A woman smiling while cradling an infant in bed. “A Mother With Her Baby” by Sarah Chai is licensed under CC by 2.0 in pexels.

Household resources during the birth of a child greatly affect child health and life outcomes. Because working mothers must take time off from work after having a child, low-income women often experience the greatest financial strain around the period of childbirth.

The US offers only unpaid job-protected family leave, leaving low-income working mothers with no guaranteed economic support after having a baby. Public benefits that provide cash assistance or nutritional support offer potential relief for low-income mothers who experience a loss of income around childbirth.

Researchers Colleen Heflin, Taryn W. Morrissey, and Hyojeong Kim investigated whether receiving public assistance could offset the loss of earnings around childbirth for low-income working mothers. Using data collected in the state of Virginia from 2016-2021, they estimated the change in household earnings in the four quarters before and after childbirth among households who enrolled in public assistance during that period. Virginia’s population and poverty rates are similar to US averages, making it a useful case for understanding how public assistance can address economic instability around childbirth generally in the US. Four findings stood out from the study. 

First, the researchers found that on average, annual earnings declined by $2,097 following childbirth. This loss in earnings led many working mothers who had not previously received public assistance to enroll in welfare. 

Second, they found that mothers quickly returned to the workforce after having a child. On average, the mothers in their sample returned to the labor force within six months after a birth, a decision constrained by the fact that the US offers only unpaid job-protected leave.

Third, mothers received benefits for only a short period after childbirth. Mothers received an average of about 9 months of cash assistance and about 11 months of nutritional assistance. This short period of benefit use challenges popular concerns that welfare disincentivizes recipients from working.

Finally, the authors found that working mothers who received both cash and nutritional assistance were able to recover the loss of earnings from temporarily being out of the workforce—but with some important caveats. Nutritional benefits cannot be used to help with other economic needs like housing or transportation that people can experience after having a child. Additionally, most cash assistance is provided in the form of tax credits that are received only annually and in unpredictable amounts.

Despite the limitations of current welfare programs, this study provides clear evidence that public assistance can help provide economic relief to low-income mothers after having a child. Policies prioritizing this period around childbirth are crucial for supporting the health and well-being of both women and their children.

————–

Tatum Anderson is a second-year PhD student in the Department of Sociology at the University of Minnesota. Her research interests include inequality and stratification, family, and public policy.