“The poor fellow died of Nostalgia,” said a war surgeon in 1861. “Deaths from this cause are very frequent in the army.”
During the Civil War, physicians believed that acute homesickness was a genuine disease and a sometimes fatal one. Symptoms included heart palpitations, fever, lesions, lack of appetite, incontinence and bowel irregularities and, ultimately, dementia. A veteran of the war described homesickness as a “vampyre-like,” sucking the life out of soldiers.
“The soldier’s dream of home” (Library of Congress):
Writing for the New York Times, historian Susan Matt writes that “between 1861 and 1866, 5,537 Union soldiers suffered homesickness acutely enough to come to a doctor’s attention, and 74 died of it.” Some believed that homesickness was the single most deadly threat to soldiers, above and beyond the war itself.
Physicians debated how best to avert nostalgia. Some said not enough letters from home caused it; others said too many could do so. Some units prohibited music that reminded men of home or sang its praises. They wondered whether young men — barely more than boys — were most susceptible. Or whether it was grown men, like the man in the image above — accustomed to the comforts of domestic life — who would miss home the most. If homesickness was untreatable, soldiers would be granted a furlough as a last resort and a few were honorably discharged, simply unable to function away from home.
Susan Matt, who has written a book about the history of homesickness, points out that Americans don’t think of themselves as homebodies anymore. They’ve re-cast themselves as natural adventurers who seek novelty and new experiences. When Europeans arrived on the East Coast, they didn’t sit there, they went West! Today, people get the “travel bug.” We are now a nation of tourists.
And when people do express homesickness, Matt observes, writing for the Council on Contemporary Families, we see it as a different kind of pathology: weakness or immaturity. When young adults don’t want to leave home, we call it “failure to launch,” “boomerang kids,” or “the Peter Pan syndrome.” Colleges now shoo away “helicopter parents” and have “parting ceremonies” symbolizing a “cutting of the cord” between parent and child.
But the word “homesick” reminds us that it wasn’t always that way, nor was it always so easy to dismiss feelings of nostalgia and isolation. The notion that we should be ruggedly independent and eager to set out on our own is only about 90 years old. So, the homebodies out there who first heard the word “staycation” and said YES! are holding up a true American tradition.
Lisa Wade, PhD is an Associate Professor at Tulane University. She is the author of American Hookup, a book about college sexual culture; a textbook about gender; and a forthcoming introductory text: Terrible Magnificent Sociology. You can follow her on Twitter and Instagram.
Comments 3
AG — April 7, 2016
Interesting. Assuming symptomatic afflictions are always going to be influenced by the culture that interprets the severity and weight of a particular symptom, I this it is worth comparing a Diagnosis of homesickness to "depression". .... which begs the question... when did the diagnosis of depression become a thing anyways? Time to google.
To clarify a bit, when you are missing an arm a Dr. can write down "amelia" if you were born without a limb. This conveys a lot of information, losing a limb from an accident and being born without an arm form an overlapping Venn diagram of symptoms. Compare to what a Dr. writes down when he writes "Home sickness" or "Depression" ... unlike a missing limb, there is nothing physical to prove "home sickness" or "depression" , just a collection of real symptoms (sitting around doing nothing, all morose and such) and cultural interpretation. The exception is if/when we find genes that predispose people to "homesickness" or "depression" symptoms.
Jamie Riehl — April 8, 2016
I'm curious to what extent this was an attempt to explain what we now call PTSD without risking the blame of the horrors of war.
It's also an interesting look at the way the home, or "civilization" is constructed as an element of white masculinity.
Micheal Jordan — July 11, 2023
The authors beautifully captures the complex mix of soldiers during the Civil War, longing for comfort and familiarity of home.
Hair Treatment in San Dimas CA