In a 2007 national survey, 40% of children adopted by Americans, both domestically and internationally, were of a different race than their adoptive parents (source). Transracial adoptions are very common. But who adopts who? If you ask Google Images, white families adopt non-white children. Six of the images below appear to feature white parents with children of color:
Why in America do we associate transracial adoptions with white parents?
One reason might be simply numerical. White people aren’t more likely to adopt – in fact, the population of adopters is less white (73%) than the general population (78%) – but only 39% of adoptees are white. So, when white people do adopt, there’s a decent chance that they’ll adopt a non-white baby. Compounding this, they may be more likely to adopt transnationally because whites as a group are more affluent and so may have the money necessary pay the expenses of an overseas adoption, traveling across the globe possibly multiple times.
I think, however, that we also associate transracial adoptions with white parents out of bias. Many Americans are suspicious that minorities might not be “fit parents,” especially to a white child. In this scenario, we value white children more than other children and imagine that they should be placed only with good/white parents. Or, conversely, we imagine that it is only children of color that need saving and only white people that save.
The idea that people of color never raise white children as their own is illustrated by the story of Regina and Stacey Bush. Regina is Stacey’s adoptive mother. She’s black and Stacey is white. Jessica Ravitz, at CNN, discusses the various ways in which the mother and child upset other people’s sense of what’s normal and right. Ravitz writes:
When a young Stacey once started climbing into the van to join her family at an Arby’s restaurant, patrons came running to grab her, yelling that she was going into the wrong car. The girl was given detention at school, accused of lying because she called a young black boy her little brother, which he was. At a movie theater one time, someone called the police because they feared Stacey had been abducted.
These reactions reveal that many people still can’t imagine a non-white person raising a white child that is his or her own.
Hannah Rau is a sophomore at Occidental College. She plans to study Sociology and Art History.
Lisa Wade is a professor of sociology at Occidental College. You can follow her on Twitter andFacebook.
Comments 25
Gman E. Willikers — April 30, 2013
I wonder how much of the racial disparity is due to social pressures for people of color to adopt other than a white child on the theory that white children are, by default, privileged. It would follow as a matter of logic built on the premise of privilege that people of color should not "waste" their resources helping a white child who, due to privilege, can't possible justify the expenditure of those finite resources. In other words, if their is any chance for prospective parents of color to spend their resources on children of color, isn't there tremendous social pressure for them spend where their resources are really needed (i.e., where there is no white privilege)?
Kazia — April 30, 2013
WWYD has done a few scenarios on similar situations. People's reaction are really quite fascinating!
Adopted children of a different race: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Nk6aYIT2Wh0
Bio children of a different race: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YMA5y6oQhBQ
Guest — April 30, 2013
I agree that there is a common assumption that adoptive parents are white
soctraveller — April 30, 2013
I agree that adoption is often depicted as white parents adopting non-white children. However, it seems to me that the disparity is largely numerical issue, as you indicate in the beginning of the post. As someone who has been looking into adoption recently, I have been told by domestic adoption agencies that you may have to wait a long time (and be prepared to pay more) if you want to adopt a white child.
DBChen — April 30, 2013
I am ethnically Chinese, my husband is white. We live in the USA and we adopted domestically a white Latina baby. It was an open adoption, where the birthparents chose us and we met them before the birth. I have yet to get the nanny question in the US but did get the nanny question when we visited Taiwan.
At the playgrounds here in Atlanta, children have asked if my daughter was mine and when I say yes, they respond "but she doesn't look like you." Interestingly, the inquiring children were Latino and black.
Azizi Powell — April 30, 2013
As a former Director of a Black adoption program (1991-1995) and a former Board member during that time of the international (USA/Canada) organization Adoptive Families Of America, & as a Black adoptive parent of Black children let me clarify the reasons for the initiation of transracial adoption: Transracial adoption was initiated because of the desire of White people to parent a child or children and because of the scarcity of adoptable White healthy babies & White toddlers (i e. children without "special needs") along with the very real difficulty (financially & agency criteria) of White parents to secure those particular adoptable White children). In my opinion, that is the main reason why transracial adoption continues to occur.
Without question, racism is a very real factor in the child welfare system that adoption is a part of. For instance, during the time that I was affiliated with that adoption program & that adoption organization & other adoption organizations, most agencies would not only even consider placing a White child with a person or couple who was non-White but would also usually not consider placing a healthy baby or a healthy young child who was of White/non White ancestry with any other adoptable parent but a White parent. That means that a interracial couple (for instance, a couple in which the man was Black and the woman was White) would not only not even be considered for an adoptable healthy White baby/White young child, but would also usually not be considered for an adoptable healthy baby/young child who was of Black/White ancestry.
Tusconian — April 30, 2013
I think the disparity is also tied to transnational adoption. White people aren't just more likely to adopt nonwhite children.....they're more likely to adopt non-American children, white or not. (It's also worth mentioning a LOT of these children adopted from other countries are not orphans and were not abandoned willingly by their parent/parents.) Though this is contributing to the stereotypes as well, since I have heard one or two instances of white parents with African-AMERICAN children routinely asked "where they got him/her" with the implication that the kid must have been rescued from some war-torn village in African, when in reality, there are plenty of black American children who need stable homes as well.
Also, a lot of adoptive nonwhite parents don't seem to "count" in the adoption discussion because the children are somewhat more likely to be relatives or the children of close family friends. Adopting your grandchild, nephew, cousin, or neighbor's kid doesn't seem to be discussed much, I guess because of the assumption that you're "supposed" to take in as your own children with close relations to you.
[links] Link salad celebrates M’aidez | jlake.com — May 1, 2013
[...] Representing Transracial Adoptions — Wow. As a white parent in an adopted transracial family, just wow. [...]
Elena — May 1, 2013
If you ask Google Images
Please don't treat a GIS search like anything other than a result of a computer algorithm with too many variables that you aren't counting (like, for example, keywords in the text near the image, the text linking to that image or site positioning) and are not relevant at all to the thing you're studying.
pduggie — May 1, 2013
I think it would be fruitful to consider Bayesian analysis.
Fast Eddie — May 3, 2013
"Why in America do we associate transracial adoptions with white parents?"
--Source, please
" Many Americans are suspicious that minorities might not be “fit parents,” especially to a white child. "
--Source, please
"These reactions reveal that many people still can’t imagine a non-white person raising a white child that is his or her own."
--Really? From ONE story you read?
slope unblocked — July 18, 2022
I would also encourage everyone to bookmark this page for any favorite assistance to assist posted the appearance.