Harkening back to a day when grocery and ‘convenience’ stores did not exist, one was intimately aware of where one’s food was coming from. This is because leading a life of subsistence meant growing one’s own food. It meant raising animals and growing crops and then processing them into food.
As foodstuffs began to be commodified, that is, rendered a marketable good to be exchanged for capital — and largely controlled by transnational corporations — we began to lose understanding to where our food comes from. Arguably, the dearth of this understanding is illustrated by the fact that increasingly children believe that fruit and vegetables are something that comes from the grocery store rather than from the farm or the earth.
The effects of this phenomenon, known as distancing, have social, political and economic ramifications. Typically grocery store produce is devoid of any clues as to the conditions under which it was produced, save for the country of origin. This serves to make invisible the labour taken to cultivate the produce and instead presents the consumer with the end product. The conditions under which bananas are produced, for example, are particularly problematic given their use of toxic pesticides and lack of environmental and worker protection measures.
Accordingly, I was particularly struck when I noticed this produce sign at a local grocery store.
Here the source of the bananas is specified in a way that might help combat distancing. But, in fact, knowing that these bananas are from the “tropics” does more to obfuscate than illuminate. The tropics refers to no place in particular – technically referring to parts of South America, Africa, Asia, and the South Pacific. Instead of a concrete agricultural source, then, pointing to the tropics simply creates a false sense of understanding, one that plays on consumers’ desires for (and stereotypes about) all things lush and tropical, leaving the consumers’ ignorance intact.
Kristina Vidug is pursuing a masters of arts degree in sociology at the University of Guelph in Ontario, Canada. Her research is on post-industrial risk management with a focus on women’s avoidance of synthetic chemicals in the domestic sphere. You can follow her “adventures in thesising” on her blog, jeez (kristina) louise.
Comments 58
Luey — February 26, 2011
In my local grocery store the produce section takes great pains to remind customers of where the food comes from - sort of. There are big pictures of the farmers who supposedly produce the food, usually looking wholesome and Midwestern and standing with their families.
This capitalizes on the trend towards locally grown and organic foods and preserves the illusion of the family farmer. If these people are indeed food producers and not models, they most likely run enormous conglomerate farms for one of the handful of produce corporations. The farmers shown are overwhelmingly white. There are no happy brown people smiling out over the bananas or pineapples, no non-Americans depicted at all. Perhaps the store doesn't want to remind us that most of the food comes from a lot farther than just up the road, and is produced in less than ideal situations.
m Andrea — February 26, 2011
I'm kind of wondering why the researcher is focused on "women who avoid chemicals". Shouldn't it just be "people who avoid chemicals"? It sounds like the researcher is a 1950's housewife.
Ann — February 26, 2011
It depends where you live, Luey. Our supermarkets here in the Midwest (which is quite white, sorry, that's just how it is, I don't know how to change that) get local produce, and will even say what farm it is from. Milk, too, we have an idea, because local mid sized Dairy farms are part of the co-op that supplies most of the supermarkets and grocery stores here. There are real farms, still, I swear, and people do buy from them, and they can be affordable, instead of the overpriced farmers market stuff I saw in NYC (living there 35 years). But they just can't win. Apparently they are an illusion. Or too white. Or too big. Or not big enough. The comment just reeks of urban ignorance, from here.
Marie — February 26, 2011
Anyone else notice that the sign says "of from" the Tropics? wow...
Alison Hope Alkon — February 26, 2011
For all of the commenters describing their predominantly white farming communities, do those farmers hire workers? I've seen estimates that roughly 80-85% of farmworkers are Latino/a, and it's well known that they receive low pay, few to no benefits and are not protected by many labor laws/osha standards. Do the photos of wholesome Midwestern farm owners, who may or may not be the face of an agribusiness conglomerate, also hide the racialized dimension of who does the bulk of the actual cultivation? And does it make us feel better to "know where our food is coming from" if we don't have to think about who grew it and under what conditions?
Jeanette — February 26, 2011
Interesting post, and interesting research. Although I'd be curious to know what "women's avoidance of synthetic chemicals" means.
Tamar Gablinger — February 27, 2011
I don't know if it is a German or an EU consumer law (I assume it is a law, because it is all over), but our supermarkets always have the name of the country where the fruit or vegetable came from (and if it is regional, sometimes the supermarket would add "products from your region" - "Produkte aus Ihrer Region!"). It means that a consumer can decide not to buy something that came from outside the country or the Union (or at least that came from other continents like South America, which means a far way to go). Of course, they can also choose to eat regional only, I guess that through the signs in the supermarkets it is possible without a CSA, but given that in my region it would probably means eating apples and potatoes throughout the winter, it is probably not the choice of many.
Donsie — February 27, 2011
I think rather too much is being made of this. The shop clearly wanted to keep up with other supermarkets by noting the origins of food but the staff hadn't a clue or the ability/inclination to find out what that was for the bananas. Hence they listed that they were (by their nature of being a tropical plant) from the tropics. This might reveal a bit about how the shop employees think of the tropics as a collective area (which, of course, it is in terms of both a definable region and more generally, a climate) but it is reading too much into things to make claims about such a statement playing upon consumers desires for the tropics (rather than of knowing the origin of their food). In fact, I have no desire for the tropics. They're hot, humid, and full of dengue.
Alll — February 27, 2011
I've been refusing to buy garlic lately from Whole Foods because every time I look at the country of origin sign, it says "From USA and Argentina," with no way to tell which bulbs come from which country!
blueowleyes — February 27, 2011
"Harkening back to a day when grocery and ‘convenience’ stores did not exist, one was intimately aware of where one’s food was coming from. This is because leading a life of subsistence meant growing one’s own food. It meant raising animals and growing crops and then processing them into food. As foodstuffs began to be commodified, that is, rendered a marketable good to be exchanged for capital — and largely controlled by transnational corporations — we began to lose understanding to where our food comes from."
Who's 'we'? Who, where, and when are you talking about? The days before grocery stores? (The days of yore? Olden times? The good old days in Eutopiaville, when and where people were intimately connected with their food?) And do you mean to suggest that the lack of grocery stores means subsistence farming? And that it goes from subsistence farming to control by transnationals in some sort of evolution? When do you think foodstuffs 'began' to be commodified?
Way to grossly over-simplify (or get entirely wrong) millennia of human economic and agricultural history and trade systems. The commodification of and trade in foodstuffs is as old as farming itself. And trading foodstuffs does not necessarily mean being distanced from the production and processing of food. There are many scenarios where your blanket assumption falls apart.
Owenhyde — April 16, 2012
Hi,
Here is Owen Hyde, I’m very interested
in guest posting at your sites/ blogs.
I
discovered you by your site. I have gone through your site, I was really
impressed and wanted to get involved. I am having a unique and a fresh content for "Grocery Store " to share as a
guest post and my title is ” Easy grocery shopping by saving money ”. I will be mailing my few ideas which you
might be enjoyed.
Please
reply me. Let me know what you think. I
hope all is well.
With
thanks and the best regards,
Owen
Hyde.
Christine — December 23, 2015
I don't see how that's actually legal. I thought that labels had to say country, not just domestic or non. (I'm assuming that's why fruit isn't labelled anymore, and just says "Canada", but there might be other reasons for that.)
Krogerfeedback — November 20, 2019
krogerfeedback is the survey conducted to know the feeling of regular customers about Kroger stores. We all know that Kroger is the biggest grocery store and has many branches all over the united states.
kuldip bihola — March 17, 2021
krogerfeedback.com Survey is an online survey held by Kroger supermarket store to hear their customer’s reviews and responses about their products and services. With the help of this Kroger Customer Satisfaction Survey, the clients can connect with them online through this review and leave honest reviews about their progress and experience of shopping at the Kroger store.
www.krogerfeedback.com/survey
arbys survey — March 22, 2021
About www.arbys.com/survey Satisfaction Survey
Arby’s survey is an online consumer engagement service developed by Arby’s to gather honest feedback, recommendations, and ideas from its users to co-operate the company for its development.
jess glenny — April 16, 2021
If your annual subscription to MagicJack has ended, then you need to renew Magic Jack subscription to keep enjoying its perks. Click Here
glendy — April 21, 2021
Distance to the patronized store was not directly associated with consumption of produce. ... distance to food stores, availability and consumption of fresh produce. ... to shopping at those stores located closest to them geographically. ... assess the multivariable relationships between the socio-demographic variables and the .
glendy — April 21, 2021
Distance to the patronized store was not directly associated with consumption of produce. ... distance to food stores, availability and consumption of fresh produce. ... to shopping at those stores located closest to them geographically. ... assess the multivariable relationships between the socio-demographic variables and the mylife usaa login
alex_carey — May 4, 2021
Consumer demand for food that is locally produced,marketed, and consumed ... Definitions related to geographic distance between production and sales vary by ... are often used interchangeably to refer to food produced near its point of ... farmers to restaurants, retail stores, and institutions such as government enti-.td hr portal
melania trump — May 15, 2021
Bristol Seafood Grill, a fast-food restaurant takes feedback from its customers via Bristol Seafood Grill Guest Satisfaction Survey to improves its products.
Bristolfeedback Survey is all about your recent visit experience and your feedback will help the chain to improve.website
oliver Michael — May 20, 2021
To raise the Sleep Train Mattress Centers Customer Satisfaction Survey they await your positive and reliable judgment because your important feedback would be helped to improve its facility to make your next visit betterpaydayavancelistens
mandela03 — June 24, 2021
Panda Express Survey code. The Panda Express wants genuine feedback from their customers about that employee, Product & services.
Panda Express Survey
kantari3 — June 25, 2021
Your feedback will help Giant Eagle Express to make progress so please feel free to express yourself. link text
Omegle Alternative — June 30, 2021
Panda Express Survey code. The Panda Express wants genuine feedback from their customers about that employee Omegle Alternative
Bazoocam Chatroulette Alternative — June 30, 2021
ssess the multivariable relationships between the socio-demographic variables and the Bazoocam Chatroulette Alternative
Omegle Alternative — June 30, 2021
Bristol Seafood Grill, a fast-food restaurant takes feedback from its customers via Bristol Seafood Grill Guest Satisfaction Survey to improves its products.
Bristolfeedback Survey is all Omegle Alternative
jonesdavies75 — September 15, 2021
the end of the Albertsons Guest Feedback Survey, you will be rewarded with a $100 Albertsons Gift Card on your next visit purchase. There are some rules and regulations that you need to follow to take part in this Albertsons Guest Experience Survey, https://surveyz.onl/www-albertsons-com-survey-albertsons-survey/
jonesdavies75 — September 15, 2021
the end of the Albertsons Guest Feedback Survey, you will be rewarded with a $100 Albertsons Gift Card on your next visit purchase. There are some rules and regulations that you need to follow to take part in this Albertsons Guest Experience Survey, www.Albertsons.com/survey
sergio — September 22, 2021
defined by geographical distance from grocery stores. Literature suggests that food deserts are produced through uneven development, https //aka.ms/remoteconnect account settings
jejime9225 — October 7, 2021
Share your experience that how you felt at American Family Care, your feedback will help to make changes and improvements to Doctors Express Customer Service.
FaxCoverSheet — October 29, 2021
I have seen the first-time Article it is so wonderful thanks for sharing this article.
myaccessflorida — October 29, 2021
Thank you so much for this Article this is very useful
https://myaccessflorida.me/
rapidfs — November 20, 2021
I am impressed with your content.
rapidfs — November 20, 2021
Your website is very helpful.
https://rapidfs.pro/
employee benefit — December 2, 2021
You can discover the information related to the Benefits of the Employees which are provided by the company they are working for. Employee Benefit
jonybravo44 — January 17, 2022
Taco Bell Holiday Hours – Taco Bell is an American-based chain of fast-food restaurants originating in Irvine, California.
Taco Bell offers made-to-order and customizable burritos, tacos, and other specialities with bold tastes, breakthrough value, quality ingredients, and best-in-class customer service.Taco Bell Holiday Hours
jonaz — May 22, 2022
www.capitalone.com/activate
Steve — May 28, 2022
Great Article thanks for such a great information please do follow these articles.
wecare rite aid
Costco Citi card login
vinilos de pared — July 13, 2022
This is an awesome rousing article.I am practically satisfiedh for everyone, but I hope that the more I will endure and get good results. Thank you . That appears to be excellent however i am still not too sure that I like it. At any rate will look far more into it and decide personally! My web vinilos decorativos
Princy — August 13, 2022
Portillo’s encourages their customers to participate in the survey by keeping some worth rewards which their customers can avail at the time of their next purchase with the help of the Portillos survey code which he or she will get on answering all the questions mentioned in the survey.
Nathaniel Ejeta — May 15, 2023
Thanks for the information you shared about Talktofoodlion.Com I appreciate your efforts and taking the time and sharing this content.