Katrin discovered a particularly ironic bit of photoshopping. The first picture is of Rosie Huntington-Whiteley on a photo shoot, the second is her ad for the Victoria’s Secret “I Love My Body” ad campaign. Notice that the body she is supposedly loving has significantly more cleavage than the body we see in the first photo. Apparently even models’ bodies are unlovable without re-touching (or surgery?).
Lisa Wade, PhD is an Associate Professor at Tulane University. She is the author of American Hookup, a book about college sexual culture; a textbook about gender; and a forthcoming introductory text: Terrible Magnificent Sociology. You can follow her on Twitter and Instagram.
Comments 31
Ben Zvan — June 17, 2010
It's possible that she's wearing the padded push-up bra from the 'I love my body' collection rather than being overly photoshopped. But that opens a whole new can of worms.
Deaf Indian Muslim Anarchist — June 17, 2010
aside from this photoshop B.S, isn't anyone else bothered by the "I Love My Body" campaign featuring skinny white women? Looking at that photo would just make many women (and girls) feel worse about themselves. Not all of us can afford healthy food, take time off work to work out, or can afford our own personal trainers.
TIFFANY — June 17, 2010
It's easy to love your body as a white, photoshopped supermodel.
Cori — June 17, 2010
Posture can make a huge differnce in how one's chest looks. With her arms up and thrown back as opposed to her shoulders hunched, her cleavage will always appear to be less. I don't doubt that a larger than life advertising campaign picture would be retouched, but it may not be quite as dramatic as it appears fromt these two pictures. I'd be more worried about the fact that they appear to be "fattening her up" so that her ribs weren't showing (although, that too is affected by posture). It provides an unrealistic idea of how thin you can be and still look relatively "healthy".
Anonymous — June 17, 2010
"significantly less cleavage"
I think perhaps you meant to say 'more'?
Anonymous — June 17, 2010
from what other photos i've turned of this girl, it seems like the second photo could easily be non-photoshopped.
still a bullshit ad campaign, though.
Lucy — June 17, 2010
Even if the cleavage wasn't altered, the picture is clearly very much photo shopped. I mean, her breasts are quite literally GLOWING.
Heather — June 18, 2010
They also seem to have photoshopped the second photo to reduce the appearance of her rib cage.
Sadie — June 18, 2010
Am I wierd? I prefer my boobs to appear on the smaller side. Then again, I think I may have some erroneous values about boos size being inversely proportional to brain size...which is very sad, because I know better. Still, I like small boobs. Why would having big bazongas raise anyone's confidence is kinda beyond me.
Jayde — June 21, 2010
While it's true VS is known for using a lot of retouching, you seem to be completely unaware of a few things.
1. In the first picture (shooting for the Pirelli calendar) she is wearing a bikini with support whatsoever.
2. She is leaning forward a bit in the second pic, which is giving her cleavage a bit of a boost.
3. She is wearing the Body By Victoria push up which adds about a cup size. And I know she is wearing the push up because it says so in the Body By Victoria commercials.
4. Rosie has been quoted in the press saying that in VS shoots she is padded up with up to four bra inserts to enhance her cleavage.
So, while of course she's retouched, you can't completely attribute Rosie's awesome boobs to photoshop. I realize you're trying to make a social commentary here, but next time maybe you should be a little more informed before you blog.
Maria — June 21, 2010
Re: all the 'I'd love my body too if it looked like THAT' comments - I'd just to like to point out that it's entirely possible you wouldn't, the insiduous nature of cultural beauty standards means that you could be a white size 8 blonde girl, and STILL think you were too fat and/or hideous. It's the sad nature of the beast, women especially are conditioned into competing with each other to be better-looking because it is expected that our worth is proportionate to how attractive we are, and so women are expected to spend more and more time and money on making themselves attractive to others, and especially more attractive than the other women around them. Since there will always be someone blonder and skinnier than you, it's easy to hate your body. I'm not saying that the racist nature of cultural beauty standards doesn't hit non-white or bigger (is that the appropriate word?) women harder - I'd definitely agree that it does - but it is missing the point -that objective beauty standards are imposed bullshit- to think that the possessors of bodies like these automatically love their bodies and have no issues with self-worth.
http://www.telegraph.co.uk/fashion/stellamagazine/7725736/Women-and-body-image-a-mans-perspective.html
and perhaps a little more offtopic, on the unattainability (and irrelevance) of the beauty standard
http://www.fatshionista.com/cms/index.php?option=com_mojo&Itemid=69&p=272
from this article:
"Everywhere we look we’re confronted with messages instructing us that to be beautiful is to be feminine, or at least that we ought to aspire to beauty even knowing that the vagaries of popular culture and genetics may ensure that it’ll always dance just beyond our grasp...
“Beautiful” is a loaded concept, encumbered with implications far beyond the dictionary definition. It’s a vehicle on which we can put our deeper worries, our fears that we’re not good enough, our insecurities, our sadness. It’s easier to say “I feel beautiful!” than it is to say “I feel confident!” “Beautiful” is a feeling that’s okay for a woman to express; often, “confidence” is not. But that’s a conflation of two discrete concepts. When we use it in this way, “beautiful” becomes a code word we employ when we can’t get at our deeper feelings, or at least when we can’t express them in a culturally-acceptable way. Feeling beautiful is often about nothing so much as feeling accepted, loved, appreciated, respected, and feeling those things about oneself from the inside, as well as feeling them as they are expressed by other people."
MamaMay — June 23, 2010
I am sure it is photoshoped but I didn't notice the boobs, I noticed the ribs. In the 1st picture she has them in the 2nd she has had them photoshoped out.
It says a lot about how we (we meaning our society in general) want women thin but we also want them soft.
angie — September 6, 2010
Maybe she just gained some weight.
alimentos pós treino — September 27, 2018
I liked my post was integrated, I will share it in my social media. thank you
alimentos pós treino — October 5, 2018
I liked my post was integrated, I will share it in my social media, instagram. thank you