According to Federal Parliament member Charlie Angus, leaders of the Attawapiskat First Nation have declared a state of emergency. Living conditions are so terrible on the reserve that members of the community are at significant risk of illness and death. Many residents have no electricity, heat, or running water. They are living in uninsulated tents and shacks. Many of these residences are filled with black mold and prone to quick-spreading fires. Some use buckets as bathrooms; with no facilities, they dump their sewage into the streets.
Angus writes:
When it comes to the misery, suffering and even the death of First Nations people, the federal and provincial governments have developed a staggering capacity for indifference.
Try to imagine this situation happening in anywhere else in this country. We all remember how the army was sent into Toronto when the mayor felt that citizens were being discomforted by a snowstorm. Compare that massive mobilization of resources with the disregard being shown for the families in Attawapiskat.
The government waited a month to respond, but has now accepted some responsibility for the health and welfare of the residents. Attawapiskat leaders are now trying to raise awareness of the other First Nation communities in Northern Canada with similar conditions.
Lisa Wade, PhD is an Associate Professor at Tulane University. She is the author of American Hookup, a book about college sexual culture; a textbook about gender; and a forthcoming introductory text: Terrible Magnificent Sociology. You can follow her on Twitter and Instagram.
Comments 29
Meredith Palmer — December 5, 2011
Before anyone makes any negative comments about tribal spending, please read this blog post: http://apihtawikosisan.wordpress.com/2011/11/30/dealing-with-comments-about-attawapiskat/
VERY informative, regarding the lack of sovereignty the tribe has, and how the money that does go to them ends up being spent.
Anonymous — December 5, 2011
This is absolutely horrible! What kind of welfare state worth its name would allow this to even happen in the first place?
Sariel — December 5, 2011
I wish I could say that I was shocked and horrified but I really can't. Too many indigenous peoples in both Canada and the United States live in the equivalent of a third world country on their reservations. Too much regulation, not enough awareness, and a lack of education and resources on the reservation pretty much ensure that this happens. If you want an example of this in the United States then go to the 20/20 website and watch the special Diane Sawyer did on the Lakota Sioux Pine Ridge reservation.
freelance.zombie — December 5, 2011
As a white Canadian, I will argue that it's more than neglect - the machinery of historical assimilation and extinction policies upon which our government founded itself are still chugging along in 'perfect' working order to eliminate "the Indian problem" (as Duncan Campbell Scott put it), and now all our current colonialist government and society have to do is sit back and pretend like there's nothing we can do, occasionally tinkering with the works to make it seem like we're trying to do something in response to the on-going condemnation and calls for accountability made by Indigenous communities and leaders.
EDIT: Hmm, not sure how I signed in so weird, but my usual handle is Jadey and my blog is http://thezombieheadquarters.blogspot.com/
Judy — December 5, 2011
This is completely nonsense and dangerous the state is playing with first nation lives....the marginlization continues
Gwenthegothic — December 6, 2011
People love to point fingers at Toronto for the "calling in the army" about the snow. This occurred because Toronto's Mayor at the time, Mel Lastman (also famous for shaking hands with Hell's Angels and equating trips to Africa with cannabalism) had sold off many of the snowplows to the states to make money. Blame the idiot mayor, not the 2,000,000 people living in Toronto at the time.
Kat — December 6, 2011
I am a bit... puzzled by this post. Have you ever done a post about US American tribes and their marginalization? I can't remember one. If not: Why this Canadian one?
Coincidentally, I read this related tweet by Coeur d'Alene/Spokane NDN author Sherman Alexie yesterday: "In 1972, I lived with 14 relatives in a 1-bedroom house w/o water or electricity. How rez is that!"
Larrycharleswilson — December 6, 2011
Citizens of the United States have no right to say anything about Canada's treatment of it's First Americans until we do something real to help our Native Americans. Typhoid Mary should keep its mouth shut.
Lily — December 6, 2011
Unfortunately, many native communities in Canada are in the same state as Attawapiskat. Many northern native communities have no clean running water (http://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/story/2011/11/28/f-first-nations-water.html). In a first world country.
Whatever your personal feelings about the issue, Canada is failing its citizens.
The federal government finally took some action (whether it was the right thing to do is debatable) and appointed a third party manager, who was promptly ordered out by band officials (http://news.nationalpost.com/2011/12/05/attawapiskat-officials-kick-third-party-manager-off-reserve/).
While this is a shame on Canada, as least it's getting some media attention for the deplorable conditions some Canadians are living in.
Bagelsan — December 6, 2011
Lol #firstworldproblems!
...Wait.
Kunoichi — December 7, 2011
The issue is far more complex then portrayed, but blaming the federal government (especially the current government, as these problems predate them by a long shot) is pointless. There is little to no accountability for the money that goes to the reserves. Though it's claimed that this particular reserve has been "open" about their revenue and expenditures, there are a great many questionable and unexplained items on those forms.
Based on first hand information I've encountered over the years, most of the reserves are rife with nepotism and corruption. Chiefs, band leaders and their friends and family have no problems getting new housing, new trucks, quads and snowmobiles every year, etc. Anyone who falls on the wrong side of the leaders can find themselves suddenly homeless and destitute. I know people who got paid to vote for specific individuals during band elections (then bragged that they took the money to party, then didn't bother to vote at all). Many reserves have major problems with drug abuse, alcoholism and violence, all of which they blame on colonialism/white people/the government/anyone but taking responsibility themselves. It's heartbreaking to know foster parents who've cared for drug and alcohol damaged children for years, only to have them taken away and returned to abusive situations because the foster parents were white. It's even more heartbreaking when some of those children end up dead.
Not all reserves are like this; there are a few that have managed to turn things around and prosper. They didn't do it with government assistance. The key thing was strong, ethical leadership. Without that, nothing the government does will make a difference.
emkfeminist — December 7, 2011
For anyone interested in learning more, there was a good conversation about Attawapiskat on CBC Radio's The Current a few days ago; you can listen to it here http://www.cbc.ca/thecurrent/episode/2011/12/05/aboriginal-housing-crises-pt-2/index.html
One of the guests is Pam Palmater, a First Nations lawyer and academic who is extremely knowledgeable and well-spoken about the issue at hand.
Notorious J-E-N — December 9, 2011
It's not at all surprising on two counts-- one, the Conservative gvt's agenda with aboriginal people is nothing short of assimilation and forced extinction, Harper the harpoon's non-response was extremely telling and it took Shawn Atleo and the Ontario minister of aboriginal affairs lighting a fire under his ass not to mention public outcry for him to give two shits. Two-- band councils are corrupt. Mine is (Nu-chah-nulth), theirs is and most of them in Canada are. You'll have councillors and the cheif elect in fancy new houses with new cars and tech toys and the band members and often the heriditary cheif living in utter bloody squalor. If you suggest that a 3rd party finance manager is a good idea you'll be written off as a racist when in fact all organizations should have someone with no percieved interest doing their books regardless of whether they're aboriginal or not. But really, is it so hard to barge up atco trailers for the community to live in till spring thaw when they can actually build something? Their pipes are all above ground in humidors anyway, it's really not difficult to hook up atcos for plumbing, that's what most of fort macmurray lives in. Bottom line: The department of Indian and Northern affairs doesn't care about the communities it serves, it's outdated and inherently discriminatory.
madCanadian — March 12, 2012
Did no one get a look at the Caddy sitting in front of that house??? Just sayin'!