David F. sent in a fun example of public resistance to a gendered advertising message. ITA Software put up an ad on public transportation in Boston that plays on the idea of moms as particularly inept about technology. Universal Hub posted a photo taken of the ad on the Red Line, with a Post-It someone added:
Also see our earlier post on public resistance to a Pretzel Thins ad in New York.
Gwen Sharp is an associate professor of sociology at Nevada State College. You can follow her on Twitter at @gwensharpnv.
Comments 47
kutsuwamushi — February 21, 2011
One thing that puzzles me about the technologically-inept mom stereotype is that women are still more often employed in clerical positions than men, and these days, that requires working familiarity with computers.
Developers are more likely to be men than women, still, but how many people's dads are developers?
SamR — February 21, 2011
Seems more age discriminatory, as in older people are less tech-savvy.
m — February 21, 2011
Well done indeed! This is the kind of things that tick my mom off - she's a lawyer who has done most of her work on either typewriter or computer for decades, but still got an informative handbook explaining what a mouse was a few years ago. She's been keeping tabs on her own inheritence, savings and pension for all of her adult life, and but still get a stock salesman acting like she doesn't know the first thing about saving in stock, all because of her age and gender. Seriously, is it so hard to believe that grown women can have skills beyond home making?
nakedthoughts — February 21, 2011
though I would say this is calling out SEXIST advertising, not just "gendered."
ואמא שלי DBA, הא! « משהו לנשנש כשהאורחים יגיעו — February 21, 2011
[...] מדברות על מתמטיקה ומדעי המחשב וטכנולוגיה בארוחות שבת. ודודה שלי היא דוקטור לפסיכולוגיה, ואמא של [...]
Basiorana — February 21, 2011
Calling out sexist, gendered, and AGEIST advertising. Ageism is important here. Advertisers may accept that a 50-something person could use a computer, though never hack. They may accept that a young woman could use a computer AND hack. But an older woman? INCONCEIVABLE
fog — February 21, 2011
This is just like a question I had on an exam not long ago! We were asked to explain a concept from the class to our mother. My mother is a professor of that same subject, so she definitely wouldn't need it explained by me! Regardless of my mother's job, though, I was not pleased to see that a specifically female person was invoked - why not imagine explaining to a friend who'd never taken a course in the subject?!
PharaohKatt — February 22, 2011
As well as the ageism and sexism, I notice they're using an outdated model of left-brain/right-brain split. This woman knows that that's a myth!
James Strong — February 22, 2011
Confirmation bias at its finest. This advertisment is about older people not being tech-savvy, not about moms being less tech-savvy than dads. There might very well be an ad or a gazillion ad's about fathers not being good at using computers, but since no one thinks those are sexist they go under the radar. The only ones that get posted on websites like these are the ones that talk about women, so then people automatically assume that the ad is sexist.
K — February 22, 2011
Reminds me of the grossness of the "It's Time to Tell Mum" campaign against Internet censorship here in Australia.
http://hoydenabouttown.com/20100601.7577/the-lamb-roast-roundup-mums-and-censorship/
song — February 22, 2011
Did something like that when I took college stats. The question wanted a lay explanation of something - I forget what now - but the phrasing was, "Explain in terms your mother would understand..."
I wrote, "This is where I should probably mention that my mother developed and teaches the stats curriculum at her school."
Explain it to mother | Critical Sass — February 23, 2011
[...] Nir Rosen tops all crass Lara Logan commentsExplain it to mother Posted on February 23, 2011 by GinaSociological Images featured this funny reaction to gendered advertising. The advertisement plays upon the patronising [...]
But he’s really a nice linkspam (24th February, 2011) | Geek Feminism Blog — February 24, 2011
[...] “My mom has a PhD in Math” – fighting back against gendered advertising. [...]
Green — February 24, 2011
While that is indeed a stupid ad, that's not "gendered" advertising, that's just misogynistic advertising.
"Gendered advertising" would be advertising that acknowledges that human beings come in male and female varieties, which would be - oh wait, that's already everything ever.
This is an example of sexism in tech recruitment. « Restructure! — February 25, 2011
[...] photo by Jessie Bennett (via Sociological Images and Geek Feminism [...]
Brewster — March 4, 2011
ITA is notoriously lame with their hiring ads. It irks me that they're supposedly a legimate software company, but they keep insisting that they want to hire 'hackers', which is industry slang for undisciplined programmers.
"Hackers with people skills" is an oxymoron.
Erik — March 21, 2011
I'm not completely certain that it's invoking a stereotype of women being stupid and therefore unable to grasp technological concepts. It may be that and/or the other tired old trope that women just don't give a shit about gadgetry.
No Comment: “Even Your Wife Can Turn on the DVD!” : Ms Magazine Blog — April 28, 2011
[...] to find other examples like this one–AudioOne’s ad is eerily reminiscent of a recent subway poster. That one, thankfully, was tactfully defaced, but what could be [...]
Women in CS: Good Ol’ Sexism in STEM » {blog} — October 12, 2011
[...] Time! Women in CS: Good Ol’ Sexism in STEM by admin Posted on October 12, 2011 repost from Sociological Images If you can’t read the sticky note, it says “My Mom has a PhD in math”Whenever I [...]
Dev — November 11, 2011
If I had to phrase a "explain it simply" direction, I would go with something like "Explain it to a fourth grader, who has the vocabulary, education, and attention span of a fourth grader. Good Luck"
11 Sexist Tech Ads | Sinister News Network — August 4, 2015
[…] Throw in some ageism with your sexism and you get a lot of -ism. Note that someone added a note that reads, “My mom has a PHD in Math.” On the Boston subway, from 2011, via. […]
11 Sexist Tech Ads | Bullet Metro — November 3, 2015
[…] Throw in some ageism with your sexism and you get a lot of -ism. Note that someone added a note that reads, “My mom has a PHD in Math.” On the Boston subway, from 2011, via. […]
11 Sexist Tech Ads - encun — November 24, 2015
[…] Throw in some ageism with your sexism and you get a lot of -ism. Note that someone added a note that reads, “My mom has a PHD in Math.” On the Boston subway, from 2011, via. […]