.
Marilyn — August 8, 2011
Sigh. Not all child abuse is the same so therefore the effect of that abuse will not be the same. Surely this factoid would be obvious?
Some victims are abused once, perhaps in a very insignificant manner while for others the abuse is constant, harsh, and lasts for years. Some victims are abused for the first time when they are two years old, others when they are twenty-two. Some abuse victims are abused by multiple perps, others only by one abuser. Some abuse victims are abused by a stranger while others are abused by someone who is expected to protect and care for them. Some abuse victims are tortured both mentally and physically, others not at all. Some abuse victims have a person in their life to act as a support, a role model for sound mental health even if that support person knows nothing about the abuse (or has tried to find help and can't). Other abuse victims exist in a situation where lots of people know about the abuse but do nothing except enable further abuse, as well as scapegoating and blaming the victim.
Treating all abuse as if ANY kind of abuse should magically result in the same amount of trauma and the same type of post-traumatic stress suffered by each victim, is just beyond stupid.
What I really resent, is the way "being called a bad name once" is somehow supposed to result in the exact same level of trauma as being locked in a basement for twenty years while being raped daily. It totally minimizes and invisibilzes the extreme nature of the latter type of abuse and demands that such survivors pretend that their insanity derives from the equivalent of a hangnail. THAT attitude from people who should know better, is yet a new trauma.
Marilyn — August 8, 2011
Sigh. Not all child abuse is the same so therefore the effect of that
abuse will not be the same. Surely this factoid would be obvious?
Some victims are abused once, perhaps in a very insignificant manner
while for others the abuse is constant, harsh, and lasts for years.
Some victims are abused for the first time when they are two years old,
others when they are twenty-two. Some abuse victims are abused by
multiple perps, others only by one abuser. Some abuse victims are
abused by a stranger while others are abused by someone who is expected
to protect and care for them. Some abuse victims are tortured both
mentally and physically, others not at all. Some abuse victims have a
person in their life to act as a support, a role model for sound mental
health even if that support person knows nothing about the abuse (or has
tried to find help and can't). Other abuse victims exist in a
situation where lots of people know about the abuse but do nothing
except enable further abuse, as well as scapegoating and blaming the
victim.
Treating all abuse as if ANY kind of abuse should magically result in
the same amount of trauma and the same type of post-traumatic stress
suffered by each victim, is just beyond stupid.
What I really resent, is the way these lessor types of abuse is
somehow supposed to result in the exact same level of trauma as being
locked in a basement for twenty years while being raped daily. It
totally minimizes and invisibilzes the extreme nature of the latter type
of abuse and demands that such survivors pretend that their insanity
derives from the equivalent of a hangnail. THAT attitude from people
who should know better, is yet a new trauma.
Katherine Elizabeth Lewis — August 8, 2011
Perhaps a more appropriate campaign would reflect on the fact that the biggest damage to children from sexual abuse (or any abuse) is the lack of a secure attachment with a loving caregiver who responds to, contains and helps makes sense of their child's pain.
There will always be broken people abusing others, but there could be a lot more loving ones out there who realise their role in a child's recovery. I'd rather see that message.
Jess Geez — August 8, 2011
Am I the only one who finds the half-naked child imagery disturbing?
Andrew — August 8, 2011
Interesting. I found out in high school that I had been abused while young (my memory of my childhood pre 3rd grade is very spotty). While I was shocked at first, since I had no memory of it, the more I thought about it, and the more I read (and even listening to Dr. Drew on LoveLine), the more I realized that everything in my life was affected by the event. And that certain things in my life were the way they were BECAUSE of the event.
I still do not remember it, but I do know it's affected me. I couldn't say that I'm "over it" or not, mostly because I was never really "not" over it, since I don't remember it. But I have found ways to deal with the effects of it.
Fake — August 8, 2011
I wanted to ask you to please reconsider how you promote your organization.
I had a VERY visceral negative reaction to this post (one that I did not have to your post below).
I suspect it was because of the premise that victims need to let go (and relive their abuse on your website), and particularly because it was directed at someone who said they have not gotten over their abuse.
I know your comment wasn't directed at me, but I felt compelled to speak out.
Michal — August 9, 2011
From my experience, and the unexpected places that it caught me and came up (as being much older in age than your students who maybe simply haven't yet encountered those unexpected places) I would say that a person who was abused as a child and thinks he has recovered, is pretty much like a drunk person who is convinced that alcohol has no effect on him.
Marie — August 9, 2011
Why are so many of the comments here from 1 year ago?
Mazouko — August 10, 2011
That ad looks like the Asphyxia monster from Silent Hill: Homecoming.
http://i.neoseeker.com/ca/silent_hill_5_conceptart_O3rXc.jpg
http://i.neoseeker.com/ca/silent_hill_5_conceptart_O3rXc.jpg
Dnickerson55 — December 3, 2011
it is up to interpretation. I believe that the image of the hands all over the child sends a message as to what sexual abuse survivors go through when being abused and the visual feelings they feel later on in life. The real issue should be that sexual abuse happens more than what is reported, it is mostly by people the child knows, and in turn our society still is oblivious to sexual abuse of a child. fact of the matter is that many do not or are not able to get effective help. its not that they cannot end up emotionally healthy adults but the process can be long and hard to which some never get to reach that. The ad simply puts a visual as to what many victims feel. like the ad or not this is what is happening to children, teenagers and some adults.
muhsingyu — February 1, 2015
I'd like to fuck child's pussy.
Joe Tan from Singapore — April 19, 2015
I was sexually abused as a child, and my finger is severed from my hand to date it is crippled. It hangs on forever, the advertisement is correct but you don't understand it at all, even though you are a professor.