In the last few hundred years, dark-skinned peoples have been likened to apes in an effort to dehumanize them and justify their oppression and exploitation. This is familiar to most Americans as something that is done peculiarly to Black people (as examples, see here, here, and here). The history of U.S. discrimination against the Irish, however, offers an interesting comparative data point. The Irish, too, have been compared to apes, suggesting that this comparison is a generalizable tactic of oppression, not one inspired by the color of the skin of Africans.
Irish woman, “Bridget McBruiser,” contrasted with Florence Nightengale:
(source)
A similar contrasting of the English woman (left) and the Irish woman (right):
(source)
Cartoon facing off “the British Lion” and “the Irish monkey”:
(source)
An Irishman, looking decidedly simian, in the left of this cartoon:
(source)
The Irish and the Black are compared as equally problematic to the North and the South respectively. Notice how both are drawn to look less human:
(source)
A depiction of an Irish riot (1867):
(source)
An Irishman, depicted as drunk, sits atop a powderkeg threatening to destroy the U.S.:
(source)
Two similar cartoons from the same source:
About this cartoon, Michael O’Malley at George Mason University writes:
In this cartoon, captioned “A King of -Shanty,” the comparison becomes explicit. The “Ashantee” were a well known African tribe; “shanty” was the Irish word for a shack or poor man’s house. The cartoon mocks Irish poverty, caricatures irish people as ape like and primitive, and suggests they are little different from Africans, who the cartoonists seems to see the same way. This cartroon irishman has, again, the outhrust mouth, sloping forehead, and flat wide nose of the standard Irish caricature.
(source)
So, there you have it. Being compared to apes is tactic of oppression totally unrelated to skin color — that is, it has nothing to do with Black people and everything to do with the effort to exert control and power.
For more on anti-Irish discrimination, see our post on Gingerism. And see our earlier post on anti-Irish caricaturein which we touched on this before.
Lisa Wade, PhD is an Associate Professor at Tulane University. She is the author of American Hookup, a book about college sexual culture; a textbook about gender; and a forthcoming introductory text: Terrible Magnificent Sociology. You can follow her on Twitter and Instagram.
Comments 226
jfruh — January 28, 2011
One thing I find interesting is the (possible?) connection between use of apes as a stand-in for "subhumans" and the theory of evolution. Do any of the cartoons here predate the publishing of the Origin of the Species in 1859? Despite the theory's controversy then and today, the idea that there might be a continuum between humans and apes (and that people or groups we don't like fall on the ape-ish end of the scale) seems to have been taken up with gusto fairly quickly. (Please note that I'm well aware that evolutionary theory says no such thing about different human groups; I'm just talking about the pseudoscientific bases of racism.)
Meg — January 28, 2011
Huh, I hadn't put that together before, but leprechauns are usually drawn just like that.
I know that occassionally in minstrel shows there were Irish acts, which were performed in the same black face. They fell out of favor earlier than those mocking Blacks, though, and were never as prevalent in the first place. As with other minstrel shows, dressing up in "Irish" mask was a way for privileged people, especially young people, to have an excuse to behave badly without social censure.
Hmm, just like St. Patrick's day today....
T — January 28, 2011
When it comes to the American immigrant narrative, the ebb and flow of which groups were considered acceptable and the 'hierarchy' is fascinating to me. In the early part of the last century, my own grandfather came to America via Ellis Island from Lithuania. Even though he couldn't speak a word of English, he chose to modify his family name to "sound Irish." He learned on the boat that the Irish were getting jobs and the "Russians" weren't. BUT because he couldn't speak the language, he could pull of the pretense of being English or even German. The Irish were a group that was "high" enough that he could get a job, but "low" enough that he could get away with pretending to be Irish -- i.e., the men hiring the Irish weren't exactly interested in chatting with them over tea.
Molly W. — January 28, 2011
Those interested in how the racial identification of the Irish changed might want to read "How the Irish Became White," by Noel Ignatiev.
Leigh — January 28, 2011
I think Sander Gilman said something along the lines that the short, upturned "Irish" nose was lumped in with the characteristics of the syphilitic nose during this time period. (Later in the 1960's it (the ski jump) would become very popular.)
Laughingrat — January 28, 2011
This is a very cool article, and it's illuminating to see how pervasive it was to mock Irish people by comparing them with other apes. That said, it's also pretty disingenuous of you to claim that the comparison of black persons with apes has nothing to do with their skin color or continent of origin. That particular trope has gone on too long, and too aggressively, for your statement to be really believable.
LdeG — January 28, 2011
“[April 1748] Monday 4th. This morning Mr. Fairfax left us with Intent to go down to the Mouth of the Branch. We did two Lots & was attended by a great Company of People Men Women & Children that attended us through the Woods as we went shewing there Antick tricks. I really think they seem to be as Ignorant a Set of People as the Indians. They would never speak English but when spoken to they speak all Dutch.”
George Washington on the German settlers on the Allegheny frontier - the ones who gave us the log cabin, the covered wagon, and the Pennsylvania long rifle, icons of the American pioneer spirit.
Theora23 — January 28, 2011
So, there you have it. Being compared to apes is tactic of oppression totally unrelated to skin color — that is, it has nothing to do with Black people and everything to do with the effort to exert control and power.
What an oddly triumphant tone. Is this part of that larger argument that since some Irish were once oppressed and in some cases enslaved, there's no such thing as racism because it's all really just class-ism?
Frowner — January 28, 2011
So, there you have it. Being compared to apes is tactic of oppression totally unrelated to skin color — that is, it has nothing to do with Black people and everything to do with the effort to exert control and power.
The British were heavily involved in the slave trade. Slavery wasn't abolished on most British colonies until 1833/1834. As far as I can tell, all these cartoons post-date the various pro-slavery cartoons in the UK press (late 18th century) which use this comparison. It would astonish me if there were no interdependence between the description of the Irish and the description of Africans/Afro-british people/slaves--if the comparison to apes were sui generis and not rooted in the colonization of Africa and the slave trade.
In other ways, in fact, Africans, slaves and Afro-British people were sometimes equated with white Britons. All men in the UK--particularly working class men--were subject to the press-gang and could be seized and impressed into the (violent, death-ridden) navy regardless of age or condition. In <a href="http://www.amazon.com/Bury-Chains-Prophets-Rebels-Empires/dp/0618104690MBury The Chains, Adam Hochschild argues that the experience of press-ganging gave traction to the abolition movement in the UK, because there were some parallels between the experience of slavery and the experience of the pressed men.
Especially when I look at the "Shanty" cartoon above, it seems more plausible to me that the comparison of Irish people to apes is intended to recall the comparison of Africans and Afro-British people to apes, and thus to use the more-accepted oppression of one people to justify the oppression of another.
I'm not even sure how this could be unpicked--are there a wealth of comparisons of Irish people to apes which predate African slavery? I'm also confused about why it's helpful to show that this rhetorical tactic is independent of race. Surely slavery, racism and colonialism are so deeply entwined that they create and reinforce each other?
azizi — January 28, 2011
The Irish, too, have been compared to apes, suggesting that this comparison is a generalizable tactic of oppression, not one inspired by the color of the skin of Africans.
-Lisa Wade
I'm cosigning Frowner question "are there a wealth of comparisons of Irish people to apes which predate African slavery?"
However, I would slightly rephrase that commenter's next sentence to read "I’m also confused about why it’s helpful to show that this rhetorical tactic is sometimes directly independent of race."
I'd then cosign Frowner's next sentence "Surely slavery, racism and colonialism are so deeply entwined that they create and reinforce each other?"
end of quote
If this negative imagery of comparing people to apes and monkeys was first used to represent Black people, and then used for the Irish (who were then not considered to be White), then that imagery was still connected to race.
Umlud — January 28, 2011
What is interesting to me is that a lot of the caricatures of the Irish presented above seem to be the inspiration of the design of the goblins and orcs of the British tabletop wargame, Warhammer... Perhaps, there was something that was evoked during the initial character designs several decades ago...
(Of course, the Warhammer goblins and orcs have fangs/tusks and are generally painted as green.)
Lola — January 28, 2011
Being Irish and damn proud of it (boy did we beat that rap!), I recall my mother telling me that "they" used to say, "An Irish person is just an [insert defamatory nickname for black people here] turned inside out."
But we could always hide our "irish-ness" if need be.
contrabalance — January 28, 2011
Congratulations on your first interesting post, Lisa!
LdeG — January 28, 2011
It is indeed complicated, and needs to be looked at in cultural and historical perspective. In the 17th century, the Spanish speculated as to whether American natives were apes or closely related, and as late as 1700 there was serious discussion from the other direction, complete with dissection and point-by-point comparisons of anatomy, of whether orangutans were human.
There was very much discussion through the 18th century about the continuum from apes to human, and continued throughout the 19th century as the idea of various groups of humans being at different places on that continuum.
On top of that was an old tradition of mocking various groups of others as animals of one sort or another, including Englishmen referring to Frenchmen as apes, for example.
Yes, "slavery, racism and colonialism are so deeply entwined that they create and reinforce each other" but there is a much larger picture. And it is not necessarily limited to how Europeans saw other groups of people, although that has had the largest impact on the modern world. Many tribal cultures' names for themselves mean "The People" with the implication that other groups aren't really people.
KarenM — January 28, 2011
I think it's called Siminanisation. It goes back to the era of 'discovery' and was a way of effectively dehumanising 'natives' i.e. anyone the English and other aristocrats wanted to colonise. Not saying the experience of colonisation was totally alike for Ireland and Africa, but there were certain parallels. Ostensibly colonists could claim the moral high ground and say they were civilising the savages, when really they were claiming/stealing land and resources.
Interesting aside - most of the Irish men in these images are dressed in tops and tails etc. As impoverished (often landless) labourers they would have recieved hand me downs from aristocrats (their landlords) as a form of charity. Notice how well dressed and groomed the English are beside them. In contrast, the Irish have wild hair and wrinkled/ill-fitting clothes. In posture too, the English are civilised, the Irish animalistic, possibly drunk. The message is that these animals don't know their place, they don't know they ought to be grateful for being allowed their (suitably lower) place in civilised society. It's classicm, combined with racism.
Comparing people to monkeys isn't limited to blacks and irish though. Similar imagery was used to depict the Germans before and during the first world war (think; the destroy this mad brute poster). It's a form of otherising.
Just before I finish, white Americans aren't immune to being compared to chimps either; http://0.tqn.com/d/politicalhumor/1/0/K/1/bush_chimps2.jpg
Makenzie — January 28, 2011
Check out the postures on the two women in the second image. The scene that's playing out puts one of them bending over slightly with her hands clasped together, and the other with her feet spread apart, one hand on her hip, and one arm raised in a threatening manner. The Irish woman also isn't wearing "dainty" shoes, and she has muscles and is just generally larger. Guess which one we're meant to like?
Man, there's so much going on in that picture.
John Hensley — January 30, 2011
"Journal of Civilization"
Chestnut Chicks = Pigs, Trolls, and Apes? « The Dumpling Cart — January 31, 2011
[...] then, via Sociological Images, I see this via a discussion of the ways in which Irish were portrayed by the [...]
Emily Catherine Dot Com | — March 6, 2011
[...] be the group we accept tomorrow. Irish immigrants used to be compared with apes instead of humans (here is a great collection of political cartoons that make the comparison), but now they’re just regular old white people. Today, we talk about our country’s [...]
Paddy — April 14, 2011
Ohhhhhh. These people don't know about Irish Catholic Slavery in America yet??
Well by all means - TELL THEM about it. A little research into it would do a world of good for the subject - of course it might be racially unifying, so maybe some wouldn't support your effort. >o)
They were NOT just indentured servants or immigrants.
With the LARGEST denomination in America & 2nd largest nationality - one would think people would know more about the Irish Catholic American. Just don't piss us off too much with your folly. You'll find some of the cartoons might be a matter of fact. What a riot! LOL
Another racist TEA Birther! - Page 7 - Christian Forums — April 20, 2011
[...] "Irish Apes" well, the go-to caricature for the Irish was quite simian for a long time. Here's a page with some examples, including one that explicitly puts up an "Irish monkey." As [...]
Magically Delicious! | Food and Visual Media — September 28, 2011
[...] historically the stereotyping of the Irish was just as ugly as, and was bizarrely similar to, the visual stereotyping of African-Americans in the late 1800s and early 1900s. Characterized as apes, as sub-human, as [...]
Fionnuala — January 12, 2012
"I am daunted by the human chimpanzees I saw along that hundred miles of horrible country. I don't believe they are our fault. I believe that there are not only many more of them than of old, but that they are happier, better and more comfortably fed and lodged under our rule than they ever were. But to see white chimpanzees is dreadful; if they were black, one would not feel it so much, but their skins, except where tanned by exposure, are as white as ours." Historian Charles Kingsley on visiting Ireland during the great famine, taken from intro to How the Irish saved civilisation by Thomas Cahill.
Aren’t we all just members of the human race? | Erin V Echols — February 27, 2012
[...] across time as evidenced by changes in census categories and the movement of certain groups, who once experienced discrimination, into the white racial [...]
Anonymous — March 17, 2012
Si where's the English James Joyce, Samuel Beckett, WB Yeats, Oscar Wilde, GB Shaw?
US American Irish Stereotypes | I blame it on cultural capital — April 7, 2012
[...] How can you use pictures and drawings for political propaganda? Well, how about portraying your opponents (or a group you want to oppress) as monkey-like creatures behaving irrationally and being unruly? The website Sociological Images has a fascinating collection of anti-Irish propaganda pictures, mostly from the 19th century. If you find contemporary cases of racial stereotyping crass, how about this? Find it here. [...]
MJArmstrong — November 16, 2012
It's quite an overstatement to conclude "Being compared to apes is tactic of oppression totally unrelated to skin
color — that is, it has nothing to do with Black people and everything
to do with the effort to exert control and power."
The Irish were not seen as "white people" at the time, and the use of simian imagery against Blacks continued long after the it was no longer used against Blacks.
Dr. GS Hurd — January 25, 2013
Excellent analysis
Star Trek: Deep Space Nine – Captive Pursuit (Review) | the m0vie blog — September 5, 2013
[...] a rigid class system that would probably be offensive to O’Brien’s cultural identity. Given the historical portrayal in British cultural of the Irish as inherently sub-human, O’Brien’s response to Tosk’s plight feels in some way driven by his own [...]
Redheads = Pigs, Trolls, and Apes? | The Dumpling Cart — January 6, 2014
[…] find anything else. So I set it all aside, figuring that I was over-reacting. But then today, via Sociological Images, I see this cartoon in the context of a discussion of the ways in which Irish were portrayed by the […]
That Line in Human Nature « Professor Norton's Class Space — February 11, 2014
[…] http://thesocietypages.org/socimages/2011/01/28/irish-apes-tactics-of-de-humanization/ […]
IRISH | Life Is Color — March 17, 2014
[…] IRISH APES: TACTICS OF DE-HUMANIZATION (thesocietypages.org) […]
Representation and “Irish Apes”: Tactics of De-Humanization | Society Pages | ΡΟ Π ΤΡ Ο Ν — March 17, 2014
[…] Irish Apes: Tactics of De-Humanization. […]
Culturally Inappropriate Team Names and Mascots: What about Notre Dame? | seandalai — April 8, 2014
[…] Irish Catholics and those unwilling to assimilate is clear in his and many other cartoonist’s portrayals of them as apes, slovenly, drunken, lazy, brawling brutes. […]
"Banana Envy": Notes on a Global Obsession « Americas Studies Americas Studies — May 2, 2014
[…] Source […]
Herb Suhl — July 14, 2014
You guys screwed up. You never should have let us in.
Christian Wright — March 10, 2015
The parallels with this and the Scottish experience pre and post indref are chilling. It seems history is repeating itself.
http://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/picture/2015/mar/09/steve-bells-if-
Opinion: Disheartening stereotypes cloud great Irish history | Montreal Gazette — March 20, 2015
[…] lowest-paid jobs and earned the derogatory labels that come with doing them. At worst, they were considered sub-human; at best, alcoholic and […]
why is Europe the only place that gets criticized for its immigration policies - Historum - History Forums — January 9, 2016
[…] In the article linked above, Alan J. Levine also points out that historically racism was used first and foremost against Europeans. For example (apart from well-known Anti-Ashkenazi racism and Anti-Slavic racism): Irish Apes: Tactics of De-Humanization - Sociological Images […]
Ireland 1916 1: Towards the Easter Rising | First World War Hidden History — January 27, 2016
[…] [5] Carroll Quigley, The Anglo-American Establishment, p. 32. [6] Gollin, Proconsul, p. 179. [7] http://thesocietypages.org/socimages/2011/01/28/irish-apes-tactics-of-de-humanization/ [8] Micheal Foy and Brian Barton, The Easter Rising, p. 2. [9] A J P Taylor, Essays in English […]
Blake Dim Mak Fitzgerald — September 9, 2016
Can anyone confirm or deny that this was used on the Irish peoples first?
Dfabos@mail.com — November 8, 2016
poem vocabulary quantity
Ooyster.com - hidden pearls of alternative news! — January 1, 2017
[…] white Irish immigrants were also compared to apes and baboons in political cartoons of the period, as you can see here. So while this kind of treatment isn’t right no matter which ethnic group is targeted, you should […]
Same cereal company that doesn’t want GMOs listed on the label also doesn’t want positive ID required for voters | News Flash U.S. — January 7, 2017
[…] white Irish immigrants were also compared to apes and baboons in political cartoons of the period, as you can see here. So while this kind of treatment isn’t right no matter which ethnic group is targeted, you […]
Paddy Works on the Blog Post | Jeffrey K. Walker — March 15, 2017
[…] Not Exactly White. (And if you think the English had a better opinion, check out the standard apelike depictions of the Irish in the cartoons of London magazines in that […]
Sebastian@reallyracist.com — July 7, 2017
Ohhh it has everything to do with black people, when is the last time you have seen the Irish or any other European white depicted as an ape, Whilst the Irish were originally sharing some oppression, it is quitwe a different story in modern day White Nationalism. Hence most White nationalist and white supremacists group will accept membership, including the KKK, from the Irish
davidfabos — August 8, 2017
Pseudoscience cant think. yes, on online wikapedia
The Cost of Addiction to U.K. Society — August 18, 2017
[…] group (rich, white men again I’m afraid). Historically the press has dehumanised black people, the Irish, women; more recently it has turned its freezing gaze on immigrants and single […]
The Past That Forever Haunts Us – Global Modernisms in a Digital Age — September 17, 2017
[…] 2: A political cartoon illustrating the “Irish Monkey” and the “British Lion” facing off, which represents both […]
flassbeck economics international - Economics and politics - comment and analysis — January 12, 2018
[…] even considered fully human. Nineteenth Century drawings depict them as Quasimodo-like simians (see here). The question of their true ‘complexion’ arose when the Irish – for the most part extremely […]
David Fabos — June 11, 2018
Medicine smell nothing. Everything again. Still real.
Jonathan Christophers — September 2, 2018
Irish DNA is nearly identical to English. They are so identical that there is more genetic distance between the English and Danes than there is between the Irish and English. You couldn't even organize a random group of Irish and English into their respective ethnic classes by looking at them.
Thomas Nast was the only one publishing political cartoons during the period in question. We know this because he's the "father of political cartoons" and before him they didn't exist. Nast was brought up a German Catholic and for some reason couldn't recall any other parts of his childhood except for when he was getting bullied by Irish kids. He converted to Protestantism later in life and dedicated is sterling career as a cartoonist to living out his revenge fantasy. He depicted the Irish that way because, as a victim of constant bullying, an ape was just the right kind of brute he saw them for. It wasn't uncommon for him to depict others as apes, though, and it wasn't done for the reasons you'd suspect. Nast depicted Lincoln as an ape in one of his cartoons.
Catholic immigrants faced hostility in the mid-19th Century: this no one disputes. But what is conveniently ignored in these "anti-Irish" histories is the fact that the most stridently anti-"Irish" (more like anti-Catholic) in the US at the time were none other than the Irish Protestants. They played a big role in the Know-Nothing movement and participated in violent riots that nearly burned down entire sections of cities. Their descendants also happen to be the largest component of the Irish diaspora in America these days.
The attempts to exaggerate Irish-American history are not without consequences. First, the contributions of countless Irish Protestants in the early days of the republic are completely ignored. Second, by the late antebellum, no less than 300,000 enslaved African Americans were owned by Southerners of Irish descent. There are millions of black descendants of these slaves who now walk around with Irish names because their ancestors were once owned by these pseudo-victims.
And if you want to talk about prejudice, the most persistent and reoccurring theme of out-group prejudice in American history (other than the obvious enslavement of black Africans) was, in actual fact, Anglophobia, which continued to occur as late as the second world war. In this respect, the Irish had found a home in this country, whether they were fighting the British during the Revolution (more than half of Washington's army was from or had roots in Ulster), or boycotting British exports. There was one tiny blip of time when famine refugees faced hostility from nativist groups that were populated in large part by Irish Protestants, and that was it.
So why all the obsession for this little blip of Irish-American history? I think we all know the answer to that. The pseudo-historians that are promoting this new brand of fake-victimization are almost entirely far-left political activists who are trying to call the concept of race into question. Occasionally you will see a right-wing activist using the same Irish-American myths to make a supremacist argument.
Edward ODonnell — April 15, 2019
Jonathan Christophers is missing a key point. The negative virws described about the Irish are actually about the old order Irish/ Irish Catholics with names beginning usually with O' or Mc...those who the English tried to exterminate...not the plantation "Irish" of protestant Scotland and England with names like Porter or Cunningham, or Adams or any of the other names of the majority of those newer invading Ulstermen. Do your research.
Angle Stop — June 19, 2019
In this piece, I describe the experience of an Arab woman living in Israel who became "the subject of the apartheid state":
I was born at Rosh HaShanah. It was Jewish holiday season, so I spent most of my childhood with my family. My father, who works in a clothing factory, and his sister lived with their parents in a makeshift camp next door to their hometown, Kiryat Gat. There were a few other families living here as well. My father and I were raised surrounded by people who looked like our family. People called me Kike, Tzach and Shush. I'd never been much interested in Jewish holidays before I was born, other than enjoying them and knowing that I was a Kike—like, kind of like a member of the kadom—a type of Jew. "I never want to miss an Arab day!" one mother told me during our childhood. When I was seven, I decided to go back home to Tzach, who would continue to live with his mother until he turned fourteen; he's fifteen now. I wasn't going to miss any Arab days at all.
Sir David Fabos — August 20, 2019
0 racis is question everyone do with or for once feel like doctor?
Sir David Fabos — August 20, 2019
Then 0 racis not personality why have that study and no drugs real
Angelina Gudeeva — March 12, 2020
I joined this site last week, and I have to say that this is the best, great offer to join, great bonuses, and I won my first deposit! Large selection of games and bingo, definitely recommend for sure play video slots for free online https://www.baocasino.com/games/popular
Best Bao casino!
Angelina Gudeeva — March 12, 2020
Собаки
Joe — June 30, 2020
Very interesting article - though I think the finisher is unfortunate :
"So, there you have it. Being compared to apes is tactic of oppression totally unrelated to skin color — that is, it has nothing to do with Black people and everything to do with the effort to exert control and power."
It is much more prevalent for black people, so it's important not to undermine that fact.
Christopher Fogarty — July 10, 2020
Read the great book; Nothing But the Same Old Story, by Liz Curtis.
Joe — December 16, 2020
Another take on this is how, in the 19th Century, members of the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter Day Saints were portrayed as less than white, and as destroying the white race with polygamy and interracial marriage (including to Irish, Black, Native American) etc.
One article discussing this is found on FAIRMormon: "W. Paul Reeve: From Not White Enough to Too White: Rethinking the Mormon Racial Story."
Joe — December 16, 2020
https://www.fairmormon.org/conference/august-2015/rethinking-the-mormon-racial-story
Here are a couple of excerpts from the article showing how anti-mormonsim has turned full circle:
"So you have a black mammy in Brigham Young’s family. You also have another black wife, a couple of black children. And then, even if you look at this other wife – if any of you are familiar with the ways in which Irish immigrants are racialized in the 19th century – the suggestion was that they were more ape-like or simian than they were white. That same kind of accusation is then being projected onto the Mormons in this political cartoon. If you look at the facial angle of several of the children and this particular wife, the suggestion is that polygamy is giving rise to a degraded race, and you have Brigham Young’s interracial family here as “evidence” of this."
"The New York World published an editorial in 1865. Remember this is the end of the Civil War. Four million blacks have been freed in the South. And the New York World is fearful, then, that because, it argues, black people are racially prone to superstition and racially highly sexed, they make the prime candidates for mass conversion to Mormonism. And they will convert en masse to Mormonism and then American democracy will be at stake because you’ll have Mormons in the Intermountain West combining with these newly freed blacks who have converted to Mormonism and they will control presidential politics in the United States."
Of course now, although Church members are predominantly non-white, media portrays them as too white...politics, gotta love it : )
"Then in 2012 Lee Siegel publishes an editorial in the New York Times calling Mitt Romney “the whitest white man to run for president in recent memory.”
Ranking the best logos in Boston Celtics history - CelticsHub — April 15, 2021
[…] the United States for decades. This included tremendously dehumanizing imagery, cartoons, and other bits of symbolism that painted the Irish as sub-human, pugnacious, and […]
Anonymous — June 13, 2021
I find his so called ,Cartoons.hateful.
I don’t see many people ,just flat out calling it
Out for what it is.
A disgrace.pure and simple.
That’s al it is.
Eamonn Mac Uí Táiliúir — June 20, 2021
Have a listen
https://youtu.be/bCafNgZIgW4
https://youtu.be/T_hK_lbOHD4
Mark Deegan — July 25, 2021
Of course, as the apes are our pre human ancestors. Before we evolved to Homo Sapiens.
Irish in America — Jeffrey K. Walker — October 28, 2021
[…] Not Exactly White. (And if you think the English had a better opinion, check out the standard apelike depictions of the Irish in the cartoons of London magazines in that […]
Irish in America — Jeffrey K. Walker — October 28, 2021
[…] literally considered Not Exactly White. (The English had no better opinion. Check out the standard apelike depictions of the Irish in cartoons from London magazines of that […]
aricjoshua — January 23, 2022
Aside: the most of the Irish men in these photographs are dressed in tops and tails, etc. They would have received hand-me-downs from nobles (their landlords) as a kind of charity as destitute (often landless) laborers. Take note of how well-dressed and groomed the English are in comparison. The Irish, on the other hand, have wild hair and garments that are wrinkled or ill-fitting. The English are civilized in their stance cookie clicker, whilst the Irish are animalistic and maybe intoxicated. The implication is that these creatures have no idea where they belong, and that they should be grateful for being permitted to take their (appropriately inferior) position in civilisation. It's a mix of classicism and racism.
ทางเข้าเล่น pragmaticplay — June 22, 2022
Thanks for your valuable information. Keep posting.
ทางเข้าเล่น pragmaticplay
ลิงค์รับทรัพย์ 123bet — July 12, 2022
I think this is a really good article. You make this information interesting and engaging. You give readers a lot to think about.
ลิงค์รับทรัพย์ 123bet
Allison Sola — September 30, 2022
I was assigned "How the Irish Became White" in grad school. There is much geopolitical history regarding British domination and the general ethos of the "White Man's Burden." This cultural and racial elitism really was economics and power. Reading the comments, it struck me to connect the tyranny the English caused the Irish much prior to the slave trade. There is a true connection here of justification to subjugate a portion of a population. Do "white Americans" now justify subconscious racism by some sort of elitism, collective guilt, or plain lack of self-confidence? It's nuanced.
James F. Harrington — October 29, 2022
Back in my working days for New England Telephone Company, I met an elderly Irish woman who recalled when she was young the time she and her friends were walking past Paines Furniture store in Boston when they came across a sign in the window that read: HELP WANTED - NO IRISH NEED APPLY
As it was winter and there was frost on the windows, they wrote the following words with their fingers on the glass next to this sign: IN HELL.
James F. Harrington — October 29, 2022
There used to be signs posted on the Boston Common that read: NO IRISH OR DOGS ON THE GRASS.
James F. Harrington — October 29, 2022
While working for the telephone company in the Charlestown section of Boston, I was in the basement of an old house. I noticed that someone had placed pages of a very old Boston newspaper on the top of some shelves.
I went over and read a little from the first page.
There was the following description: John Kelly, that Irish bastard, etc., etc. (he had committed some crime).
dream gaming — November 7, 2022
I will keep up to date with news from you. dream gaming
OMHBG — November 15, 2022
While working for the telephone company in the Charlestown section of Boston, I was in the basement of an old house. Healing Prayers I noticed that someone had placed pages of a very old Boston newspaper on the top of some shelves.
John Shostack — February 7, 2023
Perhaps if American students were taught about the bigotry experienced by many different nationalities over our history it would create solidarity and understanding among people, as opposed to saying that all whites are guilty in the same way for the treatment of blacks in this country. Maybe this history would create more compassion for all people /groups who have and continue to suffer from the effects of bigotry.
John Shostack — February 7, 2023
Perhaps if American students were taught about the bigotry experienced by many different nationalities over our history it would create solidarity and understanding among people, as opposed to saying that all whites are guilty in the same way for the treatment of blacks in this country. Maybe this history would create more compassion for all people /groups who have and continue to suffer from the effects of bigotry.
สล็อตคลิปโต — February 16, 2023
I know you better than this through your article. I really like your article, everything, from start to finish, I read them all. สล็อตคลิปโต
sdfas — April 19, 2023
Fantastic blog. Reading your articles was enjoyable. For me, this was a really enjoyable book. I have it bookmarked and am eager to read more things from it. Continue your wonderful effort! quordle
โปรโมชั่น sa gaming — May 12, 2023
This is a really interesting article. Every topic has changed my mind to be more open-minded. More and more new knowledge โปรโมชั่น sa gaming
SMM Panel One — July 16, 2023
Genuine SMM offers trustworthy and effective social media marketing solutions that prioritize authenticity and real engagement. Our dedicated team of experts helps businesses and individuals grow their online presence by implementing genuine strategies tailored to their unique needs. With Genuine SMM, you can expect organic growth, increased followers, and improved brand visibility in the competitive social media landscape. Trust us to provide authentic and impactful social media marketing services that drive meaningful results and connect you with your target audience in a genuine and meaningful way.
Charli — August 15, 2023
It's amazing to have the chance to visit a place like that, and I'm happy to know about it. We appreciate you giving us this chance, and we will try to make the most of it. Furniture in Karachi
media feathers — August 15, 2023
It was kind to me and a big assistance to me. Like you, I wish to return the favor by assisting those in need. digital marketing agency in Pakistan
Asad Umer — August 21, 2023
This is a great opportunity to visit such a site and I’m glad to know about it. Thank you for giving us the opportunity to take advantage of this opportunity Smart watch price in Pakistan
Rainbow water — September 11, 2023
I found the post to be highly good. The shared information are greatly appreciated
Limo in UAE — September 12, 2023
I found the post to be highly good. The shared information are greatly appreciated
SMM Panel — September 13, 2023
If you're seeking a reliable source for Free Instagram Likes, SMMPanel2 is your destination. Their services are designed to help individuals and businesses of all sizes enhance their Instagram presence, free of charge.
Fakaza — September 18, 2023
By far i would give credit to this wonderful article which is of gold and more useful to today on Fakaza criteria in the kitchen model
Fakaza Latest Song — September 18, 2023
Fakaza is the biggest and most visited wwebsite to get all South Africa music downloaded, it has all genre and music types relating to your taste and choice of Artiste you wish to listen to Fakaza
Neroli — October 2, 2023
OUAHADA TUNISIE S.A.R. L is specialized in the production of natural essential oils of Tunisian origin.
OKTOPUS — October 2, 2023
Digital Marketing is a future of a marketing
Udyam registration — October 4, 2023
Apply for udyam registration in an easy and hassle-free manner with the best consultancy by our experts We have a team of experts for registering your business under MSMEs. We provide services like udyam registration,udyam re-registration, print udyam registration certificate, etc.
Private instagram viewer — October 16, 2023
I Really enjoyable to read this article.It was a pleasure to read your useful content.you know how to view Instagram's private profiles? If you don't know, then don't worry. you can view private Instagram profiles using ther Private Instagram Viewer tool. More information about this tool is provided in the article. Visit the article and share it with your friends.
Gospel Songs — October 22, 2023
Get the latest music on Gospel Songs
Gospel songs — October 22, 2023
grETA
Ohale — October 22, 2023
Angola Gospel Songs
Fakaza — October 22, 2023
Amapiano Songs
Fakaza Songs — October 22, 2023
South Africa Latest Songs
Fakaza — October 22, 2023
Play and Stream the latest songs on Fakaza
Ohale — October 22, 2023
Get the latest music on Latest Mosambik Songs
Fakaza Latest Songs — October 22, 2023
Amapiano Latest Songs
Amapiano Songs — October 22, 2023
Amapiano
Muhammad Umer — October 25, 2023
This mosque has recently implemented a state-of-the-art Donation Kiosk, which has proven to be an effective means of collecting donations for various charitable causes. Mosque Donation kiosk
Muhammad Umer — October 25, 2023
I would like to recommend this pakistani boutique near me the stylish, high-quality clothing which you grown in any event and looks special! Must Visit Now and check all of the collections.
Muhammad Umer — October 31, 2023
This is a great opportunity to visit such a site and I’m glad to know about it. Thank you for giving us the opportunity to take advantage of this opportunity furniture in Pakistan
Şile Prefabrik — November 2, 2023
Bu blog yazısı, konuyla ilgili önemli bilgiler içeriyor ve okuyuculara faydalı oluyor. Yazarın araştırmasını ve deneyimlerini paylaşmasını takdir ediyorum. Yazıyı okuduktan sonra, konu hakkında daha fazla bilgi edindim ve uygulamaya geçmek için ipuçları aldım. Teşekkürler! Şile Prefabrik
Çorlu Web — November 2, 2023
This blog post contains important information about the topic and is useful for readers. I appreciate the author’s research and sharing. You can share your opinions by leaving a comment under the blog post.
треба меблі — November 20, 2023
Мебель Эверест — это сочетание элегантного дизайна и функциональности. Она предлагает широкий выбор стильных и практичных решений для каждого помещения. Будь то стильные шкафы, удобные тумбы или изысканные пуфы, мебель "Эверест" поможет создать уют и гармонию в вашем доме, подчеркнув вашу индивидуальность и вкус.
https://treba-mebli.com.ua/ru/everest-ru
треба меблі — November 21, 2023
Тумбы для обуви Эверест – это эстетика и порядок в вашем пространстве. Сочетая в себе стильный дизайн и функциональность, они обеспечивают удобное хранение обуви, сохраняя порядок в прихожей или специально выделенном месте. Разнообразие моделей и отделок позволяет подобрать тумбу "Эверест" по вашим потребностям, дополняя интерьер и облегчая его организацию.
https://moveme.berkeley.edu/project/standwithhongkong/#comment-258466
Треба Меблі — November 21, 2023
Тумбы для обуви Эверест – это эстетика и порядок в вашем пространстве. Сочетая в себе стильный дизайн и функциональность, они обеспечивают удобное хранение обуви, сохраняя порядок в прихожей или специально выделенном месте. Разнообразие моделей и отделок позволяет подобрать тумбу "Эверест" по вашим потребностям, дополняя интерьер и облегчая его организацию.
Fakaza — November 28, 2023
Разнообразие моделей и отделок позволяет подобрать тумбу "Эверест" по вашим потребностям, дополняя интерьер и облегчая его организацию.
Vaotas — November 28, 2023
Welcome to VAOTAS.COM, your one-stop destination for good and amazing music! At VAOTAS, We are more than just a website; we are a community of passionate music enthusiasts, eager to share our love for melodies, lyrics, and the magic and memories that good music brings into our lives. Billboard top 100
Afronewsng — November 28, 2023
Our team of experienced writers and editors work tirelessly to bring you the latest news, analysis, and insights on everything from politics, business to sports and entertainment. Naija News
лора — November 29, 2023
У нашому магазині пармашоп ви знайдете найновітніші тренди спортивного одягу та аксесуарів, що дозволять вам виразити свій стиль і забезпечити комфорт під час активних тренувань та повсякденного життя.
мебель эверест — November 29, 2023
мебель эверест мебель найкращого качества в Украине! Заходим разгребаем как пирожки!
белтимор — November 29, 2023
Отличный сайт для покупок для дома!
Baltimor
мебель — December 4, 2023
Прихожие эверест — это место, где встречается мир горной красоты и практичности. Здесь каждый предмет имеет своё назначение, будь то удобная полка для обуви или вешалка для верхней одежды, но при этом в каждой детали просматривается уважение к природе и её величию. Яркие оттенки и натуральные материалы создают атмосферу, в которой легко встретить рассвет перед новыми вершинами дня.
udyam certificate — December 6, 2023
Your article is quite useful. Thank you for sharing it. If you're looking for an udyam registration site, please visit our udyam portal. and by following a few simple procedures, you can get your udyam certificate.
мебель — January 20, 2024
Ортопедичні матраци - це ключ до здорового сну і відновлення енергії для вашого тіла. Вони розроблені з урахуванням анатомії людського тіла, надаючи оптимальну підтримку хребта і суглобів. Завдяки спеціальним технологіям і використанню високоякісних матеріалів, ортопедичні матраци сприяють правильному розподілу ваги тіла, покращують кровообіг та зменшують точковий тиск.
Ці матраци відмінно адаптуються до контурів вашого тіла, забезпечуючи максимальний комфорт і відсутність напруги під час сну. Вони також відбивають рухи партнера, забезпечуючи спокійний сон обом сторонам. Ортопедичні матраци - це інвестиція у ваше здоров'я та добробут, яка забезпечить вам відновлення і ефективний відпочинок кожної ночі.
Gvibe — January 31, 2024
Good article. This is probably the best website I have ever visited.
orabelle hana — February 15, 2024
The appeal of the Watermelon game goes beyond its simple mechanics and addictive gameplay.
Tubidy — March 2, 2024
Best information i like it.
FlixHQ — March 2, 2024
It keep a amazing blog post.
Maxon Pakistan — March 27, 2024
Introducing Maxon Pakistan, your destination for premium mobile accessories in Pakistan. Explore our range of cutting-edge earbuds, headphones, power banks, and more, all crafted for superior performance. We guarantee 100% satisfaction with every purchase.
cricket id — April 2, 2024
Our target is to become Mexico's top SEO agency. Excellent post
Мебель Эверест — April 16, 2024
Матрац - це один із ключових елементів для комфортного сну. Він являє собою подушечку, зазвичай виконану з піни, латексу, пружин або їхньої комбінації, яка поміщається поверх ліжка або ліжечка. Головне завдання матраца - забезпечити підтримку тіла під час сну, утримуючи хребет у правильній позі та знижуючи напругу м'язів.
Матраци доступні в різних розмірах, типах і рівнях жорсткості, щоб відповідати потребам різних сплячих. Вони можуть бути односпальними, двоспальними або навіть спеціальними розмірами, такими як queen size або king size. Вибір матеріалу та рівня жорсткості матраца залежить від індивідуальних уподобань та особливостей здоров'я кожної людини.
Важливо обирати матрац, який забезпечує не лише комфортний сон, а й підтримує здоровий хребет і покращує якість вашого життя загалом.
udyam registration — May 8, 2024
Hey, thanks for sharing such an informative article. I found your article very useful. We are also providing services related to udyam registration.
Haartransplantatie — May 8, 2024
This is truly a great article. Thanks for your sharing.
ismart — May 8, 2024
При покупке матрасов пружинных важно учитывать не только их качество, но и соответствие индивидуальным потребностям. Матрас пружинный 90х190 предлагает оптимальное сочетание размера и поддержки для комфортного сна. Прежде чем купить матрасы пружинные, рекомендуется ознакомиться с различными вариантами жесткости и типами пружин, чтобы выбрать подходящий вариант. Также стоит обратить внимание на обивку матраса, которая может влиять на его долговечность и комфорт.
Media Feathers — May 15, 2024
Streamline your HR processes with Empowering UK investors with premier property opportunities in Dubai. Investment in Dubai from UK
Burun dolgusu — May 29, 2024
This is truly a great article. Thanks for your sharing.
Оля — July 17, 2024
Стол – это важный элемент любого интерьера, который обеспечивает комфорт и функциональность помещения. Существует множество видов столов: обеденные, офисные, журнальные и письменные, каждый из которых имеет своё назначение. Выбирая стол, стоит обратить внимание на материалы, размеры и дизайн, чтобы он идеально вписывался в ваше пространство. Деревянные столы добавляют тепла, стеклянные – лёгкости, а металлические – современности. Купить стол можно как в магазинах, так и онлайн, сравнивая цены и отзывы, чтобы найти лучший вариант по качеству и цене. В частности, большой выбор столов можно найти в интернет-магазине Страна Мебели
Ann — August 13, 2024
Модні жіночі костюми сьогодні є втіленням елегантності та сучасного стилю, що поєднує класичні елементи з новими тенденціями. Вони варіюються від класичних строгих фасонів до більш розслаблених і креативних варіантів, що дозволяє кожній жінці знайти свій ідеальний образ. Сучасні моделі часто експериментують з кольорами, текстурами та деталями, такими як асиметричні крої, нестандартні матеріали або унікальні аксесуари. Такі костюми ідеально підходять для будь-яких ситуацій, від ділових зустрічей до святкових заходів, додаючи в образу стильності та впевненості.
Найкращий вибір жіночих костюмів можна знайти в інтернет-магазині Nyni!
Digitize India — August 23, 2024
The blog has accurate information I like the way you have delivered the main point related
digitize india
ORT
SSO Rajasthan — August 23, 2024
Buy old coins sale online at best price in India. We have wide range of old coins sale in Coins & Stamps.
sso-rajasthan
ORT
Shala Darpan Portal — August 23, 2024
I Like your post
shaladarpanportal
ORT
TEMPOTOTO — September 4, 2024
You can only find entertainment games that can also be used as a place to make money in this game, By playing this amazing and very profitable online game, you want to know more information, please visit our website https://jepenih.com
slot deposit qris — September 5, 2024
In this article, we will take you deeper into the world of slots, exploring strategies, tips, and secrets that can help you win bigger. We will discuss how to choose the right machine, recognize payout patterns, and explain interesting features that are often overlooked by players. If you want to know more information, please visit our website slot deposit qris
sedaptogel — September 5, 2024
Online lottery games have become a very popular phenomenon among betting enthusiasts, combining aspects of traditional lotteries with the ease of digital access. For more information, you can visit our website available here sedaptogel
which allows players to choose their favorite numbers and bet from the comfort of their own home, as well as enjoy different types of games such as 2D, 3D, and 4D which offer different winning odds.
TEMPOTOTO — September 7, 2024
We proudly invite you to experience an unrivaled online slot gaming experience on our site, where a collection of stunning and innovative slot games are designed with the latest technology to provide a truly immersive gaming experience, combining high-quality graphics, captivating sound effects and lucrative bonus features, all in a safe and secure environment to ensure that every spin is filled with exciting winning opportunities and a truly entertaining gaming experience. If you want to know more information, please visit our website https://mestirank.com/
KASINO TERVIRAL JP BESAR — September 8, 2024
Imagine every spin, every card, and every dice as a step on the journey to the biggest prize. At Terviral JP Besar, you are not just dealing with a game, but with countless possibilities. Every bet is a chance to hold the big prize you have long dreamed of. if you want to know more information, please visit our website http://rgstudiodesign.nl/
STARGEMS SLOT ONLINE — September 11, 2024
Online slot games are one of the most interesting and exciting forms of entertainment. In this game, players will feel the thrill and excitement of spinning the reels and hoping to get a profitable combination of symbols. Online slots offer a variety of different themes, from epic adventures to stunning natural beauty. Each theme has stunning graphics and stunning sound effects, creating an unforgettable gaming experience. If you want to know more information, please visit our website https://17thavenue.co/
abutogel — September 11, 2024
Every time I read an article on this blog, it feels like I have discovered a hidden treasure. abutogel
You have an amazing way of packaging what may seem like mundane topics into something truly captivating and insightful. Your writing always manages to make me feel smarter after reading it. Thank you for creating content that is not only interesting but also very useful!
KASINO ONLINE JACKPOT TERCEPAT — September 12, 2024
Are you ready to step into the world of online gaming where every second can be a big win moment? Here, we present an online gaming experience that is not only amazing, but also offers the chance to hit the fastest jackpot ever! if you want to know more information, you can visit https://petespestpatrol.com/
IAISP — September 23, 2024
IAISP offers an exceptional AI Cybersecurity & Risk Certification that truly equips professionals with the necessary skills to navigate the complexities of modern cybersecurity threats. Their comprehensive curriculum combines AI technology with risk management strategies, ensuring you're prepared for the challenges ahead. Highly recommend it for anyone looking to advance their career in cybersecurity!
pay someone to take my online nursing class — September 25, 2024
Exams and written assignments aren't the only forms of assessment that students face in today's classrooms. The frequency with which yearly reviews take place makes it feasible to see them as a process. Professors often utilize essays and research projects as means of evaluating their students' progress in class. A student's education is not complete without term papers. There should be an introductory paragraph, body paragraphs with proof, and a conclusion that summaries the essay. Writing essays is a common requirement for college affirmation officers. Therefore, more and more students are looking for ways to Pay someone to do my online class for me. It ensures that you will do well in school and helps a lot of other students.
FOOTBALL REVIEW — October 3, 2024
This blog is very good because the content is very helpful for beginners like me. Therefore, if you want to know more information, you can visit it https://footballreview.net/
TOGEL PASTI JACKPOT 2024 — October 7, 2024
Togel game is one of the most popular forms of online games, this game is increasingly popular among online togel players. It has even become part of the local community tradition, if you want to know more, you can visit the site https://infernalrevulsion.com/