Michael G., Sarahjane C., and Marlow sent us this commercial, designed for a small market, advertising a furniture store called The Red House. It was produced by Rhett McLaughlin and Link Neal. It is a real commercial, though it was designed to self-consciously spoof the many poorly-produced and weirdly-sloganed commercials that we’ve all seen advertising local small businesses on late night television. Word on the street is that the commercial has been maligned as racist. What do you think?
McLaughlin and Neal felt obliged to respond to the accusations of racism in another video. In it, they make a distinction between “racist” and “racial” and suggest that the video only seems racist if any and all talk that acknowledges race is considered bad.
This is an example of how the internet operates as a public sphere and can facilitate discussion about difficult topics. Without youtube, attention to this commercial would have remained local and/or restricted to a two minute discussion on the nightly news. Instead, the commercial has been viewed over 1.2 millions times and the response has been viewed over 50,000 times (as of today). Blogs all over the internet have picked up on the controversy and people are chiming in. I wouldn’t say that the discussion is all that sophisticated, but it is really interesting to see so many Americans discussing racism at all.
Then again, maybe the commercial has gotten so much attention because most people conclude that it is not racist. That is, are race and racism more likely to be widely discussed when the collective conclusion is “not racism”? Do we see such wide discussion of clearly racist material?
What do you think? Is this an example of the revolutionary power of the internet? Or just business as usual?
Comments 18
Jeannie — May 24, 2009
I only watched the first one, but it was pretty funny to watch in terms of the acting and filming! They looked like they were just having fun and "getting along," as they put it.
To answer whether or not the commercial was racist is difficult. Yes and no? One part features a black woman with a tele next to her showing some zebras and giraffes, which I think was tacky.
Overall, I don't think it's a racist commercial.
"This bed is perfect for a white person...AND a black person."
"This sofa is perfect for a black person...AND a white person."
Haha. I honestly don't find that racist, but indeed silly. People may be labeling it racist because not many are comfortable having an open dialogue about anything related to race. Unfortunately, many believe that being colorblind is the right approach when it really sweeps things under the carpet, or furniture! The commercial is silly for highlighting how furniture is race-appropriate, but it isn't racist.
"Rainbow coalition"? Where are the Asians!?
Just kidding.
Coco — May 24, 2009
Haha... I see it as a parody of so many ads that attempt to indicate their high level of racial tolerance to the consumer subconsciously through the use of 'token' people of color. The difference in this ad is that they make the implicit point explicit, thereby revealing the absurdity (and contradictions) of this particular manifestation of "colorblind" ideology. In fact, I think that the rejection of colorblind ideology in this clip may be what makes people identify it as racist.
I also can't get over the singers; they also seem like an effort to make the implicit absurdity of local ads explicit: rather than having a voice-over of mystery singers, we actually see two men singing at the top of their lungs in honor of a local furniture store.
Vidya — May 24, 2009
I agree with Coco on this one. In fact, few norms serve to better perpetuate racism than 'compulsory colourblindness'.
BTW, I did notice that the bed was described as "perfect for a white person...OR a black person" rather than "AND a black person," which I thought would have been even better/funnier/edgier -- but perhaps a little too suggestive for audiences that still harbour racial prejudices.
Liz — May 24, 2009
When I first saw this commercial a month ago or so, I honestly thought it was a reaction to the intense racism in that part of North Carolina (not that other parts are much better). I'm from NC, and the area around High Point has had a strong increase in Hispanic immigrants and a subsequent strong increase in racist actions (I seem to recall something about the KKK resuming marching in the area, but I can't remember...).
On the Scatterplot blog, someone wrote that their uncle called the Red House and asked them if they were "for homosexual people, too," and they responded, "Yes, we're for all people."
On a totally non-racist or -racial note, this commercial is hilarious.
Joshua — May 24, 2009
At the very least, it's potentially racist because it does the "listing the minorities that you recognize" thing that has been previously pointed out on this blog. The couch is good for a white person and a black person? Does that mean Chinese are out? American Indian? Eastern Indian? Etc... The ignorance in the commercial is that it reveals the creators' tacit belief that the only races worth recognizing are black and white.
Fernando — May 24, 2009
Joshua, you don't honestly expect the guy to list every single ethnic group when jumping on the couch right? There's a practical limit to things. They would lose the joke if they didn't say "black person... or white person". Besides, you have to take the context into account. And the end makes it pretty obvious that they are not attempting to exclude any race.
lgreen — May 24, 2009
Joshua - That's why at the end they say "and hispanic people too. And all people." Not ignorant. Sweet.
Rachel — May 24, 2009
i think it is certainly attention-getting.
Hank — May 24, 2009
I found it interesting that there is a white man in the video extending credit to a black man. I will, however, take the advertiser's good intentions at face value, while keeping in mind the law of unintended consequences. The problem with satire is that it can sometimes be very difficult to tease the real message out of it and even more difficult may be the creation of satire of race matters by majority members who have good intentions, but may not entirely understand what they are doing.
Keith — May 25, 2009
I for one found this commercial both heartwarming and funny. Sure, it's over-the-top corny and just silly, but in the south, for some people there is tension between blacks and whites. It's less pronounced, but there are places that people of other races aren't really welcome. I grew up in Alabama, so I've seen it. And it's not always as overt as "Blacks aren't welcome here" or "White people not allowed", but there is a sense that people of a certain race don't belong in certain places. It's nice to see a company address this in a humorous, nonthreatening way.
For everyone who comments that they only really mention blacks and whites, the south is OVERWHELMINGLY black and white. These days there are a fair number of Hispanics, but 12 years ago, when I used to live there, almost everyone was black or white. They did through the line in at the end about Hispanics and everyone else.
senorglory — May 25, 2009
Nnothing mean spirited to this commercial.
marinus — May 26, 2009
There are several processes and layers to this commercial and the discussion surrounding it.
As I have gathered from reading this blog as well as others such as Jessica Valenti's blog called "Feministing", there are no "real" races. Instead people simply have different amounts of melanin in their skin as well as perhaps a few other genetic markers. By this reasoning some people would argue that calling anyone by any racial name eg. "white" or "black" the person employing these terms are racist.
I would think that what we need to do is also differentiate between race and ethnicity. By ethnicity I mean to say discrete cultural groups. If there was a commercial saying this "chair is for zulus ... xhosas" or "irish and italians" there would not be this question of racism.
My personal feelings and conclusions about this commercial are mostly positive in an ambiguous way.
Links « Stuff — May 27, 2009
[...] Is this racist? [...]
Franvers — May 6, 2011
Hello,
If this publicity is racist, is it what the antiracism ?
is rose red a real house in seattle - localguidewashington.com — March 30, 2023
[…] Error message | View complete answer on https://thesocietypages.org […]
markmin — November 4, 2023
https://basketballstarsunblocked.io is a free online basketball game that you can play on any device.
sandy63 — February 2, 2024
Welcome to five nights at freddy's, where childhood dreams turn into chilling nightmares. Night guard, are you ready to face the animatronic horrors that lurk after dark?