A month or two ago I commented on the New York Times Upfront magazine for high school kids. I recently came across their latest, which features a cover story titled “What We Eat.” The story is really just an interesting collection of photographs of families from nations all over the world, but with each family sitting with all the food in their house.
However, although the title of the article inside the magazine is “What We Eat,” the title listed on the cover of the magazine is “What They Eat.” The picture selected for the cover is not one of the family photos, but is, instead, a photo apparently selected to elicit the maximum negative visceral response possible from American kids:
So the cover separates an “us” and a “them,” and shows the American high school students how gross and weird “they” are.
Check out the issue that preceded this one by just two or three weeks:
Here American high school students learn that people around the world with dark skin are violent, dirty, and poorly dressed.
No wonder American kids grow up to be American adults whose voting habits reflect the view that American foreign policy should be paternalistic.
——————–
Missives from Marx is an Assistant Professor of Religious Studies.
If you would like to write a post for Sociological Images, please see our Guidelines for Guest Bloggers.
Gwen Sharp is an associate professor of sociology at Nevada State College. You can follow her on Twitter at @gwensharpnv.
Comments 27
Larry C Wilson — May 1, 2009
Negative response? Possibly. What the images are meant to do for the individuals who chose them is to get the attention of potential readers/buyers.
Duran — May 1, 2009
I'm sorry that you don't feel for the plight of child soldiers in Sierra Leone and other war torn territories.
Gwen Sharp, PhD — May 1, 2009
I believe the point is that we rarely see stories about Africa that DON'T emphasize that it's a brutal, uncivilized place. You can care about child soldiers and still think it's problematic to depict Africa ONLY through stories of brutality, the Rwandan genocide, and so on--it plays into the "dark uncivilized Africa" story that many people are comfortable with.
Elena — May 1, 2009
Well, talking about child soldiers, I was in a shock the first time that some teenaged fellow poster in a message board mentioned going to a JROTC program or a military academy in the US. The militarisation of society (as in, military training or boot camp is often the first thing suggested to "straighten up" unruly teens) in the USA can look more than a bit weird to other countries.
Vettekaas — May 1, 2009
ah I've always suspected that something was amiss in my education in that respect! I am a generally open-minded person, but I some how made it half-way through high school with a "them vs. us" perspective. Unlike many people in the US, I was given the opportunity to go abroad and "discover" that people around the world... are people! going about their lives like people do!
Agawa — May 1, 2009
Gwen is right on the spot here. It is a problem because "Africa" is so rarely depicted or explored as a place with more than one culture (which usually consists of rape/child soldiers/starvation/aids).
There is a great deal of development, living, and creating of all kinds going on all over the place, just like everywhere else in the world. It's depressing that the only articles considered newsworthy are those that focus on the worst of the worst, with little examination of causation or development.
Larry C Wilson — May 1, 2009
Good news is no news.
Larry C Wilson — May 1, 2009
The plight of child soldiers? Are you familiar with the history of homo sapiens?
Beth — May 1, 2009
If anyone was interested in seeing the rest of the photos, they're here: http://www.time.com/time/photogallery/0,29307,1626519,00.html
Sonja — May 2, 2009
I agree with you on the first one, but the second - hmm. It's not a story about "Africa", it's a story about child soldiers which is illustrated with a child soldier. The fact that there's hardly any stories about Africa not depicting violence is another issue.
Anne — May 2, 2009
I think the Upfront magazine is mis-representing "them." That child isn't eating that fish, he's just killing it by biting. So, that makes it even more calculated to be a gross-out... taking it out of context and making it look like he is doing something he isn't. After all, raw fish with no scales = sushi. Raw fish with scales = gross and weird.
I read the online article to see if they explained the picture, but it wasn't in there. It's possible the inside cover of the real magazine explains it, of course.
theunbeatablekid — May 2, 2009
i agree with all of this post except for labeling the child soldier as poorly dressed.
i'm no fashionista but that dinosaur football t-shirt is the pretty sweet.
YT — May 2, 2009
You're mistaking sensationalism with discrimination. You also seem to read into things with self-righteousness indignation. When I saw these photos, I didn't think that it portrayed these foreigner as savages but contrasted them from our privileged lifestyles. It shows and teaches disparity rather than looking down on them.
Fernando — May 2, 2009
I agree with Sonja. Also, compared to the amount of reports related to problems people face, news outlets rarely (at least here) talk about the positive things even in their local communities.
And that makes sense. The point of reporting something is to raise awareness of it, and I think it is more important to let people know about what's wrong. Of course there is a thin line between this and stereotyping a place as violent and awful, still that doesn't mean that pieces talking about violent and awful things are trying to build a negative perception on the public.
Missives from Marx — May 2, 2009
YT: I never had a problem with the pictures of the kitchens and the food. In fact, I said in the post that it was an "interesting collection of photographs." I think you're right that many of them rightly can be contrasted with the privilege of others. My problem was with what was on the cover.
Sonja and Fernando: I don't think that we can take the picture of the soldier in isolation. If I insult my wife once it's not emotional abuse, but if I do it a thousand times, it probably is. I can't take the 990th instance by itself and say "this by itself isn't abuse." Of course, by itself it isn't. In context, however, it may be PART OF a history of abuse. Similarly, I think the sensationalist nature of this photograph, alongside MANY OTHER similar photographs in the media makes it problematic.
Also, Fernando: I doubt that the the New York Times INTENDS to build a negative perception of Africa. But their intentions and the actual message that audience receives are two different things.
Despite any differences or disagreements, I thank you all for your comments!
Dubi — May 3, 2009
"we rarely see stories about Africa that DON’T emphasize that it’s a brutal, uncivilized place".
And, at least for the press in Israel, you rarely see stories about the US that don't emphasize that it's a place full or insane, murderous and exceedingly fat people.
I'm amused at how you can complain about how Africa is homogenized by the press, but at the same time talk about "western culture" as if all of Europe and North America are exactly the same.
Gwen — May 3, 2009
Dubi,
Point taken. I've been trying to get much better at specifying what cultural context I'm referring to, but it's just been a hard habit to break. That said, there *is* a history of colonialism that many countries in Europe, as well as the U.S., share--clearly the form of colonialism varied, but there were certain similarities in how colonized areas of the world were viewed and the justifications used to support it.
NancyP — May 4, 2009
I hate to say it, but to the average 8 to 11 year old, at least the majority of boys and a sizable minority of girls, the photo of the Inuit kid eating (or killing) untrimmed fresh fish is likely to elicit - kewl! (I had assumed that it had been cleaned already). On the other hand, I was one of the 6th grade dare-ya crew eating weird-ass stuff like tinned caterpillars. And I still cook fish head-on and eat the masseter (cheek) as well as the regular part of the fish.
Us and Them at Racialicious - the intersection of race and pop culture — May 14, 2009
[...] by Guest Contributor Missives from Marx originally published at Sociological Images [...]
Stinky39 — October 22, 2009
Discuss proper etiquette and social graces. ,
Coder98 — October 22, 2009
In the earliest times humans would look at the sky and explore the universe. ,
Faggot13 — October 23, 2009
Thank you all very, very much! ,
Faggot31 — October 23, 2009
I wanted to find a hobby big enough to accommodate my bounteous ego. ,
Which Images Represent India? » Sociological Images — November 20, 2009
[...] “we are all African” campaign, making charity recipients look gross, tourism in Brazil, us and them, Burger King’s Whopper Virgin campaign, India needs western technology, and de-racializing [...]
tocksix — December 3, 2009
72]II?II NAEO
http://topstore.org/as/52.jpg http://topstore.org/as/191.jpg
http://topstore.org/as/95.jpg http://topstore.org/as/45.jpg
72]ретро секс
72]фото порно 2006
72]порно книги
72]секси костюмы
72]seks ry
72]порно фото видео рассказы
avi ролики порно phorum
порно avi - онлайн порно avi
фотки голых девчонок
девчонка голая
семейное порно видео blog
фото порно семейное
порно видео сперма - много спермы видео
видео сперма порно
женщины любят анальный секс
секс со женщинами - секс со зрелыми женщинами знакомства
18 порно - онлайн порно 18
18 порно - онлайн порно 18
порно фото галереи жопа
порно blog жопа
первый секс парня blogs
секс девушка парень
жесткий бдсм онлайн
онлайн порно бдсм
онлайн порево смотреть - супер порево онлайн
онлайн порево смотреть - супер порево онлайн
порнуха ролики видео - порнуха порно ролики comment
видео ролики порнуха
порно фото взрослых - порно взрослых дам
порно взрослых фото
порно фото зрелых лесбиянок
порно лесбиянок blogs - лучшие порно видео лесбиянок добавить
секси видео скачать - скачать видео секс машины
секси видео скачать - скачать видео секс машины
порно анал онлайн - порно фото анала comment
порно анал онлайн - порно фото анала comment
порно видео ролики бдсм
порно бдсм онлайн - жёсткое бдсм порно видео
очень красивые голые девушки
фото голы красивых девушек
порно видео фильм отрывки
видео порно фильмы е
секс порно видео send thread
секс порно видео
посмотреть оргазмы
женский оргазм видео
секс фото молоденьких девочек
порно девочки молоденьке
видео гей - жёсткий гей секс видео смотреть
гей видео
секс ru - секс чат ru posts
ru секс
порно клипы без платно
порно бес платно - бес платное порно онлайн
секс просмотр
секс порно просмотр - просмотр секс роликов comment
порно видео мастурбация
мастурбация видео скачать - мастурбация видео post new topic
девочки порно ipb
порно девочки
порно кино смотреть
видео порно смотреть безплатно
фото секс - животные секс
секс фото
порно фото галереи извращения экстрим
галерея го порно - порно галереи секс
смотреть е секс видео - секс видео смотреть добавить сообщение
смотреть е секс видео - секс видео смотреть добавить сообщение
анал секс видео
е анал видео - ебля анал видео
список порно сайтов
порно видео сайт
скачать геи
гей - гей актер
sitemap
марина максимова порно - фото марины порно my blog
rss
скачать секси видео - скачать секс видео posting
частная русская эротика блог
частная эротика русская блог
юля тимошенко порно блог
тимошенко юля порно блог
rss
фото супер порно - супер порно унижение рабыни
sitemap
видео порно смотреть блог
смотреть онлайн короткое порно
короткое порно видео - порно видео короткие posts
посмотреть е порно видео - посмотреть порно видео школьница blog
посмотреть е порно видео - посмотреть порно видео школьница blog
женская мастурбация онлайн видео
женская мастурбация
порно бабушку ебут forum
порно фото бабушек - порно фото бабушка и внук
мальчик девочка секс
секс фото девочек
скачать анал comment
скачать анал - секс скачать анал
оргия праведников blogs
оргии порно
порно ролики групповое
порно групповой секс - порно групповой секс comment
фотки голых подростков
голые подростки
голая алена винницкая фото
голая алена - голая алена водонаева фото blog
порно видео анал отправить сообщение
анал видео - порно видео анал send thread
ножки девушек - ножки в чулочках
ножки девушек - ножки в чулочках
порно видео фильмы journal
порно видео онлайн фильмы
секси видео смотреть блог
секси видео смотреть - секс с конем смотреть видео
частная русская эротика - домашняя русская эротика comment
частная русская эротика - домашняя русская эротика comment
пенис блог
пенис - размер пениса
голая маша из папиных дочек - голая маша малиновская
голая маша из папиных дочек - голая маша малиновская
скачать порно видео звезд - голые звёзды порно скачать journal
звезд видео скачать порно блог
sitemap
блог секси геи
rss
видео порно блог мамочек
смотреть порно трах - смотреть трах на кухне
смотреть порно трах - смотреть трах на кухне
девственницы онлайн - фильм восемнадцатилетняя девственница
девственницы онлайн - фильм восемнадцатилетняя девственница
порно со звёздами - смотреть онлайн порно со звездами
порно со звёздами - смотреть онлайн порно со звездами
фото минета - глубокии минет
минета блог фото
групповой секс blog блог
групповой блог blog секс
лезбиянки видео - голые лезбиянки
видео лезбиянки блог
строение женского полового органа - женские внутренние половые органы
органа блог полового строение женского
порно зрелые мамаши posts
порно зрелые мамаши - жесткое порно мамаш journal
порно яны - яна рудковская порно
порно яны - яна рудковская порно
бдсм видео он лайн
скачать бдсм видео
порно большие члены смотреть
порно фото член - порно галерея члены
лесбиянки видео ролики - скачать ролики лесбиянки
лесбиянки видео ролики - скачать ролики лесбиянки
скачать эротических порно видео
порно медсестры
прикольное видео бесплатное
уроки секса фильм
порно жирная баба фото
ким трахов
скачать порно мульты
видeо ролики
animals секс
взрослые дамы порно
заставлять заниматься сексом
порно ру бесплатно
беспатное порно видео
трахаться 3gp
юноши порно
фото порно сперма
дом2 порно просмотр
писька тимоти
колготки секс фото
порно самые старые
(Lack of) Global News Coverage in the U.S. » Sociological Images — February 5, 2010
[...] Afghanistan, meaningless statistics, U.S. and international versions of magazine covers, “us and them,” which missing kids get news coverage?, covering Obama and McCain, covering Obama and [...]
Roberttwins — October 12, 2018
предоставления парикмахерской услуг парикмахерские услуги ип