Binyavanga Wainaina does an excellent job, in this 3-minute video, describing ways that “Africa” tends to be written about in the West. See how many of the tropes you recognize:
To paraphrase Jose, at Thick Culture, it’s important to be engaged with the world, but our engagement shouldn’t be entirely on our terms. And, especially, not terms in which the Western world gets to construct itself as the savior of the less fortunate (e.g., Avatar).
Such ideas make it seem as if underdeveloped parts of the world are somehow inherently deficient (culturally or otherwise). When, in fact, insofar as underdeveloped parts of Africa or other continents need saving, it is partly (largely?) because of (1) a history of colonialism that stole their resources and disrupted their societies and (2) the current global economic system that continues to put them at a devastating disadvantage.
See also: The Single Story of “Africa”
Lisa Wade, PhD is an Associate Professor at Tulane University. She is the author of American Hookup, a book about college sexual culture; a textbook about gender; and a forthcoming introductory text: Terrible Magnificent Sociology. You can follow her on Twitter and Instagram.
Comments 52
mordicai — January 6, 2010
This is great.
Rolton — January 6, 2010
Just to clarify, the piece is indeed written by Binyavanga Wainaina (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Binyavanga_Wainaina), but the actor who narrates the article in this video is Djimon Hounsou (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Djimon_Hounsou).
ptp — January 6, 2010
What is with your fixation on Avatar? There have been plenty of 'white savior' movies in the last few years that were far more patronizing and far less self-aware. Trying to shoehorn Avatar in as the poster child for the white savior trope is bizarre to me.
Underaged — January 6, 2010
Love this, saw it on feministing.
It's interesting that the written work was titled "How to Write About Africa".
I wonder why the people who turned this into a video thought the sarcasm wouldn't be understood.
apocalyptopia — January 6, 2010
It annoys me when people lump all of Africa together like it's one big country. A few years ago at the trucking company I worked for in L.A. we had a guy from Nairobi and a guy that grew up right outside Johannesburg on our security team. Everyone else just called them "the Africans".
(v)ictoria — January 6, 2010
I've seen this video before, and found it ironic that its production seems to be sponsored by the (RED) campaign, a group started by mostly white westerners and celebrities who promoted the idea that shopping for their special red products can help poor Black people.
see:
http://adage.com/article?article_id=115287
http://buylesscrap.org/
Nonetheless, the content of the original text is extremely important, so I will give credit where due.
Ranah — January 6, 2010
- They still have resources. Why aren't they using them? Isn't it because of lack of knowledge?
- How exactly is our economy responsible for them not having a working economy?
- Was it possible not to disrupt their culture? What would have happened if we didn't disrupt it?
Jeremy — January 6, 2010
Along these lines, here's a great talk by an African woman, Chimamanda Adichie at TED: http://www.ted.com/talks/lang/eng/chimamanda_adichie_the_danger_of_a_single_story.html
"The Danger of a Single Story" discusses Africa in particular, but is applicable to any people, country, or religion and how we perceive it. It gets at the root of why we have the prejudices we do, that we hear only one story about someplace and assume everyone there is that way.
Craig — January 6, 2010
I just resent the narrator because of his accent and diction. Why can't I have that kind of voice?
Have you heard Chiwetel Ejiofor's Othello? I think Shakespeare, wherever he is, is finally saying, "Yes, that's what I was hoping for." Naxos Audiobooks, if you didn't hear it live or on BBC radio.
andrea — January 7, 2010
"Underdeveloped" is a conflicting term, unless such countries ARE deficient.
Dan — January 7, 2010
Note: English is not my first language.
When we only mention that the root of all problems in Africa are (as the author stated):
(1) a history of colonialism that stole their resources and disrupted their societies.
2) the current global economic system that continues to put them at a devastating disadvantage.
...is it really a surprise that Westerners want to construct themselves as the saviors of Africa? After all, this argument states that the West has a moral responsibility towars Africa for what they did in the past and should also repair the damage for what they are doing now. This argument implies that because all the problems in Africa are caused by the West, only the West can solve them somehow.
Sure, the state of many African countries has a lot to do with what the West has done and is doing right now. Nevertheless, if you rule out government corruption, geography and other factors that have seriously impacted the development of many areas from the argument, you are essentially saying that "it's all about the West". That leaves no room for what many Africans can do to improve their situation, implying that they are just helpless without Western intervention.
Beccy — January 9, 2010
Loved it!
However, I can't help but have issues with the "mutilated genitals" comment. This is still a major issue in some countries within Africa, and needs to be continued to be discussed, rather than ignored so as not to damage people's perceptions of the continent.
However, at the same time I realise that genital mutilation is a serious problem in areas outside of Africa, by no means excluding male "circumcision" in the US, and so it is unfair for the issue to be associated with and addressed in relation to the region. Furthermore, as discussed here http://thesocietypages.org/socimages/2008/05/13/spanish-ads-compare-women-with-genital-cutting-to-fuck-toys/ people who have undergone this horrid practice should not be defined by lack of intact genitalia, ignoring personality, history, life achievments etc.
hmm...
My Maasai Life: Romanticizing Kenya » Sociological Images — February 10, 2010
[...] Recently Lisa posted a video listing suggestions for how not to write about Africa, pointing out the ubiquity of a number of stereotypes and tropes used in novels or memoirs set in African countries. [...]
Erasing the City of Nairobi | Scientopia Guests' Blog — August 4, 2011
[...] also: How Not to Write about Africa and The Single Story of “Africa.” Tags: Africa, Kenya, race, [...]
klehkelly — September 30, 2011
That's not Binyavanga Wainainain the clip, it's Djimon Hounsou reading Binyavanga Wainain's piece "How to write about Africa". Has someone pointed this out yet?
maxporter — March 10, 2012
Transcript, please?
Rebecca Campbell — April 26, 2012
Don't forget to mention that the way Africa has been portrayed in the history is totally screwed up