In a society in which masculinity is valued over femininity, like the U.S., the words “woman” and “girl” (not to mention words like “pussy,” “bitch,” and “cocksucker”) are effective slurs against both men and women. The flipside of this, of course, is that acting like a man is considered good. Acting like a man means being powerful, assertive, and effective. In masculinized arenas, like politics, both men and women are expected to act like men and being accused of being a woman is an effective slur against any politician.
Case in point: Dmitriy T.M. sent a 30-sec Politico video in which Sharron Angle tells Harry Reid to “man up.”
Politico reports five other instances in which candidates of both sexes delivered this chide to opponents. The fact that both men and women find this insult useful suggests that everyone has accepted sexism in politics and is willing to endorse and manipulate it to win. But, while the slur may help individual women and men win races, it ultimately affirms the idea that politics is no place for a woman.
Lisa Wade, PhD is an Associate Professor at Tulane University. She is the author of American Hookup, a book about college sexual culture; a textbook about gender; and a forthcoming introductory text: Terrible Magnificent Sociology. You can follow her on Twitter and Instagram.
Comments 17
Natalie — October 24, 2010
I'd like to add "douche" to that list of words.
JKinsman — October 24, 2010
Gross. There's an entire campaign devoted to fighting sexism against women candidates right now: http://www.nameitchangeit.org/
It's funny, because they keep having to defend women against media sexism... who then turn around and tell their male opponents to "man up." This comes from everyone.
Andrew — October 24, 2010
I see your point... but... being called a "cock" or a "dick" isn't quite complimentary either.
John — October 24, 2010
Not too longer after that, Harry Reid's campaign spokesperson said Angle needed to "man up" - http://tpmdc.talkingpointsmemo.com/2010/10/harry-reid-camp-tells-sharron-angle-to-man-up.php?ref=fpb
A. Helin — October 24, 2010
Related to this: Pekka Isotalus, professor of speech communication at the University of Tampere in Finland, has been doing research on the voices of Finnish female politicians. Their voice has lowered by an average of half an interval over the past 50 years; female politicians either lower their voice to masculinize it unconsciously, or speech coaches get them to do it. This gives them more credibility as a politician. Apparently Margaret Thatcher was told to do the same thing. Female politicans with naturally higher voices are seen (heard, natch) as "screechy" and have a harder time than those who have lower voices.
I can only offer a link to the news item in Finnish, he doesn't seem to have published much in English, but it's an interesting venue into this as well. http://yle.fi/uutiset/kotimaa/2010/01/matala_aani_tuo_naispoliitikolle_uskottavuutta_1372034.html
DORU — October 24, 2010
It's more subtle than 'male gender good, female gender bad'. This insult wouldn't work in reverse. If he told her to 'man up' it would only end up making him look chauvinist. Women in politics aren't subject to the same rules as men; they aren't required to behave as men, and indeed can employ tools that men don't have at their disposal because they are women. Recall Hillary's fantastically successful weeping in New Hampshire during the primaries. What male pol could pull that off? I mean, imagine that!
Men are required to behave as men, and women can move between archetypes at their convenience. Sharron Angles' is a gendered insult that women can deploy with unique force and it works to emasculate him. This dynamic doesn't work in reverse. Harry Reid needs maintain his masculine identity at all times; Sharron Angle not so much.
MJS — October 24, 2010
I don't think I've ever heard "cocksucker" directed at a woman. If anything I think that one's rooted in anti-gay sentiment.
AD — October 24, 2010
Haters gonna hate, but I couldn't help thinking of the film The Cement Garden, "for a boy to look like a girl is degrading, because you think being a girl is degrading."
Ames — October 25, 2010
This is so typical we don't even see it in our daily lives. The most popular epithet, "fuck you," (or it's stand-in, flipping the bird) references rape. For much of our history, the worst thing you could think to hurl at someone places that person in the position of a woman or a gay man (since straight males are the default human beings). The vast majority of people would say that's not what they're thinking when they use that phrase (or gesture) - it's an unthinking moment - but just why then does it still carry so much weight and what COULD one mean other than what it actually DOES mean?