Chelsea C. brought our attention to this billboard for McDonald’s coffee or McCafe:
90210 is the zip code for Beverly Hills, a notoriously rich neighborhood in California. And, Chelsea explains, 48503 is a zip code in Flint, Michigan.
The ad is interesting to me because of the double meaning of taste (hello Bourdieu!). Taste refers to how things taste on your tongue (literally the taste of the coffee), but it also refers to who has good versus bad taste (people with good taste are “high class” and they like things like classical music and caviar). The idea that this ad is capitalizing (pun intended!) on both meanings of the word taste is supported by the use of the term “cafe” in “McCafe” and the portrayal of a fancy coffee drink (“Mochas”).
So the ad is saying that, even if you live in Flint and don’t have the economic resources of someone who lives in Beverly Hills, you can have the taste of expensive coffee because, of course, expensive coffee is to your taste.
There is something interesting here that ties into our consumer culture and wide range of advertising, television programming, and Paris Hilton-watching that encourages us to aspire to be just like the rich. This means buying expensive things that you can’t really afford and/or valuing things that mark you as a high class person with good taste (such as Mochas from McCafe, if that’s the best you can do). There is no questioning as to whether it’s a good idea for everyone to aspire to such heights, whether there is something problematic in the disparity between 90210 and 48503, or even whether it’s true that the rich have better “taste.” So, ultimately, the hierarchy goes unchallenged while we all just jocky for position.
This reminds me of the moment in the Sex and the City movie when Carrie realizes that her assistant, Louise, rents super-expensive purses even though she is too poor to buy them. Carrie is impressed by Louise’s “taste” and her dedication to having “the best” things even if they are completely inessential and renting them only exacerbates the fact that she doesn’t have oodles of cash.
So, yeah, I think this billboard plays into that.
Comments 11
thoughtcounts Z — December 15, 2008
Where does this billboard actually appear? I assume in Michigan...? I doubt people would really "get it" otherwise, as zip codes that haven't had TV shows named after them are a bit harder for people out of the area to recognize. I'd be a little surprised if it's actually in 48503 though, because it seems kind of insulting.
eallen — December 15, 2008
The source blog states that this particular billboard is appearing around Flint, MI.
Vidya — December 15, 2008
Hmm, if the ad really is appearing/targeting those in the latter zip code, it would seem to change the dynamics of the ad (versus if it was placed elsewhere and encouraged 'outsiders' to identify 48503 with the 'economically challenged').
Andrew — December 17, 2008
I saw this ad last night and again today. I saw it at the 8 mile and Telegraph area, which is Detroit. I thought it was kind of funny but at the same time offensive. I actually had too look up the zip code because I wasn't sure where that was at. I was assuming a Detroit zip. But I guess not.
Sha — December 20, 2008
I recently saw an ad of theirs that said something to the effect of "Coffeehouse taste with a shot of reality."
This makes me think of the politicians that try and convince their constituents that they're just average Joes when in reality they own eight houses.
Business Memes » A $10,000 COCKTAIL FOR TWO — December 30, 2008
[...] identify with them over and against people of our own class? (I described how this might work in a previous post on McDonald’s coffee.) Would actual physical integration (insofar as it doesn’t exist) have a different impact [...]
Sociological Images » “REDNECK” WEDDING CAKES AND GETTING MARRIED RIGHT — February 2, 2009
[...] also this related post on “taste” and two more posts on how to do weddings right (i.e., girls should be skinny and be [...]
Joe — March 27, 2009
McDonald's is smart for adapting high-end coffee to a slow economy, but still, their McCafe coffees aren't a whole lot less than Starbucks
DoctorJay — August 16, 2010
I just saw a billboard in Times Square for a liquor store. Said "Hamptons quality. Newark prices."
Sam R — September 15, 2010
I would be slightly put off that McDonalds is saying that I am a person of low economic means.