In recent weeks, we’ve seen multiple examples of women on the political right straddling two kinds of womanhood: the girlboss and the tradwife. The visibility of these women exposes a hidden link between conservative womanhood and girlboss feminism that deserves our attention.
Katie Britt broadcast her response to the State of the Union from her kitchen. Michelle Morrow, the conservative activist from North Carolina who has just been elected state Superintendent of Education in North Carolina, burnishes her credentials as a wife and mother above all else.
They aren’t the first to do this; #tradlife has been trending since at least 2019. Tradwife influencers perform a version of femininity that leans on a strong husband providing financial support so they can devote themselves to caring for children and the home. There is almost always an apron, a kitchen, and a perfectly coiffed, carefully made-up woman in a serene environment cooking from scratch recipes — a vibe that belies the real chaos of having young humans to care for in a home.
We might assume that tradwives hearken back to an earlier “backward” mode of femininity and marriage. But this way of being in the world is unmistakably modern because it involves “choice” and entrepreneurship. It is not enough for a tradwife to simply focus on her husband and kids, she must be entrepreneurial about it. She must blog about it, vlog about it, become an influencer. This is where the “girlboss” mentality comes in.
Sheryl Sandberg’s 2013 book Lean In told women that if they would just ask for what they wanted in the workplace, like the men, they too would advance. But women continue to face barriers in corporate America and marginalization in labor markets. Despite this girlboss feminism has been incorporated into our culture across the political spectrum. US women widely believe structural problems are with women ourselves. With individual effort, good planning, the right domestic help, and a little luck and chutzpah, we can overcome societal inequalities. We rely on a myth of mutuality that belies the true gender division of labor in American families.
It turned out lean-in feminism was both colorblind and a sham. And the #tradwives know it – there are even Black tradwife influencers. They say proudly: we have decided it’s way too exhausting to run the family and corporate America at the same time. So we will focus on our family and “opt out” of the vulnerability and constant stress of the labor market, which values our labor less. And in doing so, we take a stand with men and shore up the dying ideology of the father as breadwinner. We choose this, and you too can see just how great this choice is on our successful TikTok channels.
As we discuss in depth in our new book, The Gender Order of Neoliberalism, U.S. has long drawn soft power from the idea that its women are “empowered.” Not “backward,” like those oppressed women in the Middle East or India or Africa, who are poor and come from patriarchal cultures. Our women, we like to tell the world, make choices of their own, work outside the home in high-powered jobs, fly planes, and even save women in other parts of the world.
But focusing on the individual choices of women who must “do it all” was not always what “women’s empowerment” meant. We show in our book that women involved in transnational feminist organizing in the 1950s and 60s lobbied for reproductive justice, fair pay for fair work, universal childcare, universal healthcare, and fair trade between countries. Those visions of empowerment have all but disappeared from our collective political imaginations. What would a joyful life look like if there were community kitchen tables, childcare collectives, and widely available healthcare? Where are the inviting visuals for that kind of empowerment?
Our impoverished feminist imagination leaves us straddling the skinny divide between tradwives and girlbosses and reinforcing the notion that women should continue to be America’s social safety net.
Smitha Radhakrishnan is Marion Butler McLean Professor in the History of Ideas and Professor of Sociology at Wellesley College. She is author of Making Women Pay: Microfinance in Urban India.
Cinzia D. Solari is Associate Professor of Sociology at University of Massachusetts Boston. She is author of On the Shoulders of Grandmothers: Gender, Migration, and Post-Soviet Nation-Building.
Comments 81
lindango — June 17, 2024
This is a really helpful post. Thank you very much for sharing it for me and everyone to know. Play game penalty shooters 2 free.
Harry Parker — June 18, 2024
hi nice information
slice master — June 19, 2024
Although girlboss and tradwives feminism are opposites, both are family-oriented.
Wilson Williamson — June 19, 2024
slice master is an interesting game that you should try. Definitely not a waste of your time.
Clark Kent — June 19, 2024
Hailey's Treasure Adventure latest version is a charming mobile game where players embark on a quest with Hailey to uncover hidden treasures across enchanting landscapes. With puzzles to solve and obstacles to overcome, it promises an engaging and delightful journey for adventurers of all ages.
James — June 21, 2024
I think someone often overlooked in the #tradwife discourse is that this is primarily, or at least has it's origins as, a sexual fetish first, rather than any sort of ideological project. Most early tradwife content is fetish content, and many tradwife influencers are themselves either current or former adult entertainers.
Raymond M. Dennis — June 23, 2024
In the realm of space exploration, the SpaceX Starship and Falcon 9 stand as formidable contenders. The Starship, a colossal vessel designed for interplanetary travel, dwarfs its predecessor, the Falcon 9, in both size and ambition, starship vs falcon heavy thrust. While the Falcon 9 has proven its reliability with numerous launches, the Starship aims to revolutionize space travel by embracing full reusability, potentially reducing costs significantly.
Linda Walters — June 24, 2024
Highly recommend this Ryan Gosling Drive Jacket to any fan or anyone who loves a classic varsity style. America Jackets has tons of styles and sizes, so check them out!
Shannon — June 25, 2024
Feminism has been watered down since the 1980s in order to appeal to men. This is liberal, or choice, feminism. Unfortunately, it is another tool of the patriarchy. Radical feminism is what seeks to liberate women, so is there any surprise that it is misunderstood and demonized, even by women?
Anna — June 26, 2024
Godrej Woodscapes is a premium residential project that blends modern living with the serenity of nature. Nestled amidst lush greenery, this development offers beautifully designed homes with top-notch amenities, ensuring a perfect balance of comfort and luxury. Ideal for those seeking a tranquil yet contemporary lifestyle, Godrej Woodscapes promises a haven where you can unwind and rejuvenate.
isadoraabhaya — July 3, 2024
This is a really useful post. Thank you for sharing it with the world and myself. Play game baby in yellow free.
Harry Edward — July 5, 2024
It's intriguing to observe how contemporary conservatism navigates between traditional femininity and modern entrepreneurialism, blending the roles of "tradwives" and "girlbosses". This fusion, as highlighted by figures like Katie Britt and Michelle Morrow, reveals a complex narrative where domesticity intertwines with entrepreneurship, challenging conventional notions of gender roles and empowerment. Your insights into the societal dynamics and the evolution of feminist ideals offer a compelling perspective on how these narratives shape our understanding of women's choices and societal roles.
aniwaves.cc — July 8, 2024
well done
asfaf .nea — July 8, 2024
this is really wonderful i just love it >>>>>>>>>> baby in yellow
Hemoni — July 8, 2024
This is a really helpful post. Thank you very much for sharing it for me and everyone to know. Play game uno online free.
mina12 mina — July 9, 2024
candy clicker 2 Thank you for producing such a fascinating essay on this subject. This has sparked a lot of thought in me, and I'm looking forward to reading more.
cookie clicker — July 10, 2024
I am very satisfied with this article. The author has thoroughly researched and provided in-depth analysis of social and environmental issues, helping me have a more comprehensive and in-depth view of the challenges.
Gary Mark — July 10, 2024
The article was presented in a very inspiring and detailed way, helping me discover a lot of new information cookie clicker.
whamelated — July 19, 2024
The girlboss mentality emphasizes breaking through glass ceilings, shattering gender norms, fireboy and watergirl and achieving professional success on one’s own terms.
quordle — July 23, 2024
I believe that your concept will be emulated and employed to motivate the development of numerous additional ideas due to its originality and brilliance. quordle
Jones — July 25, 2024
I am impressed with the high quality and fit of the suit I ordered from America Jackets. Highly recommended! Next, I’ll be ordering Marty Mcfly Jeans Jacket from them.
Kawin Pollad — July 25, 2024
I highly recommend trying download TeraBox mod APK if you want extra cloud storage and premium features. Just make sure to get it from a trusted source to keep your device safe from potential risks.
Shane Watson — July 27, 2024
Looking for a classic gaming experience? anchor
Traffic Rider Mod APK Old Version offers all the original features and more. Download now to enjoy the retro feel with added perks!
Josh Root — July 27, 2024
Dude Theft Wars Mod APK is incredible! Unlimited resources make the game much more enjoyable. Easy to install with no bugs encountered. Highly recommend it for an enhanced gaming experience!
Harry Edward — July 27, 2024
This is a fascinating exploration of how traditional and modern femininity converge! 🌟 The blend of #tradwife and girlboss ideals highlights a complex intersection of choice, entrepreneurship, and societal expectations. 🌐 To dive deeper into this nuanced discussion, [discover more](https://paxitracking.com)!
Chris Gyle — July 29, 2024
For an exciting card game experience, check out the Teen Patti Happy Club APK. Enjoy popular games like Teen Patti and Rummy, earn real money, and benefit from fast withdrawals and great bonuses. Perfect for card game enthusiasts!
GuauMod — July 30, 2024
This will be very good for your family. You should also entertain yourself after every working hour or you can cook on the cooking simulation game at GuauMod.
EvansT — July 30, 2024
Benefit from our top remote software developers, engineers, designers, and software architects. We can cover all tech needs for whatever project you have in mind.
hire remote developer
harry — July 31, 2024
Smitha Radhakrishnan's critique highlights the shift in feminist empowerment from collective justice to individual success. Reflecting on this, it's essential to recognize that true empowerment involves systemic support, such as fair wages and universal childcare. For those seeking assistance with academic exploration of such topics, law assignment help UK can provide valuable insights and support.
John Sir — August 3, 2024
The S9 Game is a great way to play card games and earn real money. With daily bonuses and easy withdrawals, it's a top choice for gamers. Check out S9 Game Pakistan for more information and start playing today!
Deepak — August 10, 2024
In this case, however, Microsoft says its actions were justified based on the circumstances. sattamatka
Recycling company in UAE — August 10, 2024
Interesting analysis of the Girlboss and Tradwife movements! The convergence of these ideas is surprising. Recycling company in UAE
Mnguni Clan Names — August 14, 2024
Explore the rich history and cultural significance of the Mnguni Clan Names with a curated list of names that honor their ancestral legacy.
Mel — August 15, 2024
Definitely a great effort! It's encouraging to see such well-considered and articulate opinions written out. The writing was not only enjoyable, but also great. For more information and experienced support, please visit Laser Hair Removal in Miami.
Su Arıtma Sistemleri — August 16, 2024
Realy where are the inviting visuals for that kind of empowerment? A very nice article, congratulations. thank you for sharing
Loisua — August 16, 2024
Welcome to slope 2 - where your skills and reflexes are tested!
Amelia — August 19, 2024
Broken Silenze visit website for daily updates.
quordle — August 29, 2024
I really enjoy reading your essay because it is very thorough and interesting, and I hope you keep sending me more work like this. quordle
Antika Kuran Alanlar — September 1, 2024
This app spotifypremium Tools boasts a wide streaming selection but comes with good security. Search for or explore this with good updated malware software. Antika Alanlar !
Antika Tablo — September 1, 2024
really enjoy reading your essay because it is very thorough and interesting, and I hope you keep sending me more work like this. antika alanlar
Antika Kuran Alanlar — September 1, 2024
really enjoy reading your essay because it is very thorough and interesting, and I hope you keep sending me more work like this. antika alanlar
alakay — September 7, 2024
terasa cu carti. All the Episodes will be share with you on our blog terasa cu carti. You will be love to watch your favorite tv shows everyday.
daixie yy — September 10, 2024
网课代上通常由具备丰富学科知识的专家提供,他们精通所在领域的最新研究进展和教学方法,能够为学生提供高水平的学术支持。这样的协助不仅有助于完成作业,还能激发学生的学术兴趣,推动他们进行更深入的研究。
FrancescaJackson — September 12, 2024
When you have the appropriate person by your side, you won't need that other 80 percent of the time. This place, cookie clicker is where I was able to find the joy I was looking for. They were able to tell me the answer, which has made it possible for me to have delight each day, despite the long and difficult hours I spend at work.
YeniKodlar — September 13, 2024
thanx you Promosyon Kodları
traffic rider — September 15, 2024
https://trafficrider.com.in/ thanks for the information
edie jonsan — September 19, 2024
test ahref
love calculator — September 20, 2024
The game True love calculator tests your love. Let the algorithm determine your compatibility by typing your crush's name and yours!
Terrisa Bijlic — September 20, 2024
I have a one stop solution for never stopping fun, endless laughter and giggles. We are committed to bringing joy and laughter in your daily life. We present a wide array of fun filled witty names by nameswhisper that would leave you in splits whenever you read them.
Before It's News — September 25, 2024
This is amazing. Thanks for sharing this blog Before It's News. I have become a fan of your blogs. This blog is so interesting and informative.
Borys — September 25, 2024
Want to boost your logic? Dive into games at IO Games
Alvis — September 27, 2024
Thanks for sharing this educational article. Indigo Travel Diary
lucifer donghua — September 28, 2024
Watch Chinese Animegn Lucifer Donghua / Mister Donghua / Japanese Anime In English Sub, Luciferdonghua, all Series, Movies, BTTH ,Soul Land 2 Watch Ads Free
lucifer donghua — September 28, 2024
Watch Chinese Animegnlucifer donghua / Mister Donghua / Japanese Anime In English Sub, Luciferdonghua, all Series, Movies, BTTH ,Soul Land 2 Watch Ads Free
Chris — October 3, 2024
I recently tried the vblink download on my phone, and it was super easy and quick! The app works smoothly, and the variety of games available is incredible. Whether you’re into slots or table games, VBlink has something for everyone. Highly recommend downloading it for a great gaming experience!
Peterson — October 4, 2024
Vblink is a comprehensive platform dedicated to connecting online gambling enthusiasts with valuable insights and resources. It offers a community-driven space for sharing experiences, strategies, and tips related to various casino games and betting practices. Whether you're a seasoned player or just starting out, Vblink provides a wealth of information to enhance your gambling journey.
traffic rider — October 6, 2024
traffic rider online dodges traffic on mopeds and motorbikes on congested highways and metropolitan streets.
traffic rider — October 9, 2024
traffic rider is unlimited money games where you can unlock every things with this unlimited money
traffic rider — October 9, 2024
https://trafficrider.com.in/ traffic rider is unlimited money games where you can unlock every things with this unlimited money
animeflv — October 10, 2024
El mejor portal de anime online para latinoamérica, encuentra animes clásicos, animes del momento, animes más populares y mucho más, todo en animeflv
Harry Willliam — October 10, 2024
What I love most about the chicago bulls varsity jacket is its versatility. It’s perfect for those chilly game days but also works great for casual wear. The design is bold yet classic, and it goes well with just about any outfit.
eva — October 15, 2024
Your positivity and optimism are contagious It’s impossible to read your blog without feeling uplifted and inspired Keep up the amazing work blank T shirts
Traffic Rider — October 17, 2024
The convergence of the girlboss and tradwife ideologies is fascinating, especially how both are shaped by modern entrepreneurship and societal expectations of women. It’s intriguing to see how these seemingly opposing identities intersect through the lens of choice and self-promotion. As a reflection of this duality, even in gaming culture, we see shifts toward blending fun and responsibility. I recently found myself exploring the Traffic Rider APK, which allows you to embrace adventure while maintaining a sense of balance in gameplay. If you’re curious, you can check it out here: Traffic Rider at https://trafficridergame.net
eva — October 19, 2024
This is my first time visit here. From the tons of comments on your articles, I guess I am not only one having all the enjoyment right here! https://tasmeerindigo.com/
maksromanov — October 19, 2024
As a business enthusiast, I find that keeping up with the latest trends in cryptocurrency and blockchain can provide a significant edge in today’s market. For anyone looking to explore various projects and potential investments, I highly recommend checking out https://icoholder.com. They offer a comprehensive overview of upcoming ICOs, DeFi projects, and market insights that can be incredibly beneficial for making informed business decisions. Staying updated is key in this fast-paced industry!
Alex Rodriges — October 19, 2024
As a business enthusiast, I find that keeping up with the latest trends in cryptocurrency and blockchain can provide a significant edge in today’s market. For anyone looking to explore various projects and potential investments, I highly recommend checking out https://icoholder.com. They offer a comprehensive overview of upcoming ICOs, DeFi projects, and market insights that can be incredibly beneficial for making informed business decisions. Staying updated is key in this fast-paced industry!
Anonymous — October 26, 2024
test comment
Daniel Bates — October 28, 2024
Geometry Dash has some of the catchiest soundtracks in any game. The music in geometry dash keeps me pumped up and motivates me to keep trying, even on tough levels.
love calculator — October 29, 2024
Apply our smart love meter and estimate to find your love percentage. Use our love calculator to obtain correct answers.love calculator estimate for love
alfalaj — October 29, 2024
great post
https://alfalajwater.com/
Rider — October 31, 2024
Thanks dear for sharing value post
aliya — November 5, 2024
Hey guys i am raashi ,Pinkgoa.in i am here to become your night partner Just Join My link now
Shah Jahan — November 5, 2024
Interesting take on the convergence of different expressions of womanhood. It's fascinating to see how these identities intersect and evolve in today's society. By the way, for anyone looking to unwind with some gaming fun, check out vblink login 777 for a seamless gaming experience!
resrei — November 6, 2024
Quick Draw will give you interesting challenges like never before. Can you draw quickly and accurately so that AI can guess correctly?
Raza Ahmed — November 11, 2024
For an enjoyable and immersive online gaming experience, milkyway casino provides a diverse range of games that keep things exciting for players of all levels. The platform is easy to navigate, offering smooth gameplay with chances to win great rewards. If you're looking for a place to unwind and have fun, Milkyway Casino is a fantastic option for online gaming enthusiasts.
David Jonah — November 12, 2024
Doodle Jump has become a staple in my mobile gaming routine! The quick gameplay makes it easy to fit into my busy schedule. I love the thrill of competing against my own high scores and the satisfaction that comes with improving my skills.
Adam Meredith — November 12, 2024
Vblink online is an awesome platform for exciting online games! Easy to use and available for both Android and iOS. Great features and fun bonuses make it worth checking out
George patel — November 12, 2024
The platform betpkrgame emphasizes quick withdrawal processes, ensuring that users can access their winnings promptly.
David Peterson — November 13, 2024
Vblink customer support is responsive and aims to help users quickly resolve any issues. Whether it's about account queries, payment concerns, or game-related questions, the support team is attentive and available through multiple channels. It makes the overall experience smoother and more reliable for players, ensuring their concerns are addressed effectively.
George patel — November 20, 2024
Win PKR game, likely referring to online betting or gaming platforms using the Pakistani Rupee (PKR) as the currency, are gaining traction in the entertainment and gaming industries.
Dawn glover — November 21, 2024
I found this very relatable. DS Haven Comfort cooling system recommendations made our summers much more bearable