Cross-posted at Brad’s Blog.
Here are a few commercials for the new MilkBite™ from Kraft. They play on stereotypes about mixed-race individuals.
[youtube]https://youtu.be/ffkDRynWAMw[/youtube]
Here is a transcription:
You didn’t think, did you? You, uh, didn’t think what life was going to be like for me — mom, dad — for your son.
In another commercial, the characters have the following conversation:
I just have a question. Your profile said you were milk.
Uh huh, yep, I am.
You just look like granola.
Granola, yeah, I know. I get that a lot. This was a mistake.
No, wait. Please don’t go. I’m kinda into it.
There are other spots on Kraft’s YouTube page, most playing on these same themes. The problem with a marketing campaign like this is that it trivializes the experience of people with multiple racial/ethnic identities who are still often met with derision and confusion. The first ad above perpetuates the self-fulfilling prophecy about “confused” identities. As a child, I remember family members telling me that they didn’t have a problem with interracial couples but worried about how others might react to their children.
In my classroom earlier this year, a young white woman expressed overt anger when I told the class that the 2010 2000 Census, for the first time, allowed individuals to check more than one racial category. “How can they do that?!!” she demanded to know. Living in a country with a president who had a black father and an white mother complicates all of this. Beyond the standard “post-racial America” narrative, Pres. Obama’s racial identity — even though he identifies only as black — means that people feel entitled to be dismissive of the problems that come with our increasingly complex constructions of race.
Anita Sarkeesian at Feminist Frequency points out that the marketers are likely fully aware of the inappropriate nature of these types of campaigns, and in fact, that is precisely why they launch them. They are seen as ironic, over-the-top, cynical, and tongue-in-cheek. It’s “they know that I know that they know” that it’s racist. It’s a virtual “wink and a nod.” Lisa Wade at SocImages points out that it’s a “no-one-will-ever-believe-we’re-serious” mindset. Sadly, not all people are in on the joke and will find their bigotry and ignorance reinforced, but the rest of us should know better than to perpetuate racism, even under the guise of humor.
————————
Bradley Koch is a sociologist at Georgia College. He is currently the co-director of the study abroad program based in Athens, Greece. His research interests include religion, sexuality, higher education, and teaching and learning. In his free time, Brad enjoys making music and riding his road bike around rural Georgia.
Comments 33
myblackfriendsays — April 27, 2012
What is even more annoying about this is that when people have complained on their Facebook page for this product, https://www.facebook.com/milkbite it's pretty clear they don't give a crap. They give the same non-committal answer to everyone.
Ladyguertia — April 27, 2012
It took me a while to understand the commercial. I mean the only characters I see on tv that talk about the mixed race experience was that commercial and Spock from Star Trek. I will admit I found the first one cute but the rest is just pretty dismissive and plain stupid. I try to voice my experience as a mixed race women I do get dismissive comments and a befitting attitude.
Bill Mazza — April 27, 2012
it's like you and jezebel planned it:
http://jezebel.com/5905291/a-complete-guide-to-hipster-racism
Casey — April 27, 2012
What's the racism here? Pointing out that mixed race people face discrimination? This sounds like false "color-blind" antiracism here.
Lilaveronica — April 27, 2012
it was not so much the t.v adds that got to me but the you.tube posts that realy made me mad he is in tharpy for being mixed shame on kraft.
Cocojams Jambalayah — April 27, 2012
I share the distaste for this MilkBite commercial for the reasons that other commenters have already given. Those commercials fail on so many levels.
However, I'd like to mention that the article that is hyperlinked regarding President Obama's Census choice of his race indicates that "He chose the option “Black, African Am., or Negro.” I believe that that choice doesn't necessary mean that Pres. Obama "identifies only as black" as the author of this post put it. Even if that is so, I question what "identifying only as Black" means.
People can select the "Black, African American, or Negro" option on the census form and still fully acknowlege and be accepting of their mixed racial ancestry. Indeed, I believe that most African Americans are mixed race, so indicating that you are African American doesn't necessarily mean that you aren't accepting of your mixed race ancestry. (I hasten to say that I believe that people who are first generation mixed race may have different experiences with racism and might struggle with identity issues in other ways than people who aren't first generation mixed race.)
There are other reasons why people who are of Black/non-Black ancestry might select the "Black, African American, or Negro" option on the census form. One of those reasons is the recognition that selecting the "black-white", the "other" selection, or the "white" selection*, would lead to a decrease in the "African American" category and therefore would negatively impact funding and political power.
*That said, I believe that a person who is racially mixed should have the right to choose and be fully accepted in each of the races that are part of his or her mixture -including the White race-regardless of the physical appearance of that person. However, I'm realistic enough to know that many people don't agree with this position and people who are Black/non-Black who assume that they will be fully accepted by that other race are setting themselves up for considerable difficulties- which is another reason why some Black/non-Black people might select the "Black" racial census choice (my built in assumption is that Black people are more accepting of Black/non-Black people than other races. Of course, there are many exceptions to that generality.)
Anonymous — April 28, 2012
Wow, what year is it, 1960? Are we still perpetuating this idea that all mixed folks are tragic mulattos and mestizos in this day and age? This seems so archaic.
Gilbert Pinfold — April 28, 2012
That's a preachy last paragraph for a site for grown-ups; even, dare I say, intellectuals. When did Sociology become 17th century Divinity?
John Hensley — April 28, 2012
What I find odd about these ads is that they fail even as ads. The product is fetishized as something undesirable, except perhaps to weirdos.
Heatherleila — April 29, 2012
This reminds me of the Cavemen in Hollywood Geico ads from a few years ago. Those were also playing with issues of race and discrimination in a dismissive way. I think I remember one line from a Hollywood exec. character saying "Caveman? I didn´t think there were any of you around anymore," and the Caveman is offended and gets up to leave the meeting (he wants to be an actor, which is supposed to be hilarious). There are groups of people (Native Americans, for example) who actually receive offensive comments like these, and Geico turned it into an ad campaign. The ads were so successful they tried to turn them into an awful, short-lived t.v. show.
BalancingJane — April 29, 2012
I started a Change.org petition asking Kraft to pull these offensive ads. I'd really appreciate it if you'd sign it and pass it on. http://chn.ge/IAZFrH
Adopting the Inferior Child – the Untermensch « The Life Of Von — April 29, 2012
[...] to finish a little something to chew on – The Mixed-Race Milk Bite » Sociological Images. Like this:LikeBe the first to like this [...]
Guest — May 2, 2012
I have a good friend in a mixed race relationship. In my country of origin, better opportunities are given to people who are "non-white" (the term used here and which usually includes those who are "previously disadvantaged" due to race - another category used here which includes women and the disabled). We used to have to tick a racial group on birth certificates; however, I don't think we still have to. She and her partner have discussed this eventuality and I was surprised that, as opposed to choosing their right to ignore the tick box, they have decided that they will choose the mixed race category so as to better the child's opportunities. I am not sure what I would do in the same position...
‘Biracial is Bad’: How KRAFT’s MilkBites Campaign Perpetuates Stereotypes & White Supremacy | Bicultural Mom™ — May 12, 2012
[...] truly can’t believe that I have to write what I’m about to write. Via a Sociological Images post by Bradley Koch, I found out about a KRAFT campaign for their new MilkBites, a snack that is [...]
‘Biracial is Bad’: How KRAFT’s MilkBites Campaign Perpetuates Stereotypes & White Supremacy — May 16, 2012
[...] truly can’t believe that I have to write what I’m about to write. Via a Sociological Images post by Bradley Koch, I found out about a KRAFT campaign for their new MilkBites, a snack that is [...]
Jerry Johnson — May 23, 2012
"The rest of us should know better than to perpetuate racism."
Really? Is it that high a priority in your little world?
Ten thousand "racist" white men -- scare quotes employed to denote that there is no infraction, politically-incorrect opinion, or slight too minor to qualify one as such (as demonstrated by your blog post) -- leading otherwise law-abiding lives are less to fear than one young black man with a gun in his waistband and a criminal record to his name.
Allpeople Gifts — May 27, 2012
.
The entire "Tragic Mel" marketing campaign for this
product is so racist and offensive on so many levels
(For example -- the reinforcing of the false and racist
stereotype of ''The Tragic Mulatto'; the reinforcing of
the stereotype of “the closeted-racist White person”
who chooses to 'Fetish-ize’ and / or ‘Objectify’ either
Interracial-Relationships, Mixed-Race / Multiracial
people or People-Of-Color, in general – and worse
yet, expects them to “enjoy it”; etc.) – that one is
led to wonder “What on earth was the marketing
department thinking when they approved of then
created this unnerving and offensive nonsense?”!
.
By the way – listed below, please find links that were
created in HONOR of interracial relationships and of
mixed-race / multiracial people and groups. =D
http://groups.yahoo.com/group/Generation-Mixed/message/4162
https://www.facebook.com/allpeople.gifts/posts/452738141409383
.
'Biracial is Bad': How KRAFT's MilkBites Campaign Perpetuates Stereotypes & White Supremacy — June 9, 2012
[...] truly can’t believe that I have to write what I’m about to write. Via a Sociological Images post by Bradley Koch, I found out about a KRAFT campaign for their new MilkBites, a snack that is [...]