I invite you to spend seven minutes listening to Baratunde Thurston explaining what, exactly, is wrong with the fact that Barack Obama was hounded into releasing his long form birth certificate. He does a wonderful job of historicizing the requirement that Obama prove that he is an American (to a man such as Donald Trump), at the same time that he explains why this questioning of Obama’s citizenship is deeply hurtful to all Black Americans and their allies.
Via BoingBoing. Transcript after the jump (via Racialicious).
Lisa Wade, PhD is an Associate Professor at Tulane University. She is the author of American Hookup, a book about college sexual culture; a textbook about gender; and a forthcoming introductory text: Terrible Magnificent Sociology. You can follow her on Twitter and Instagram.It’s been a very difficult morning for me. Got the news that President Obama released his long-form birth certificate due to the increasing media circus surrounding claims that he is not one of us. That he is not an American. And it comes at a very interesting time for many reasons, one of which is, it’s April 27 2011 and this just happened. So that’s really interesting to me. Also because I’m reading, right now, a book by Manning Marable called Malcolm X a life of reinvention and he unearths a lot of amazing detail and correspondence around this exceptional American. But through this book you also get a window into the civil rights movement throughout this country’s history – especially the 40s 50s and 60s and you are reminded if you read this book or see a documentary special or know anything about the complete history of the United States, you’re reminded of the extraordinary level of sacrifice that has been involved in allowing all Americans to exist as, be treated as, participate as Americans. To be that which they are took a lot of work. A lot of tears, a lot of pain, a lot of death.
There were people who dropped out of their ordinary lives, sacrificed their personal safety, their reputation, their ability to earn money, to intervene on behalf of those who they also saw as American. They got on buses and Freedom Rides. They sat in, they died in waves and waves of domestic terrorism so that someone like me could go to a voting booth and not be asked by some racist poll worker to pay a tax or prove that my grandfather wasn’t a slave or pass a literacy test that got increasingly difficult the more I passed it. And today, the President of the United States had to prove that he was an American, to the satisfaction of the 75 percent of Iowa republicans who doubt that or the 43 percent of National Republicans who believe that or the one heinous low-class individual who took credit for it after: Donald Trump.
A man who was given every advantage – who inherited millions and lost it all twice but had that opportunity because no one’s ever had to ask him to prove anything. A man who lacks intelligence, compassion, common sense, respect, decency, or an understanding of WHAT THE FUCK it means to be an American that he would come out moments after the President of the United States – and I stress that: the President – released his long-form birth certificate – and Donald Trump comes out moments later and says, “I’m really proud of myself – but it shouldn’t have taken so long. I wanna see the birth certificate for myself. I want to test it for authenticity. I don’t want the press asking me about birth certificates anymore.”
I find it hard to summarize in mere words the amount of pain and rage this incident has caused. It’s humiliating – not just to Barack Obama, not just to the office of the President, not just to Black Americans who died and those who supported our quest for freedom. It’s embarrassing to the entire nation that we would sit and let this nation. We have all been debased by this incident. By a charlatan, by a con man, by a mere promoter of himself. And for him to take credit for this, and for him to revel in it, and yet not be satisfied makes him no better than a Klansman. No better than a Bull Connor. No better than an anonymous, privileged white man in the 1950s who, regardless of his position in society, knew his position was higher than that of a common nigger. And that is what the fuck Donald Trump has done to the President of the United States. To the office of the President of the United States. To me. And to you.
I am disgusted. I have cried, because I know my own ancestors paid a very high price, and never would have imagined that we might have the President that we do, but certainly, part of their joy in the ancestral, celestial skies right now has been greatly diminished by what has happened here today. I hope that eventually, not just in the post-mortal world of karma and spiritual justice, Mr. Trump pays an exceptional price. I hope that price comes during his life. To then be able to walk around, a super-free, super-white, super-privileged man lording over all who would pay attention – which is far too many – at what you have done has got to cost you something in this life, as well.
I don’t wanna hear about The Apprentice. I don’t wanna hear about your new cologne. I don’t wanna hear about the new tower you’re building in whatever fuckin’ town. That cologne smells of racism. That tower is built on the blood of disrespected slaves and freedom fighters, and that show is merely a showcase for the dishonor you have brought among anyone who would call themselves an American.
My name is Baratunde Thurston. I’m heartbroken over this.
Comments 100
Snugg — April 28, 2011
Donald Trump is disgusting, I am so sick of seeing and hearing about him.
Eve P. — April 28, 2011
>>he explains why this questioning of Obama’s citizenship is deeply hurtful to all Black Americans and their allies.<<
No, actually, he explains why this questioning of Obama's citizenship is "humiliating, not just to Barack Obama, not just to the office of the president, not just to black Americans who died and those who supported [their] quest for freedom -- it's embarrassing to the entire nation".
I say this not to be nitpicky, but because I think part of his fundamental point is that this goes beyond just "Black Americans and their allies" -- it is shameful to *all* Americans that this happened. Really, I think it's *especially* shameful for those Americans who don't see the problem with it. They may not have enough sense to realize they should feel ashamed and humiliated, but they absolutely should. And you can bet that citizens of many other countries will be looking at America, yet again, as a nation full of bigots and idiots.
Yrro — April 28, 2011
Out of curiosity (and not saying that it explains away the birther nonsense) does anyone know who the last president to be born to a foreign citizen was? A little research on Wikipedia shows that Woodrow Wilson appears to be the most recent whose parents were immigrants, but that's not quite the same thing.
It's somewhat unfortunate that we don't have a recent white president whose eligibility is even vaguely plausibly in doubt to compare as a control.
It is an interesting aspect of Obama's presidency that his election may show some proof of how far Americans have come on racism (although 90% of blacks voting for him sends a bit of a mixed message), but I don't think it has actually done anything to continue to improve those relations :(
Sophia — April 28, 2011
Is there any chance of getting a transcript of what the video says, please? I'm deaf and can't exactly "spend seven minutes listening to Baratunde Thurston explaining" anything.
Katie — April 28, 2011
There is one on www.feministing.com
m Andrea — April 28, 2011
That was a really powerful video, thank you. Hope lots of people see that.
Alicia — April 28, 2011
Trump's creation of this racially motivated spectacle and use of it for his own political visibility is morally reprehensible for many reasons. The most prominent of these reasons is who he indirectly injures the most: minority children, particularly those in the working class. As a former Teach for America teacher of Puerto Rican, Mexican, Dominican, Bengali and African American students in Manhattan, I was shocked to find that my students equated being American with being white. They would use this descriptor of nationality to describe someone's race, as in, "oh yeah he's American," but meaning "he's white." This entire situation completely underscores the question of whether one's full "Americanness" can be questioned because of one's race, and who is truly "American." Is this the message we want to send our children - yes, anyone can be President, but if you're not white, prepare for people to question not only your policies or ability to lead, but your citizenship and integrity? The damage done by this may not be easily seen or measured but it is there, a nudging reminder of those powerful individuals in society who would reify racial differences and use them to create or maintain advantage. What will you do, Mr. Trump, to correct this implicitly unwelcoming and marginalizing message that you have sent to our nation's Black, Latino, and multiracial students that their full Americanness can be questioned by people like you because of the color of their skin or the origin of their parents? They are sharp to the tone of these conversations in our country, and that's what they've learned from you.
karla — April 28, 2011
Let all reasonable people boycott Trump and anyone or any business that embraces "Birthers" and their hateful racism. Don't watch Fox news, listen to Rush Limbaugh et. al, or buy anything from any business that contributes their voice or money to supporting these Racist Elitists. Enlist your friends and neighbors. We have to rise up strong against this!
John Yum — April 28, 2011
I have wondered if Trump is using this to up his own ratings, and that he'll be "opening the curtains" at some point; pulling a celebrity stunt and telling the US, "You're fired." I can imagine that his popularity would jump (if he did it right): he shows up the birthers for having believed him, thus elevating his popularity among the "anti-birthers", and he shows up the "main stream media" for having believed him, thus elevating his popularity among the US right.
I keep looking at his "candidacy" and wondering, "WTF's in it for him?" I cannot see any long term political capital that he could gain from birtherism. That he's crowing about pulling off a "victory" (along with very dangerous statements of invading other countries for their oil) only shows me how shallow, near-sighted, and populist a political campaign he is running. If all of this is a con, however, then (again, if he sells it right) he can capitalize on it as an entertainer known for his who-the-fuck-cares-what-you-think attitude.
In that light, this insistence of playing up the birther card (and then immediately turning around and blaming the press when the talk to him about it) makes a kind of twisted sense, since it leads birthers, a plurality of the GOP, and many many media types further down the rabbit hole (all the greater patsies when the curtain is opened). However, although a part of me really wishes that he run for president (the same part of me that liked watching what happened to my SimCity as I clicked repeatedly on the "natural disaster" button), the rational part of my head is saying, "What if he is dead serious about what he's saying? What if he's not kidding around?"
It is to the rational part of my mind that I find myself agreeing full-heartedly with Baratunde's video commentary. This is my president, and the actions taken against him have done nothing to help the country and have only diminished the national dialogue and diminished the office of the presidency and its legitimacy. This (and so many other actions) have legitemized an avenue of racism and thrown back the clock on race relations, while creating a lot of distraction and "cover" for other things that are actually going on that are hurting the country, such as restricting new voter registration, government union contract negotiations, killing federal social programs, etc.
While it is fun to occasionally watch a bull run rampant in a china shop, if that china shop is ours, WE are the ones that will have to clean up the mess and rebuild. The bull suffers next to nothing.
Anonymous — April 28, 2011
Yes, Donald Trump is a piece of shit but we can't get so caught up in this that we forget how terrible of a job Obama is doing as president:
An extension of the wars to Pakistan and Yemen which has involved the deaths of many civilians in faceless drone attacks (which he has made jokes about: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WWKG6ZmgAX4)
A healthcare bill that makes it illegal not to have a healthcare plan with private companies.
Guantanamo Bay is still open and operational which is so absurd that detainees are not even allowed to have Casio watches (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_Guantanamo_Bay_detainees_accused_of_possessing_Casio_watches)
The list could go on.
Rickey — April 28, 2011
Damn, Donald, trollin the President of the United States in real life. Epic Win!
politicaobscura — April 28, 2011
You do all realize that Gov. George Romney was attacked a few decades back for his place of birth when running for President, right? Or is that fact completely inconvenient to the facts at hand. Oh, in case you didn't know, Romney was white.
Here are four of the hundreds of newspaper articles from that time.
http://news.google.com/newspapers?id=icJPAAAAIBAJ&sjid=ZJMDAAAAIBAJ&pg=3059,2673197&dq=george+romney+birth&hl=en
http://news.google.com/newspapers?id=SVdQAAAAIBAJ&sjid=OFcDAAAAIBAJ&pg=7051,3815949&dq=george+romney+birth&hl=en
http://news.google.com/newspapers?id=-2ZYAAAAIBAJ&sjid=2vcDAAAAIBAJ&pg=7188,3796491&dq=george+romney+birth&hl=en
http://news.google.com/newspapers?id=yck0AAAAIBAJ&sjid=JGkFAAAAIBAJ&pg=2560,5670104&dq=george+romney+birth&hl=en
TTT — April 28, 2011
My ancestors were owned by the Egyptians, the Mesopotamians, the Greeks, the Romans, the Huns, and the Spanish. Do I feel that any of those cultures owe me something now? Should I?
Barack Obama was born to a white mother in Hawaii. Doesn't that make him white? His black father was African, not American at all. And there is no indication that his father or any of his ancestors were owned by anyone. How could he know what being the great grand children of slaves feels like? Obama isn't black any more than he is white, not that it matters at all.
Is he a could President? He had two years and control of both houses and all he managed to get done was a poor excuse for health care reform and he had to cheat the numbers make it seem like he could pay for it. He didn't do anything about the deficit, he didn't even acknowledge the problem until the Republicans and the Tea Party made it their ticket back into Congress. Wasn't it a problem before then?
I'd love to see President Obama succeed. In order to do that, he needs to STOP CAMPAIGNING and START GOVERNING. He's surrounded himself with a bunch of second rate talent and that's to be expected of someone with so little experience in Washington. He couldn't very well ask the best people to do the jobs because they might show him up, detract from his continued campaigning. That and no one with real talent would take his calls. Where was Colin Powell as Secretary of State? Hillary Clinton? Seriously? Leon Panetta as Defense Secretary and Gen. Petraeus to head the CIA? Did they read the order wrong?
Until 09 the highest position Panetta served was three years as Clinton's chief of staff. Now he gets to head up the the most expensive part of the federal budget? I get warm fuzzy feelings.
I am not asking for Barack Obama to be a great black president. Nor do I hope he is a great white president. I only pray that he become a great president.
Paul — April 28, 2011
Maybe I'm missing something, but why is the date April 27, 2011 really interesting?
Otherwise, great video!
Anonymous — April 28, 2011
1.) Before the African slave trade, people were not slaves based on the color of their skin. They were slaves because they were conquered peoples, often considered "savages" by the conquerers. African slave trade ended much, much more recently than those other instances so it's still a pretty important subject to people who are just a few generations away from enslaved relatives.
2.) Black people have been systematically screwed over up until today so obviously the issue is still important. People are often treated poorly for having black skin not because the person or people treating them badly knows they are a descendant of slaves or has a white mother or father but because they are black-skinned.
3.) I agree, I think that Obama is doing a terrible job as president but what can you expect from the second most enthusiastic capitalist party?
Darkwing Duck — April 29, 2011
Hey, Hawai'i? I'm sorry that the Mainland is dissing your birth certificates hardcore. I understand that the very questioning of President Obama's nationality is the result of his race. At the same time, the dismissal of the "short form" of his birth certificate has, I think, more than a teeny-tiny bit to do with the fact that his birth was registered in a state that happens to be made up of islands out in the Pacific that mainlanders treat as little more than a charming vacation destination and a military base.
Modern day colony, anyone?
m — April 29, 2011
Really makes you want to tear your hair out. It just goes to show, that you can climb to the top of the bloddy world, rule the world's most powerful nation - an all you'll be to these people is still someone less than the white, male, cis stright, able bodied ideal. It's incredible.
TTT — April 29, 2011
Most schools in America are segregated? That's 100% hogwash. Name ONE public school that is segregated.
SamR — April 29, 2011
Please forgive my ignorance, but does the President have to show a (short form?) birth certificate at some point, and why wasn't the short form good enough?
Goodbye CA — April 30, 2011
We need to ask ourselves; "would Obama have been elected if he was the exact same person, only having one difference; white skin?"
I say no, he would not have been. The margin that propelled him to the top was an extremely large turnout of black voters. A group, when polled, expressed that the MAIN reason they voted for Obama, was that he was black. That is racism, and is not one bit different from a white voter who did not vote for Obama because he was black. Both are wrong.
If you remove color from the equation, Obama would not have made it far into the primary season, as the media which was enamored with him, would have examined and exposed his lack of qualifications and his questionable background.
I know some of you will take umbrage with this; but please ask yourself, if there had been a white but very junior senator running against Hillary, who would have won? I say Obama won ONLY because of his race.
Say it. I Dare You (jr) - Page 624 - CurlTalk — April 30, 2011
[...] [...]
Sisou — May 1, 2011
I love how people conveniently forgot that before the primaries many thought Hilary would win the Black votes.The majority of Blacks ( at the time according to polls, favored the Clintons). Blacks btw helped elect Bill Clinton ( duh). But you are ignoring that fact and how Bill and Hilary were both race baiting during the campaign. They lost South Carolina and clearly could not believe a Black man could beat them. Instead of trying to prove to Blacks that they were worthy of their votes, they spent the rest of the primaries insulting us. It was their words that ensured the landslide.
And btw, John Mccain voted against MLK day three times
Guess what Blacks read, pay attention and vote for the best person based on our unique needs and the needs of the country. PERIOD!
*knows she shouldn't feed the trolls but can't help herself*
Catherine — May 3, 2011
You know, it isn't automatically racist for black people to vote for a black canddidate or for white people to vote for white candidates.
If you and a candidate share goals, values or objectives, the fact that you share a skin color or ethnic background is irrelevant.
I find the whole birther thing to be embarassing to all of us, white as well as black. I also find it to be a bunch of whiney Republican babies throwing tantrums because they didn't win the election.
Shame on your birthers!
Derangierte Einsichten - Linkspam: Rage against Everybody — May 5, 2011
[...] dafür gefunden, dass die Urkunde eine Fälschung ist. Aber noch mehr: Obama gibt hier einem rassistischen Gedankengut nach, nach dem Schwarze eben keine »echten US-Amerikaner« sein [...]
Friday Link Roundup | BasBleuStocking — May 6, 2011
[...] certificate, which focuses exclusively on politics. To my mind, it isn’t as compelling as this, which discusses why it ultimately did more harm than [...]
Juan — May 9, 2011
""Anonymous 9:12 pm on May 8, 2011 | # Neighborhoods aren’t segregated based om racism. Nice try. You are a moron and a fool. Not only do you not know what you are talking about, you don’t know what anyone else is talking about. Your use of generalities and vast assumptions indicates you haven’t studied any social sciences.""
History. White Flight. Gerrymandering. Now go do some studying and stop making yourself look silly.
Aos tv v18.0.5 — April 24, 2020
I am not very good at writing, after I saw this very good website, I became excited to write smarter. Aos tv v18.0.5
whatsapp plus — September 28, 2020
It's no wonder that in recent whatsapp plus became a huge part of our lives. It's conveyears nient quick and easy to use.
whatsapppluspro – Yts Subtitle — September 30, 2020
[…] https://thesocietypages.org/socimages/2011/04/28/understanding-the-demand-for-obamas-birth-certifica… […]