The Chicago Tribune ran a story this week about the rash of bad behavior by politicians, celebrities, and athletes alike in recent months.
The breakdown:
After watching South Carolina Republican Rep. Joe Wilsonheckle the president during a joint session of Congress,Serena Williams cuss out a line judge at the U.S. Open andKanye West snatch the microphone from a 19-year-old newcomer, to champion a much-honored megastar, on theMTV Video Music Awards, you may have had the following thought:
What the (bleep) is wrong with people these days?
Those three incidents during the past week represent the latest trifecta of public incivility in a year in which town-hall health-care discussions routinely have devolved into shouting matches, President Barack Obama has been compared to and depicted as Adolf Hitler and figures across the political spectrum have flung epithets unprintable in a family newspaper.
The incidents, notable as much for their breaches of decorum as for their content, follow a general pattern: incident, outrage, hundreds of thousands of YouTube hits, apology and, maybe, punishment. What’s unclear is whether such outbursts are signs of shifting times or just a news cluster that gives us an excuse to wring our hands and look back at polite ol’ days that may never have existed.
Sociologist Gary Alan Fine is asked for his comments, and thoughtfully responds that this is likely not a new pattern of behavior, but a new pattern of interest…
Northwestern University sociology professor Gary Fine was reluctant to draw big conclusions, noting that Williams follows a long line of athletes — among them tennis players Jimmy Connors and John McEnroe — who have berated umpires, that presidents have been heckled in some form at least since Lyndon Johnson and that the British Parliament shows far less respect toward its head of government.
What the current controversies really indicate, Fine said, is what kind of news most people prefer.
“People like to pretend that they care about policy, but they really care about people and stories,” Fine said, noting that the Wilson outburst “provided a story about what is otherwise a complicated, confusing and, dare I say, boring debate about the details of health care.”
Comments 1
jesse — September 24, 2009
in my world, such media wouldn't get a dime.
makes me wonder what else is going on while so much time and money and "interest" (i'd like to know who's really interested) is spent on such consequential(?) events. like, i don't know, maybe... that 'Sibel Edmonds' case?! one would think such a juicy story would get better coverage.
i would also think a recession has the potential to refocus efforts on vital resources, news and media being one of them, and maybe a "downturn" would help to eliminate the hollywood extravagance in funding and therefore coverage.
maybe there is a long way to go still, either way, the floor still doesn't look that great.