In an interesting article at Slate, Libby Copeland observes that Ron Paul has disproportionate support from young people and men. Why? She cites political scientists explaining that young people, on average, think in more black-and-white terms than older people:
…age and newness to politics predispose young voters to a less nuanced view of the political world. They’re less likely to take the long view, less likely to have patience, less likely to spin out the implications of their political theories.
Ron Paul does, indeed, articulate a straightforward ideology, especially compared to the other candidates.
Copeland doesn’t do as good of a job of explaining why men tend to like him more than women. I wonder, though, if it maybe has something, just a little bit, to do with his branding. Consider this ad:
This ad is a clear adoption of masculinity and a strong rejection of femininity (symbolized by the Shih-Tsu and its supposed weakness). In this sense, his ad is centrally in the genre of ads designed to associate products with MEN, partly by the deliberate exclusion of women and mocking of anything feminine.
It seems to me that Paul has decided to double down on his appeal, focusing on the market that he thinks is most likely to support him, and throwing everyone else out along with the social programs.
Thanks to Letta and Alex for sending along the article and commercials!
Lisa Wade, PhD is an Associate Professor at Tulane University. She is the author of American Hookup, a book about college sexual culture; a textbook about gender; and a forthcoming introductory text: Terrible Magnificent Sociology. You can follow her on Twitter and Instagram.
Comments 94
Yrro Simyarin — January 26, 2012
So, given that the branding in the ad is relatively new, and that high levels of support among young men has been the trademark of his campaign since the beginning of the '08 primary... I can see the argument that he's doubling down on that demographic, but the branding doesn't seem to explain the original support. Especially since a frail old doctor with a non-interventionist stance on the military is about as un-macho as you can get among republican candidates.
Anonymous — January 26, 2012
There is also the part where his philosophy, of freedom from government interference, has traditionally served men far, far better than women. During the era he idolizes marital rape was legal, women were fired for being women and marriage was unescapable. That is a much harder sell to women than it is to men.
Anonymous — January 26, 2012
There is also the part where his philosophy, of freedom from government interference, has traditionally served men far, far better than women. During the era he idolizes marital rape was legal, women were fired for being women and marriage was unescapable. That is a much harder sell to women than it is to men.
cee — January 26, 2012
Personally, the first ad I remember seeing use that style was for Pizza. The truck ads came later.
I don't remember it clearly enough to recall whether it was for 'macho' pizza.
It's certainly a distinctive style, but what about the style (not the content) is inherently masculine? (real question)
cee — January 26, 2012
Also, are you saying that women are like shi-tzus, that shi-tzus are, in fact fierce and powerful, or that men don't like small fluffy dogs? Because two of those are offensive, and they're all plainly untrue.
Ricky — January 26, 2012
It is easy to understand really, men and young people in particular resent being nannied. Naturally they will gravitate towards Dr. Paul since he is the one candidate that seems to authentically share that resentment of the Nannystate.
ctl — January 26, 2012
"That's not a shih-tzu, it looks like a havanese!" I guess I'm not part of his target audience.
Gilbert Pinfold — January 26, 2012
Interesting that RP's two slogans are 'real money' and 'no more faraway wars'. Does the latter being popular with young men amount to some kind of paradox, or maybe a trend?
But certainly, justifying some of America's recent foreign policy in North Africa for example would take more nuance than a tropical sunset.
Anonymous — January 26, 2012
Most of the young men I've seen supporting Paul do so because they think he will legalize pot. [rolls eyes]
Anonymous — January 26, 2012
Most political ads look this way, this is nothing special about Ron Paul.
IamWonderMommy — January 26, 2012
I'm more offended by your suggestions and this article than I am the advertisement! You're essentially claiming because it has semi trucks, pyrotechnics, and a dog with a spiked collar-it's MASCULINE. Who the hell are you to decide what is masculine and what is feminine? Why can I, as a woman, not be as drawn in by the bigger dog or the blown up boxes?! Just because I have a vagina doesn't mean I'm immediately in love with all things small and "cute" or pink! Shame on you for drawing from the same gender stereotypes you supposedly stand against! Here's a hint, pull the foot from your mouth and reassess what you just wrote. FAIL!
astrocomfy — January 26, 2012
Intelligent comments regarding Ron Paul on this thread. I feel like I just fell into an alternate universe or something... :)
Violet — January 26, 2012
Oh, I don't know. In many ways, those who attack Ron Paul are fairly limited in their thinking. Let's take racism. Obama hasn't exactly stopped the war on drugs nor has he pardoned victims of the drug war. Ron Paul is supposedly racist and yet, his policy ideas would result in less incarceration of black men. As an intelligent and educated woman who is also a liberal, I am quite able to grasp that Ron Paul is the only candidate calling for the end of the war on terror and talking about the increasing military presence in our society. This woman can understand that Ron Paul's ideas about the privacy clause in the Constitution are just wrong and I think that he underestimates the extent of sexual harassment in the workplace. Nevertheless, I find this entire post to be decidedly black and white. Expect a little more nuance from this page.
Beth L. — January 26, 2012
I'm a woman, and I like Ron Paul and the ad. I also think that Shih-Tsus are typically pampered dogs that yap a lot, which is a fitting description for most politicians. I'm also a big fan of the Constitution, yet still a feminist! This might make me a bad feminist, but I'd rather vote for the states rights guy than the dude who keeps pretending like he's going to end the wars and bring all our troops home.
Calvinprefect — January 26, 2012
Some excellent points on masculinity but the whole analysis on why Ron Paul gets disproportionate support from younger men is substantially lacking. As a reminder, young voters overwhelmingly vote Democratic. So in that respect, the voter-attitude theory presented above needs to be re-examined.
Violet — January 26, 2012
The number of women in prison, a third of whom are incarcerated for drug offenses, is increasing at nearly double the rate for men. These women often have significant histories of physical and sexual abuse, high rates of HIV infection, and substance abuse. Large-scale women's imprisonment has resulted in an increasing number of children who suffer from their mother's incarceration and the loss of family ties.
Guest — January 26, 2012
Am I the only one that is baffled by candidates pushing to eliminate a variety of cabinet departments (e.g. education, energy, etc)?
Dasha — January 27, 2012
The President cannot make decrees. He relies on the Congress to get things done, the assumption that Ron Paul is somehow the magician that Obama isn't is laughable. And given his ignorance of sociological issues, and his racism (because no matter how you slice it, either he's a racist and he's lying about his newsletters or he's telling the truth and he's too foolish or lazy to check on what was being published in his name), sexism and homophobia, he's not the liberal savior people are apparently looking for. He's all the worst things about Neo-Republicanism wrapped up in a little package of awfulness.
Guest — January 27, 2012
Hmm...ok, if he's only targeting young males, what about these ads?
http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2011/12/29/ron-paul-ad-iowa-2012-newsletters_n_1174298.html
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6R04r4IFjnc
cheap bras — January 29, 2012
Amazing write-up! This could aid plenty of people find out more about this particular issue. Are you keen to integrate video clips coupled with these? It would absolutely help out. Your conclusion was spot on and thanks to you; I probably won’t have to describe everything to my pals. I can simply direct them here!
Culture + Politics — February 7, 2012
[...] more likely than men to support the most moderate candidate left in the GOP primary, Mitt Romney, over his more conservative [...]