Dmitriy T.M. and Andrew L. sent a link to a collection of post-World War I men’s magazine covers. They are a window into a time when being a man was clearly a very distinct achievement, but much less related to consumption than it is today.
Today’s men’s magazines emphasize control over oneself and the conquest of women, as do these vintage magazines, but instead of tests of strength, cunning, and fighting ability, they emphasize conquest through consumption. The message is to consume the right exercise, the right products (usually hygiene or tech-related), the right advice on picking up women and, well, the right women. In contrast, these old magazines pit man against nature or other men; consumption has not yet colonized the idea of masculinity.
View a selection of the covers at The Art of Manliness.
Lisa Wade, PhD is an Associate Professor at Tulane University. She is the author of American Hookup, a book about college sexual culture; a textbook about gender; and a forthcoming introductory text: Terrible Magnificent Sociology. You can follow her on Twitter and Instagram.
Comments 114
Meera — June 8, 2010
These covers don't suggest a consumption of commercial products, it's true. But the representations are part of a larger trend of fostering an 'imperial masculinity' which, particularly in the decades previous to these particular magazines, had been promoted as a way of ensuring a masculinized dominance by Western powers on the world stage -- a dominance which involved the consumption of huge amounts of natural and human resources from colonized/subjugated areas of the world.
Lurkin Merkin — June 8, 2010
I'm not sure what I like better - "Cannibal Crabs Crawl to Kill!" or "Mad Monkeys Manned the Lifeboats!"
"Flying Rodents Ripped My Flesh!" is also quite endearing.
Deaf Indian Muslim Anarchist — June 8, 2010
They're all white, too. I don't know if this is noteworthy, but all of them have brown hair. Not one blonde or redhead there. Does it mean something?
Dire Sloth — June 8, 2010
These have got to be some of the most hilarious things I've ever seen. I'm having a hard time believing some of them are legit.
Didn't "Weasels ripped my flesh" form the basis of some famous album art?
Emily — June 8, 2010
I'm confused/intrigued by the headline "Sex can be fun!" Was this really a novel thought? I mean, most sex should be fun, right? Right? I'd actually love to read the sex-advice articles in these, to see how male sexuality was constructed during this period.
I'm also amused by precisely how many animals I think of as cute, cuddly, or ignorable are apparently DEADLY KILLERS in these. I mean, really. Squirrels? Turtles? Lobsters?
I think there are a hundred thousand really good band names in this post.
b — June 8, 2010
I really, really want to read all the sex articles. Why SHOULD I marry a virgin??? I do think it gets a bit into "women to be consumed" in some of these. Or at least women as trophies.
Heather — June 8, 2010
I'm deeply amused by the proportion of these covers that depict critters leaping at/crawling on partially clothed men.
Makenzie — June 8, 2010
I deeply adore the earnestness of "Sex can be fun!"
Crash — June 8, 2010
Is there some special reason that all of these uber masculine battles between man and nature occur in the water? In 8 of the pictures, water appears to be a significant handicap that hampers the man's ability to defend himself against whatever hoard of animals have been lying in wait for his flesh. Were the artists simply uncreative, or is there some other symbolism that I am missing here?
Brandon — June 8, 2010
"I'm Teaching My Kid to Fight Dirty" and "Don't Be a Sucker: Cheat!"
Interesting... fighting dirty and cheating don't seem to fit in with the hypermasculinity of these mags.
Stephanie — June 8, 2010
Those. Look. Awesome! I mean, I knew People, Cosmo, Maxim, Vogue, Elle, (the list goes on) were snoozefests, but come on! I wish magazines had more stories and actual, less "Buy this!".
bellacoker — June 8, 2010
1) Killer Turtles!!!
2) "Why Foreign Girls Make Better Wives and Lovers" could be ripped from any MRA handbook today. That's interesting.
Noir — June 8, 2010
I love love "cannibal crabs crawl to kill." Like you have no idea. Apparently, crabs see white adventurous men as part of their species.
Maya — June 8, 2010
Did anyone else see a connection between the "red tide of death" in the first picture and a fear or menstruation?
splack — June 8, 2010
What's a sex racket?
MaggieDanger — June 8, 2010
I'd love to see a fight between those killer turtles and ninja turtles.
Amanda — June 8, 2010
I love the angry swarm of monkeys crawling into the lifeboat. Also, "CHEWED TO BITS BY GIANT TURTLES"
po — June 8, 2010
Very cool! If any of those mags were around now, I'd buy a couple.
puppy — June 8, 2010
Do these seriously have all those articles in them? The covers look like something a comedy site threw together with Photoshop.
Shy — June 9, 2010
Jesus! Men couldn't do anything without having to fend off crazed wildlife!
Ed — June 9, 2010
Attack of the flying squirrels! I love it.
I believe all these covers come from a time before TV was as common as it is now, and certainly before cable/satellite TV and the internet were as common. People used to read, and in the twentieth century had access to large numbers of books through at least the libraries. But most people probably did not have great reading skills and probably didn't enjoy it much, so covers like these were needed to draw readers in (and I would love to read some of the stories, to see what level they were written at)(plus, you know, the vicious flying squirrels). Boys probably thought they would gain skills reading these, or learn about/experience indirectly something about sex. As Lisa says, the magazine is about nothing more than the consumption of the magazine, and perhaps consuming the products of what ever advertisements there are in the magazine (Lucky Strikes! or Gillette razors!).
Now, with TV and the internet, we have all have a wide sort of knowledge, we have all heard of Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles, and we all recognize a ninja when we see one in a movie or TV episode. But our knowledge of ninjas (for example) is shallow. We vaguely know they have something to do with Asia and martial arts. If pressed, some might admit they know ninjas have something to do with assassination. Just in the last couple of days the NYTimes has been running articles about how information overload is affecting our attention spans. I didn't read the articles, I had too many 30 second tasks to do.
mercurianferret — June 9, 2010
One comment: while lisa is technically correct in saying that these are post-WWI magazine covers, it would be more accurate to point out that they are from the 1950s and 1960s. Things like, "Nuclear Scientists Demand: Stop H-Bomb Testing Now" and "Why Rocky Marciano Didn't Really Retire" points to these covers being from at least the mid-to-late-1950s (H-bombs didn't really start testing in the US until the 1952, and Rocky Marciano retired in 1956).
While the idea of a "Red Scare" could possibly be referring to those movements in the 1910s, it is more likely, too, referring to the anti-Soviet sentiment that swept the nation (the "Second Red Scare"), and brought McCarthy into the headlines (late 1940s to late 1950s).
Also, the idea of "dodging the draft" wasn't something that I would have imagined would have been celebrated in a men's magazine of the immediate WWI era, nor would really any of the above stories, what with all the influenza deaths taking place during 1918. (And I didn't know that color magazines were so ubiquitous in the immediate post-WWI period; or that magazines were so relatively expensive.)
Maybe no one else was mislead as to the time period, but -- for me -- a little more precision on the date/period would have been appreciated.
thom — June 9, 2010
"Consumption has not yet colonized the idea of masculinity" is a pretty sweeping statement based on a dozen men's mag covers (only covers) from the 1950s and 1960s. As early as the 1870s (and probably earlier), adverts in newspapers for were promising hair growth for men, weight loss for men, muscle growth for men, increased "vitality" for men, etc. etc. all based on the masculine ideal that one needed a full head of hair, a flat gut, and muscular torso in order to be a "real" man. And I'd love to see the adverts on the insides of these magazines, which I assume offer essentially the same commercial judgements/promises. That these covers were designed to sell magazines, not other products, is really just another example of "consumption colonizing the idea of masculinity."
Blue Jean — June 9, 2010
No wonder 1950's men had no time for consumerism. They were too busy being consumed by snakes, lobsters, turtles, flying squirrels, etc. not to mention the odd grizzly bear or two.
(Really, a grizzly bear? In the desert?)
Lyrwen — June 9, 2010
The message is very clear: to be a REAL MAN you must single handedly fight off large numbers of mutant versions of some sort of animal traditionally regarded as vermin with a stick, semi-shirtless.
Someguy — June 9, 2010
Man, I hate having to fight off vicious turtles to protect my passed out spouse.
Finally, a magazine for me!
Becks Other Hangout — June 10, 2010
[...] least we don't have to fight Cannibal Crabs" or Mad Monkeys" anymore.Source:http://thesocietypages.org/socimages/2010/06/08/vintage-mens-magazines-and-a-pre-consumerist-time-2/ Jun [...]
The Morning After: Battle Cry of the Menaissance Edition - The Sexist - Washington City Paper — June 10, 2010
[...] Sociological Images takes a ride on the way-back machine to examine the men’s magazines of yore . . . you know, back when men were men. Tip via Jess, who was particularly fond of Battle Cry [...]
juan — June 10, 2010
Have you noticed the cover art? It appears they used the same model for many of the paintings. Whatever money he made to look...mean, surprised, angry, ...whatever, must have paid for the happy hours.
Donna — June 10, 2010
Some of these covers are hilarious to look at nowadays. I'm pretty sure the "flying rodents ripped my flesh" may have inspired the title and/or cover of a certain Frank Zappa album...
I think my favorite, though, is the one with the "cannibal crabs" (by the way, if the crabs are cannibals, won't they just eat each other?).
Deborah — June 10, 2010
I was born in 1954 & I remember my dad having magazines like these in his "library", aka bathroom. He was a blue-collar guy. He & his friends had magazines like this, but none of my friends' fathers seemed to have them around. Those fathers were engineers, teachers, school principals,etc. I really think there was a class issue going on. I just doubt that educated, professional men were reading these kinds of magazines even in the 40's 50's 60's- what ever decade we're talking about here. Just like someone in the future could get a copy of Cosmo & make all kinds of social/cultural conclusions about women of today - not realizing it's only a subset of women reading that magazine.
Bombus — June 10, 2010
I see a very unhappy man about to hit a monkey with another monkey, and I can't stop snickering
Home Goddess — June 11, 2010
[...] least we don't have to fight Cannibal Crabs" or Mad Monkeys" anymore.Source:http://thesocietypages.org/socimages/2010/06/08/vintage-mens-magazines-and-a-pre-consumerist-time-2/ Jun [...]
Editors’ Picks of the Week: June 7-11 : Ms Magazine Blog — June 11, 2010
[...] the blog Sociological Images, here are men’s magazine cover stories from the pre-feminist era, when being manly still meant being [...]
Bring Back Man’s Life « TheGloss — June 12, 2010
[...] have enough time to publish anymore? Bring back Man’s Life! If only for the lulz. – thesocietypages.org Saturday, June 12, 2010 - 11:39 am ET [...]
Bring Back Man’s Life - Best Beauty Care — June 12, 2010
[...] by admin on Jun.12, 2010, under Beauty Care Forget Sassy. Forget Spy. I’m pretty sure that if Man’s Life were still around, I would be a subscriber. What happened? Did the red snakes of doom eat it? Did it commit suicide along with the air force? Did it hit puberty, realize the sex CAN be fun, and not have enough time to publish anymore? Bring back Man’s Life! If only for the lulz. – thesocietypages.org [...]
oracle2world — June 14, 2010
I wouldn't bet on a pistol to put down a grizzly bear. But I digress.
Your conclusion about today's men's magazines seems spot on. None of today's men on the cover would last 10 seconds in the UFC cage, and fashion model looks don't matter in a man. Being wealthy (aka nest building) IS important. A wealthy man can look like a toad for all it matters.
Phoenix — June 14, 2010
I think my favorite are the sugargliders/flying squirrels attacking that guy--as an owner of sugar gliders, that just cracks me up!
--Phoenix
Comme des Garçons « Birthday Bread Horse — June 15, 2010
[...] rather curious reaction I had to the blog The Art of Manliness. I found the blog when Soc. Images featured its delightful collection of vintage men’s magazine covers (“chewed to bits by giant [...]
Jen — June 16, 2010
Hi, I think you meant "post WWII" up there, though "post WWI" is technically accurate, the style and as someone else has pointed out, the content indicate these are defo post 1945.
Anon — June 18, 2010
What I don't get is that these men don't even look like they're winning their epic monkey/turtle/squirrel battles...
Very interesting indeed. I want to read the articles!
Sheena — August 25, 2010
The Blog provides its simple, but one of the best platforms I have used and have seen in a while, I think more will start using more often.
Mens Health magazine India
Luke — December 1, 2010
Has anyone read any old Dan Dare comics? They're very good fun. The whole thing is set in the distant future of 1999 and the futuristic advertising is for robots and jet packs, but is in exactly the same style as these magazine covers. I mean, obviously technology would improve, but why would anything else change? Society was perfect in 1958 anyway, surely?
Also, from the above "Man's Conquest" November: Cheesecake model!!
Always » Blog Archive » vintage male photos — June 12, 2011
[...] Vintage Men's Magazines and a Pre-Consumerist Time В» Sociological … Jun 8, 2010 … In 8 of the pictures, water appears to be a significant handicap that hampers the man's ability to … [...]
latest news — December 25, 2018
nice post
Thomas J. Herling, Ph.D. Syracuse University, 1994 — June 30, 2019
Oh, Jesus H. Christ, what a load of bullshit. They were written by starving writers who had to write such hack work to pay the rent and the covers painted by artists doing equally hack work so some sleazly miserly publisher could make a few bucks selling ads for the Rosicrucians and poor slobs with miserable lives had a few minutes of escapist reading from the old ball and chain and bawling kids while downing a couple of beers. Today it's just put on television and made equally ridiculous but with current stylish sensibilities.
Give somebody a Ph.D. and they make up all sorts of stuff and people think it's some kind of wisdom. Feh.
Furosap — October 23, 2020
Hello,
It was a great Blog, I must appreciate your work. It will definitely help most of us. Thank for sharing your precious words.
I want to tell you about one of our product which is genuine Ayurvedic Testosterone Booster and help in supporting healthy testosterone level.
Furosap — October 23, 2020
Hey,
I must say you did a really good job. It was always pleasure to read your blogs.
Thank you for sharing such a beautiful blog.
I am here to tell you about one of the best Ayurvedic Testosterone Booster which will help in supporting Healthy testosterone level.
rani — October 30, 2020
please give me a one approach unit"thank you"
250 words Review all of the blog posts below (they - Affordable Nursing Essays — February 6, 2022
[…] Vintage Men’s Magazines and a Pre-Consumerist Time […]
250 words Review all of the blog posts below (they - Research Paper 123 — February 6, 2022
[…] Vintage Men’s Magazines and a Pre-Consumerist Time […]
Review all of the blog posts below (they are short!) Select three to analyze.??Write an article that uses the examples in - PayperWritings — February 6, 2022
[…] Vintage Men’s Magazines and a Pre-Consumerist Time […]
Review all of the blog posts below (they are short!) Select three to analyze.??Write an article that uses the examples in - Essayabode — February 6, 2022
[…] Vintage Men’s Magazines and a Pre-Consumerist Time […]
Review all of the blog posts below (they are short!) Select three to analyze.??Write an article that uses the examples in | WritePal — February 7, 2022
[…] Vintage Men’s Magazines and a Pre-Consumerist Time […]
Review all of the blog posts below (they are short!) Select three to analyze.??Write an article that uses the examples in - Writerden — February 8, 2022
[…] Vintage Men’s Magazines and a Pre-Consumerist Time […]
Sociological Images blog by?Abby Kinchy and adapted for our course. Gender and the Environment Gender is such a powerful way - Student pals — February 8, 2022
[…] Vintage Men’s Magazines and a Pre-Consumerist Time […]
250 words Review all of the blog posts below (they are short!) | Wridemy — February 9, 2022
[…] Vintage Men’s Magazines and a Pre-Consumerist Time […]
Sociological Images blog by Abby Kinchy and adapted for our course. | Wridemy — February 9, 2022
[…] Vintage Men’s Magazines and a Pre-Consumerist Time […]
Sociological Images blog by?Abby Kinchy and adapted for our course. Gender and the Environment Gender is such a powerful wa | Wridemy — February 10, 2022
[…] Vintage Men’s Magazines and a Pre-Consumerist Time […]
Sociological Images blog by?Abby Kinchy and adapted for our course. Gender and the Environment Gender is such a powerful wa - PayperWritings — February 10, 2022
[…] Vintage Men’s Magazines and a Pre-Consumerist Time […]
Sociological Images blog by?Abby Kinchy and adapted for our course. Gender and the Environment Gender is such a powerful wa - Writerden — February 10, 2022
[…] Vintage Men’s Magazines and a Pre-Consumerist Time […]
In what ways have patriarchal ideas influenced cultural representations of nature, past and present? - Infinite Essays — May 31, 2022
[…] Vintage Men’s Magazines and a Pre-Consumerist Time […]
Sociological Images blog by Abby Kinchy and adapted for our course. - Wridemy — December 24, 2022
[…] Vintage Men’s Magazines and a Pre-Consumerist Time […]
Nick — February 14, 2024
Embarking on the path to a smoke-free lifestyle is a commendable decision, and finding the right support is crucial. At Shop Top Vape Brands, we understand the challenges of quitting smoking. That's why we've carefully selected a range of top-quality vape devices and accessories to aid your journey. Our products offer a less harmful alternative to traditional smoking, with a variety of flavors and styles to match your preferences. Dive into our collection and discover the perfect companion to help you leave cigarettes behind for good.
Nick — February 14, 2024
Exploring healthier alternatives to smoking? Dive into the world of vaping with Shop Top Vape Brands. Our curated selection of vape devices is designed to cater to both beginners and seasoned vapers, offering a smoother transition away from traditional cigarettes. With innovative technology, a wide range of flavors, and user-friendly designs, our products aim to enhance your vaping experience. Whether you're looking to reduce your nicotine intake or searching for a cleaner alternative, our collection is here to support your journey towards a healthier lifestyle.