In Fair and Foul: Beyond the Myths and Paradoxes of Sport, Stanley Eitzen discusses a number of contradictions in modern sports. One of the most prominent is the way that sports is both unifying and divisive in ways that can be extremely strong. Fans often feel a sense of solidarity simply because they like the same team — whether the local football team or a specific nation’s representative athletes at the Olympics. Individuals who might have little else in common, and might in other aspects of their lives be in conflict, can form a sense of affiliation and friendship through sports fandom.
This is true because fans identify with their teams, talking about “our” team, “our” win, and so on (though, oddly, when the team loses, it’s often “their” loss), often despite the lack of any direct connection to a team (I have relatives involved in constant low-level battles with their spouses about the placement of University of Oklahoma vs. Oklahoma State University memorabilia in their houses, cars, yards, and even pets and children, thought neither spouse attended either school).
Jay Smooth at Ill Doctrine recently put up a video about fan reactions to the NBA finals that awesomely addresses the joy fans take in their love of sports, the social constructedness of these affiliations, and how comments by LeBron James bring this all into view:
Comments 7
Matthew Glidden — June 23, 2011
Nice work by Jay on the video and commentary. I'd add that many find sports involving because it brings them together with friends and family, giving them a language to express shared connections...even if it's basketball fans telling LeBron James that he's falling short of (amazingly high) expectations.
Anonymous — June 23, 2011
Mitchell and Webb have a great sketch about "your team vs my team" and self-insertion: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xN1WN0YMWZU
`david — June 23, 2011
I think Jay is ultimately correct in asserting that sports don't really matter in the grand scheme of things. However, I do think that athletes can and should provide more moral leadership. Anyone in the public eye that much today has a chance to lead. Look at Muhammad Ali. I am in no way comparing Lebron to Ali, but Athletes can make a difference even if their sport doesn't really matter...except that it makes people happy
Riccardo Mario Corato — August 13, 2011
Great job Jay!
Very meaningful, subtle and profound behind the irony.
Keep working on decoding the social construction of reality: it is a very useful job.
Congratulations from Italy.
Riccardo Mario Corato
Jeorge J Waters — March 24, 2023
I have never been a fan of sports, but now I watch various sports matches quite often and try to follow important sporting events. This is due to the fact that I started betting on sports. If you also want to try it, I advise the bookmaker https://mel-bet.et. I think it is good for both beginners and more experienced bettors.