Teresa C., from Moment of Choice, sent in the trailer for the movie “The Secret Life of Bees.” What brought her attention to it was that it had a female voiceover, which is very uncommon. Voiceovers are almost always male. Unfortunately, she hasn’t been able to find a video of the trailer with the female voiceover online; if anyone finds it, let us know. This trailer just has some of the characters’ lines from the movie as narration.
What struck me about it–and Owen Gleiberman over at Entertainment Weekly–was that this seems to be another movie in which wise, long-suffering African American characters protect or enlighten White characters who are, at their core, good, kind liberals (we know that Dakota Fanning’s character is a Good White Person because she knows about the Civil Rights Act). As Gleiberman says in his review,
Isn’t it time that Hollywood took a sabbatical — maybe a permanent one — from movies in which black characters exist primarily to save the souls of white ones?…Over the years, we’ve all seen too many anachronistic ”magic Negroes” in movies like Forrest Gump and The Green Mile.
I would add “The Legend of Bagger Vance” to the list. They have important Black characters, but those characters’ main role is to facilitate the moral development of the White character through their wise advice and unending patience. I may be totally off, since I’ve only seen the trailer (though Gleiberman has seen the whole film), but “The Secret Life of Bees” seems to have a lot of the same themes.
Thanks for sending in the clip, Teresa!
Comments 6
Alex Pruteanu — October 27, 2008
This entire slant in HW has been around since DW Griffith's "Birth of a Nation." We all cheered when Hattie McDaniel (Mammy) was given the Oscar for Gone With The Wind, but she went on and played maid roles the rest of her life. Let's not forget Driving Ms. Daisy--an abberation. HW is awful and clings to stereotypes, though they spin them in different ways. The "Magic Negro" in Green Mile is King's fault, though HW jumped on that immediately because it knew it would work w/audiences. For fresher looks at the black culture, please go see Spike Lee's canon of films.
Rachel — November 17, 2008
Haven't seen the movie, but the book The Secret Life of Bees actually confronts that--the main character, Lilly, does at least initially see the Black characters as "there mainly to facilitate her personal development," and, remarkably, she actually gets called out on it.
Sociological Images » IKEA’S “MAGIC NEGRO” — April 12, 2009
[...] white, in attaining his or her desires. We recently identified a magic negro character in this post about the movie The Secret Life of Bees and in this post featuring a travel ad for Australia. [...]
Sociological Images » “BORING WHITE GUY” REALLY WANTS A “SOULFUL BLACK FRIEND” — April 14, 2009
[...] onto black people specifically is problematic (for posts on the “magic negro,” see here, here, and here). Most of us desire to be friends with people who see us as individuals and not [...]
Jasmine Rivers — April 29, 2009
Could someone tell me how this movie illustrates sociology???
therantingteenager — December 16, 2009
I haven't wathed the movie, but the book actually undermines racial stereotypes pretty well.