Flashback Friday.
Sociologists are lucky to have amongst them a colleague who is doing excellent work on the modeling industry and, in doing so, offering us all a rare sophisticated glimpse into its economic and cultural logics. We’ve featured Ashley Mears‘ work twice in posts discussing the commodification of models’ bodies and the different logics of high end and commercial fashion.
In a post at Jezebel, Mears exposes the Model Search. Purportedly an opportunity for model hopefuls to be discovered, Mears argues that it functions primarily as a networking opportunity for agents, who booze and schmooze it up with each other, while being alternatively bored and disgusted by the girls and women who pay to be there.
“Over a few days,” Mears explains:
…thousands arrived to impress representatives from over 100 international modeling and talent agencies. In the modeling showcase alone, over 500 people ages 13-25 strutted down an elevated runway constructed in the hotel’s ballroom, alongside which rows of agents sat and watched.
But the agents are not particularly interested in scouting. In shadowing them during the event, Mears finds that they “actually find it all rather boring and tasteless.” Pathetic, too.
Mears explains:
The saddest thing at a model search contest is not the sight of girls performing womanhood defined as display object. Nor is it their exceedingly slim chances to ever be the real deal. What’s really sad is the state of the agents: they sit with arms folded, yawning regularly, checking their BlackBerrys. After a solid two hours, Allie has seen over 300 contestants. She’s recorded just eight numbers for callbacks.
…
Meanwhile, agents ridicule the wannabe runway, from the “hooker heels” to the outfit choices. About their physiques, [one agent recounts,] “I’ve never seen so many out of shape bodies.”
While model hopefuls are trading sometimes thousands of dollars for a 30-second walk down the runway, the agents are biding their time until they can head to the hotel bar to “…gossip, network, and commence the delicate work of negotiating the global trade in models…” One agent explains:
To be honest it’s just a networking event. The girls, most of them don’t even have the right measurements. For most of them, today is going to be a wake-up call.
Indeed, networking is the real point of the event. The girls and women who come with dreams of being a model are largely, and unwittingly, emptying their pockets to subsidize the schmooze.
To add insult to injury, what many of the aspiring models don’t know is that, for “…$5,000 cheaper, any hopeful can walk into an agency’s ‘Open Call’ for an evaluation.”
I encourage you to read Mears’ much longer exposé at Jezebel.
Originally posted in 2010.
Lisa Wade, PhD is an Associate Professor at Tulane University. She is the author of American Hookup, a book about college sexual culture; a textbook about gender; and a forthcoming introductory text: Terrible Magnificent Sociology. You can follow her on Twitter and Instagram.
Comments 56
Sue — September 20, 2010
Great timing. This morning I saw a "Local Hero" feature on TV that appalled me. It involved a beauty contestant veteran (don't suppose she won anything big) who was making sick little girls' "dream come true," a chance to walk a runway at NY's Fashion Week. It was ridiculous, the girls looked like little whores, strutting in short skirts. Then there was a shot of a little girl who wasn't photogenic, because of a bandage over her eye.
I couldn't help thinking, "This is the 'New Yorker of the Week'"?
Sue — September 20, 2010
Here's a link to the story:
http://www.ny1.com/content/features/125663/nyer-of-the-week--former-pageant-competitor-lets-young-patients-enjoy-glamour
Jihad Punk 77 — September 20, 2010
these models are like cattle, parading out to be judged for their bodies. Despicable and depressing.
Hilary — September 20, 2010
A quote from the full story made my blood run cold: "Now I can typically tell if a girl is at the bone and can't lose anymore, and you have a little, um, bit of tush you can shed."
I know, the modelling industry is heartless, but that "At the bone" really drove it home.
Woz — September 20, 2010
So it's essentially the modeling version of the ASA meetings?
"Indeed, networking is the real point of the event. The girls and women who come with dreams of being a model are largely, and unwittingly, emptying their pockets to subsidize the schmooze."
Just replace "girls and women" with "graduate students," replace "dreams of being a model" with "desperate attempt to get anyone to take their no-name work seriously," and you've described every experience I've had at the meetings.
I don't feel this is particular to the modeling industry at all -- in any industry, the people trying to break in have to rigidly over-conform themselves to expectations while those who hold the power generally couldn't care less and are mostly there for the booze, networking, and free-ish vacation
Tom M. — September 20, 2010
The open calls at modelling agencies aren't any better. The unscrupulous ones sign the kids up for expensive "lessons" then send them to an allied (and expensive) photographer for the requisite portfolio shots. It goes nowhere.
Ames — September 20, 2010
Gosh, the very idea that men who make money on trading in woman-flesh (not unlike livestock traders, gee!) are actually low down, dirty boors is just a huge shock.
While it's obviously important that this research gets done and that industry gets exposed, it's still frustrating that we have to return to "the patriarchy hates women 101" repeatedly.
How about if we stipulate that and continue having somewhat more advanced conversations about how the patriarchy keeps getting women and men, girls and boys, to go along with the program.
Sally — September 20, 2010
There's an extra layer here when you strip away the feminist issues. (And there are a lot of disgusting misogynistic stuff here.)
This is a scam aimed primarily at minors. It's offensive when pyramid schemes prey on adults with lies, but these girls (and most of them are girls) lack the life experience to understand that this is about money, not about discovering talent. (Also, the whole "adolescent brains aren't fully formed" thing factors in.)
I know I didn't know what an open call was until I read this. Kids and parents may not realize that they have other options to get discovered.
They never mention parents in this article. It makes me wonder what kind of power they have to stop their child from going, and if they support their daughters participating. If their teens have a bank account, a credit card or a part time job, the girls could get the $5,000 without their parents knowing. (Or without parents knowing until the money is already gone.)
Sue — September 20, 2010
The little girls in the story I linked to and the teenagers in the article featured above are obviously on the same spectrum.
I don't know why some of you aren't seeing that.
The point of many behind-the-scenes stories about models and the fashion industry is they're treated almost as if they were sex workers (except for the top 1%). It's not glamorous.
It's not appropriate for young girls to sashay down runways in high heels and in any kind of clothing and makeup.
I think some of you need a reality check.