This 48-second ad is a fantastic example of framing, as well as a super-ridiculous blast-from-the-past. Paid for by the movie theater industry, the ad attacks the idea of cable. Cable, of course, was going to deliver more content to television sets and potentially compete for the business movie theaters enjoyed. So they frame cable as “pay tv” and counterpose it to “free tv.” They don’t, you might notice, frame cable as “pay tv” and the movie theaters as “pay movies” because that comparison is not as useful for them. Instead, without drawing attention to the fact that they charge for entertainment, they try to delegitimate the idea of paying for on-screen entertainment at home.
They also try to argue that cable tv will bring scary monsters into your living room. So cute. In an era where millions of instances of pornifed violence are just a click away, it is almost incomprehensible to imagine wanting to make sure that scary movies stayed at the theater.
Via BoingBoing.
Lisa Wade, PhD is an Associate Professor at Tulane University. She is the author of American Hookup, a book about college sexual culture; a textbook about gender; and a forthcoming introductory text: Terrible Magnificent Sociology. You can follow her on Twitter and Instagram.
Comments 5
Christina_angelopoulos — April 17, 2012
Actually, "pay tv" is a legitimate industry term referring to subscription-type services. "Cable" merely refers to the method of transmission. By contrast, pay tv can be both analogue and digital terrestrial, as well as internet television. See here: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pay_tv
MHBLabs » ‘Pay TV’ — May 4, 2012
[...] spot, for fear that money spent on cable would reduce money spent at theaters. Sociological Images notes that: So they frame cable as “pay tv” and counterpose it to “free tv.” They don’t, you might [...]
mark steven — August 19, 2022
We are pleased to be able to make available our Framing Pay TV with VeePN service. This is a package that allows you to watch and record pay-tv channels securely in your own home. The service is fully integrated with your existing set-top box and router, so no changes to your existing setup are required. On top of that, super simple manageability options mean you can pause, record, or clear live recordings as often as you like without interrupting what you’re watching.
Daniel Adams — November 18, 2023
Thanks for sharing this gem of an anti-cable ad! It's impressive how they skillfully frame the narrative to protect the interests of the movie theater industry. The contrast between "pay tv" and "free tv" is both clever and amusing, showcasing the art of persuasion. And speaking of entertainment, if you're into movie films, do check out Loklok is a fast Download for watch films and movies
.