Dieting is for women.
I mean we all know that dieting and women go together like peas and carrots. We know this — collectively and together, even if we don’t agree that it should be this way — not because it’s inevitable or natural, but because we constantly get reminded that women should be on diets and dieting is a feminine activity.
@msmely tweeted us a fabulous example of this type of reminder. It’s a reduced fat block of Monterey Jack cheese, re-named “Monterey Jill.” There’s curvy purple font and a cow in pearls with a flower, in case you missed the message. And, oh, on the odd chance you thought that this was about health and not weight, there’s a little sign there with a message to keep you on track: “Meet Jack’s lighter companion.”
So now we’ve gendered cheese and managed to affirm both the gender binary (heavy vs. light), heterocentrism (Jack’s companion Jill), and the diet imperative for women. And it’s just cheese people! Cheese!
That is all.
Lisa Wade, PhD is an Associate Professor at Tulane University. She is the author of American Hookup, a book about college sexual culture; a textbook about gender; and a forthcoming introductory text: Terrible Magnificent Sociology. You can follow her on Twitter and Instagram.
Comments 30
Rep. Steve King is so mad that Obama has not congratulated Tim Tebow on his praying | Death and Taxes — May 13, 2013
[...] true, at least according to Tea Party favorite Rep. Steve King of Iowa. He took the time to explain all of this in a grandiose speech on the House floor last [...]
ps — May 13, 2013
Compare to http://www.skinnycow.com/
Personally I don't want to eat any food that calls me a cow.
Djiril — May 13, 2013
And it's not like men would ever want to lose weight. Right?
Ana O'Connor — May 13, 2013
Waitaminute. Is Monterey Jack a boy cow (like in the animated pic Barnyard) or boy cheese?
Laura D — May 13, 2013
I'm actually a little surprised they didn't sex up the cow. Can't have a fat cow lady on your diet cheese donchaknow!
Tusconian — May 13, 2013
Only ladies go on diets, and ALL ladies go on diets. Of course.
Rep. Steve King is so mad that Obama has not congratulated Tim Tebow on his praying | Brav's Bookmarks — May 13, 2013
[...] true, at least according to Tea Party favorite Rep. Steve King of Iowa. He took the time to explain all of this in a grandiose speech on the House floor last [...]
RonJ — May 14, 2013
I'd like to see more equality in this regard. We also get messages about what a “manly” look is, but obviously not nearly as often as women do. I feel healthier since I started working out again, and even though I haven't lost a lot of weight, some fat went away, I built more muscle and have a more pleasing appearance (or so my wife tells me). Dieting -in the sense of NOT stuffing your mouth with junk food- combined with exercise would be a positive message to send to everyone. The problem is when someone takes it to extremes and conflates dieting with starvation, which is sad. As a side note, we shouldn't take women's agency away
in this whole dieting thing and automatically assign them the “victim” status. Women are not mindless zombies and can make decisions for themselves instead of being brainwashed by the ad industry. It only works that way with weak minds.
wileywitch — May 14, 2013
The cow next to the brand name is looking at her and looks kind of horny.
Gynomite’s Reading Room! | Gynomite! — May 14, 2013
[...] Monterey Jill, because ladies be fat. [...]
Carol J. Adams — May 17, 2013
Lisa, I think there is something else going on here as well; the negative reference to cows as "old, fat cows" i.e., that all they do is stand around and eat and "have to be milked", the complete control of the cow's female reproductive system to produce milk in the first place; so underlying this negative attitude to "fat cows" is that they represent what oppression looks like though we don't want this to be in our explicit consciousness. Thus the idea that the "skinny cow" has somehow escaped reproductive slavery and thus can be "thin" and also "free" is going on. Look at the cover of NEITHER MAN NOR BEAST, that image is from the New York Times, a skinny cow as though in a weight loss pose (i.e., "I used to be a fat cow but now look at me"). anyway, the unspoken aspect of this ad is that cheese is feminized protein, a product of female slavery.
20th century schizoid man — May 18, 2013
"And it’s just cheese people! Cheese!"
But let's get outraged about it anyway.....
haeyeonJ — May 20, 2013
"Heterocentrism" isn't even a word.
Gender binaries should be upheld AND affirmed. As should class, tribe, nationality, etc. Don't buy into that Western thinking, it's based only on feelings and "good intentions", then a lot of wasted time justifying those feelings.
The old Asian traditionalism has a much longer and better track record: The more hierarchy, class and groupings, the more advanced and ordered a society becomes.
Besides, what's the problem here? You don't tailor things for women, femmis call you sexist for ignoring them. You do tailor things for women, femmis call you sexist for... stereotyping them? Or something? In the end it's always some variant of hurt feelings, so these complaints shouldn't be considered too seriously.
AlbertBarr — May 22, 2013
The question is "Are they making more money with this marketing?" If the answer is "yes" then we will have a hard time convincing those who created the campaign that they should be doing it differently. I don't buy much Lucerne cause the cheese is "meh"—so it makes sense that they have to resort to gimmicks.
Gendered Cheese! | Dead Wild Roses — May 25, 2013
[...] to Dr. Lisa Wade over at Sociological Images for the pic and [...]
You Can Tell This “Monterey Jill” Reduced Fat Cheese Is For Women Because It’s So Pretty - Exploring the News — July 9, 2014
[…] isn’t a new product — though we first saw it on the Seanan’s Tumblr, the blog Sociological Images had a post about it over a year ago and brought up all the issues anyone with a pair of eyes and a […]
You Can Tell This “Monterey Jill” Reduced Fat Cheese Is For Women Because It’s So Pretty - Perfect Your Lifestyle — July 10, 2014
[…] isn’t a new product — though we first saw it on the Seanan’s Tumblr, the blog Sociological Images had a post about it over a year ago and brought up all the issues anyone with a pair of eyes and a […]