Earlier this week a series of photographs of sweaty men climbing a greased up phallic symbol went ’round the blogosphere. The pictures were of a naval tradition: at the end of their first year, students enrolled at the U.S. Naval Academy come together to climb a monument covered in lard. In a ritual designed to mark their completion of their first year, they swap a newbie’s sailor’s hat for the next iteration of their headgear, one that looks a little bit more like the one worn by naval officers.
What was interesting to me about the series of photos is the absence of women. It might not immediately strike you as odd — given that, symbolically, the U.S. military is a strongly masculine space — but, in fact, 31% of the USNA class of 2015 is female. So almost one in three of the students pictured should be female. But they are almost entirely absent and are never featured close up. Shots of the crowd of students suggest that this wasn’t the photographers’ choice; even among the students on the ground, women are few and far between. They weren’t excluded from participation, since we see one here and there. So, where are they? What kept them from participating in this time-honored tradition?
Lots of photos at Buzzfeed.
Lisa Wade, PhD is an Associate Professor at Tulane University. She is the author of American Hookup, a book about college sexual culture; a textbook about gender; and a forthcoming introductory text: Terrible Magnificent Sociology. You can follow her on Twitter and Instagram.
Comments 106
Mythosopher — May 27, 2012
Where are you getting the 31%? Class size says 236/1229 students are women.
Regardless, your point stands: a hypermasculine ritual that doesn't seem to have any women participants.
casey — May 27, 2012
All activities forever should be Co-ed. Separating anything by gender is an abomination.
NicNac — May 27, 2012
turned on? ...think so!
Dan Taipua — May 27, 2012
I'd venture is has to do with the water being hosed everywhere around white t-shirts, So it's a choice between being photographed with a wet see-through shirt, or going 'topless' like many of the men shown.
Leesm — May 27, 2012
In college, guys used to slide down the beer-soaked hallway in their underwear. Women were always welcome to participate, but chose not to join in. Nothing wrong with that. Just because someone can do something does not mean she wants to do it.
Elaine — May 27, 2012
As far as you know, there is no evidence that the women were *forbidden* to participate? And none that they were *discouraged* or *intimidated by the men* from participating? If that is indeed so -- that they're not here by choice as opposed to not being here due to sexism -- then my interpretation would be that they'd rather not "be like men" by climbing a slicked-up pole and being sprayed by water and shoved and pushed around by pumped-up men. Cannot imagine why not....
Let the guys keep this stupid ritual; over time, particularly as more and more women enter the military, this will go by the wayside like lion-fighting. In the meantime, if the guys think it is fun, I say (yawn) let them have at it.
tressiemcphd — May 27, 2012
Welp. The classic greeks would be proud. Bless their hearts.
I do think that examining why women chose not to participate is an interesting sociological question. Their choosing not to participate is actually as interesting as them being barred from participation. Are these choices individually made? Has it been made as a collective? Is it a historical choice? Is it a tradition handed down to female cadets from other female cadets to let the boys have this one? Do they ignore it or participate as members of the crowd? Do they celebrate with the male cadets? If they do, do they do so as fans or as peers? Can they celebrate the group achievement if they did not participate themselves?
It's sociologically interesting to me.
Sarah — May 27, 2012
While this is admittedly juvenile of me to say, and completely off topic, I must remark on the homoerotic nature of this activity: a great pile of wet young boys, wrapped around a giant phallic symbol. My word, that is hot! Who wouldn't want to be in the middle of that.
*Also, why are all these dudes white? Is there a shortage of minorities in the navy? I do not claim to know..
LC — May 27, 2012
Why doesn't someone ask the women why they did or didn't participate? I would, if I cared enough.
anon — May 27, 2012
The maximum pull-up score for a high school senior applying to Annapolis is 18 for men, and 7 for women, and women are allowed to substitute a flexed-arm hang in the event that they cannot perform a single pull-up.
It is surprising to me that no one considers this relevant when we ask why women are under-represented in what is essentially a group feat of upper-body strength with some collective punishment thrown in.
Sophie — May 27, 2012
This is the Herndon Monument climb. If you YouTube it, you can see a female presence and sometimes females are part of the inner circle that actually helps get the plebe to the top. Funny how the guys can use their shirts to get the grease off but the girls can't. In 2010 they decided against putting lard on the monument and the shirts didn't come off, and you even see a female at one point on someone's shoulders taller than the rest. I couldn't resist, I counted 17 instances of "grease"/"greased" mentioned in this video on the Herndon climb: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5lUZseybFbY.
Abbie — May 27, 2012
This is a hazing ritual. The strongest and "best" are the ones specifically ordered to be there. This isn't as optional an occasion as the rhetoric would have one believe.
Josh — May 28, 2012
Is this the NYC pride parade?
Gilbert Pinfold — May 28, 2012
Very moderate, good humored comments. It seems the subject matter is beyond the pale of the hard core misandrists who usually turn up: Not even a 'wow... Just wow.'
Xiao Mao — May 28, 2012
This has got to be one the most homoerotic, homosocial and creepy things I've ever seen in my life.
snuhfoo — May 28, 2012
While a few people have alluded to this, I'm surprised no one has outright said it. Women's bodies are read differently than men's bodies. Men who participate in events like this are read as strong and persevering. Yet woman participants will be read as sexual. I imagine many women would be uncomfortable with activities like this because they don't want to hear comments like 'you can climb my pole hea hea hea' wile their male peers are congratulated for their strength and perseverance.
Yunnan Chen — May 28, 2012
I'm also gonna throw it out there, but I'm guessing a lot of the women don't want to be in a situation where they're pressed between a lot of greasy sweaty men smeared with lard and sprayed with water and in a position for lots of easy accidental groping.
celebdiur — May 28, 2012
Was in necessary to include a catologue of sexualised male bodies in order to make the point that event was absent of women? Seems a little conflicted with the retinue of articles that consistently slate the sexualisation of women
tauceti — May 28, 2012
We have exactly the same tradition at my alma mater, although the grease pole is taller. It being an engineering tradition, there aren't as many women as in other disciplines, but they're there and they're as gung-ho as the men. The person who goes for the hat is usually the tallest person in the group, because the hat is nailed down and you need a firm grip to rip it off. Hence, the top person is usually a guy, the middle group tends to have the lighter folks and the bottom props are the strongest. And then those folks are surrounded by a free-for-all of people trying to push them all in and keep them standing. It's a sight to see.
It used to be that women weren't allowed to participate, but that's because the grease water was so toxic that they were worried about birth defects. The guys would tape up their underwear and they probably still got all kinds of terrible diseases from that sludge.
Tradition!
tauceti — May 28, 2012
I should clarify that the "grease water" I refer to was a waist-deep pit of mud and lanolin and other mysteries, hence the need to tape up one's orifices.
Dianne — May 29, 2012
Seriously? There are 1200 in the class and only so many can do the task. A certain type tends to gravitate to these sort of things. Most of them are capable physically but many are too smart to participate. A few years ago some midshipmen were injured and couldn’t graduate as a result. The event was banned for a year by the Admiral. Then people said “wait, we can send them to fight in a war but not accept the risk of climbing a block of stone?” The event was brought back. Its not inherently sexist any more than mowing my lawn. Also, the class is way less than 31% female.
Erin — May 30, 2012
Let's also comment on this: THIS is the strategy they chose to get that hat? Really? Is that even a strategy?
Pixietrack — December 5, 2012
The reason for so few women participating in this event is due to the large crowd of Alumni who hail from the age of a military without women. Whenever a female midshipman makes it to the middle or upper tier of the climb up Herndon, these same old men chant "Pull her down" and her classmates do. Additionally, many women (and men) at the Naval Academy are Varsity Athletes and have a summer training block during this event which prevents them from participating. And really, as a Midshipman, the idea of spending the day after Sea Trials (a sixteen hour evolution) trying to climb a monument, getting kicked, punched, scratched, and ending up covered in lard that takes an hour to wash out of my hair is not appealing.
Former Plebe — January 26, 2021
As a former female midshipman of USNA, I believe that the reason women don't participate in the event is because climbing Herndon is notorious as an event where females are sexually assaulted by digital penetration. This was true in the early 1980s when I attended the academy.
Meryden Seaver — December 29, 2021
Former Plebe, I can confirm that it was also happening in 2008 when I was a plebe. I hope that these women didn’t participate as fully as they could have because they got critical information passed to them by their female shipmates who truly cared about them. Certainly leadership was/is not wanting to use their words. Also I hope you know that if you didn’t graduate because you were discharged with some bullshit, I see you. Don’t ever think that you missed out or failed. You didn’t.
During my last exam at USNA I was given a piece of bent steel by this substitute prof who proctored for me, I had missed the final exam with my class. I was on some meds that made me shake uncontrollably. He told me-
You bent.
You didn’t break.
<3