Abby K. alerted us to this video from the New York Times about boys who cross traditional gender lines to compete on a double-dutch jump-roping team in Brooklyn:
Click here for the NYT article that accompanied the video.
It’s a good illustration of the pressures boys face to avoid anything defined as feminine, usually more than girls are told to avoid things that are masculine (which can sometimes make them cool). ZeAndre Orr’s mom tried to dissuade him from doing something that was for girls, other boys at school picked on him because of his involvement with double dutch, and of course there is the time-honored tradition of calling boys who participate in “girly” activities sissies. For many boys, the fear of such repercussions–particularly harassment by other boys–is enough to make them steer clear of things they might be good at or like doing. And yet, despite these pressures, both boys and girls do cross gender lines all the time…a fact we conveniently forget when we talk about gender in a way that implies that “real boys” just naturally like certain things and not others, for example.
The other thing this made me think about is the way that physical activities get defined as sports…or as something else. If jump-roping were in the “sport” category, it would be socially acceptable, even encouraged, for ZeAndre to take part. And there’s no particular reason I can see that double dutch is clearly not a sport–it requires stamina, physical skill, fitness, and excellent hand-eye coordination, and involves team competition. I’ll probably get myself yelled at here, but seriously, this looks like it has as much of a claim to be called a sport as golf does.
But much like competitive cheerleading, competitive jump-roping has not attained social recognition as an athletic endeavor. Some sociologists argue that physical activities that predominantly attract women tend to be defined as something other than sports simply because we associate athletics with men, not women. I’m not arguing about whether or not competitive jump-roping should be seen as a sport–I really don’t care–but you might use this video as a starting point for a discussion about why we define some activities as sports but not others, and how gender might play into this.
Back to the issue of the messages boys get that discourage them from doing things coded feminine, Nathan M. (see his truly awesome artwork at The House of Tomorrow) sent in a link to this Nike ad (found at gigposters), which makes it clear that parents are supposed to be horrified at the idea that their son would be in ballet:
Thanks, AK and Nathan!
Comments 64
styleygeek — January 9, 2009
I flicked over to youtube and googled for other videos of this competition, since I think it looks amazing. I found this and what surprised me was that almost all the teams featured seemed to be mixed, and many looked like they had more than just one or two token boys.
I wondered whether potential explanations are:
(a) that media are more likely to focus on the mixed teams or male teams when filming
(b) that it becomes more acceptable for boys to participate in "girl" sports and games once they are more prestigious and highly competitive (i.e. the international format of this competition legitimizes double dutch as a sport in a way that doesn't happen when it's just a bunch of friends jumping at the park)
(c) that this competition is international and internationally, jump-rope doesn't have the same gender skewing as in the USA?
Does anyone know if any or all of these are the case?
Sarah O — January 9, 2009
When "fancy" competitive jump-rope first came to my school 16 years ago (I was in grade 5), it was introduced in gym class by a male gym teacher, and was introduced as an equal-opportunity sport right away (they never split the girls from the boys in gym class). By the time the jump-rope team started travelling to international competitions, there were fewer boys involved, but they tended to be the athletic boys, the ones who are good at all sports, and I don't think there is any stigma attached.
I'm from Canada's east coast, so I know absolutely nothing about this beyond movies, but I wonder if double-dutch in its casual, recreational form is more explicitly a girl's past-time in the U.S. (coupled with rhymes and calls), and if that is what makes it harder for gender-traditional parents to accept?
genderkid — January 9, 2009
I'm from Argentina, and over here, too, it's mostly girls that jump rope.
I think boxers from all over the world jump rope as an exercise. Or is that just in movies?
Gwen Sharp, PhD — January 9, 2009
styleygeek--
Those are excellent questions, and I really don't know the answer--any and/or all of your suggestions might be partially at play. I know that while cheerleading remains an overwhelmingly female activity, many competitive cheerleading squads have men on them. I've read a couple of studies of mixed-gender squads, and the men go to a lot of trouble to emphasize the physical prowess needed to do the stunts, trying to masculinize cheering by focusing on the need for stamina, etc. It would be really interesting to conduct some interviews with boys on jumproping teams to see how they explain their participation.
Of course, it's also possible that in most areas there are at least one or two boys willing to cross gender lines just because they think jumproping looks neat, even though they are ridiculed and aren't able to really avoid the stigma. Who knows?
genderkid--
You are absolutely right that male boxers--and other athletes--often incorporate jumping rope as part of their exercise routines. Somehow we define it as just fine for an individual guy to jump rope as part of a work out, but it's feminine if it's *group* jump-roping (as opposed to an individual) and if it's just for fun or done in a stylistic way, instead of for the purpose of burning calories or getting in shape (as though team jump-roping wouldn't serve those purposes). This is a great example of how arbitrary our gender rules are--some ways of jumping rope are ok for men, but others are too girly. It's silly.
joe — January 9, 2009
NYT is a little late on this one! As my under-10 kids know well, the Disney Channel made a tv movie about this already, starring Corbin Bleu (of High School Musical Fame). Probably 2 years ago now...
SarahMC — January 9, 2009
That Nike ad is awful. "How to raise a child who resents you and doesn't feel accepted for who he is as a person."
Anonymous — January 9, 2009
As a regular reader, I am used to seeing a lot of offensive ads here, but the Nike one is especially disturbing...I cannot even imagine that it went into press in this day and age without being reported.
Elena — January 9, 2009
I hope the Nike ad is from before Billy Elliot was released ¬_¬;
Kit — January 9, 2009
Agreed, that Nike ad just makes me very sad. So your need to fit into rigid gender norms is more important than your son's dreams. Wow. You should love and support your kids no matter what. And yes, that means willingly going to your son's ballet performance. Your "masculinity" is not more important than raising your kids well.
It's such a terrible and disheartening ad-- I have no idea how they expected it to sell shoes.
lgreen — January 10, 2009
That Nike ad is so cruel and gross. My brother is a professional dancer, and I just think about how crappy he must feel seeing that ad, and how crappy it must make my dad (who is incredibly proud of him) feel. Then I think about how many male dancers there are in the world, and how that ad is a slap in the face to all of them. WTF, Nike?
The Nerd — January 10, 2009
The thing that upset me about the video was how the coach put them down for getting second place. I think second place is great! These are children, they should be celebrating how awesome it is that they could work together to accomplish so much. The time for focusing on mistakes is before the competition, not afterward.
avon — January 11, 2009
"...and of course there is the time-honored tradition of calling boys who participate in “girly” activities sissies."
girly? er, skipping like this would probably kill me.
also: yes, genderkid, ("I think boxers from all over the world jump rope as an exercise. Or is that just in movies?") boxers do skip in the real world. it is physically demanding and builds co-ordination
LittlePunk — January 11, 2009
First off, those jump ropers are amazing! I remember watching them on sesame street as a kid, I thought they had super powers :D
Secondly, in regards to the nike ad, BALLET IS HARD CORE!!! I took ballet for about 10 years, and it is physically and mentally challenging. My ballet coach talked about the time she helped train some footballers, and they found it very difficult >:)
So eff you nike! This former ballet dancer would be proud to watch her hypothetical son at a dance, as he would be both physically strong, and emotionally secure and brave enough to say "no" to stupid societal hangups!
Alexis — January 11, 2009
That Nike ad is so...well, blatant in its promotion of gender norms. Wow.
Nike and A-1 Steak Sauce « SAMMY LIF blogblogblog — January 12, 2009
[...] Links AdGoodness Feministing Superman Wears Rob Long Underoos Tau Beta Sigma - Eta Alpha The Curvature Nike and A-1 Steak Sauce January 12, 2009, 5:45 am Filed under: Uncategorized found in CMYK Magazine, whose tagline is “inspiring visual communication” via feministing, via sociological images [...]
DncrMm — January 12, 2009
I'm going to point out (as a person who took dance classes for many years) that there was always a shortage of qualified male dancers - one of my best teachers was a man, a professional dancer - it is hard to perform many pieces without enough boys in class... so I'd love it if my son were a ballet dancer ;) And my husband wouldn't mind, being a traditional Hungarian folk dancer. (Let me tell you, any one who's tried that wouldn't say dancing is for sissies!)
LP — January 12, 2009
I was on a jump rope team for 9 years. Of those nine years, there were five or six guys on the team (out of about say 15). We did double dutch. I guess, however, this is more in relation to double dutch being a kid's recreational activity rather than a sportish/team type activity.
Also, some of the hottest straight guys are ballet dancers!
Felicity — January 12, 2009
Hmmph. When I was a kid, Sesame Street had a segment with an NFL player who took ballet classes for conditioning and agility. He was very matter-of-fact about it and said many football players did ballet.
I guess Nike never watched Sesame Street. I'd be willing to bet some of their signed male athletes do ballet.
Al — January 13, 2009
I think a major line between what society considers sport and non-sport is the use of judges versus officials.
In almost every Sport I can think of, officials make binary decisions and the scoring is very clearly defined. Golf counts strokes, football and rugby have a goal line, lacrosse, ice & field hockey, basketball and the like have a net.
Skateboarding, jumprope, gymnastics, diving, etc. have judges and the scoring is more arbitrary and complex.
The football player Felicity is thinking of that took ballet lessons is Lynn Swan, Hall of Fame receiver for the Steelers, and it was an appearance on Mr. Rogers Neighborhood, not Sesame Street.
L — January 14, 2009
The US's soon to be Chief of Staff used to do ballet, I think he might want a word with the people from Nike.
Jonathan — January 14, 2009
I've noticed that our society defines sports and non-sport physical activities on the level of male homoeroticism inherent in the sport.
jumping/sports and gender « strength never power — October 22, 2009
[...] more analysis @ Sociological Images [a great site btw] Leave a Comment No Comments Yet so far Leave a comment RSS feed for comments on this post. TrackBack URI Leave a comment Click here to cancel reply. Line and paragraph breaks automatic, e-mail address never displayed, HTML allowed: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <pre> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong> [...]
Robert — January 3, 2010
Here today when children in the U.S. are becoming obese at an alarming rate, boys that are engaging in physical activity are going to be berated for engaging in team jump roping. This is one of stupidous ideas I've ever heard of. Some churches have even declared it as "devil homosexual" activity with gross repudiations attached and sanctioned by the church.
Jumping rope, team or otherwise, is far from engaging in transgendered or homosexual activity. I mean are the boys putting on dresses to jump rope, or are the boys kissing each other for high score. Not only is this activity being frowned upon, but the simple childhood game of hopscotch is also being placed into the same classification. If allowing boys to play hopscotch or to jump rope is going to turn them gay, then the statisticians should get out their calculators to refigure the number of homosexual boys and men there are here in the U.S.
“We’re Only Protecting Them From Themselves” » Sociological Images — January 28, 2010
[...] many examples of this policing of men’s behavior. It’s everywhere, in sports (see here and here), cartoons, schools (see here and here), and Cosmo, and in advertising for McCoy [...]
Sam — January 31, 2010
That Nike ad makes me feel sick to my stomach. I danced competitively and did tumbling, as does my brother now, and he's only 10. I can't imagine how it would make him feel to see this ad. I'm horrified this got past anyone at Nike. Do they really want to shame kids and parents that way? Sure, play up your stereotypical masculinity all you want, but that's downright mean.
Adam — August 19, 2010
FYI people upset with Nike, the advertisement was a student submission and is not a real advertisement. No advertising agency would ever produce anything that ugly. Also they said so:
http://chuvachienes.com/2009/01/14/nikes-controversial-ad-nope-its-not-nikes/
shabd yadav — May 28, 2021
Let's all play this game together free v-bucks
terrasse mit Garten — October 2, 2021
terrasse mit Garten
Crossing Gender Lines: Boys Doing Double Dutch - Sociological Images
dildos — October 3, 2021
dildos
Crossing Gender Lines: Boys Doing Double Dutch - Sociological Images
сериалы 2022 года — November 14, 2021
сериалы 2022 года
Crossing Gender Lines: Boys Doing Double Dutch - Sociological Images
Фильмы 2022 онлайн — November 16, 2021
Фильмы 2022 онлайн
Crossing Gender Lines: Boys Doing Double Dutch - Sociological Images
сериалы lostfilm — November 20, 2021
сериалы lostfilm
Crossing Gender Lines: Boys Doing Double Dutch - Sociological Images
Смотреть фильмы онлайн — November 28, 2021
Смотреть фильмы онлайн
Crossing Gender Lines: Boys Doing Double Dutch - Sociological Images
читать комиксы — November 30, 2021
читать комиксы
Crossing Gender Lines: Boys Doing Double Dutch - Sociological Images
vitamin c powder — December 2, 2021
vitamin c powder
Crossing Gender Lines: Boys Doing Double Dutch - Sociological Images
сериалы 2021 онлайн — December 4, 2021
сериалы 2021 онлайн
Crossing Gender Lines: Boys Doing Double Dutch - Sociological Images
Сериалы 2022 онлайн — December 20, 2021
Сериалы 2022 онлайн
Crossing Gender Lines: Boys Doing Double Dutch - Sociological Images
blocked drains west bromwich — December 26, 2021
blocked drains west bromwich
Crossing Gender Lines: Boys Doing Double Dutch - Sociological Images
Free Phone Wallpapers HD — January 13, 2022
Free Phone Wallpapers HD
Crossing Gender Lines: Boys Doing Double Dutch - Sociological Images
комиксы онлайн — January 15, 2022
комиксы онлайн
Crossing Gender Lines: Boys Doing Double Dutch - Sociological Images
lostfilm-hd.online — January 16, 2022
lostfilm-hd.online
Crossing Gender Lines: Boys Doing Double Dutch - Sociological Images
Фильмы без регистрации и смс — January 17, 2022
Фильмы без регистрации и смс
Crossing Gender Lines: Boys Doing Double Dutch - Sociological Images
Смотреть тут бесплатно lostfilm — January 18, 2022
Смотреть тут бесплатно lostfilm
Crossing Gender Lines: Boys Doing Double Dutch - Sociological Images
designer crossbody bags — January 21, 2022
designer crossbody bags
Crossing Gender Lines: Boys Doing Double Dutch - Sociological Images
ең жақсы фильмдерді — January 21, 2022
ең жақсы фильмдерді
Crossing Gender Lines: Boys Doing Double Dutch - Sociological Images
Лучшие фильмы lostfilm — January 24, 2022
Лучшие фильмы lostfilm
Crossing Gender Lines: Boys Doing Double Dutch - Sociological Images
Скачати комікси безкоштовно — January 30, 2022
Скачати комікси безкоштовно
Crossing Gender Lines: Boys Doing Double Dutch - Sociological Images
дивитися тут — February 7, 2022
дивитися тут
Crossing Gender Lines: Boys Doing Double Dutch - Sociological Images
2022 фільми онлайн lostfilm — February 7, 2022
2022 фільми онлайн lostfilm
Crossing Gender Lines: Boys Doing Double Dutch - Sociological Images
манхуа мангасын онлайн оқыңыз — February 15, 2022
манхуа мангасын онлайн оқыңыз
Crossing Gender Lines: Boys Doing Double Dutch - Sociological Images
* — February 16, 2022
*
Crossing Gender Lines: Boys Doing Double Dutch - Sociological Images
мұнда тегін — February 18, 2022
мұнда тегін
Crossing Gender Lines: Boys Doing Double Dutch - Sociological Images
комикстерді тегін жүктеу — February 20, 2022
комикстерді тегін жүктеу
Crossing Gender Lines: Boys Doing Double Dutch - Sociological Images
фільми без реєстрації і смс lostfilm — February 20, 2022
фільми без реєстрації і смс lostfilm
Crossing Gender Lines: Boys Doing Double Dutch - Sociological Images
кращі фільми — February 22, 2022
кращі фільми
Crossing Gender Lines: Boys Doing Double Dutch - Sociological Images
Мультфильмдер 2022 онлайн — February 26, 2022
Мультфильмдер 2022 онлайн
Crossing Gender Lines: Boys Doing Double Dutch - Sociological Images
Читать мангу тут — March 1, 2022
Читать мангу тут
Crossing Gender Lines: Boys Doing Double Dutch - Sociological Images
https://villa-bouwen.villabouwgruwez.be/uncategorized/is-mijn-tuin-geschikt-voor-een-robotmaaier/ — March 3, 2022
https://villa-bouwen.villabouwgruwez.be/uncategorized/is-mijn-tuin-geschikt-voor-een-robotmaaier/
Crossing Gender Lines: Boys Doing Double Dutch - Sociological Images
загонка зеркало — March 10, 2022
загонка зеркало
Crossing Gender Lines: Boys Doing Double Dutch - Sociological Images
Www.winnowpro.com — October 14, 2022
Www.winnowpro.com
Crossing Gender Lines: Boys Doing Double Dutch - Sociological Images
Norris Severe — February 19, 2023
Terrific write-up! Incredibly useful and properly written. You protected The subject in fantastic detail and supplied fantastic examples to again up your factors. This information will be a terrific source for those seeking To find out more with regard to the subject. Thanks for The nice work!
technology — March 14, 2023
technology
Crossing Gender Lines: Boys Doing Double Dutch - Sociological Images
burberry sock — March 26, 2023
burberry sock
Crossing Gender Lines: Boys Doing Double Dutch - Sociological Images
free dedicated servers — March 29, 2023
free dedicated servers
Crossing Gender Lines: Boys Doing Double Dutch - Sociological Images