A new survey of 557 female scientists found widespread experiences of discrimination and alienation in the workforce that varied in interesting ways by race.
While all types of women reported experiencing these forms of discrimination in large numbers — and 100% of a sub-sample of 60 interviewed for the study reported at least one — the race differences are interesting:
- Black women were especially likely to need to prove and re-prove competence.
- Asian and white women, especially, received pressure to withdraw from the workplace after having children.
- Asian women were most likely to be pushed to perform a stereotypically feminine role in the office, followed by white and then Latina women. Black women rarely reported this.
- Latina and white women were most likely to feel supported by other women in the workforce; Black women the least.
- And almost half of Black and Latina women had been mistaken for janitors or administrative assistants, compared to a third of white women and a quarter of Asian women.
The study, by law professor Joan Williams and two colleagues, can be found here.
Lisa Wade, PhD is an Associate Professor at Tulane University. She is the author of American Hookup, a book about college sexual culture; a textbook about gender; and a forthcoming introductory text: Terrible Magnificent Sociology. You can follow her on Twitter and Instagram.
Comments 9
Weekend reading | Of Means and Ends — July 4, 2015
[…] Nearly half of black and Latina scientists mistaken for janitors or assistants. […]
Shades of Milk & Linkspam (6 July 2015) | Geek Feminism Blog — July 7, 2015
[…] Nearly Half of Black and Latina Scientists Mistaken for Janitors or Assistants | Sociological Images: “A new survey of 557 female scientists found widespread experiences of discrimination and alienation in the workforce that varied in interesting ways by race.” […]
Interesting Read: Half of Black, Latina Scientists Mistaken For Janitors, Assistants | Now I ain't saying she a GoalDigger — July 7, 2015
[…] Approximately half of Black and Latina women in the Science, Technology, Engineering, and Math (STEM) fields say they have been mistaken for janitors and administrative staff, according to a new study. […]
CanuckAmuck — July 9, 2015
But...but how can this be? Both Fox news and various internet intellectuals say that there's no racism in the U.S.!
[/sarcasm]
Nearly Half of Black and Latina Female Scientistz Report Being Mistaken for Janitorz or Assistantz | Moorbey'z Blog — July 18, 2015
[…] post originally appeared on Sociological Images, a Pacific Standard partner site, as “Nearly Half of […]
O — October 28, 2020
I've been trying to track this study down, but the link to the study leads to a "not found" page at the UC Hastings website. Was this study retracted, or is it still available somewhere?
daniyal abbas — May 3, 2021
Karnataka board will release the 2nd PUC result 2021 one month after the conclusion of examinations. Students can check their Karnataka 2nd PUC result 2021 on the board's official results website - karresults.nic.in or from the board's official website - pue.kar.nic.inkarresults.nic.in PUC Result 2021 by providing their "Registration Number". Students can also make use of the direct link given on this page to download their PUC results 2021.
Nayan Warrior — August 20, 2023
You can save a lot of money by visiting the Walgreens Pharmacy & buying your required medicine in it. Walgreens is one of the leading Pharmacy chains in the united states, and they have more than 9000 stores located in 50 states in the US. Not only saving money also you can also earn a $3000 gift card on your future visit for free. You have to do a simple way to earn this gift card for free by taking the official WalgreensListens customer satisfaction survey at https://www.walgreensreceiptsurvey.com/. Buy Health Products at Walgreens Pharmacy to save money to participate in the official Walgreens Survey & win a gift card for free.
Ronald — August 20, 2023
You can save a lot of money by visiting the Walgreens Pharmacy & buying your required medicine in it. Walgreens is one of the leading Pharmacy chains in the united states, and they have more than 9000 stores located in 50 states in the US. Not only saving money also you can also earn a $3000 gift card on your future visit for free. You have to do a simple way to earn this gift card for free by taking the official WalgreensListens customer satisfaction survey at https://www.walgreensreceiptsurvey.com/. Buy Health Products at Walgreens Pharmacy to save money to participate in the official Walgreens Survey & win a gift card for free.