Elisabeth R. sent in a commercial that, I admit, I kinda like. As the ad progresses, a Mustang driven through urban streets gets a new paint job as a diverse group of people project their personalities onto the car. At the very end a little girl holding the hand of her father, wearing a pink ballerina get-up, spies the car. The car turns pink and then goes black. As it drives by her, she’s reflected in the mirror as a bad-ass black angel pictured above.
What I like about the commercial isn’t the fact that they portray the girl as resisting girliness. Suggesting that girls who are less girly are better than those who aren’t is just another form of sexism, one that demeans femininity. Likewise, the characters are diverse, but that’s par for the course these days, especially when an item is being marketed as urban and modern.
What I like, instead, is just the fact that the ad has an ounce of creativity, that it ends with a twist. Advertising is so stereotypical today and relies so strongly on tropes, that I find it exhausting to watch. So, while the twist wasn’t totally subversive, I was relieved that the marketing team for Mustang did something interesting. Really, at this point my standards for not-horrible are pretty low.
Lisa Wade, PhD is an Associate Professor at Tulane University. She is the author of American Hookup, a book about college sexual culture; a textbook about gender; and a forthcoming introductory text: Terrible Magnificent Sociology. You can follow her on Twitter and Instagram.
Comments 11
Leechcraft52 — September 2, 2012
http://goo.gl/Y8tyi
Trianglekitty — September 2, 2012
I don't see it as being anti-girlygirl at all! It would be different if she ripped off the pink tutu and the dark costume was underneath. By having it be her inner view of herself or reflection it felt more like the message was that wearing pink tutus doesn't mean you aren't a badass on the inside. She's not resisting girliness....she's just not confined to stereotypical definitions of girl.
I really liked the commercial for that reason. Really, we should be past the point where wearing pink but also being a little badass shouldn't be a twist, but it sadly is. But I really loved that she wasn't resisting those stereotypical 'girlygirl things' by tearing them off or shredding them like you sometimes see. The car drives off and she's still wearing a pink tutu...she's just not encapsulated by it.
Annie490 — September 2, 2012
I hate to say it but this might be less anti-girlygirl and more sexualized that anyone here could hope. It would depend on if she's supposed to be a badass or the black swan from Swan Lake.
Tusconian — September 2, 2012
It's not a "bad-ass black angel." It's a reference to the Odile from Swan Lake, made more popular recently by the movie Black Swan, which the particular example in the commercial definitely references. It really doesn't subvert or go against girliness, just presents another aspect of it. As opposed to delicate, innocent, light, etc., she's more sexy, cunning, dark.
Whether this makes it problematic or not, I'm not sure, and it's a neat reference, but the movie is, ah.....not for children, to say the least, so I'm not sure that this is the same as a little girl in a ballerina costume imagining herself as a scientist, a motorcycle stunt driver, or a rock star. More like a girl in a ballerina costume imagining herself to be Britney Spears. Which I don't think is inherently wrong or anything, but it's also not terribly subversive.
Bob — September 2, 2012
Reminds me a little bit of the more recent T-Mobile commercials where the spokeswoman who usually wears the pink dress changes into a pink and black leather jumpsuit and gets a motorcycle.
I like this commercial and also the T-mobile commercial. I don't either one is going against femininity, I think they are both just trying to show a different side of femininity.
Bluehilda — September 2, 2012
I thought we had moved further in the thought process here than to assume that pink=girly=femininity. Frankly i am surprised to read that nonsense here, of all places.
Bluehilda — September 2, 2012
I thought we had moved further in the thought process here than to assume that pink=girly=femininity. Frankly i am surprised to read that nonsense here, of all places.
Koldpurple — September 3, 2012
Actual creativity?! I can't believe it!
glaborous_immolate — September 4, 2012
C'Mell "was a girly girl and they were true men, the lords of creation, but she pitted her wits against the, and she won. It had never happened before, and it is sure never to happen again..."
(the Ballad of Lost C'Mell - Cordwainer Smith. Sorry, always makes me think of that opening when you use girlygirl)
Anon Y. Mous — September 4, 2012
Meh. All I see is more of the same shapely, able-bodied, clear-skinned, fashionably-groomed folks. Not interesting.
Anjasa — September 5, 2012
I don't really think that just because a little girl wanted to be the black swan she was being sexualized. Most little girls wouldn't understand the underlying themes of the dance and be attracted more to the costume and the dance itself.