Here is something quite simple, sent along by Judy B. It’s a screenshot of Gimp, an open source image editing application. An optional plug-in, created by a user, offers a series of filters for images, including ones that “beautify.” One of the options is “skin whitening.”
This is one more reminder that we live in a racist society that conflates whiteness with beauty. Remember, too, though, that someone — very possibly a set of people — had to make a conscious decision to include skin whitening as an option and position it as a sub-category of beautification. Then they had to, literally, type the words into the program and make it so.
This shit doesn’t just happen. It’s not random. Racism isn’t just an ephemeral cultural thing. It involves actual decisions made by real people who, if not motivated by racism, are complicit with it.
Cross-posted at Racialicious.
Lisa Wade, PhD is an Associate Professor at Tulane University. She is the author of American Hookup, a book about college sexual culture; a textbook about gender; and a forthcoming introductory text: Terrible Magnificent Sociology. You can follow her on Twitter and Instagram.
Comments 83
Coltrane — September 20, 2013
Just playing devil's advocate for a second; don't some companies claim that skin whitening is just to cover blemishes or skin conditions? It might be BS of the Michael Jackson vitiligo variety but I might anticipate such a defense from this software company.
Blahblah — September 20, 2013
While I agree that a "beautify" setting that whitens skin is very problematic, this isn't a standard part of the Gimp package. It's a plugin, designed by one person and released to whoever wants to download it.
Here's the original (on GitHub) - https://github.com/hejiann/beautify.
And here's the plugin at the Gimp registry - http://registry.gimp.org/node/26835.
As an avid user of Gimp, I just wanted to clarify that this doesn't seem to be a decision made by the designers but rather by one end user. So your notion that "... someone — very possibly a set of people — had to make a conscious decision to include skin whitening as an option and position it as a sub-category of beautification. Then they had to, literally, type the words into the program and make it so" is not true. As with much open-source software, one user created a new tool that people can choose to download and use. The racial vitriol about beauty = white should be focused on that individual, not the Gimp developers.
Coltrane — September 20, 2013
A function to change skin color has existed on Gimp for a long time before this plug-in, and there are various 'tutorials' on Youtube showing how to use it. That might imply that a racist potential has existed in the software far longer than this particular plug-in; however, Gimp could claim that it's a neutral tool because you can darken as well as lighten the skin.
CocoPandaba — September 20, 2013
Maybe they should just say 'skin brightening' because no matter what color your skin is, it can always look brighter in pictures. Right?
Larry Charles Wilson — September 20, 2013
It is interesting, at least to me, that Roman women whitened their skin with cosmetics and that blonde hair was very popular among the upper classes.
Borya — September 21, 2013
Is it still racist if it was developed by an east Asian developer?
https://github.com/hejiann
This isn't to suggest that POC are incapable of racism toward other POC, but all signs point to this plugin being borne of lookism rather than racism.
In many eastern Asian cultures, there is a preference for lighter skin, particularly among women. This preference is not a result of racial bias or emulation of western beauty standards as some commentators have suggested - it goes back centuries and seems to be rooted in classism, with lighter skin being indicative of higher social status and darker skin being associated with farmers and other laborers. This dichotomy is found throughout many cultures and seems to have developed independently in most of them.
Of course, a skin "whitening" plugin is very suspicious when viewed through a western lens, as it should be. But sociology is all about context and by leaving out the context of this plugin - its origin and the nationality of the developer - you leave out a vital part of the story.
chucklin72 — September 23, 2013
For a professor of sociology, you seem to have zero clue as to why light skin is akin to beauty. For most cultures, it has nothing to do with race, but everything to do with economic class.
Darker skin in most cultures signify that the person works in the field or manual labor. Ask any asian why they wish to have lighter skin and they will tell you that its associated with being economically privileged, not racially privileged.
Возмущенный — September 25, 2013
Hey you, "PhD", look here. Geishas in Japan still use your "racist" methods of beautifying to get almost white skin: http://theimpaladiaries.files.wordpress.com/2013/04/geisha.jpg
And this is tradition of bridal makeup in India: http://dilmilgaya.files.wordpress.com/2012/08/indian-bride2.jpg?w=642
In other words: when cat does nothing, he lick balls. You do the same. Don't force your ass-stupid nonsense standards worldwide please.
Lovely Links: 9/27/13 — September 27, 2013
[...] this is horrifying: Someone created a photo editing plugin called “beautify,” and one of the sub-options is “skin whiten... Because white = beautiful? GAH. A thousand times [...]
Claire — October 15, 2013
This photo editor pales in comparison to some of the smart phone apps to come out of East Asia. Take a look at PhotoWonder and you will see that the conclusion of white=beauty is a bit oversimplified. Their "beautify" setting whitens and softens skin, plumps lips, enlarges eyes, and makes the person thinner. I believe these things have much more to do with infantilizing women and (as previous comments explain) the centuries-old, cross-civilization practice of equating wealth with beauty.
LoveCelebHair — October 28, 2013
Beauty is in the eye of the beholder! I love PhotoEditorX because I'm not an expert and although Gimp is an amazing free alternative to PS, I prefer PhotoEditorX because it comes with very useful tutorials.
PhotoEditorX : http://newphotoshop.com/
William Beckett — November 29, 2013
A great blog post, and informative also. It's necessary to know how to use photoshop to Create Your artwork! Thanks lisa. You had made a good effort.
Photo Editing Software
pranit — July 18, 2017
aadesh
Fieldworkhq — May 8, 2021
From the Fieldwork Office app, you can see your schedule, including tasks, estimates, or work orders. All changes are immediately reflected on the map. You can even overlay missed and upcoming appointments from the work pool to see what is closest to your scheduled appointments. Clicking on specific pins helps to sort your work pool by distance so that you can be sure your routes are optimized and efficient.
m tomas — May 29, 2021
I've had a hard time understanding why the white racist are growing in number. Where is all the anger coming from?. Then I do a cursory read of the above and understand that a simple filter called "beauty" which does a score of useful action unrelated to skin color is now pilloried racist because the it can make a model's skin look whiter.
When did whiteness become conflated with racism?
Don't worry, no one is about turn me into some altright naybob. But I believe there is some old proverb about attracting more bees with honey than with vinegar. Give it some thought before you erupt into self-righteous fury.
BrighterGuide — June 7, 2021
The best video editing software is a must-buy for professional editors, not to mention YouTubers looking to enter the big leagues. And even if you're just someone who wants your smartphone clips to look better for sharing online, there's easy-to-use video software out there to make your footage look slick.
best video editing software 2021
St3v3 — February 11, 2022
Now there is quite a lot of ready-made software that we can use for our purposes. However, there are situations when you need to develop software specifically for your company, so you can hire software developer. This is very convenient, because there are a lot of experienced and responsible outsourced developers.
Jerome — March 10, 2022
Throw in the options for Pest Control Software for business, otherwise I was faced with the issue of choosing software for my needs. It seems like the guys from Fieldworkhq have a very good option, but I would like to consider more suggestions, who can advise something about this?
nickmel67 — October 18, 2022
Experienced developers are likely to charge more than a fresher developer, but it's important to remember that they will complete a task more quickly than a fresher developer. You should always compare the experience of a developer with the type of task you need done. Also, be sure to consider the location of the developer. If you live in another country, you can cut costs by choosing someone who lives in that country. This can save you up to 40% of your costs without compromising on quality.
If you're looking for a talented React developer, you have several choices. While hire react developer from India or Singapore will give you access to a more experienced developer, you'll pay more than $8000 a year. In comparison, hiring a developer from Europe will ensure you get top quality React developers with a more professional approach. However, you will pay a little more than if you hire a developer from the USA or North America.
Baliar — November 27, 2022
Hire Developers for a Startup: Founder Guide
https://gloriumtech.com/how-to-hire-developers-for-a-startup-founder-guide/
Guider Man — February 1, 2023
That's really great content.
https://universalinsulationdoctor.com/
Maximilian Hohenzollern — April 6, 2023
You're right, and I'm pretty sure that every entrepreneur would rather have fast software. But I know that while choosing between inhouse development vs outsourcing, the first option can easily provide slow software because there's no guarantee that hired developers are actually good, while in outsourcing, you know for a fact that there are professionals.
lili — May 31, 2023
outsourcing vs outstaffing
Milagros Horton — December 14, 2023
Thanks for sharing this eye-opening insight, Judy B! It's disheartening to see how even photo editing software can perpetuate harmful beauty standards. The fact that Gimp, an open source tool, includes a "skin whitening" filter highlights a broader issue in the perception of beauty. It's crucial to question and challenge such norms. On a related note, while exploring image editing, it's refreshing to consider alternatives that celebrate diverse beauty. Check out Golden PicsArt for a more inclusive and empowering approach to photo editing. Let's strive for a world where beauty knows no boundaries.
M Zeeshan — January 20, 2024
"Highlighting the need for ethical choices in software development. The inclusion of 'skin whitening' filters in image editing apps perpetuates harmful beauty standards. Let's promote inclusive tech solutions instead. https://attractgroup.com/blog/how-to-develop-a-social-networking-app-like-clubhouse/
Isha Khan — January 20, 2024
Highlighting the need for ethical choices in software development. The inclusion of 'skin whitening' filters in image editing apps perpetuates harmful beauty standards. Let's promote inclusive tech solutions instead
M Zeeshan — January 21, 2024
I found this article thought-provoking, considering the implications of the "skin whitening" option in photo editing software. The discussion on cultural nuances adds an interesting layer to the conversation. It sparks a complex dialogue about beauty standards, racism, and cultural influences. For those interested in promoting digital literacy in the classroom, this resource on teaching digital literacy might be helpful:Teach Digital Literacy in the Classroom
Abhishek Prabhakar — February 6, 2024
The Square Calculator is a straightforward tool for computing the area of a square based on its side length, simplifying geometric calculations with ease. This user-friendly calculator ensures accurate results, making it invaluable for students, professionals, and anyone dealing with square measurements.
Click Here to get the tool.
Martin Luther — February 17, 2024
i am not fan of most video editors available on the market, but the software said-above impressed me a lot and changed my level of thoughts. Hats off for the creators, and I would love to share this lovely asset with my closed-ones.
Steve Haeks — February 17, 2024
Judy B., I appreciate you sharing this insightful information! It is depressing to observe how damaging beauty standards can be sustained even by photo editing tools. The "skin whitening" filter included in the open-source Gimp application sheds light on a larger problem with how people define beauty. It's imperative to challenge and examine these conventions. On a related note, while exploring image editing, it's refreshing to consider alternatives that celebrate diverse beauty. For an approach to photo editing that is more inclusive and powerful, check out Best App for Virtual Acitivties! Let's strive for a world where beauty knows no boundaries.
Download PicsArt mod apk — March 1, 2024
This post is a masterpiece! From the eloquent prose to the captivating imagery, every aspect is meticulously crafted. The depth of insight and the ability to evoke powerful emotions are extraordinary. Bravo to the talented individual behind this exceptional work!
download PicsArt mod apk
PicsArt Pro — March 4, 2024
Picsart For IOS breaks all the barriers and allows you to download the Picsart App for iOS. Indeed, the iPhone is always famous for HD snaps or images. You get a better appearance in IOS as compared to Android.
asif raza — April 10, 2024
PicsArt APK shatters all barriers, enabling you to download the PicsArt app on your Android Phone. Indeed, Phones are renowned for their HD images, offering a superior visual experience.
Jhon Doe — April 12, 2024
"Absolutely! This post highlights a pervasive issue in photo editing software – the implicit bias towards a narrow standard of beauty. It's disappointing to see how these tools often reinforce harmful stereotypes. This is where apps like Meitu can make a real difference by embracing diversity and offering features that celebrate all forms of beauty. With its inclusive approach and innovative features, Meitu Photo Editing App
empowers users to express themselves authentically, breaking free from the constraints of conventional beauty standards. Let's support platforms that prioritize diversity and inclusivity in every pixel they touch."
Picsart Hub — April 16, 2024
Judy B., I appreciate you sharing this insightful information! It is depressing to observe how damaging beauty standards can be sustained even by photo editing tools. The "skin whitening" filter included in the open-source Gimp application sheds light on a larger problem with how people define beauty. It's imperative to challenge and examine these conventions. In connection with this, it's energizing to explore image editing options that highlight varied beauty. For an approach to photo editing that is more inclusive and powerful, check out PicsArt GOLD APK. Let us endeavor to live in a world where beauty is unconstrained.
Bella — April 18, 2024
PicsArt and its modified version, Picsart mod apk, are widely recognized as photo editing and creative toolkits offering a multitude of features and tools to enhance your photographs.
Even though PicsArt’s official edition has a lot of capabilities, some users might want more features or premium options without having to pay for them. Presenting Modified version of PicsArt, a modified programme that grants free access to premium features.
Bella — April 18, 2024
PicsArt and its modified version, Picsart mod apk, are widely recognized as photo editing and creative toolkits offering a multitude of features and tools to enhance your photographs. Free Download Now.
Even though PicsArt’s official edition has a lot of capabilities, some users might want more features or premium options without having to pay for them. Presenting Modified version of PicsArt, a modified programme that grants free access to premium features.
safasdf — May 8, 2024
Fortune OX
jsoni — May 8, 2024
thi si ldjpowrlsfo
safasdf — May 8, 2024
Fortune OX
Max — May 26, 2024
Great information! I would recommend you to edit your photos using Download.
Jhanzaib Jani — July 6, 2024
Terabox MOD APK is the latest modded version of the official Terabox app. It is an online storage app that provides 1Tb (1024 GB) of permanent free storage which is developed by Flextech Inc. You can store, share, and edit the multimedia file, Photo’s and Videos in Tarabox Mod Apk.
https://teraboxmodd.com/
jimmy — August 2, 2024
Yeah very impressive app like inshot pro apk https://inshoteditor.com/ give it a try as well.
Creek — August 6, 2024
I've found that mastering photo editing is essential for showcasing the beauty and details of my fashion items from Carlanisa. Whether it's enhancing the colors of our Baju Kurung, adding the perfect amount of brightness to our Instant shawls, or sharpening the intricate patterns on our hijabs and kebarung, good editing can make a huge difference. If you're into fashion photography and want your outfits to truly stand out, investing time in learning photo editing techniques is definitely worth it!
Josh — August 25, 2024
"Still the best endless runner out there! The vibrant graphics, fast-paced action, and those slick hoverboards never get old! 🚄✨ Always a blast to dodge trains and collect those coins! 💰🤩 If you're as obsessed with Subway Surfers as I am, check outlink Premium Premium tips and tricks, and more! 🎮🔥"
Casey Harper — September 12, 2024
While some may argue that these features cater to user demand, it’s clear that such options reinforce problematic ideals. We should be pushing for more inclusive and representative standards of beauty in tech.
On a similar note, tools like the Meitu photo editing app offer a wide range of filters that focus on creativity rather than perpetuating outdated beauty norms.
Lucas — September 20, 2024
Great information! I would recommend you to edit your photos using picsartpro.com
David Lara — October 6, 2024
Great information! I would recommend you to chat with your firneds using blue whatsapp download
zainab824 — October 9, 2024
donwload top follow apk and enjoy unkimited instagram followers by posting your editing pictures on this
dexter hale — October 13, 2024
On a similar note, tools like the Meitu photo editing app offer a wide range of filters that focus on creativity rather than perpetuating outdated beauty norms.