We have become more aware that Americans’ chances of upward economic mobility have for decades been a lot lower than Americans imagined, that being poor or rich can last generations. Efforts to explain that lock-in have pointed to several patterns, from the intergenerational inheritance of assets (or debt, as the case may be) to intergenerational continuity in child-rearing styles (say, how much parents read to their children). In such ways, the past is not really past.
Increasingly, researchers have also identified the places – the communities, neighborhoods, blocks – where people live as a factor in slowing economic mobility. In a post earlier this year, I noted a couple of 2008 studies showing that growing up in poor neighborhoods impaired children’s cognitive skills and reduced their chances to advance beyond their parents. In this post, I report on further research by NYU sociologist Patrick Sharkey (here and here) suggesting that a bad environment can worsen the life chances not only of a child, but that of the child’s child, an unfortunate residential patrimony.
Consider the ways that the immediate environment shapes a child’s development. It does so physically. Air and soil pollution, noise, and traffic, for example, measurably affect children’s health, stress, and cognitive development. Local institutions and resources, such as the policing, quality of the schools, availability of health services, food options, parks, and so on matter, as well. And the social environment may matter most of all. Growing up in a community with gangs, dangerous streets, discouraging role models, confused social expectations, and few connections to outsiders commanding resources is a burden for any child. Just getting by day-to-day can be a struggle. (In a pair of studies, Sharkey found that a violent crime occurring near black children’s homes in the days before they took a standardized test reduced their scores on the test, presumably because of anxiety and distraction.)
In their research on historical effects, Sharkey and co-author Felix Elwert used a survey that has followed thousands of American families since 1968 (the PSID). The researchers know much about the adults in the survey, including where they lived when they were around 16, about the children they had and where those children lived around the age of six. The researchers also have the results from cognitive tests administered to those children in 2002.
Sharkey and Elwert found that living in a neighborhood where 20 percent or more of the residents are poor — many other things being held constant (including the parents’ education, health, and attitudes) — seems to lower the test scores of children. And so does having a parent who grew up in such a neighborhood. The effect on children of living in a poor neighborhood and having parents who had also are substantially greater than the effect of only the second generation living in a poor neighborhood. Moreover, the children of two generations of poor neighborhoods do much worse than those of two generations who managed to stay out of poor neighborhoods (over half a standard deviation worse). For technical reasons, these statistical results probably underestimate the real effect of neighborhood poverty on scores.
What appears to have happened is this: Survey respondents in the first generation who grew up in poor neighborhoods ran higher risks than other respondents, on average getting less education and worse jobs, if any, and bearing more physical, social, and psychological problems. Not surprisingly, they tended to end up in poor neighborhoods as adults. When this first generation became parents, they commonly passed on some of their personal disadvantages, such as weak reading skills, to their own children. And they also passed on their places, raising the second generation in poor neighborhoods, which further hampered their children. In this way, Sharkey and Elwert argue, neighborhood problems dragged down (at least) two generations.
No discussion of neighborhood effects can ignore the racial dimension, because the residential segregation of blacks has been and, though reduced, continues to be extreme: 41 percent of the African-American parent-child pairs in the study grew up in poor neighborhoods in both generations; only 2 percent of white families did. Poor whites were less likely to live in concentrated areas of poverty and are more likely to get out of them if they did. The weight of the past is much heavier for some than others.
Claude Fischer is a sociologist at UC Berkeley, is the author of Made in America: A Social History of American Culture and Character. This post originally appeared at Made in America and was re-posted on the Boston Review BR Blog.
Comments 12
Simone — January 13, 2015
I would add that if someone (and their parents) does not grow up in an affluent neighborhood, they wouldn't be comfortable living in one later in life if they do get out of poverty. No one wants to feel like a social outsider -- they would be even if their finances improve. There is a learning curve to living as someone with privilege, and feeling comfortable with it. Many people never feel comfortable because our ideals are different - I don't feel comfortable living in upper or middle-class neighborhoods, even though I am no longer impoverished, because I see them as shallow people. Not all of them, but it does seem that poor people develop a deeper meaningful view of life out of necessity, and those who live in excess don't need to develop those deeper meaning outlooks. There is a trade-off for both sides I think.
Growing Up Poor Has Effects on Your Children Even If You Escape Poverty | MemePosts — January 13, 2015
[…] View Original: Growing Up Poor Has Effects on Your Children Even If You Escape Poverty […]
Growing Up Poor Has Effects on Your Children Even If You Escape Poverty - Treat Them Better — January 13, 2015
[…] Growing Up Poor Has Effects on Your Children Even If You Escape Poverty […]
Darryl H. Alvarez — November 14, 2019
In my opinion, I think they are right if girls and boys spend their time together as a child, they will learn how to live together, how to respect each other and this will be very beneficial for them going forward and mobile casino new zealand are best to gamble. It’s a nice informative blog and it gives us a very upright message.
John — January 23, 2020
Thanks for sharing such a good info.
daniyal abbas — May 26, 2021
JAC 12th syllabus 2021 for Science/Commerce/Arts is provided by the Jharkhand Academic Council (JAC). Therefore, JAC publishes the JAC syllabus for all classes online. Candidates can download all the stream syllabuses, i.e., Science, Commerce & Arts, from the official website. JAC 12th syllabus 2021 is available in PDF file format. Candidates can therefore download and refer to the syllabus for future reference. JAC Intermediate Syllabus 2021 Jharkhand (JAC) Intermediate JAC Inter 2nd Year Syllabus 2021-2022New Textbook 2021 JAC Intermediate Biology Subjects 2021 JAC Intermediate Physics Syllabus Paper 2021 JAC Intermediate Chemistry Syllabus Question Paper 2021 JAC Intermediate Mathematics Subjects Question Paper 2021
daniyal abbas — June 2, 2021
Rajasthan Board (RBSE) New Syllabus 2021 Pdf – 10th 12th 11th 9th Class: The Board of Secondary Education Rajasthan has changed the syllabus of 9th, 10th, 11th and 12th class for the session 2021-2021 due to COVID-19.Raj 10th Textbook 2021-2022
The aspirants who are preparing for their annual board examination they will require the Rajasthan Board 10th New Syllabus. It will help them to learn and study according to the updated topics of the exam. As we know the board examination plays an important part in the career of any student. The students of the 12th class can download the RBSE 12th New Syllabus 2021.
dalvinsmith147 — June 21, 2021
Dear SBI Credit Cardholder, your payment will be credited instantly. In case of any issues with bank settlement or network failure, we request you to wait for 24 hours. How to Make SBI Bank Credit Card Payment through BillDesk · how to link your aadhaar card with hdfc bank account online
Click here to go to BillDesk's SBI Card bill payment page. Credit Card (Visa) Bill Pay is an online service and requires an Internet Banking enabled account with State Bank of India.
daniyal abbas — June 21, 2021
I just found out about how to protect a locked pdf document after I visited fr.altorotatepdf.com. I read the reviews and it convinced me to use this service to lock the document. Kırklareli Escort
daniyal abbas — June 23, 2021
I regularly visit this site to check out the events and functions and sometimes for resources. However, it has been a while that you have shared some news about latest or upcoming events. Çorum Escort