Monica Y. sent a collection of vintage ads and cartoons illustrating how soap and cleanliness has been used as a metaphor for colonization. The first two ads show how soap manufacturers and colonialists alike colluded in suggesting that the colonized were unclean/uncivilized and needed to be cleansed/enlightened.
This first ad for Pears’ Soap reads:
The first step towards lightening The White Man’s Burden is through teaching the virtues of cleanliness. Pears’ Soap is a potent factor in brightening the dark corners of the earth as civilization advances while amongst the cultured of all nations it holds the highest place — it is the ideal toilet soap.
The phrase “White Man’s Burden” refers to the colonial-era idea that white men were burdened with bringing civilization to the uncivilized. See our post on a modern-day Pamper’s commercial invoking a white woman’s burden for another example.
This ad for Ivory soap depicts Uncle Sam (I think) passing out soap to American Indians (in blankets, no less) (text transcribed below):
Text:
A NEW DEPARTURE
SAID Uncle Sam: “I will be wise,
And thus the Indian civilize:
Instead of guns, that kill a mile,
Tobacco, lead, and liquor vile,
Instead of serving out a meal,
Or sending Agents out to steal,
I’ll give, domestic arts to teach,
A cake of IVORY SOAP to each.
Before it flies the guilty stain,The grease and dirt no more remain;
‘Twill change their nature day by day,
And wash their darkest blots away.
They’re turn their bows to fishing-rods,
And bury hatchets under sods,
In wisdom and in worth increase,
And ever smoke the pipe of peace;
For ignorance can never cope
With such a foe as IVORY SOAP.”
This political cartoon, circa 1886, uses the metaphor of washing to describe the cleansing of the Chinese from the U.S. At the bottom it reads, “The Chinese must go.”
See also our set of vintage ads selling soap with depictions of African Americans as dirty.
Lisa Wade, PhD is an Associate Professor at Tulane University. She is the author of American Hookup, a book about college sexual culture; a textbook about gender; and a forthcoming introductory text: Terrible Magnificent Sociology. You can follow her on Twitter and Instagram.
Comments 21
kai — August 10, 2010
Anne McClintock does a fantastic analysis of these images in her book Imperial Leather.
Vidya — August 10, 2010
I don't think that's Uncle Sam in the first image; I've seen a clearer reproduction (perhaps in McClintock's text) that makes him appear to be a typical captain-figure. Also, Pears is a British company, not an American one.
PS Birch — August 10, 2010
I don't believe the third item is a political cartoon but rather an actual advertisement, and one based on Nativism and xenophobia rather than colonialism. The Library of Congress has further information here : http://www.loc.gov/pictures/collection/pga/item/93500013/
You've elsewhere on this site pointed out the connections between Chinese stereotypes and clothes cleaners, especially in the mid- late-1800s. I take from this third ad a sense of 'use our soap to do your own washing, because then we can kick out the Chinese.' The LOC version (apparently identical) has the text below "The Chinese Must Go" reading as:
"We have no use for them since we got this WONDERFUL WASHER. What a blessing to tired mothers It costs so little and don't (sic) injure the clothes"
A — August 10, 2010
Jean-Michel Massing, an art historian, has written a series of articles on this subject (I would particularly recommend 'From Greek Proverb to soap advert: Washing the Ethiopian' in The Journal of the Warburg and Courtauld Institutes, 1995); the articles trace the development of this line of thought and feature some rather strange advertisements which actually show soap as literally removing skin pigmentation.
Ryan — August 11, 2010
The second image down made me laugh. The native people in contact with the first European colonists in (what is now) the United States had very high cultural standards of personal hygiene. The Europeans bathed ~once per month. The native people thought the Europeans were, for the most part, absolutely disgusting.
ina ina — August 16, 2010
I found this treasure at the museum of immigration in Paris.
http://www.histoire-immigration.fr/upload/file/ext_para_col1_image_217_17-05-23_228.jpg
Fundstücke Nr. 2 « Afrika Wissen Schaft — August 26, 2010
[...] Sociological Images gibt es einen Beitrag, der anhand von alten Werbungen den Zusammenhang von Seife und Kolonialismus aufzeigt. In den [...]
Why Race Still Matters in The Netherlands « PLUG — April 20, 2011
[...] beauty. This means in the public consciousness, those characteristics are demeaned and equated with dirty, objectionable [...]
Normalizing the outliers « Poems, Prayers, Promises & Politics — January 24, 2012
[...] I want you to stop giving me a bar of soap to wash with without giving me the water to rinse. If you’re going to include me, go ahead and do it. [...]
Why Race Still Matters in The Netherlands | Processed Life — November 24, 2013
[…] beauty. This means in the public consciousness, those characteristics are demeaned and equated with dirty, objectionable […]
Pond’s Skin Whitening Cream | GNDS 125 Blog — March 27, 2014
[…] http://thesocietypages.org/socimages/2010/08/10/colonialism-soap-and-the-cleansing-metaphor/ […]
What Brands Need to Know When They Get into Politics | FreshMR — April 29, 2019
[…] The connotations of the ad instantly drew negativity and led social media users to draw parallels with racist soap adverts that were prominent in the turn of the 20th century. […]
crystal glow — December 11, 2020
Hey
I was checking out some of the articles on your site and found this post about the topic eg (skincare) & I really loved it
https://thesocietypages.org/socimages/2010/08/10/colonialism-soap-and-the-cleansing-metaphor/
It will be a great help for us if you can add https://crystalglow.in/all-you-need-to-know-about-crystal-glow-advanced-brightening-cream/
On your website.
It might be worth a mention in your article.
Either way, keep up the awesome work
crystal glow — December 11, 2020
Hey
I was checking out some of the articles on your site and found this post about the topic eg (skincare) & I really loved it
https://thesocietypages.org/socimages/2010/08/10/colonialism-soap-and-the-cleansing-metaphor/
It will be a great help for us if you can add https://crystalglow.in/all-you-need-to-know-about-crystal-glow-advanced-brightening-cream/
On your website.
It might be worth a mention in your article.
Either way, keep up the awesome work
Bernard Conde — February 22, 2024
The article "Colonialism, Soap, and the Cleansing Metaphor" offers a thought-provoking exploration of how language and imagery shape our understanding of power dynamics. It adeptly deconstructs the metaphor of "cleansing" often used in colonial contexts, shedding light on its implications for marginalized communities. This insightful piece prompts reflection on the narratives we perpetuate and the perspectives we privilege. On another note, while considering the impact of language, it's crucial to acknowledge the perspectives of locals, whose voices are often sidelined in discussions about their own communities. This website, like many others, could benefit from amplifying local voices and narratives.
Sexe Grenoble — May 28, 2024
Chacune interaction numérique avec les Mature Sexe Grenoble françaises est une exclusive immergeance dans la pluriformité et l'opulence culturelle. Leurs contes et vécus offrent une vision particulière du monde.
sexe mamies — June 27, 2024
Il est invariablement un contentement de parler virtuellement avec des sexe mamies. Leur charme et leur raffinement font chaque discussion spéciale !
shemale a Napoli — October 14, 2024
Le interazioni con shemale annunci Napoli affascinanti sono sempre una gioia. Ogni dialogo è un piacere.
incontri sesso messina — October 28, 2024
Chattare con sesso a messina stimolanti rende ogni scambio piacevole.